Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t treat a prisoner like this?

233 replies

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 08:51

www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1523361/Robert-Maudsley-killer-die-Wakefield-Prison-glass-box/amp

A concrete slab to sleep on, no television, no music? Surely that’s just not right?

OP posts:
Anotherlovelybitofsquirrel · 20/11/2021 11:16

It's disgusting. They don't treat child abusers and child murderers this way. But they should. He rid the world of trash. The way he's treated is sickening.

KurtWilde · 20/11/2021 11:15

@DrSbaitso because he didn't attack staff Confused

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 11:14

It is all very interesting. On the face of it of course no one should be kept like that, but when you hear from prison staff about why it might be it's hard to see an alternative.

What is striking is the huge cost there must be in detaining him like this.

If only we could put similar sums into protecting and supporting our most vulnerable children and young people, we might not need such facilities. But I dare say he was a "delinquent" child/teen who no one wanted their children to play with and none one felt should get any special treatment. Certainly "people" aren't going to vote for spending more on helping troubled teens, but harsh prison sentences are somehow popular.

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 11:13

[quote KurtWilde]@Nomorepies staff were never at risk from him. [/quote]
How so?

KurtWilde · 20/11/2021 11:12

Maudsley didn't just murder child offenders, he murdered ordinary people. Let's not forget that.

He killed his client Mr Farrell - the man you're referencing - when he showed Richard pictures of children he'd abused. Nothing 'ordinary' about that guy.

Sofiegiraffe · 20/11/2021 11:10

@Puttingthekettleon

I don’t think giving him a remote control and a TV, and some books, is putting other prisoners or guards at risk, *@Nomorepies*

Weapons can be fashioned out of anything in prisons, including a plastic remote control. The pages of books are often used by prisoners to conceal weapons, too. A prisoner intent on causing harm to others can be incredibly resourceful. I say this with "inside" knowledge having worked in numerous prisons.

KurtWilde · 20/11/2021 11:09

@Nomorepies staff were never at risk from him.

Yourstupidityexhaustsme · 20/11/2021 11:08

'But Maudsley, who suffered years of abuse at the hands of his father as a child, had murdered his first victim, Mr Farrell, when he was just 21 in the early '70s.

Maudsley had turned to sex to earn money but killed Mr Farrell, his client, in Wood Green, north London.'

Maudsley didn't just murder child offenders, he murdered ordinary people. Let's not forget that.

That being said, this is torture and as a cultured and democratic society I find this treatment abhorrent. What the solution is however, I'm not sure.

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 11:07

@Puttingthekettleon

I don’t think giving him a remote control and a TV, and some books, is putting other prisoners or guards at risk, *@Nomorepies*
It is though - it’s putting him at risk (because he could swallow the batteries) and when he’s known to be an exceptionally violent man, who’s to say how he’ll react when the guards come in to save his life? Would you risk it?
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 11:06

[quote Puttingthekettleon]@Saucery isn’t being at all ridiculous.

Technology in 1983 is a bit different to now. Wouldn’t you agree?[/quote]
I absolutely would! It’s completely different!

How do they fit an Alexa to his cell?

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 11:04

I don’t think giving him a remote control and a TV, and some books, is putting other prisoners or guards at risk, @Nomorepies

OP posts:
Nomorepies · 20/11/2021 11:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 11:02

I do however think Robert Maudsley should be allowed to die.

That would necessitate legalising assisted suicide. I'm not saying that should or should not happen, but it's a massive and very complex issue that would need many rounds of drafting and consultation before the law could be passed (campaigners haven't managed it yet). And of all the arguments in its favour, it being the wish of an incredibly dangerous and violent man is probably one of the worst.

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 10:59

@Saucery isn’t being at all ridiculous.

Technology in 1983 is a bit different to now. Wouldn’t you agree?

OP posts:
Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 10:59

I don’t see the problem here

You don’t see the problem? What the hell?

