Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t treat a prisoner like this?

233 replies

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 08:51

www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1523361/Robert-Maudsley-killer-die-Wakefield-Prison-glass-box/amp

A concrete slab to sleep on, no television, no music? Surely that’s just not right?

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 20/11/2021 13:11

@YoComoManzanas

I imagine the parents of the 7yo girl Bill Roberts molested thought he did a good job....? Very tricky. Theres no reason why he couldn't have a tv played outside the viewing screen and music controlled by an alexa or similar. He would probably be safe to put in a womens prison too. Very tricky case and it seems he has been failed as a youngster. Also don't trust the daily express reporting though. Hmm. Thought provoking case.
Shall we do that and check if the women will be ok? Ffs. Unfuckingbelievable.
Cordyceps · 20/11/2021 13:08

Prisons in most Northern European countries are incredibly humane, allowing prisoners to cook their own food, decorate their cells, have TV and (restricted/monitored) internet, etc. They also have the lowest re-offending rates in the world.
If your goal is to rehabilitate criminals and protect potential future victims, you treat them as humans - the punishment is loss of freedom, that doesn't have to include mental torture. Unless of course the cruelty is the point, which does seem to be the case for many people.

Funnylittlefloozie · 20/11/2021 13:07

There might be the technology out there, but there absolutely is not the money! Also, there is no WiFi in prisons so any amazingly clever WiFi enabled ideas are simply silly suggestions.

It is perfectly possible to put a TV in a place where a very vulnerable prisoner can watch it, but not have physical access to it. Anyone who is that unwell is likely to have a prison officer supervising them constantly, so the officer can change the channel etc.

aprilanne · 20/11/2021 13:05

I read a book on the psychiatrist who treated him and the first victim maudsley killed in prison. They actually flayed him peeled the skin of him before they hung him .yes he was a child abuser and yes he deserved punishment. But such sick acts is why maudsley can never be released or with general prison population.

Moonbabysmum · 20/11/2021 13:04

Where is the money coming from to provide it to a violent prisoner? Where is the WiFi coming feom?

A custom made cell. An entire team effort job it is to solely look after him. 6 guards needed to escort him for 1hr for exercise each day.

I think a few hundred quid so he can at least listen to music is a drop in the ocean isn't it.

DaisyandSimeon · 20/11/2021 13:04

Its clearly because he is a danger to himself and others. A matress or wooden furniture would be ways to kill himself or injure others.

Its an extreme case so I think extreme circumstances. Prisoners are not normally treated in this way.

Saucery · 20/11/2021 12:59

don’t recognise your username, do you namechange a lot?
Nope. Feel free to check with AS or MNHQ Smile

I understand you don’t want this man to have any sort of entertainment whatsoever, not even the basics that other prisoners have. I also understand the reasons why the usual access to such entertainments aren’t possible. However, there is technology out there to make it possible. Whether you feel he should have access to it, or indeed whether I feel he should, is neither here nor there.

That’s the last time I’m going to respond to you, Pumps. Go get your jollies somewhere else.

FrankGrillosWrist · 20/11/2021 12:57

I’d release him so he could continue.

Nomorepies · 20/11/2021 12:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 12:51

@Saucery

Oh bless you, Pumpy love, don’t lower yourself to beg a stranger on the Internet Grin

I didn’t mention WiFi. I said something like an Alexa button on a Firestick, not give him Sky and Netflix subscriptions. As in, a nearly flat, recessed, sealed button flush with a solid surface. Dig it out, the connecting wires drop backwards, no opportunity for getting them.
Maybe a university electronics dept could do it as a project. It would have applications beyond this one, after all.

I also didn’t not say it was cost free technology. I didn’t put any monetary value to it, so not sure why you are throwing that in. Setting up a bullet-proof cell with surveillance round the clock isn’t cheap, I bet, yet we appear to be paying/have paid for that.

Loving your work, btw. Seen you in action in other Topics deliberately targeting individual posters and making shit up that you pretend they said. How honoured I am to be part of you passing the time of day with such dogged persistence Flowers

So going by your logic - we don’t have to come up with any ways he could get entertainment, we just have to suggest ways he could be entertained - why don’t we send in an entire film crew and he could be the star of his own movie? Why don’t we give him his own library and home cinema system?

I don’t recognise your username, do you namechange a lot?

LagunaBubbles · 20/11/2021 12:51

How could he harm himself with paperback books?

Easy. Rip the pages out, scrunch them up and then use them to choke or suffocate to death. I'm a Psychiatric Nurse and I know someone who did this. Would love to see all the people on this thread with their outrage and cries of inhumane etc etc a tially work in prison or secure hospital with someone like this guy and see what they would say then.

Saucery · 20/11/2021 12:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

JurgensCakeBaby · 20/11/2021 12:45

@DeliriaSkibbly have you been inside Norwegian prisons? I have (for professional reasons) for many they are more liberal than in the UK however they still use restraint to contain (beds with leather straps) for significant period of time and subcontract much worse prisons in other countries for lower level or immigrant offenders who are transported there. Not every prison in Norway is like Halden, in fact most are not.

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 12:40

@Tal45

Euthanasia should be legal in the country IMO, to people with terminal illness, with very painful conditions that have no cure, those who develop dementia (if they request it before/early on) and prisoners with with no chance of release. It's just cruel to make people live with/through all these things if they don't want because some people don't like the idea of euthanasia for themselves - that's fine! but give others the choice.

