Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is boastful behaviour/showing off always a sign of insecurity/low self-esteem?

166 replies

flashbac · 20/11/2021 08:38

I seem to come across alot of boastful behaviour (either that or I am on high alert for it). Sometimes full on showing off and more often the stealth boast.
I tend to get very annoyed and impatient with people who do this (which is why I'm not on FB) but it helps me to know its often a sign of low self-worth.
But is it? Or are people just more accustomed to boasting because of the society we now live in?

OP posts:
MatildaIThink · 21/11/2021 13:28

@MintJulia

Not all the time. My brother very seldom boasts but when his daughter got 12a* at gcse, he couldn't contain himself. It was funny to watch because he does it so seldom.

Sometimes people are just genuinely & justifiably excited. I wouldn't begrudge him his day of pride. That would have been insecure of me.

Good on him for being proud of his daughter for doing well, it would be a better place if all parents were like that.
MatildaIThink · 21/11/2021 13:27

@flashbac

I seem to come across alot of boastful behaviour (either that or I am on high alert for it). Sometimes full on showing off and more often the stealth boast. I tend to get very annoyed and impatient with people who do this (which is why I'm not on FB) but it helps me to know its often a sign of low self-worth. But is it? Or are people just more accustomed to boasting because of the society we now live in?
Boasting or showing off often does yes, but a lot of what gets labelled as boasting or showing off is not, that is just the perception of the envious/hatred crowd.
MintJulia · 21/11/2021 13:26

Not all the time. My brother very seldom boasts but when his daughter got 12a* at gcse, he couldn't contain himself. It was funny to watch because he does it so seldom.

Sometimes people are just genuinely & justifiably excited. I wouldn't begrudge him his day of pride. That would have been insecure of me.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 13:19

@ILoveHuskies

I think the main take from all this is to never, ever post anything on Facebook or any other social media about your achievements / possessions / happy event etc 😂
My main take from it is that people shouldn't be so oversensitive and judgemental, and should have enough self-awareness that if they are offended by someone else being happy then they need to examine the reasons for that reaction.
Courtier · 21/11/2021 13:10

I think people are allowed to be proud of themselves or their achievements and it's a shame that it's so looked down upon here in Britain. Compared to other countries it makes us all seem quite negative. I've even felt weird 'showing off' on my CV because it feels boastful.

Just ignore it!

ILoveHuskies · 21/11/2021 13:02

I think the main take from all this is to never, ever post anything on Facebook or any other social media about your achievements / possessions / happy event etc 😂

Bluntness100 · 21/11/2021 12:51

@ThousandsOfTulips

What I mean is, what both the person posting and reading the comment perceive to be "boastful" is determined by a whole load of factors including the person's cultural references like national culture, current circumstances, current mental health. I like to think that - aside from a few boring arseholes - most people wouldn't deliberately make other people feel bad. So mostly I think a perception of boasting probably just arises from a mismatch between the poster and the person reading it on some or all of the other factors.
This. This is very well put.

I never view the things the op states as boastful as boastful but I’m not envious. I post very few images of my life on social media, but have many Facebook friends and follow many on Instagram, I usually jist think oh that looks lovely or she looks like she’s having fun. I don’t think I’ve ever reacted and thought how boastful.

So I agree it’s how the reader takes it.

Bluntness100 · 21/11/2021 12:49

Meh, i don’t really judge to be honest, and I think people are allowed to take pride in things they are doing or achieving. I meet very few truly boastful people

My concern is you’re not happy with your life and are envious of things people have and do.

Lanareyrey · 21/11/2021 12:41

@DietrichandDiMaggio

No, often it's an over-inflated ego -people who think others are more interested in their lives/family etc. than they actually are.
Agreed. No one gives a fuck.
Lanareyrey · 21/11/2021 12:39

I get tired of boasting and stealth boasting especially on FB. It could very much be low self esteem and definitely insecurity and IMO I think more and more people are seeking validation and attention and are definitely more self absorbed these days. To me it reads quite the opposite of what they are hoping to achieve by being boastful/bragging.

It’s ok to be proud…there is a difference between proud and purposely bragging…and share with close family and friends. I also don’t know what happened to modesty but certainly seems non existent these days…

DietrichandDiMaggio · 21/11/2021 12:08

No, often it's an over-inflated ego -people who think others are more interested in their lives/family etc. than they actually are.

CookPassBabtridge · 21/11/2021 12:04

It's always cringe and it's part of why I'm rately on facebook, because I find myself doing it too and I cringe at myself!
My friend boasts a lot about her little girls achievements and it comes across badly, but she has an older autistic non verbal son so can see why she does it. There is usually an explanation but it's still cringe.

ILoveHuskies · 21/11/2021 12:03

@HelplesslyHoping

Not always. I know boastful people who are very confident, but also new to having things to boast about. Others boast because they choose to pretend to be very happy with their situation.
Oh god yeah I've got a friend who has an absolute dick head for a dh and is quite unhappy ...but from her social media she paints the most ideal life 😞 it's a shame
Cam77 · 21/11/2021 11:59

It’s not as simple as “low self esteem”. Look at in evolutionary terms. Humans are social animals. Bragging and boasting is a way for us to show or declare our ”status” to other members of our group/tribe. “Showing off” our status will hopefully provide us with greater respect, security, economic benefits etc.

