Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

if it's being posted to you.... it's not eco-friendly!

32 replies

Whose · 20/11/2021 08:59

My social media is full of ads for eco-friendly alternatives of everyday products; usually ones that have had their plastic packaging removed and are now in "pod" form.
Examples: laundry tablets, washing up liquid, deodorant, toothpaste.

Lots of BIG CLAIMS in BOLD FONT about how they're x% better for the environment and they are !!Plastic Free!! etc etc

.... and they're available by subscription, posted directly to you.

I love the fact the world is moving towards plastic free and that we are becoming more aware of buying thoughtfully. But AIBU to think that if you are taking a product that you'd usually be purchasing in your usual grocery shop, that having it mailed to you separately every month-3 months completely wipes out the environmental benefit? I can't find much info on it anywhere, but it seems like quite a glaring flaw?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Valeriekat · 20/11/2021 17:55

Yes, so often there is a lack of joined up thinking around this stuff (ie just marketing).

ReviewingTheSituation · 20/11/2021 13:20

Sadly there isn't the 'huge demand' for environmentally friendly products that we think there is. The majority of people just aren't prepared to make compromises (pay more, less convenience (eg pack format), changed product taste/performance) purely for the sake of an environmental benefit - there has to be something else in it for them. Sustainability/environmental issues are very low down the decision hierarchy for the vast majority.

I buy smol on subscription. I love that they're eco friendly. But my main reason for buying them was that they're fragrance free. I'm happy to pay a bit more for that (and the convenience of them being delivered so I never run out) and the eco stuff is a nice to have.

Honeymint · 20/11/2021 13:05

Subscriptions seem like a bit of a scam, but otherwise if it’s coming from within the country and it’s relatively in-bulk, some products could be better?

I wish there were more regulations on plastic packaging so we could buy without having to work out what’s best for the environment on an indivisible basis, it’d really de-stress shopping.

Mouseonmychair · 20/11/2021 12:35

I agree my dishwashing brush is 2 years old now. It's made of plastic but goes in the dishwasher to clean. The eco ones seem to degenerate much quicker.

Elephantsparade · 20/11/2021 12:28

I dont get why supermarkets havent twigged that there is a huge demand for environmentally friendly products and made it easier to identify them. I spend ages in the shop trying to weigh up pros and cons of well this in plastic, but this contains palm oil and this uses lots of fuel. A nice little traffic light stytem of carbon footprint would help.
Or just gathering all the 'eco' products in one isle as long as there is a verification of what makes them eco.

delilahbucket · 20/11/2021 12:20

I normally have my dishwasher tablets delivered to me by Amazon. I have just switched to Smol. I still get a delivery, but one which is much lighter and smaller and it goes on the postie's bag rather than needing a van delivering individually door to door. This is much better for the environment in many ways, not just the less plastic part.

Stevenage689 · 20/11/2021 12:12

The washing sheets are the size of a medium letter. About 1000 of these sheets would take up the same space as the pods that I used to buy in packs of 20. So you can take 50x more of them in one lorry. Therefore, provided the journey to the houses is less than 50x as long as the journeys to the supermarkets, it's reducing fuel use. And I am confident it is less than that. Royal mail are coming to my house anyway...

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 20/11/2021 12:02

These things will eventually make it to mainstream supermarkets if it can be shown by the manufacturers that there is huge demand. I would buy them to help demonstrate a general preference for more sustainable goods with well considered lifetime impact. This should pressure supermarkets into supplying them.

The greatest power individuals have is to use Keynesian economics to force change. If demand for better choices increases then that forces retailers to provide them. And then the cost goes down as supply increases, and gradually unsustainable choices no longer appear cheaper.

Yusanaim · 20/11/2021 11:56

...... and all the trees cut down to make the cardboard box it is carried in? and all the energy used to convert the trees to pulp, paper and cardboard......

the answer is to buy less in the first place.

purplesequins · 20/11/2021 11:52

'eco' packaging (paper/glass/tin) usually weighs more than plastic. and the weight alone of course costs more to transport.
plus unpackaged fresh foods spoil quicker.

but I agree I would actually want to see real life comparison for a 4 person household.

workwoes123 · 20/11/2021 11:20

What @EggsellentSmithers said.

