Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Melanie Sykes has revealed she's autistic

236 replies

Latenightpharma · 20/11/2021 09:37

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this. On one hand I think it's great that people like her are coming forward and are increasing representation, on the other hand I'm worried that others might underestimate how much the condition affects me (also have autism) at work because news outlets tend to report on stuff like this with an air of 'no big deal'.

To be clear, I'm not trying to suggest that Melanie or Christine are less affected by being autistic than I am, I don't know how much it affects them on a daily basis. What I'm trying to say is that someone like my boss might look at this and go 'oh, see, no big deal, do you really need accomodations to work or are you just being difficult? These people manage just fine.' AIBU?

OP posts:
ancientgran · 21/11/2021 11:54

@claymodels

The Oh. OK. sounded to me like you thought I was saying something odd.

Not so much odd as dismissive. I didn't respond last night because you would have got a barrage of fucks, now I have thought about it I realise it's simply not worth my time to explain.

Explain what? I thought it was normal not to be able to listen to one thing while saying something else. It is my experience so obviously I thought it was normal, apart from telling my husband to stop talking if I was on the phone it isn't something I've ever thought to ask anyone about. Similarly my DD was amazed when she read about someone seeing pictures when they closed their eyes. Her experience when she closed her eyes was darkness, my experience was I could picture the things I was thinking about. Until someone told us they had the opposite experience we just accepted our own experience and never questioned it

I don't know why you would see it as dismissive, I was surprised to find out that people seemed to think that NT people would find it normal to be able to listen to one thing while saying another. I'm obviously lacking in that department but I can see pictures with my eyes closed and wiggle my ears so we all have different abilities and I can't even imagine why I'd be dismissive of someone being able to do something I can't. I've never been dismissive of someone who can play the piano, speak a foreign language or do 100 and 1 things I can't, I just knew they could do that.

DDMAC · 21/11/2021 09:39

That’s interesting about Melanie Sykes. I watched her on MasterChef recently and recognised some traits and didn’t know she had had this diagnosis. I thought she was awesome on it.

claymodels · 21/11/2021 09:30

The Oh. OK. sounded to me like you thought I was saying something odd.

Not so much odd as dismissive. I didn't respond last night because you would have got a barrage of fucks, now I have thought about it I realise it's simply not worth my time to explain.

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 21/11/2021 09:15

@claymodels

She was diagnosed at 51. Christine McGuiness also shared an autism diagnosis recently, and I wonder how I feel about all this.

I don't think you get to feel anything.

I'm actually fed up with autism gate keeping. The arguments from all sides about whether there should be functioning labels, people raging because their child struggles much more so someone who doesn't struggle so much should not be allowed a voice - it goes on and on and it's utterly ridiculous. Many conditions have 'variations' and nobody should be in some sort of competition to validate their/their child's autism over someone else's experience.

The only thing I really object to is the 'self diagnosis' brigade who shout the loudest but know fuck all.

Absolutely hit the nail on the head here 👏🏻

Two adult women who were recently diagnosed with autism have shared their stories and explained how it has been the best thing for them and their families. They have admitted how much their lives have been a struggle... yet there are actually some of you who are QUESTIONING the motives and even the diagnosis!!!

I think a lot of people forget that autism, despite what people say these days, is a SPECTRUM neurodiversity. Some have it mildly and can function well though do still struggle (hence the diagnosis). Other autistic people are non-verbal and have other severe issues that go with it.

I am going to get so much hate for this, before anyone starts I have several family members with autism and they all present differently. One of my cousins is non verbal and needs round the clock care, whereas my brother has the old diagnosis of "aspergers" and whilst he struggles socially sometimes, he has a wonderful life and is "high functioning".

But the autism gatekeeping is actually quite harmful. Christine and Mel's diagnoses can only be helpful to everyone. I am sorry that some of you don't feel the same way.

nanbread · 20/11/2021 23:50

I am not discounting someone's diagnois because they are in the public eye

This is exactly what you did, stop fucking gaslighting! @Sobeyondthehills

You pretty much said people in public eye were jumping on a trendy bandwagon

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 23:09

@claymodels

Well can you honestly have a proper conversation with someone on the phone and at the same time listen to someone telling you some news they want you to pass on? I honestly can't. I have to ask one of them to stop while I listen to the other.