HelplesslyHoping · 21/11/2021 11:52

Not always. I know boastful people who are very confident, but also new to having things to boast about. Others boast because they choose to pretend to be very happy with their situation.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:48

What I mean is, what both the person posting and reading the comment perceive to be "boastful" is determined by a whole load of factors including the person's cultural references like national culture, current circumstances, current mental health. I like to think that - aside from a few boring arseholes - most people wouldn't deliberately make other people feel bad. So mostly I think a perception of boasting probably just arises from a mismatch between the poster and the person reading it on some or all of the other factors.

Furzebush · 21/11/2021 11:45

@BraveGoldie

For sure the 'one-upmanship' which is often at the heart of boasting is yucky.

But if we're simply talking about being honest about our strengths and celebrating achievement (in ourself and others) that can be a really cultural thing.

The uk, Northern Europe and many Asian cultures tends to greatly discourage expressing your own self confidence and achievements (especially in women). The USA and many African cultures for example will celebrate abilities and achievements much more explicitly, and 'display' of wealth etc is much more part of the culture.

My partner is From an African country and I am British. I was out with him the other night in the uk and someone asked 'oh you're a singer?' And he answered 'yes I'm a fantastic singer'. Now he is - he regularly performs and has an album, but if you were British you'd have to be a total nob to say that. He is totally not a nob! I've had to give him lessons in 'British style false modesty'! 😁

This is what I was going to say— the appearance of modesty is strongly cultural and gendered, and one society’s ‘boastfulness’ is another’s positive celebration of a strength or achievement.

I’m from an intensely self-deprecating culture, and was brought up by a mother who was mortified by her children’s achievements in case it looked like ‘we were getting above ourselves’ (I once overheard a neighbour tell my mother she must be very proud I won a big postgraduate scholarship, and my mother laughed and said ‘Oh, Furze is too lazy to get a actual job, so she just stays on at university!’) so I had to consciously work on not automatically putting myself down in adulthood. Especially in cultures where there isn’t such a fetishisation of ‘modesty’ and ‘not getting too big for your boots’.

The stuff you read about on here, though — people banging on about their cars etc — is pretty tedious, though.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:43

Surely that depends on context though? For some (very lucky!) people going to the Maldives may not be a big deal so they might not perceive it as boastful. Or maybe the fact they were not in the UK was relevant to the thing being discussed even if the original post wasn't about the Maldives specifically but about a holiday somewhere else. 🤷🏻‍♀️ Etc.

flashbac · 21/11/2021 11:38

OK, so things are getting a bit lost on the meaning of 'boastful'. What I'm getting at is not when people share good news like getting a new job. It's when people say things like:
"Oh, that reminds me of when I went to the Maldives" in response to something completely unrelated to the Maldives.
Or
"I don't need to work you know, my husband has loads of properties"

OP posts:
ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:35

Actually that's just made me think that there is a weird cognitive dissonance between the whole "stiff upper lip" thing and British people in reality having very thin skins and taking many straightforward things as some kind of veiled personal slight, then just silently seething with rage and pretending they don't care. 🤣 Things are far better when people are open and direct rather than looking for subtext which in many cases - if you are speaking with somebody direct - simply isn't there. So people end up offended/ annoyed by their own perception of something as a personal put down when there was actually nothing to indicate it was anything or the sort.

DeepaBeesKit · 21/11/2021 11:32

A friend of mine commented the other day that a mutual friend is "boastful". I was astonished. She is a cheerful and happy woman. She is very positive in her outlook, quite glass half full. The first friends examples of her boasting were situations where she had simply been open about good things in her life - a DC getting the uni place they dreamed of, a lucky windfall on an investment coming good.

I don't regard these as boasting and find it annoying when people act doom and gloom about everything when they have in fact got much to be grateful for.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:32

I've particularly noticed that in things like facebook groups, where people take general comments that are not about them very personally, because it's in a group. But a group of even 50-100 people is nothing like a one-to-one conversation so different social norms apply.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:30

@ILoveHuskies

I have noticed that it depends on whether you genuinely like the person posting as to whether you think it’s a nice or irritating post

@Boobicoosg this is so true ^

Also totally agree with this. Why would anyone be annoyed by someone they like sharing good news? Unless it is actually the irritated person who is suffering low self-esteem.

Also, in an individual conversation people are mindful of the other person's sensitivities if they know about them. Whereas people can't be expected to not post a general post on social media if a single person in their friends list may be struggling with that issue e.g. you can't post news of a new baby as someone who may or may not even see it is struggling with infertility. I think perhaps some of the resentment comes from people not grasping consciously that social media posts are general and not directed at them personally in the way that a direct comment in a personal conversation is.

ThousandsOfTulips · 21/11/2021 11:25

@MizzFizz

I think it's also cultural.. I'm Canadian and we generally tend to be straightforward... If I'm happy about something, I say I'm happy about it ("I got a new job this week! So happy!") And if I'm not happy, I would also say it ("My rent is going up, booo"). We wear our hearts on our sleeves. But I do sometimes feel that this type of attitude isn't always seen well in the UK, as it could be "boasting" (re: good things). I just want to be authentic about what's happening in my life, and if someone can't be happy for me/rolls their eyes that it's boasting, then I don't really have time for their mind games.
I'm British and I totally agree with this. It sounds much more healthy and it must be bliss living in a place where most people think like that. The very idea of labelling something "boasting" is laden with bitterness. It's as unhealthy as the British "stiff upper lip" aka burying your emotions.
ILoveHuskies · 21/11/2021 10:22

I have noticed that it depends on whether you genuinely like the person posting as to whether you think it’s a nice or irritating post

@Boobicoosg this is so true ^

Swipe left for the next trending thread