Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
IggleyP · 20/11/2021 16:25

@Caddycat - It is not literally all she talked about.

She talked about her struggles at school. Being seen as straight talking in a way that others commented on. About being vulnerable because she believed what people said to her.

BlankTimes · 20/11/2021 16:15

@THisbackwithavengeance

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

THisbackwithavengeance

The DSM-5 Manual defines autism spectrum disorder as “persistent difficulties with social communication and social interaction” and “restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviours, activities or interests” (this includes sensory behaviour), present since early childhood, to the extent that these “limit and impair everyday functioning”.

I repeat, limit and impair everyday functioning

If those criteria do not limit and impair everyday functioning, then the person being assessed will not be given a diagnosis, because they are not autistic.

It is possible for non-autistic people to have some autistic traits, but for those traits not to limit and impair everyday functioning.
Those people are not autistic. But often those people read about autism online, recognise a few traits in themselves then self-diagnose as autistic.
And then they declare a formal diagnosis is not necessary because although they have decided they are autistic, they are not disabled, need no interventions and infer they live life like an NT.

Further info about diagnosis here www.autism.org.uk/advice-and-guidance/topics/diagnosis/diagnostic-criteria/all-audiences

Caddycat · 20/11/2021 16:10

[quote IggleyP]@Caddycat -

“I felt very annoyed too. "I can't read big numbers" and "I can't listen to the director in my ear and talk to guests at the same time" is not representative of autism.”

You know more than the psychiatrist who diagnosed her then? Since that’s obviously all there was to it.[/quote]
I'm not saying this at all. She's reduced autism to something simple rather than what I witness many children struggle with. No one gets a diagnosis simply because they can't do 2 things at once. It may be a trait, but this is literally all she talked about.

nanbread · 20/11/2021 16:09

Stories portrayed like the Melanie one on BBC today worry me a bit because they might reinforce the idea that the only thing stopping autistic people from being successful at work is to not hire them because of discrimination.

Well I would agree with that had Mel not clearly said how much she struggled with certain aspects of her job.

OhDear2200 · 20/11/2021 16:03

@EdenFlower sorry not doing very well today Confused

IggleyP · 20/11/2021 15:59

@Caddycat -

“I felt very annoyed too. "I can't read big numbers" and "I can't listen to the director in my ear and talk to guests at the same time" is not representative of autism.”

You know more than the psychiatrist who diagnosed her then? Since that’s obviously all there was to it.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 15:47

I felt very annoyed too. "I can't read big numbers" and "I can't listen to the director in my ear and talk to guests at the same time" is not representative of autism.

It is for some though. I can't listen and think/talk at the same time. I need one thing at a time

Caddycat · 20/11/2021 15:39

@cansu

I read an article about what she has been saying and I felt v pissed off. All this guff about her autism being the best thing about her and completely rebuilding the education system so children can learn in nature. She seemingly doesn't see or want to see the many people with autism whose autism has blighted their lives. I have a dc with severe non verbalautism and v severe learning difficulties and epilepsy. I don't really see his autism as a gift and the best thing about him.
I felt very annoyed too. "I can't read big numbers" and "I can't listen to the director in my ear and talk to guests at the same time" is not representative of autism. It almost sounded like she just wanted a label to justify her incompetence.
TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 15:28

@Gentleness

I'm interested in the different attitudes to diagnosis on this thread. Deciding to seek diagnosis is not a simple choice. I think some of us have been so concerned not to make a fuss and so aware we might just be weak that we resist seeking diagnosis because it might simply confirm we're just crap at life and friendships. Ok, me, that's talking about me.

I don't agree with self diagnosis, but I do want to understand whether the struggles I feel are genuine or just due to my laziness. My difficulties are not severe, though they are holding me back, and seeking diagnosis through the NHS seems inappropriate. They're unable to provide decent mental health support (we made sacrifices and paid for that) and I've been on a waiting list for specialist HRT help for over a year. To go in and talk about another "maybe" seems wasteful. We could use savings again and pay for private help, but the HRT help is going to be more life changing so takes priority. I doubt I'll ever get more insight into whether I have ASD than the series of online tests I've taken to try and work out if it's worth seeing a professional. Would it be worth it or naval gazing? I just don't know.

Diagnosis is for the following parties.
  1. Yourself ; in understanding how you work.
  2. Other people ; in requesting help, reasonable adjustments etc.

Under certain conditions 1) might be enough for people. If nobody else needs to be extra understanding, or has a go at you for not being able to do things that other people can then it doesn't matter. If your own understanding of being neurodiverse is enough then leave it be.

My difficulties are similar to you - in a sense that they're not 'severe'. I can hold things together at the cost of everything else. I spend double the amount of time other people take on everything . Which means that by the time I've finished my work, and made dinner ( a simple one that SHOULD take just 30 mins for people who don't get distracted constantly) the whole day is gone. No time or energy to go out, live my life, or have fun just the endless grind of surviving. My life isn't particularly complicated no DC just the two of us.
I liken it to having to think about every time I breathe in while everyone else does it subconsciously. Try it - and see how hard it is.

