Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t treat a prisoner like this?

233 replies

Puttingthekettleon · 20/11/2021 08:51

www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1523361/Robert-Maudsley-killer-die-Wakefield-Prison-glass-box/amp

A concrete slab to sleep on, no television, no music? Surely that’s just not right?

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 15:31

@plumsageplum

Why do people think statements like this make them better humans? It's so facile.

I don't think it makes me a "better human", that's a strange assumption. I just feel a certain way about it. I recognise it's a position that is mostly unworkable and has all sorts of detrimental effects, but I can't lie and say I feel sad when a child molester is murdered or assaulted, I feel glad. Tbh, people who can feel that way and still hold to to the principles and ethics of our civilised society are probably the ""better"" humans.

Yes, they are. Think about that, and think about why.

An case for straightforward death penalty or lashing, much as I would passionately disagree with it, would arguably make more sense. At least it involves following due process and doesn't give carte blanche to vigilantes to take it upon themselves to decide who lives and who dies, validated by those who don't care about prisoners' safety.

You should care about prisoners' safety, even the worst of them, because to disregard that is to disregard the principles and safeguards that uphold our legal system. The principles amd safeguards that prevent any random person from appointing themselves judge, jury and executioner to someone else. That doesn't mean you have to shed tears if a child molester is killed, but you should care, because their safety is tied up in what is supposed to protect ALL of us.

plumsageplum · 20/11/2021 15:24

Why do people think statements like this make them better humans? It's so facile.

I don't think it makes me a "better human", that's a strange assumption. I just feel a certain way about it. I recognise it's a position that is mostly unworkable and has all sorts of detrimental effects, but I can't lie and say I feel sad when a child molester is murdered or assaulted, I feel glad. Tbh, people who can feel that way and still hold to to the principles and ethics of our civilised society are probably the ""better"" humans.

PinkSyCo · 20/11/2021 15:22

I usually despair that certain prisoners in the UK are treated far too leniently, but I am truly shocked at the treatment of this man! He should be secluded yes, but he should also be given psychiatric help, a comfy place to rest and something to do with his time. His treatment is barbaric and he is being failed dreadfully, just as he has been his whole life. So sad.

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 15:20

@plumsageplum

Because it’s illegal. The prison guards have to keep him alive.

Yes, I am aware, my argument is that it should not be illegal.

How about caring about the ethics, principles and safeguards of a supposedly civilised society with a legal system?

Not for child molesters, no.

So who else in our society should get no protection for their life, in your opinion? And who gets to appoint themselves judge, jury and executioner? And what safeguards should we have for people's lives, and how do we decide when they don't apply?

Why do people think statements like this make them better humans? It's so facile.

plumsageplum · 20/11/2021 15:16

Because it’s illegal. The prison guards have to keep him alive.

Yes, I am aware, my argument is that it should not be illegal.

How about caring about the ethics, principles and safeguards of a supposedly civilised society with a legal system?

Not for child molesters, no.

DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 15:01

@plumsageplum

Let him kill himself? Obviously not that, so what?

Why not? If he's going to be spending the rest of his life in prison, under these conditions, what's the point in living?

other prisoners have a right to be safe.
Can't find myself caring too much about whether pedophiles are safe in prison.

How about caring about the ethics, principles and safeguards of a supposedly civilised society with a legal system?
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 15:00

@plumsageplum

Let him kill himself? Obviously not that, so what?

Why not? If he's going to be spending the rest of his life in prison, under these conditions, what's the point in living?

other prisoners have a right to be safe.
Can't find myself caring too much about whether pedophiles are safe in prison.

Because it’s illegal. The prison guards have to keep him alive.
DrSbaitso · 20/11/2021 15:00

@fucketyfuckwit

I would let him and all the peados in a room together and let them crack on.
Great username.
plumsageplum · 20/11/2021 14:59

Let him kill himself? Obviously not that, so what?

Why not? If he's going to be spending the rest of his life in prison, under these conditions, what's the point in living?

other prisoners have a right to be safe.
Can't find myself caring too much about whether pedophiles are safe in prison.

DameAlyson · 20/11/2021 14:37

I would let him and all the peados in a room together and let them crack on.

Will you be volunteering to go in and clear up the mess afterwards, or do you propose to leave it to prison staff, emergency personnel, medical practitioners?

Itsnotallaboutyoubaby · 20/11/2021 14:19

Yes the sooner euthanasia is allowed the better

fucketyfuckwit · 20/11/2021 14:18

I would let him and all the peados in a room together and let them crack on.

keepingthisanon · 20/11/2021 14:14

@StoneofDestiny

There is a lot of naivety about what a prisoner can weaponise against themselves or others. They can use anything - paper to choke themselves on - bits of TV’s to Jill themselves with. This man was able to kill in a secure mental hospital - that is why he is where he is. Prison officers must be protected - they have done no wrong, yet spend every day of their working lives ‘at risk’ of assault or worse. They are an underpaid and undervalued profession who are keeping us all safe - so their safety is paramount.

This prisoner cannot be allowed to kill or injure other prisoners either - their punishment is to lose their liberty - not to be attacked by vigilante thugs or murderers.

I won't give specifics in case someone recognises the incident but the most creative piece of weaponary I know of on a secure unit was a food item. Resulted in a death. There are so many 'how could x be used as a weapon' on this thread....just...trust the posters who are saying...you'd be surprised.
Sofiegiraffe · 20/11/2021 14:02

@Veeveeoxox

I work in secure hospitals and frequently nurse people in seclusion. They have a mattress on the floor strong rip proof bedding and clothing recently 6 of us had to go in while being hit , punched and spat at, we had to give the patient an IM and take the improvised weapon which was a plastic bottle lid with the edges sharpened.