No, I can't. I'm not sure why you are asking though, I said I can't do this.

The Oh. OK. sounded to me like you thought I was saying something odd. I've always thought people on TV who could listen to something in their ear and carry on talking were quite amazing.
EatSleepRantRepeat · 20/11/2021 22:47

I'm so sorry for some of the experiences people are having here, and the self-diagnosis debate is a hard one. I think the media are really focusing on the autism label but the vast majority of people don't understand the overall impact and impairment when trying to lead a normal life.

I've always been incredibly academic but I've been let go from so many jobs because of my issues - not seen as a team player, not getting along with the right people, not able to lie about things (like telling the MD their latest idea is a crock of shit). Unable to function well at events, and in meetings when trying to follow the slides as well as the speaker because of the two or more different flows of information.

I have more problems with the diagnosis than before it, as its seen as a pre-existing disability for my health insurance so my psych cover has been cancelled Hmm so I have no idea why people would want to spend money for a 'fake' one. However, I do have a friend who is shopping their self-dx'd kid around different therapists because he's not meeting the criteria for diagnosis, so there must some benefit to some people.

Tunnocksmallow · 20/11/2021 21:23

“Kind of annoys me too... my dd was diagnosed at 2.5 because she was so behind, she's now a young woman at university but within a few minutes in her company you can tell. If you can get to 30+ without a diagnosis and only get one because a private psychiatrist who is being paid by you to tell you what label you have diagnosed you, it's not really a diagnosis is it? The fact they went public makes me even more uncomfortable. Autism is lifelong, I could tell at just weeks old she was different”

So so offensive!!

My DD is now 22, I also knew that there was something different from a very young age too. I was blocked at every turn by health professionals, school staff, etc etc. I suspect it was because I was a young, single mum, and they just wanted to tar me with the lazy brush.
I even had a teacher tell me that my DD could have no problems as her older brother was on the G&T register. Obviously, they didn’t believe 2 siblings could be different. And they are , they’re chalk and cheese.
Anyway, I kept fighting, but was blocked at every turn. I would end up in the school crying and told it was my parenting. I attended courses. I was pushing for dyslexia tests too as her father is dyslexic but again they said nope she’s fine. Even though she couldn’t read or write properly until going to high school.
Fast forward, her teen years were horrific. Putting herself in dangerous situations despite my trying to protect her. And again begging school for help and nothing.
Until she went to college- suddenly a dyslexia diagnosis.
When she was 19, we demand a new GP send a referral for ASD assessment. They met her, she’s done the assessments. That was 3 years ago, here, there is a major waiting list. She was told in summer that she is 400 on the list, so could be waiting another 2-2.5 years. The team have all but told her she is autistic, but they cannot formally diagnosis her until she meets the team again in…. 2 years.
Her life is on hold. She works, but she spends her free time in meltdown because she feels she has to hold it all together so much for everyone else.
Her fathers family have no idea how to handle her. They tell her she’s ‘putting it on’ and lazy.
If I had the money I would pay for the private diagnosis.

But anyway, getting to an older age without diagnosis does not mean you are doing fine and do not need that diagnosis. It means that you are one of the many women who slipped through the cracks because you were/are so good at masking when in school/college/work. Or you/parents were ignored when trying to push for help.
It’s well known there is a crisis now of women of 30+ getting ASD/ADHD diagnoses because they were ‘missed’
Do some research, or possibly look further than your own backyard.

Cheeseplantboots · 20/11/2021 21:00

@JaniieJones

God, its like anxiety and depression everyone seems to have it so the ones that actually do have it then struggle to access services.

Who cares if she is autistic. She seems to be living a full and happy life surely she could focus on that.

This 100%
claymodels · 20/11/2021 20:52

Well can you honestly have a proper conversation with someone on the phone and at the same time listen to someone telling you some news they want you to pass on? I honestly can't. I have to ask one of them to stop while I listen to the other.

