Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you believe in psychics?

422 replies

EwwwwDavid · 20/11/2021 00:47

I've been to a few psychics over the years and some things they've said have been weirdly accurate, some not so much.
I had a very tragic bereavement about 12 years ago and haven't seen one since but done things I was told almost predicted what would happen.
Does anyone have any similar stories?
Ps im very much atheist and not at all 'woo' but sometimes reflect on things that are weirdly accurate.

OP posts:
notthemum · 21/11/2021 12:41

Nope. No a chance. Complete BS in my opinion.

Pumperthepumper · 21/11/2021 12:38

@JollyHostess ok, let’s look at it from the paranormal side then.

This man dies. Twenty years later, his ghost pesters John Edwards to the point of madness because he works with the dead man’s son in law.

The message he’s absolutely desperate to pass on is: information about his childhood pets.

Why?

JollyHostess · 21/11/2021 12:32

[quote Pumperthepumper]**@JollyHostess* but other people must* have known those stories if they recognised the dead person from those descriptions. And if they were a larger than life character, isn’t it possible that they shared a lot about their life with people when they were alive?

And if John Edwards was trying to build a name for himself as an incredible psychic, isn’t this just exactly the sort of thing he would exploit?[/quote]
Maybe? He hadn't just died though, it was a good 20 years previously at least.

So two people working in a hospital, don't know each other. One approaches the other with stories/messages from the other guy's dead father in law who he'd never even met. Lots of details such as something that had to be done to the family dog on the kitchen table (I know).

I can see it either way to be honest. I get what you're saying and it is completely logical. But that doesn't necessarily mean you're right.

sybillalle · 21/11/2021 12:27

@Kanaloa

And why would you presume I had misunderstood? I was simply saying it’s not proof of psychic ability.
The app itself is not proof of anything. It's simply a tool you can use to collect your own evidence, for yourself.
sybillalle · 21/11/2021 12:24

@Kanaloa

And why would you presume I had misunderstood? I was simply saying it’s not proof of psychic ability.
I hadn't heard of that other app you mentioned but from how you described it it seemed like the app was "reading your mind" rather than the other way around.

In any case, the app is not necessary, it's just an easy starting place with instructions. You can use other targets on the web, or team up with a friend if you prefer.

Pumperthepumper · 21/11/2021 12:23

@JollyHostess but other people must have known those stories if they recognised the dead person from those descriptions. And if they were a larger than life character, isn’t it possible that they shared a lot about their life with people when they were alive?

And if John Edwards was trying to build a name for himself as an incredible psychic, isn’t this just exactly the sort of thing he would exploit?

JollyHostess · 21/11/2021 12:20

@Puzzledandpissedoff

The colleague of the psychic was not a direct relative of the deceased person but their son in law so didn't know whether a lot of the fine details of what was being said to him was true until he told his wife about it

But as PPs have explained, the process doesn't lie in what the "psychic" has said, but in what the listener does with it
So in this instance, the son in law may well have related some vague statement to his wife, the wife filled in the balnks and he then came to believe the "psychic" has actually told him all those things himself

Just as with the pal I mentioned upthread, who heard a statement which wasn't directed at her at all, and altered it to fit an "amazing psychic" narrative

They definitely weren't vague details, they were very specific indeed. Stuff from the wife's childhood about a family pet, in jokes and things that truly no one else would have known. The dead relative was a larger than life character who absolutely would have been the type to badger someone until they did what he asked. John was apparently very apologetic and kept saying this guy just won't leave me alone.

I can see from reading other posts on here how you could interpret John's actions as fishing around to start making a name for himself. I suppose it's possible? But this was a very convincing, detailed and unsolicited event so....🤷🏻‍♀️

sybillalle · 21/11/2021 12:19

[quote Kanaloa]@sybillalle

I understand perfectly. As remote viewing has never been proven as psychic under properly controlled conditions it’s just another little novelty.

If you enjoy thinking you’re psychic then carry on, don’t let me get in your way.[/quote]
The beautiful thing for logical and enquiring minds is that this is a phenomenon where you can carry out your own experiment, so you don't need to take anyone else's data. I understand why you don't think it's possible, as that was my position too, until I had evidence to the contrary.😃

It's apparently nothing special and anyone can do it, even those who don't believe that they can.

Kanaloa · 21/11/2021 12:09

And why would you presume I had misunderstood? I was simply saying it’s not proof of psychic ability.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/11/2021 12:09

The colleague of the psychic was not a direct relative of the deceased person but their son in law so didn't know whether a lot of the fine details of what was being said to him was true until he told his wife about it

But as PPs have explained, the process doesn't lie in what the "psychic" has said, but in what the listener does with it
So in this instance, the son in law may well have related some vague statement to his wife, the wife filled in the balnks and he then came to believe the "psychic" has actually told him all those things himself

Just as with the pal I mentioned upthread, who heard a statement which wasn't directed at her at all, and altered it to fit an "amazing psychic" narrative

Kanaloa · 21/11/2021 12:08

@sybillalle

I understand perfectly. As remote viewing has never been proven as psychic under properly controlled conditions it’s just another little novelty.

If you enjoy thinking you’re psychic then carry on, don’t let me get in your way.

sybillalle · 21/11/2021 12:05

Or if you prefer an instant reveal there are many online targets - for example : www.greaterreality.com/rv/instruct.htm

sybillalle · 21/11/2021 12:02

So you see, the experience occurs inside your own consciousness, and as such, can only ever be personal to you. I understand that this sounds strange. It is very strange!

RosaRosaRosaRosa · 21/11/2021 12:01

@sybillalle I've gone on rv tournament and I'm waiting until 9.30 when the image is revealed to see if I'm psychic.