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 10:58

@Saucery

Can you answer my questions first

I have. The same procedures they use for exercise, medical attention etc. I done work there so I’m afraid I can’t produce the exact processes they use, or the Risk Assessments Hmm
Neither do I know precisely how they fit the Alexa button in my Firestick. Only that it is there, it exists and someone put it there. Smile

And you don’t need to respond, as your replies to me have a distinct whiff of Goad about them, so…… 🤷‍♀️

I think it’s more you realise how ridiculous your comment was. They can’t fit anything to his cell because there’s nowhere else for him to do in the meantime. They can’t have more guards protecting him because that then puts more guards at risk. There will be certain times he’ll need physical contact with guards - but those will be individually planned and risk assessed, not to mention will have staff trained to deal with that exact situation (toilet trips/exercise).

There will be nothing stopping him smashing his head off the concrete block but it’s likely his guards will be trained for exactly that eventuality. How do you train guards to, say, help him cough up the Alexa he’s ripped off the wall and eaten? What if he rips it off every single day, and punches a guard in the process? Every day?

If you give it two seconds of thought you’d soon start to see the pitfalls. He’s not being punished - he’s being (legally, and horribly) protected.

Thelnebriati · 20/11/2021 10:57

YANBU. What he has done is irrelevant, this is a human rights abuse. No one should have to live in an empty cell with nothing but a concrete slab. Not even the worst kind of criminal.
This is the kind of treatment I'd expect to see in regimes investigated by Amnesty International.

claymodels · 20/11/2021 10:54

@Motnight

https://news.sky.com/story/autistic-girl-who-was-locked-up-24-7-now-loves-hair-dye-gardening-and-fishing-one-year-on-12087199

Most of us have little idea of what happens in the UK either in the name of justice or protection.

She should never have been locked up, obviously, but that's where the similarities end.

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 10:53

@SweeneyPlodd

There is a good documentary on YouTube about Robert, he was severely abused as a child and killed one person after being shown photos of children he was abusing. He handed himself in to police straight away hoping he would get the help he needed. Instead they threw him in broadmore with peadophiles and sex offenders. It was a recipe for disaster.

One of the interesting things said on the documentary was:
Robert was not a serial killer until he went to prison.

I don’t understand why that quote is significant. He had an appalling childhood and is very clearly a very damaged man. But he had killed before he went to prison, who’s to say he wouldn’t have been a serial killer outside of prison?
Saucery · 20/11/2021 10:53

don’t work there…..

Saucery · 20/11/2021 10:53

Can you answer my questions first

I have. The same procedures they use for exercise, medical attention etc. I done work there so I’m afraid I can’t produce the exact processes they use, or the Risk Assessments Hmm
Neither do I know precisely how they fit the Alexa button in my Firestick. Only that it is there, it exists and someone put it there. Smile

And you don’t need to respond, as your replies to me have a distinct whiff of Goad about them, so…… 🤷‍♀️

CounsellorTroi · 20/11/2021 10:53

Does he have clothes? He could harm himself with those.

EllaVaNight · 20/11/2021 10:53

He was failed as a child. Terribly failed. That doesn't excuse what he did, whoever he did it to. I would rather my rapist and the person who sexually abused me as a child be locked up for the rest of their lives rather than killed. Death is too easy for them.

I do however think Robert Maudsley should be allowed to die. He isn't beyond help. But he is beyond the help which could be accessed in prison.

wombat1a · 20/11/2021 10:52

If he is solitary confinement then he still has interaction with the guards, with medical people, with inspectors etc etc and therefore could use any item in his cell (including cardboard furniture) to attack them.

The obvious solution: to remove all items from his cell so he can not use them to create weapons to harm a) the guards b) other inmates and c) himself.

I don't see what the problem is here?

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 10:52

Even if you think good riddance to the people he killed, are you glad about the staff who have to deal with the aftermath? Both what they see and the process they'll have to go though about how they didn't prevent it?