I didn't want to live like this. Which is why I finally decided to get diagnosed. I did some reading online and tried some tips, which helped but ultimately I needed more help. I was lucky enough to be able to pay for private (DP also contributed to the cost). Adjustments at work and medication have helped enormously plus DP's support.

Ultimately it is for your own benefit so whether or not to get diagnosed is up to you. And nobody really cares. What they I do care about is people self-diagnosing (as in not even trying to get a professional assessment or spoken to a GP at least!) and wanting the same adjustments, 'sharing stories' etc as those who are diagnosed. If they wanted all of that then at least speak to a medical professional about it.

Gentleness · 20/11/2021 15:26

@Figgit

I’m an adult diagnosed with ASD. The diagnosis was life changing for my mental health. I’m indifferent about Melanie Sykes’ diagnosis - to misquote the Smiths ‘it says nothing to me about my life’. I get more worked up about how difficult it is for adults to access a diagnosis unless they have a lot of money to pay for it. Or how too many people think all people with ASD are the same. Christine McGuinness upsets me a little the way she monetises her children. But not my circus and all that.
I'd love to know more about how it changed things for you if it's not too personal.
Figgit · 20/11/2021 15:24

I’m an adult diagnosed with ASD. The diagnosis was life changing for my mental health.
I’m indifferent about Melanie Sykes’ diagnosis - to misquote the Smiths ‘it says nothing to me about my life’. I get more worked up about how difficult it is for adults to access a diagnosis unless they have a lot of money to pay for it. Or how too many people think all people with ASD are the same.
Christine McGuinness upsets me a little the way she monetises her children. But not my circus and all that.

AlphabetAerobics · 20/11/2021 15:15

I got my autism medal when I was 46 - very fashionable it seems. Hmm

None of us know what Melanie’s life has been like behind closed doors - but I’ll bet it’s been really fucking hard and because she’s slim/beautiful/successful will have been told she’s bitchy/uptight/aloof/snobby.

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 15:01

I guess it depends on the individual, some people clearly feel the diagnosis is worth it. I think the other important thing is that even if you don't have something with a label it doesn't make your struggles any less, they are what they are.

I worked with someone who was non verbal and very vulnerable who had a ASD diagnosis for 30 years, new psychiatrist saw him and said he didn't have ASD and his diagnosis was changed. It didn't change anything, he had exactly the same needs and exactly the same support as before.

I hope you get your HRT sorted out soon.

EdenFlower · 20/11/2021 15:01

[quote OhDear2200]@EdenFlower I find your suggestion that people who only ‘know’ that their child was different at 2.5 massively offensive. That’s your experience not everyone’s. It’s a crass opinion that hugely ignores the years of confusion and worry for people.

I would have hoped a parent of an autistic child would understand that.[/quote]
I think you were talking to the wrong person here!

tootyfruitypickle · 20/11/2021 14:58

How much does it cost to go through a private assessment does anyone know ? For me, being able to make sense of my childhood would help a lot- and the pandemic has really allowed me to let my 'mask' slip and revert to usual ways, which is a relief tbh. I'm assuming I could be autistic and giving myself a break rather than always feeling like I'm weird. Not making myself do things I don't really want to. I'm sure if I was at school these days I would have been assessed. It's sad how little awareness there was .

TractorAndHeadphones · 20/11/2021 14:57

@THisbackwithavengeance

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

If it's your business, known to only you and DH then me saying you're not autistic doesn't matter , right? After all you don't want a 'medal', or any recognition. It doesn't cause you any problems, since you can't see why other people want medical advice.

Don't worry I understand completely. I'm actually a pineapple, I've read lots about this, and it's really obvious.

Gentleness · 20/11/2021 14:52

I'm interested in the different attitudes to diagnosis on this thread. Deciding to seek diagnosis is not a simple choice. I think some of us have been so concerned not to make a fuss and so aware we might just be weak that we resist seeking diagnosis because it might simply confirm we're just crap at life and friendships. Ok, me, that's talking about me.

I don't agree with self diagnosis, but I do want to understand whether the struggles I feel are genuine or just due to my laziness. My difficulties are not severe, though they are holding me back, and seeking diagnosis through the NHS seems inappropriate. They're unable to provide decent mental health support (we made sacrifices and paid for that) and I've been on a waiting list for specialist HRT help for over a year. To go in and talk about another "maybe" seems wasteful. We could use savings again and pay for private help, but the HRT help is going to be more life changing so takes priority. I doubt I'll ever get more insight into whether I have ASD than the series of online tests I've taken to try and work out if it's worth seeing a professional. Would it be worth it or naval gazing? I just don't know.

LonginesPrime · 20/11/2021 14:45

I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

If the only purpose of seeking a diagnosis is to brandish it like a medal, then you don't fit the criteria for a medical diagnosis anyway - if it's not impairing your everyday functioning, you wouldn't meet the medical criteria.

