Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
IggleyP · 20/11/2021 14:26

@THisbackwithavengeance. That was really rude.

Does your daughter only have a diagnosis so she can “brandish it about like a medal”?

Maybe you don’t need reasonable adjustments (and actually, maybe you are not autistic at all !) but that isn’t the same for everyone. Maybe you are satisfied with diagnosing yourself, but that isn’t the same for everyone. Maybe you don’t want to publicly share your story (of your non diagnosed autism), but that isn’t the same for everyone.

Your comment was really judgemental.

dabbydeedoo · 20/11/2021 14:22

[quote HousethatChunkbuilt]@THisbackwithavengeance that's completely different as you're not mentioning it in a 'I'm one of you' sort of way. The lack of sensitivity from Janet or similar with a full time job in accountancy, three degrees and tons of friends saying she understands what I'm going through with my dd as she is a self diagnosed herself as having ADHD. Fuck off, try the school ringing you to gently ask why they keep finding cups of spat out food hidden around the place and you slowly feel all your daughters friends distance themselves from her as she's overly tactile. Heartbreaking.
Not to mention all the autistic/ ADHD kids who also have LD who are largely invisible in all media representations. [/quote]
I've got a full time job in a well-paid field, three degrees and friends (not tons of friends, but some). Doesn't make me any less autistic or ADHD. You have no idea about my life or what it has taken to get to where I am today. The years of depression, anxiety, self harm, borderline alcoholism, failed relationships, broken friendships, lost jobs, inability to grasp basic life skills like driving a car. I'm sure if I mentioned ADHD to you at work, you'd think I was some silly air headed millennial latching onto a 'fashionable' diagnosis because I outwardly appear pretty normal and friendly. You have absolutely no idea what anyone's life has been like.

Just.Stop.Gatekeeping.

Quaver5 · 20/11/2021 14:22

I’m the same age and 100% certain I have autism. My dd has recently been diagnosed at 16 due to struggling with anorexia. She has other SENs too but is bright and although they hold her back she is doing Alevels in a selective school. I’m aware compared to others we are fortunate however autism and not knowing has been a huge blight on our lives. Although not struggling with mental health life would have been so much easier if I’d known and I’m pretty sure dd wouldn’t be dangerously ill if we’d known about her autism sooner. Many people with autism struggle with mental health issues and it shouldn’t be pushed to one side because others have it worse. There should be room for compassion for everyone.

AlexaIWillNeverSayDucking · 20/11/2021 14:21

I'm thrilled that successful women are talking openly about this. My 11 yo DD is similar (and diagnosed ASC) and she won't engage with the idea she has autism or any of the groups at school as she thinks autism is non verbal, seriously impacted boys. She admits to being sensitive to sound and needing down time as certain things drain her, but mention autism and she rolls her eyes.

She would also go through life undetected and fairly easily (after obvious pre-school signs she learned to mask) if we could ensure that nothing bad or unexpected was to happen to her. However, when things do go wrong the house of cards tumbles quickly and the diagnosis allows us to understand and put safety nets in place.

She was also fine at school pre-diagnosis but has been doing extremely well since as the school were able to help her reach her potential. So using standard measures of success don't mean anything, without autism or without a diagnosis Melanie Sykes might have had a hugely different life, none of us know.

Sobeyondthehills · 20/11/2021 14:20

@claymodels

Sorry Claymodels, just to clarify, I am not talking about the public, I am taking about rich people or people who are trying to get into the spotlight.

Right; that makes it better then Hmm

As I said, maybe its because they don't feel as much stigma or maybe they are jumping onto the next bandwagon, whether than is mental health, gender or sexuality, autism, then onto the next thing.

Or maybe it's because they are autistic. You can't dismiss someone's diagnosis because they are in the public eye.

Maybe they are, maybe they are just trying to break down barriers, which is a brilliant thing.

Right up till they start saying how easy it is to get a diagnoises and what wonderful support they have. When for most people that is bullshit.

I am not discounting someone's diagnois because they are in the public eye, I am saying their path on getting that diagnoises and any support afterwards is going to be massively different to a lot of people.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 14:19

@THisbackwithavengeance

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

You have provided a great example of the very thing i hate about people who think self diagnosis is a ok. Fair enough, you can think you are autistic, but self diagnosis whilst putting people down for being diagnosed Hmm

What's the shit about a medal? Really?

claymodels · 20/11/2021 14:16

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

What's with the "answers" ?

