Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t treat a prisoner like this?

233 replies

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 08:51

www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1523361/Robert-Maudsley-killer-die-Wakefield-Prison-glass-box/amp

A concrete slab to sleep on, no television, no music? Surely that’s just not right?

OP posts:
saveourtrees · 20/11/2021 12:14

@Bumblenums1234

I was going to say good but then I read his motivations for killing people were because they were showing pictures of kids they had abused and a man who murdered his wife.

Why aren't we treating the child abusers and women killers like this? Oh yeah, because women and children's lives are worth less.

I've always thought 'no that just can't be right' but I'm reality it seems it is true.

I don't blame him, I really dont.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 20/11/2021 12:13

@AnnaMagnani

An Alexa

So funny, do you think there is Wifi in prisons? It's basic that there are no mobile phones or internet access in prisons. Fucking Alexa, the naivety.

I think if a prisoner is deemed to need to be held in these conditions then the authorities should be required to do everything possible to make it as bearable as possible for him. I'm sure it would be far beyond the normal facilities, but he's essentially being tortured. No-one could bear to live like that. Saying it's for his own protection isn't good enough. This is inhuman.
Veeveeoxox · 20/11/2021 12:10

TVs can be smashed and use the screen pieces to make an improvised weapon the electrical cord can be used to strangle yourself or others. Batteries can be swallowed

DeliriaSkibbly · 20/11/2021 12:10

I think this is a very difficult situation and the people reaction with 'He deserves a medal' and similar are, frankly, one of the reasons our society is such a mess.

If we could, somehow, move away from the baying of Daily Mail and Daily Express journalists demanding that people are hanged for just about any conceivable crime and look at countries where they have a successful justice and prison system we might all do a lot better.

Being deprived of your liberty is punishment enough. If you look at countries like Norway or Finland, where they have much better prison regimes they have far less recidivism, which is surely the most desirable outcome ? Leaving any moral questions to one side, it's just cheaper. Keeping someone in prison is very expensive. Helping someone to live a more fulfilling and constructive life when they leave prison is cheaper in every way and better in every way. But until we can move past this mob mentality of wanting to put the boot in I fear nothing will change.

In this particular case I feel very sorry for the man involved - it's quite clear he's had a troubled life and a poor upbringing. I don't have all the answers, but I cannot believe that keeping someone incarcerated like this on a permanent basis is either helpful or desirable. It reflects badly on us as a whole and speaks volumes to us as a so-called civilised society.

Veeveeoxox · 20/11/2021 12:06

I work in secure hospitals and frequently nurse people in seclusion. They have a mattress on the floor strong rip proof bedding and clothing recently 6 of us had to go in while being hit , punched and spat at, we had to give the patient an IM and take the improvised weapon which was a plastic bottle lid with the edges sharpened.

Some people will literally make weapons out of anything it would have been risk assessed and risk assessed and sadly Robert is just too dangerous to other prisoners and the staff to be let out of seclusion.

Sofiegiraffe · 20/11/2021 12:01

@AnnaMagnani

Had to think for a bit on the books but - tear them up, shove them down the loo, instant dirty protest.

Am sure there are other ways to create chaos with books if you are so minded.

Concealment of fashioned weapons. It's a common tactic used by prisoners.

AnnaMagnani · 20/11/2021 12:00

Had to think for a bit on the books but - tear them up, shove them down the loo, instant dirty protest.

Am sure there are other ways to create chaos with books if you are so minded.

wombat1a · 20/11/2021 11:54

@Puttingthekettleon

I don’t think giving him a remote control and a TV, and some books, is putting other prisoners or guards at risk, *@Nomorepies*
And that is the essential problem here, you don't see this is putting other people at risk. However those that deal with this man and others like him i.e. those with experience so know this could be the cause of someone getting serious and life-changingly hurt.
Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 20/11/2021 11:51

@IamtheDevilsAvocado

The punishment is losing their freedom.

Treating them inhumanely doesn't reflect well on society.

We don't want to be a society of kangaroo courts / tortuous treatment of prisoners.