No, I can't. I'm not sure why you are asking though, I said I can't do this.

x2boys · 20/11/2021 20:49

I think in America they have different levels of autism to show how much a person needs support and how it impacts them ,for me and I accept others won't agree it ,s the way to go,it might also help in pointing people in the right direction to get help in my Lea for example there are quite a few charities that support children with autism ,but a lot are aimed at children who for want of a better word are higher functioning ,this is obviously a good thing for them but my child just can't access them he has no interest in gaming ,or mine craft or lots of other activities they put on he would be happy to spend the day sitting I the sink and pouring water into different cups and jars etc it's not one size fits all
And then there is also the fact that for many people with autism they have co morbidities

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 20:33

@claymodels

I thought that was normal, not the big numbers. I'm always telling DH off as he insists on talking to me when I'm on the phone, I can't cope with it.

Oh. Ok.

Well can you honestly have a proper conversation with someone on the phone and at the same time listen to someone telling you some news they want you to pass on? I honestly can't. I have to ask one of them to stop while I listen to the other.
BodgertheJogger · 20/11/2021 18:04

Yanbu, OP. I have severe adhd and i worry about this exact issue.
What I will say is that it comes down to the observer's own ignorance.
What one person with the 'same' disability can do is very different to what another can do. It's annoying when people can't understand that and I get it all the time but you can't force people to understand. Luckily the world is changing and becoming more aware.

tootyfruitypickle · 20/11/2021 18:02

@ofwarren thank you

One of the things with this is that if you get to your 50s undiagnosed, then you have an element of coping strategies . However I think for a lot of people it would reduce anxiety etc if you could understand why you had found simple things such as making friends so difficult throughout your life ?

The only thing I'd change perhaps is not to go to huge work sessions or 'do's , plus work remotely permanently - and a diagnosis may help with that - but I was increasingly self excluding anyway even before the pandemic as I had enough of trying to cope . I definitely am better wfh and going into the office does me no good at all.

A number of my family members and children have been diagnosed over the past 5 years so I have been trying to be less self critical and forcing myself to fit in as I've realised it's possible that this may explain a lot of things I find difficult .

Secondary school was hell and I'm so glad that children are having diagnoses at primary these days . I still can't believe no one picked up on me .

I

SpeedRunParent · 20/11/2021 17:58

It's essential that the notion of the autism spectrum is as widely understood as the condition is becoming known.
Autism is prevalent in my family (Nan,uncle,mum,husband,son) and they have as many ASC differences as they do commonalities. My step brother and friend's son also have a very different presentation of autism than those in my family.
The public perception of Autism has come quite a way but there is much further to go.
Take heart, we'll get there. You may find your buds has more understanding than you fear.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 20/11/2021 17:46

@THisbackwithavengeance

I'm a self diagnosed autistic.

My DD has a diagnosis. It took years to get.

It's so obvious I am autistic and my daughter inherited it from me: the more I read about it, the more obvious it becomes.

But so what?

I have a job, a decent life, a nice DH and kids. I don't need disability benefits. I don't see any point bothering a GP or overstretched NHS for a referral which will take fucking years even if if is taken seriously in the first place and will serve no purpose other than me being able to brandish a diagnosis like a medal.

It's my business. Known only to my DH and something I have only mentioned on here in a cloak of anonymity.

My not being diagnosed doesn't make my experience any less than others who've taken themselves off to a doctor or psychologist for "answers".

Your experience is less because your autism doesn’t affect you as badly as it affects other. Stop being so fucking offensive. I bet you have no problem blaming your rudeness and arseholery on your “autism.”
WithANameLikeDaniCalifornia · 20/11/2021 17:01

@Wowthemuggles

It upsets me because, standard thinks they might be autistic woman may go to their local NHS commissioned diagnostic service and not be diagnosed because they are not impared 'enough'. It's all put down to ADHD when really that is only the half of it. That's if they're lucky enough to have had a diagnosis of ADHD in the first place.

How can somebody who has done that well for themselves in life be 'impared enough' for a diagnosis.

I am not impaired enough for a diagnosis. I have to have massive amounts of help from family members. Don't qualify for help from Adult services, but could have quite easily had my children taken away from me due to me just finding the demands of raising young children so difficult.