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 14:14

@BoredZelda

What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

Yes, because it is all about the spectrum, just like any other condition. Dyslexia, Down Syndrome, CP, MS etc, all depend on how these things affect the individual. One could say the same for you working. Someone with autism who can’t work might say you are wrong to be working as it makes people think everyone with Autism can work and that makes things harder for them. I’m sure those who’s lives are really affected by dyslexia are sick of hearing how Einstein was dyslexic and Branson is dyslexic and why aren’t you a genius or a billionaire.

But that is not quite what I'm trying to get at. I'm specifically talking about this BBC article for example.

BBC News - Melanie Sykes and Christine McGuinness praised for openness about autism diagnosis
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-59352983

It ends by saying only 22% of people with autism are in employment, but the article doesn't really mention concrete barriers these women may have faced in that regard. Again, this doesn't mean I think they have not faced them, just that in these kinds of spotlight news articles it isn't really talked about, whilst at the same time always highlighting that autistic people are underemployed. I understand from other posters that both Melanie and Christine have talked about their struggles elsewhere, but I wish it would be more of a focus in any of these mainstream news media.

Sorry, I don't seem to be able to express what I'm saying very well.

OP posts:
HousethatChunkbuilt · 20/11/2021 14:12

@THisbackwithavengeance that's completely different as you're not mentioning it in a 'I'm one of you' sort of way. The lack of sensitivity from Janet or similar with a full time job in accountancy, three degrees and tons of friends saying she understands what I'm going through with my dd as she is a self diagnosed herself as having ADHD. Fuck off, try the school ringing you to gently ask why they keep finding cups of spat out food hidden around the place and you slowly feel all your daughters friends distance themselves from her as she's overly tactile. Heartbreaking.
Not to mention all the autistic/ ADHD kids who also have LD who are largely invisible in all media representations.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 20/11/2021 14:02

it is really hard to get a diagnosis, years of waiting,

it is great that Melanie Sykes has gone public though, and she wants education to be made aware. which is all good

THisbackwithavengeance · 20/11/2021 14:01

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

Iggly · 20/11/2021 14:01

Melanie Sykes has been clear that it has been a struggle and she has needed extra support for some things. She’s also suggested that the education system needs overhauling.

I applaud her and anyone reading her story wouldn’t assume it was easy for her!

I’m glad she’s highlighting this. I think our education system sucks and is even worse for those with autism.

dabbydeedoo · 20/11/2021 13:59

@gogohm

Kind of annoys me too... my dd was diagnosed at 2.5 because she was so behind, she's now a young woman at university but within a few minutes in her company you can tell. If you can get to 30+ without a diagnosis and only get one because a private psychiatrist who is being paid by you to tell you what label you have diagnosed you, it's not really a diagnosis is it? The fact they went public makes me even more uncomfortable. Autism is lifelong, I could tell at just weeks old she was different
Did it ever occur to you that that your DD was diagnosed because it was, what, the early 00s, and not the 70s or the 80s when many of us were children? The concept of girls being autistic wasn't even widely recognised back then. People could tell I was different alright but the word autism was never mentioned. It's really horrid when people gatekeep like this.
BoredZelda · 20/11/2021 13:59

It should be named differently.

Why? It is a medical term. That’s like saying cancer should be called something different depending on how ill it makes you.

My daughter has cerebral palsy. I will guarantee everyone here will have a different mental image of how she is.

BoredZelda · 20/11/2021 13:56

What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

Yes, because it is all about the spectrum, just like any other condition. Dyslexia, Down Syndrome, CP, MS etc, all depend on how these things affect the individual. One could say the same for you working. Someone with autism who can’t work might say you are wrong to be working as it makes people think everyone with Autism can work and that makes things harder for them. I’m sure those who’s lives are really affected by dyslexia are sick of hearing how Einstein was dyslexic and Branson is dyslexic and why aren’t you a genius or a billionaire.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 20/11/2021 13:55

[quote Charley50]@EatSleepRantRepeat - I agree that it was a mistake to get rid of the Aspergers diagnosis. The spectrum of differences / difficulties under the diagnosis autism is now so huge as to be meaningless. From non-verbal, with learning difficulties who will never lead an independent life, to Chris Packham and Melanie Sykes and everyone in between. It should be named differently. [/quote]
Definitely agree with this. With the widening of the diagnostic criteria for autism, public awareness of what autism is has changed massively over the last 20-30 years (if they had even heard of it 25 years ago).

If you tell people someone is autistic, they will assume they are verbal, maybe just a bit quirky, but can generally function independently. They don't consider that you are talking about someone that as an adult needs/will need full-time support.