I agree, but these conditions will be because of how uncontrollably violent he is. It is absolutely horrible though. But what can they do? Tbh the most humane thing to do would be to allow him to choose to die, but the law doesn't allow that. I'm surprised really that he's in prison and not somewhere like Rampton, but he must have been assessed. Poor guy.
AnnaMagnani · 20/11/2021 11:48

An Alexa

So funny, do you think there is Wifi in prisons? It's basic that there are no mobile phones or internet access in prisons. Fucking Alexa, the naivety.

knittingaddict · 20/11/2021 11:48

@Atozofpoodles

He deserves a medal not this.
No, he doesn't.

There is no place in this world for vigilante killing. That isn't something members of the public should ever be involved in. The official systems aren't perfect, but they are trained people with checks and balances in place. Vigilantes don't have that.

Also we don't have capital punishment in this country for a reason. Most people don't support state killing, so why would we support random people taking it into their own hands.

I also think that you have to like killing people to act like this. Having an excuse is just that, an excuse.

Funnylittlefloozie · 20/11/2021 11:44

It may report serious issues, but in this case its blatantly wrong.

SexyNeckbeard · 20/11/2021 11:43

@ilovesooty

They have to have contact with him to take him out for exercise. If he hasn't attacked a guard it doesn't mean that he never will.
Apparently as many as 6 (I also read 4) guards take him for his exercise so they must think he's incredibly dangerous
Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 11:42

I was led to them from my local paper which I’m sure is also shit. But a shit newspaper doesn’t mean it won’t report serious issues (case in point daily mail.)

OP posts:
SexyNeckbeard · 20/11/2021 11:41

@Funnylittlefloozie

This is absolutely bullshit. Maudsley hasn't been in that cell for YEARS. Yes he was in it for a while, but not any more.

Totally shit "journalism" from a totally shit "newspaper"

Where is he now? I've just been reading some articles about him but they're not that up to date
Yearonebesties · 20/11/2021 11:41

Don’t believe everything you read.

Moonbabysmum · 20/11/2021 11:37

It sounds to me like he to be held in specialist accomodation, given the risk he poses, but I cant see why he shouldn't have access to a tv, or an alexa - both of which could be physically outside his cell. He could control the tv with his voice.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 20/11/2021 11:36

There are quite a few prisoner YouTube channels that give some insight into different prison systems as well as the considerations for various security considerations and maximum security estate.

This US one is a gifted story teller: www.youtube.com/c/JayWilliamsLetsLiveLife

Someone can probably recommend some UK ones.

AnnaMagnani · 20/11/2021 11:35

You have no knowledge of whether he has attacked an officer or not. Numerous attacks on officers take place every day which don't attract criminal charges.

All the information you have is his sad story given to the Express. I am sure the prison would have more information which might be less flattering about how he behaves on a daily basis but they are bound by confidentiality so they are unable to share it.

Funnylittlefloozie · 20/11/2021 11:34

This is absolutely bullshit. Maudsley hasn't been in that cell for YEARS. Yes he was in it for a while, but not any more.

Totally shit "journalism" from a totally shit "newspaper"

Lovemusic33 · 20/11/2021 11:27

[quote KurtWilde]@Nomorepies staff were never at risk from him. [/quote]
So you would happily be alone with him in a cell? Would be happy to be in a room with him?

I do agree that it’s no way to keep someone, he should be allowed to die which is what he wants. But I do agree that he’s a risk to staff and prisoners, so if he’s not allowed to end his life what are they supposed to do? He has none of the things he is asking for because these items could be turned into something he can use to end his life (or someone else’s)? He’s killed a number of people and not just killed them, he has butchered them. I for one wouldn’t want to be working with him.

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 11:27

He rid the world of trash.

Who gets to decide of whom to rid the world?

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 11:26

[quote KurtWilde]@DrSbaitso because he didn't attack staff Confused[/quote]
That doesn't mean there was no risk that he would.

AnnaMagnani · 20/11/2021 11:26

I don’t think giving him a remote control and a TV, and some books, is putting other prisoners or guards at risk

It is if he swallows the batteries every single day, then has to go to hospital as a medical emergency with all the associated officers, be examined and treated by medical staff, anyone of whom he might decide was a paedophile and try to assault and so on and so forth...

Or if he smashed up the TV, used the pieces as a weapon or to self harm, then needed to go to hospital, rinse and repeat...

SweeneyPlodd · 20/11/2021 11:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.