I think this is a very difficult situation and the people reaction with 'He deserves a medal' and similar are, frankly, one of the reasons our society is such a mess.
If we could, somehow, move away from the baying of Daily Mail and Daily Express journalists demanding that people are hanged for just about any conceivable crime and look at countries where they have a successful justice and prison system we might all do a lot better.
Being deprived of your liberty is punishment enough. If you look at countries like Norway or Finland, where they have much better prison regimes they have far less recidivism, which is surely the most desirable outcome ? Leaving any moral questions to one side, it's just cheaper. Keeping someone in prison is very expensive. Helping someone to live a more fulfilling and constructive life when they leave prison is cheaper in every way and better in every way. But until we can move past this mob mentality of wanting to put the boot in I fear nothing will change.
In this particular case I feel very sorry for the man involved - it's quite clear he's had a troubled life and a poor upbringing. I don't have all the answers, but I cannot believe that keeping someone incarcerated like this on a permanent basis is either helpful or desirable. It reflects badly on us as a whole and speaks volumes to us as a so-called civilised society.