That people with terrible conditions go to court begging to be allowed to die and told no because it's not legal is just awful IMO. The same for this guy who was terribly abused as a child including he says being raped, took drugs and was a sex worker as a teen and then killed someone who showed him pictures of children he abused - and turned himself in straight away to the police. What an awful life he's had, he's gone about taking some awful people off the streets in completely the wrong way but give the man some peace now. Then there'll be no worries that he might kill anyone else.

I agree with euthanasia. But you’re on shaky ground introducing that kind of choice to prisoners. Think of Wayne Couzens, does he get to just escape his life (and his punishment) after what he did? It’s not an easy conversation.
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 12:38

@Saucery

Oh good lord, the technology exists for recessed speakers and voice activated speakers already. No one is asking for funding to put him on the Moon.
Where is the money coming from to provide it to a violent prisoner? Where is the WiFi coming feom?

I’m literally begging you, think about it for four seconds.

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 12:36

@Tal45

Euthanasia should be legal in the country IMO, to people with terminal illness, with very painful conditions that have no cure, those who develop dementia (if they request it before/early on) and prisoners with with no chance of release. It's just cruel to make people live with/through all these things if they don't want because some people don't like the idea of euthanasia for themselves - that's fine! but give others the choice.

That people with terrible conditions go to court begging to be allowed to die and told no because it's not legal is just awful IMO. The same for this guy who was terribly abused as a child including he says being raped, took drugs and was a sex worker as a teen and then killed someone who showed him pictures of children he abused - and turned himself in straight away to the police. What an awful life he's had, he's gone about taking some awful people off the streets in completely the wrong way but give the man some peace now. Then there'll be no worries that he might kill anyone else.

This is so rational and yet also completely impossible Sad
Saucery · 20/11/2021 12:35

Oh good lord, the technology exists for recessed speakers and voice activated speakers already. No one is asking for funding to put him on the Moon.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 20/11/2021 12:34

@RecentYears

I think if a prisoner is deemed to need to be held in these conditions then the authorities should be required to do everything possible to make it as bearable as possible for him. I'm sure it would be far beyond the normal facilities, but he's essentially being tortured. No-one could bear to live like that. Saying it's for his own protection isn't good enough. This is inhuman.

So you're going to give the very worst prisoners the ability to communicate with and direct things in the outside world, but not the others? Grin

No, I'm not a fucking expert in how to provide mental stimulation for people in solitary confinement. I'm saying the people responsible need to do everything possible to make the situation as bearable as possible.

Pleased to give you a little bit of amusement anyway, clearly torturing the mentally disturbed is no biggie for you Hmm

Tal45 · 20/11/2021 12:30

Euthanasia should be legal in the country IMO, to people with terminal illness, with very painful conditions that have no cure, those who develop dementia (if they request it before/early on) and prisoners with with no chance of release. It's just cruel to make people live with/through all these things if they don't want because some people don't like the idea of euthanasia for themselves - that's fine! but give others the choice.

That people with terrible conditions go to court begging to be allowed to die and told no because it's not legal is just awful IMO. The same for this guy who was terribly abused as a child including he says being raped, took drugs and was a sex worker as a teen and then killed someone who showed him pictures of children he abused - and turned himself in straight away to the police. What an awful life he's had, he's gone about taking some awful people off the streets in completely the wrong way but give the man some peace now. Then there'll be no worries that he might kill anyone else.

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 12:28

@Moonbabysmum

So funny, do you think there is Wifi in prisons? It's basic that there are no mobile phones or internet access in prisons. Fucking Alexa, the naivety.

Not naive. I have visited many prisons.

If they can construct a special cell for him, then the to can work out how he can access a tv with his voice using commonly available technology.

Keeping him without any entertainment for the rest of his life is not a humane option.

This is getting more and more mad as the thread goes on - with what money are they putting this research in for this particular violent prisoner?
Moonbabysmum · 20/11/2021 12:27

So funny, do you think there is Wifi in prisons? It's basic that there are no mobile phones or internet access in prisons. Fucking Alexa, the naivety.

Not naive. I have visited many prisons.

If they can construct a special cell for him, then the to can work out how he can access a tv with his voice using commonly available technology.

Keeping him without any entertainment for the rest of his life is not a humane option.

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 12:25

I think if a prisoner is deemed to need to be held in these conditions then the authorities should be required to do everything possible to make it as bearable as possible for him. I'm sure it would be far beyond the normal facilities, but he's essentially being tortured. No-one could bear to live like that. Saying it's for his own protection isn't good enough. This is inhuman.

So you're going to give the very worst prisoners the ability to communicate with and direct things in the outside world, but not the others? Grin

Funnylittlefloozie · 20/11/2021 12:21

The overwhelming majority of prisoners, even those who have murdered other prisoners, are not held in this exceptional situation. Prisoners who have murdered other prisoners are usually held in special units, where obviously they have minimal contact with other prisoners and a high staff-prisoner ratio, but the units are not these perspex box-style cages, and the prisoners are in normal cells.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 20/11/2021 12:17

@AnnaMagnani

Had to think for a bit on the books but - tear them up, shove them down the loo, instant dirty protest.

Am sure there are other ways to create chaos with books if you are so minded.

I have mh problems and I do actually know of a man locally who did manage to kill himself using toilet paper.
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 12:15

@Theythinkitsalloveritisnow what do you suggest?