Some people will literally make weapons out of anything it would have been risk assessed and risk assessed and sadly Robert is just too dangerous to other prisoners and the staff to be let out of seclusion.

I'm in a similar field of work; this is spot on. The restrictions placed upon him will have been the result of a very detailed and specific risk assessment.
OhWhyNot · 20/11/2021 13:36

The allowing people to take their own life is a subject that needs to be talked about more

Many still hold the view that people who take their own life are mentally unwell at the time

This isn’t the case and we need to accept some people are able to make a sound judgement on their own life and this isn’t influenced but how much money they have

Shehasadiamondinthesky I am not at all surprised you have made this decision given what you have seen some experience

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 20/11/2021 13:30

That's what happens with uncontrollable prisoners I'm afraid. I worked in the prison service for 7 years.
They are just so dangerous and unpredictable they end up like this.
Unfortunately the UK is determined that nobody will be allowed to commit either suicide or have euthanasia so this is the result.
Prisons operate the same way that nursing homes do - keep them alive at all costs no matter what mental or physical pain they are suffering. The sooner this country allows euthanasia the better.
I've already saved up enough money for my own demise, I've been saving for years. It costs at least £10k and a one way ticket to Switzerland - completely unattainable for most pensioners.

StoneofDestiny · 20/11/2021 13:29

There is a lot of naivety about what a prisoner can weaponise against themselves or others. They can use anything - paper to choke themselves on - bits of TV’s to Jill themselves with. This man was able to kill in a secure mental hospital - that is why he is where he is. Prison officers must be protected - they have done no wrong, yet spend every day of their working lives ‘at risk’ of assault or worse. They are an underpaid and undervalued profession who are keeping us all safe - so their safety is paramount.

This prisoner cannot be allowed to kill or injure other prisoners either - their punishment is to lose their liberty - not to be attacked by vigilante thugs or murderers.

OhWhyNot · 20/11/2021 13:28

They could make his life more comfortable

There isn’t the incentive to do this

He has proven that he unmanageable. So few prisoners are to his level so why make the effort

It isn’t right

BigYellowHat · 20/11/2021 13:23

@Atozofpoodles

He deserves a medal not this.
For murdering four people? Confused
Funnylittlefloozie · 20/11/2021 13:18

And he's not even in this plastic cage now, so all the discussion and hand-wringing over his inhumane treatment is just moot!

RecentYears · 20/11/2021 13:18

@aprilanne

And the fact he is not in a hospital but prison shows he is not ill just a nasty piece of work .and a shit childhood cant be blamed on everything his brother did not do those things .
I thought he'd been in hospital but murdered someone there so they've had to tf him to prison even though it's acknowledged he should be in hospital?
Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 13:18

@Moonbabysmum

Where is the money coming from to provide it to a violent prisoner? Where is the WiFi coming feom?

A custom made cell. An entire team effort job it is to solely look after him. 6 guards needed to escort him for 1hr for exercise each day.

I think a few hundred quid so he can at least listen to music is a drop in the ocean isn't it.

No, because those things already exist. We’re now talking about adapting that cell (from when it was made forty years ago) to include modern technology specifically for him. That’s not a couple of hundred quid: it’s WiFi (or internet access), plus the cost of the technology - plus an entire second custom-based cell to keep him in while his new technology is being put in his original cell, because he’s not safe anywhere else.

And prisons don’t have spare cash for entertainment anyway - most people don’t want their taxes going on keeping violent men occupied while they serve their time.

aprilanne · 20/11/2021 13:16

And the fact he is not in a hospital but prison shows he is not ill just a nasty piece of work .and a shit childhood cant be blamed on everything his brother did not do those things .

Pumperthepumper · 20/11/2021 13:14

@Saucery

don’t recognise your username, do you namechange a lot? Nope. Feel free to check with AS or MNHQ Smile

I understand you don’t want this man to have any sort of entertainment whatsoever, not even the basics that other prisoners have. I also understand the reasons why the usual access to such entertainments aren’t possible. However, there is technology out there to make it possible. Whether you feel he should have access to it, or indeed whether I feel he should, is neither here nor there.

That’s the last time I’m going to respond to you, Pumps. Go get your jollies somewhere else.

Your level of understanding means you can’t see the difference between what he can and can’t have, and why. So you see ‘oh poor man, everyone is being awful to him when Alexa exists!’ instead of actually giving it a second or two of thought, and trying to work out why that might be the case.

And here’s my evidence for saying this I understand you don’t want this man to have any sort of entertainment whatsoever. It’s literally how a child would comprehend this conversation. A child who’s so desperate for an argument, they’re happy to make themselves look ridiculous. And then start slinging mud when called on it.

melj1213 · 20/11/2021 13:13

Where are people getting the idea he has zero entertainment from?

There is one single quote on that article that he wanted books/TV/music but that was from when he was moved from being in a different prison (where he would have had more free access to entertainment if he was in a "normal" prison wing) nowhere does it say that he spends 23hrs a day in silence and without any kind of entertainment, he probably just doesn't have free access to it or he is only allowed access to a very limited selection.

There are many articles from over the years that have stated he writes and receives letters and has had visitors so they clearly allow him paper and a writing implement, so I am sure they allow him books, there are probably just strict rules around him having them etc.