I see threads on here regularly from.women wondering wether they are autistic and should pursue a diagnosis and I quite often feel compelled to tell them to go to the most expensive, highly regarded diagnostic centre that is available to them. Even if it means taken out a loan or save mg for years. When first referred to my local team a few years ago it was pre pandemic. If I was trying to get referred now I would feel out of order bothering my poor GP with something so mundane or self indulgent. I don't really think it is but this is the feeling Im getting at the moment about anything healthcare related that isn't going to immediately kill me.

Christine and Mel may be truly autistic. Whatever the hell that really means. I might be. They have been helped by their diagnosis and process. I would say I have definitely been hurt by my lack of diagnosis and even if I had received a diagnosis the process was so awful it would have still hurt me.

I may check back tonight but just as likely may not. I hope you get some more replies because I should really change my user name to onemessagewonder or some such.

I also hope no one is offended by anything I've written. I will not elaborate on anything as this has been outing enough as it is. Grin

🙄

You don’t get to decide what is mundane and self indulgent and how “impaired” someone is.

Your post is all over the place.

phonetica · 20/11/2021 16:58

My DS is autistic, was picked up very quickly by nursery and he was diagnosed young, he has a lot of very obvious ‘classic traits’ (the sort you see listed on websites etc) so it was pretty apparent.

I’m on a few parenting autism groups of Facebook and similar, there is such a huge range in children- some with kids aged 10 or older who cannot speak and still in nappies, many others with children who are able to attend mainstream school and meet ‘normal’ milestones. There are children the same age as my DS who are the opposite in every way yet share the same diagnosis. There’s huge variation. I guess it’s also complicated because nobody is actually sure what autism really IS or what causes it, it’s definition is the ‘traits’.

Now that my DS has been diagnosed and I’ve researched it, I certainly recognise a lot of the traits in myself and definitely my DH, I believe my DH would be diagnosed if he was assessed. Apparently the statistics are 1 in 60 children are diagnosed but I do wonder whether it’s actually a far more sizeable chunk of the population who are on the spectrum.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 16:56

I thought that was normal, not the big numbers. I'm always telling DH off as he insists on talking to me when I'm on the phone, I can't cope with it.

Oh. Ok.

ofwarren · 20/11/2021 16:53

Sorry, that was for @tootyfruitypickle

dabbydeedoo · 20/11/2021 16:52

@Caddycat what a nasty comment. Maybe she was giving an example of one of many things she struggles with? One that's relevant to her job?

ofwarren · 20/11/2021 16:52

It's around £1500 more or less

ancientgran · 20/11/2021 16:40

@claymodels

I felt very annoyed too. "I can't read big numbers" and "I can't listen to the director in my ear and talk to guests at the same time" is not representative of autism.

It is for some though. I can't listen and think/talk at the same time. I need one thing at a time

I thought that was normal, not the big numbers. I'm always telling DH off as he insists on talking to me when I'm on the phone, I can't cope with it. Funnily enough he can't either as I discovered when I played him at his own game.
RamonaFlowers1 · 20/11/2021 16:37

Haven't RTFT but I've seen some posts that resonate. I think there's a lot of misunderstanding about ASD and how it affects everyone differently. I was diagnosed with Asperger's a few months ago. I told my boss about it, and to be fair he was supportive, asking if I needed anything. But then he showed his ignorance when he referred to it as an illness in a handover report as I was moving teams. I got him to correct that!

I went private for my diagnosis, my mum doesn't understand why I didn't go NHS (it was because of the wait) or why I got assessed in the first place, but then she also doesn't believe the diagnosis. However, she also agrees she doesn't know much about it.

I don't see my Asperger's as a gift, a superpower or anything like that, just as an explanation for why my social skills are awful! They're better than they used to be, but it still takes a lot of effort!

Figgit · 20/11/2021 16:27

@Gentleness
Ultimately it helped me understand why I was - and felt - so different. Following my diagnosis no longer thought I was a wicked or bad person. I still struggle with aspects of how my ASD presents, but I no longer blame myself or feel shame. I’m far more accepting of myself and the person I am. I also mask lot less and it’s brought a sense of freedom to be who I am.
That’s not to say I haven’t faced challenges and discrimination, I have, but the mental health burden I’ve carried through my life has lightened enormously.