People seek diagnoses when autism is adversely affecting their daily lives. If you are doing fine, then that's great for you. But it might be worth considering whether others might be struggling a bit more than you are if you think they're just after a meaningless bit of paper.

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 14:39

But Rainman didn't inform a generation correctly, most people with classic autism aren't savants and for people to assume that somebody with autism, who is non-verbal and has a learning disability, must also have an amazing talent was not helpful.

You misunderstood my point, I put "informed" to indicate I didn't think it was actually informed. Which is why I said "I think it can only help wider understanding of what a spectrum it is if people see just as much exposure of all points on the spectrum." i.e. I don't think seeing Melanie Sykes as the example of autism is any better at informing public opinion that Rainman was

I hope that makes it clearer.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 14:35

Sorry not even the DH and DD, just the DH.

LonginesPrime · 20/11/2021 14:35

[quote HousethatChunkbuilt]@THisbackwithavengeance that's completely different as you're not mentioning it in a 'I'm one of you' sort of way. The lack of sensitivity from Janet or similar with a full time job in accountancy, three degrees and tons of friends saying she understands what I'm going through with my dd as she is a self diagnosed herself as having ADHD. Fuck off, try the school ringing you to gently ask why they keep finding cups of spat out food hidden around the place and you slowly feel all your daughters friends distance themselves from her as she's overly tactile. Heartbreaking.
Not to mention all the autistic/ ADHD kids who also have LD who are largely invisible in all media representations. [/quote]
I think you've inadvertently stereotyped many other people with ASD/ADHD into your criticism there - lots of people have struggled and have managed to get degrees and professional jobs and they also have to deal with all the incredibly frustrating and heartbreaking aspects of being neurodivergent and/or being the parent of ND children.

I don't think it helps to generalise about these different factors as you don't know what other people have gone through. Having a job/degree/friends doesn't mean it has been any easier for those people, and it doesn't mean those other difficulties didn't also arise for those people.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 14:35

Also you have to question the 'it's so obvious I'm autistic' when it's followed up with 'only DH and DD know'

Not so fucking obvious at all then, is it?

NettleTea · 20/11/2021 14:32

@THisbackwithavengeance

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

maybe you think you might be, in fact suspect very strongly that you are, indeed autistic. Sharing traits and a family background does strongly hint at it.

so you can say, yes, you suspect you are. What you cannot say is that you definately are, because you havent been diagnosed, for whatever reasons you choose. And it seems you do not feel it impacts upon your life. well thats great for you and Im glad about that for you. And no, your lived experience is valid, but its not official.

However there are 2 things wrong with this - you seem to think others are only doing this for a label? These answers we get are most usually related to problems we have had. Its not a 'nice to know' kind of thing, its a 'why the fuck does this keep happening / cant I cope'

most people cant afford to fork out the price for assessment just for shits and giggles. And as said, the waiting lists are ardously long and hard to get. Nobody is doing it for fun if they havent come to some sort of crisis point. Its not a hobby or an alternative talking point. We often need to self adapt. Or understand how we need to work, or have adaptations at work after failing again.

And secondly, you insistance that you ARE autistic, (as opposed to highly likely to be autistic) opens the door for others who definately are not to come barging in and taking over the space. You might not need the gatekeeping of official verification for your own life, but plenty of us DO need to keep the distinction clear because of the self IDers and the harm they will do, especially to those who really cant advocate for themselves, and who's diagnosis isnt a blessing

IggleyP · 20/11/2021 14:30

@THisbackwithavengeance - and actually, being self-diagnosed DOES make your experience less as you didn’t have to jump through a million hoops to get it.

It also isn’t on your medical records and you don’t have to disclose it on occupational health forms or insurance applications as you are not diagnosed … therefore you can have it when our suits you and not when you don’t want it.

BoredZelda · 20/11/2021 14:28

It ends by saying only 22% of people with autism are in employment, but the article doesn't really mention concrete barriers these women may have faced in that regard. Again, this doesn't mean I think they have not faced them, just that in these kinds of spotlight news articles it isn't really talked about, whilst at the same time always highlighting that autistic people are underemployed. I understand from other posters that both Melanie and Christine have talked about their struggles elsewhere, but I wish it would be more of a focus in any of these mainstream news media.

Media are poor at reporting disability issues - shocker. Twas always thus and will likely always be.

I recall everyone telling me I had to watch a documentary about Lewis Hamilton’s brother who has CP. He was so inspiring, what he has overcome, I’d be uplifted.

What I saw was a young man who had some mobility struggles, who lived with a very wealthy family who could pay for shoes to be specially designed for him and who got a leg up into a motor racing career because of his brother. There was not a single thing about how his CP impacted on his life or the struggles he’d had.

I can see where you are trying to come from on this but the issue isn’t with Melanie Sykes, it is with how disability issues are reported in the media and how they are perceived by society. You can either be annoyed about it, or accept it’s going to happen and just speak out where you see it.