I remember watching a Ted Talk by a sustainable design expert. She said that she was constantly getting requests from companies to design more 'sustainable' packaging for their products. When she investigated it, she found that - unless the proper recycling facilities are available - the paper packaging option was actually more carbon intensive than the plastic packaging option. The companies didn't want to know though, they weren't interested in considering the whole lifetime of the product: they just wanted it to look more eco-friendly so they could catch a little bit more of the market. Her talk taught me that the sustainability - and otherwise - of products and packaging is vastly more complicated than we think.

JollyJoon · 20/11/2021 11:14

Its simple:
If you live in a city then buying stuff online is not eco friendly
If you live rurally then buying stuff online is eco friendly

Tenfifteen · 20/11/2021 10:58

How do? Bit odd!

ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 20/11/2021 10:55

I agree that there is likely a harm vs benefit trade off to having eco friendly goods delivered, however I would need to see some actual data in order to believe that any benefit is entirely "wiped out". Intuitively I would still expect to see a net positive, especially if ordering in bulk, but if you have any numbers to share with us OP then I'm happy to be corrected.

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 10:02

It'll surely be travelling a shorter distance than if it's going to warehouses and shops before you go all the way out and back to take it home. And if it's going by Royal Mail rather than a courier, presumably it's on a delivery journey that would be made anyway. Does Royal Mail use electric vehicles?

I suppose there are too many unknown variables to be certain but for most people it would seem to be a greener option.

EggsellentSmithers · 20/11/2021 09:59

This is basically my DH job and it is far far more complex than you have made it. YABU

Summerfun54321 · 20/11/2021 09:44

Waste pollution and carbon pollution are two totally separate types of pollution and to say there’s no point reducing one if you can’t reduce both is over simplified.

PriamFarrl · 20/11/2021 09:35

How do you figure that?

Stuff from shops:
Stuff is delivered from manufacturers to distribution warehouse.
Stuff is then driven to the warehouses of various supermarkets. Each supermarket having warehouses up and down the country. So lots of lorry journeys.
Each warehouse then sends a lorry to drive the product to each store. Let’s take Sainsbury’s, that’s just over 1000 stores.
Then the customer gets in their car to drive to the store.

Posted:
Stuff arrives at warehouse from the manufacturer (assuming they aren’t the one and same).
Stuff then has a label stuck on it and put in the post.
Yes lorries will be involved in that but I’m not sure how many.
Arrives in my door.

BeyondMyWits · 20/11/2021 09:33

The best thing we can do for the environment is use the Internet less... it is growing non green sector. Every search produces minute amounts of greenhouse gases, every click onto a website. The massive server farms are multiplying. The power, the cooling etc etc...

Yes I'm a hypocrite, but don't let's pretend that using the Internet for anything makes us eco friendly, if you can only buy online you are relying on advertising and millions of people making millions of clicks.

Sparklfairy · 20/11/2021 09:30

Surely the carbon footprint of delivering it is mostly divided by the number of deliveries being made in the area as the courier/royal mail would be there anyway? I was shocked having something delivered to my DM, who lives rurally. The app showed where the van was - 3 min walk away - and he was still 11 stops away.

ReviewingTheSituation · 20/11/2021 09:29

Plus a lot of them will be made in the UK (inc ingredients/components), so much shorter journeys overall.

ReviewingTheSituation · 20/11/2021 09:27

The net transport is way lower! Straight from factory to home, rather than factory to store depot to store to home.

motherheroic · 20/11/2021 09:27

One van/car delivering goods is more eco friendly than multiple single cars traveling to pick up said goods.

PinkPlantCase · 20/11/2021 09:26

Tbh I think that one of the best thing we can do for the environment is to buy less.

So buy the things you actually need in bulk or the biggest packaging you have space for. (Less packaging and fewer deliveries)

Sunshine1066 · 20/11/2021 09:25

It depends where it's shipped from. Supermarket stuff is held in warehouses first, then lorried in, then an individual car journey to go and get it (in most cases).

If the eco stuff is in a warehouse and then directly posted, surely it's the same if not less miles? I'd read somewhere that- depending on how it's done - getting stuff delivered is better because one van goes to lots of houses, rather than all those houses making lots of trips. There's also the carbon footprint of storing a large item compared to a small one.

Tbh I don't think most people know and you just have to do the best according to what makes most sense to you.

But I do find some of the eco adverts irritating - I saw one the other day for "bio cloths" that you have to throw away after 3 months into the compost (where they will decompose and give off gases), then buy new ones with the carbon footprint from constant manufacturing, as opposed to my nice cheap cloths that are 2 or 3 years old now and I wash when dirty with other household items on an eco wash (ie they are not adding a huge amount to the load).