TheOriginalEmu · 20/11/2021 13:52

@gogohm

Kind of annoys me too... my dd was diagnosed at 2.5 because she was so behind, she's now a young woman at university but within a few minutes in her company you can tell. If you can get to 30+ without a diagnosis and only get one because a private psychiatrist who is being paid by you to tell you what label you have diagnosed you, it's not really a diagnosis is it? The fact they went public makes me even more uncomfortable. Autism is lifelong, I could tell at just weeks old she was different
Fuck off. I was hyperlexic in 1981, at 18 months reading 3 languages. That just made me gifted. I was sitting GCSEs at 9, that just made me gifted. I had no friends, I had eating disorders and self harming by 11, I was just highly strung. I was doing university level maths and English at 13. But I as unhappy and self medicating on drugs and alcohol by 14. I have never held a job for more than 6 Months, I have scars from hurting myself in meltdown.

I wasn’t diagnosed because no one was interested in helping me, just exploiting my ‘intelligence’ and using me as a poster child for his awesome they were.

You know nothing about other peoples lives.

x2boys · 20/11/2021 13:49

[quote NettleTea]@HousethatChunkbuilt I dont agree with self diagnosis. I do believe that people may think they might have autism/ADHD, but without a professional outside perspective its impossible to know for sure. And a great number of people who go for assessment find out that they dont.
But identifying as autistic without professional assessmement, and then loudly taking over autistic spaces and trying to control the process, is as abhorrent to me as self identifying into womanhood. And in many cases its the same thing, and I suspect they dont want an actual diagnosis as their fraud would show up[/quote]
Yep totally agree ,and often they bully parents online who are struggling with their child's severe autism for not seeing it as "a gift" .

Ozanj · 20/11/2021 13:45

She has ADHD and a lot of people who know her are saying they aren’t surprised.

TheOriginalEmu · 20/11/2021 13:44

@Malibuismysecrethome

I think it would be more helpful if they explained how their autism effects them. As a previous poster pointed out they are both successful so it would be helpful to know what aspects they struggle with. There are so many spectrums. I know they don’t owe me an explanation but it would clarify their proclamation that they are autistic.
Christine has written a book about her life with a lot of detail about it, however they are not ‘proclaiming’ they’re autistic, they’re just revealing it. As is their right.
DietrichandDiMaggio · 20/11/2021 13:40

[quote ancientgran]@Cakeandslippers I think it can only help wider understanding of what a spectrum it is if people see just as much exposure of all points on the spectrum. Just as Rainman "informed" a generation so can these cases "inform" a new generation.[/quote]
But Rainman didn't inform a generation correctly, most people with classic autism aren't savants and for people to assume that somebody with autism, who is non-verbal and has a learning disability, must also have an amazing talent was not helpful.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 13:40

Sorry Claymodels, just to clarify, I am not talking about the public, I am taking about rich people or people who are trying to get into the spotlight.

Right; that makes it better then Hmm

As I said, maybe its because they don't feel as much stigma or maybe they are jumping onto the next bandwagon, whether than is mental health, gender or sexuality, autism, then onto the next thing.

Or maybe it's because they are autistic. You can't dismiss someone's diagnosis because they are in the public eye.

NettleTea · 20/11/2021 13:39

@HousethatChunkbuilt I dont agree with self diagnosis. I do believe that people may think they might have autism/ADHD, but without a professional outside perspective its impossible to know for sure. And a great number of people who go for assessment find out that they dont.
But identifying as autistic without professional assessmement, and then loudly taking over autistic spaces and trying to control the process, is as abhorrent to me as self identifying into womanhood. And in many cases its the same thing, and I suspect they dont want an actual diagnosis as their fraud would show up

Sobeyondthehills · 20/11/2021 13:37

@claymodels

I feel like getting an autism diagnosis now is a bit like getting a mental health diagnosis a few years back, whether that is because the stigma is lessening, in which case great, or whether it is the new trend.

Yeah; we are all getting diagnosed because it's trendy Sad

Sorry Claymodels, just to clarify, I am not talking about the public, I am taking about rich people or people who are trying to get into the spotlight. As I said, maybe its because they don't feel as much stigma or maybe they are jumping onto the next bandwagon, whether than is mental health, gender or sexuality, autism, then onto the next thing.

I have seen how difficult it is for people to get a diagnosis, especially adult women and for those people who can't go privately its a fucking long slog,

But when someone in the public eye comes out and tells me they have something, which is a hot topic at the moment, I do tend to take it with a grain of salt

TheOriginalEmu · 20/11/2021 13:35

@JaniieJones

God, its like anxiety and depression everyone seems to have it so the ones that actually do have it then struggle to access services.

Who cares if she is autistic. She seems to be living a full and happy life surely she could focus on that.

Christine mcguiness had anorexia, depression, no friends, and a really hard time coping as an adult. She’s as entitled to a diagnosis and help as anyone.