RosaRosaRosaRosa · 21/11/2021 12:00

@Kanaloa

You think the RV Tournament app is proof of psychic ability? Okay, so then is the ‘genie’ from Akinator. He can always guess what character you’re thinking of.
That genie is definitely psychic! He always knows who I'm thinking of, even when it's someone like Freddie from Rod, Jane and Freddie 😆
sybillalle · 21/11/2021 11:59

@Kanaloa

You think the RV Tournament app is proof of psychic ability? Okay, so then is the ‘genie’ from Akinator. He can always guess what character you’re thinking of.
I think you're misunderstanding, or you haven't given it a go yet.

With RV tournament, YOU are the one that is "psychic". You are the one that perceives an image, before it is revealed to you.

Pumperthepumper · 21/11/2021 11:57

@JollyHostess

What if a psychic approached someone out of the blue, not in a psychic/client situation but because they worked in the same building as someone and were being "pestered" by a deceased relative of that colleague until they passed on some messages?

That happened to my exH's family. The colleague of the psychic was not a direct relative of the deceased person but their son in law so didn't know whether a lot of the fine details of what was being said to him was true until he told his wife about it.

No money was exchanged, this was not solicited in anyway and there was absolutely nothing to be proved or gained.

It was before the days of social media and the psychic in question turned out to be John Edwards.

I didn't believe in any of that stuff but even I had to be a bit impressed by that.

I don’t understand this story but my guess is: he lucked out on some information about a dead person, realised he worked with their colleague and used it to give himself some credibility as a psychic.
Kanaloa · 21/11/2021 11:53

You think the RV Tournament app is proof of psychic ability? Okay, so then is the ‘genie’ from Akinator. He can always guess what character you’re thinking of.

Penistoe · 21/11/2021 11:53

There is some northern lass (dark curly hair in case anyone has seen her) she does live videos and people share them- it gives them points for free readings- anyway she is watching all these comments going “alright Sharon, ow r u lovely see if we can get someone for you, hello Tony me love……..blah blah”. She can just click as they are coming in onto their profiles, until one gives something away, then bam. I never know if I should feel deeply sorry for these vulnerable people often desperate or angry at their stupidity! These people are all vultures. It’s funny how not one person who has this ‘gift’ is willing to do it for free. Or that spirits are more interested in telling Mary that her slipper is behind the fridge than letting us who who killed x y z child or where some little kids body is buried.

Pumperthepumper · 21/11/2021 11:53

[quote Carrotsandbroccoli]@Pumperthepumper
You have really got a bee in your bonnet about my one isolated incident haven’t you?

Yeah, it could have been a guess, of course. Weird guess to make based on nothing though. But not impossible.

What about the other points I made? The fact that most people have come across hundreds of potentially ‘weird’ incidents? Or is mine the only example of anything previously unexplained (now explained by yours truly, of course) you’ve ever heard?

I think it’s sad to approach life in such a blinkered way. I’m off now though because you’re right - it does get tiresome after a time.[/quote]
I’m responding to your one, incident because that’s the one you wanted to talk about, that’s why you put it on this thread.

And it wasn’t a guess based on nothing, as we’ve discussed. It was a guess based on your age and any other factor - slightly pale, slightly green, not eating, walking differently, eyes slightly hooded, cheeks slightly flushed. Anything. And it’s only significant because she was right.

I think it’s sad to live so blinkered by a desire to believe in paranormal activity that you can’t see when you’ve been scammed.

JollyHostess · 21/11/2021 11:50

What if a psychic approached someone out of the blue, not in a psychic/client situation but because they worked in the same building as someone and were being "pestered" by a deceased relative of that colleague until they passed on some messages?

That happened to my exH's family. The colleague of the psychic was not a direct relative of the deceased person but their son in law so didn't know whether a lot of the fine details of what was being said to him was true until he told his wife about it.

No money was exchanged, this was not solicited in anyway and there was absolutely nothing to be proved or gained.

It was before the days of social media and the psychic in question turned out to be John Edwards.

I didn't believe in any of that stuff but even I had to be a bit impressed by that.

Carrotsandbroccoli · 21/11/2021 11:49

@Pumperthepumper
You have really got a bee in your bonnet about my one isolated incident haven’t you?

Yeah, it could have been a guess, of course. Weird guess to make based on nothing though. But not impossible.

What about the other points I made? The fact that most people have come across hundreds of potentially ‘weird’ incidents? Or is mine the only example of anything previously unexplained (now explained by yours truly, of course) you’ve ever heard?

I think it’s sad to approach life in such a blinkered way. I’m off now though because you’re right - it does get tiresome after a time.

sybillalle · 21/11/2021 11:49

@Kanaloa

So basically ‘I have proof of definite psychic evidence but I won’t share it!’

Why post then? Because realistically you know there is no way you have actual concrete evidence of this type of phenomena or you’d share it and make your millions.

I have remote viewed images, but that's not going to convince you, and nor should it. I'm not asking you to believe me. You'd be quite foolish to believe it, in fact, without your own evidence!

I'm saying, go and give it a try yourself, if you really want to know. RV tournament app, as I said. No money, no relatives, no one else involved, just you exploring your own consciousness.

Also, if you'd rather not know or try, that's fine too Smile

Pumperthepumper · 21/11/2021 11:41

[quote Carrotsandbroccoli]@Pumperthepumper

This is tiresome.

You said you lived your life with logic.

But logic means facts.

So people who want to believe in the unexplained will, even if it means ignoring logic.

The two things don’t connect - because there’s no such thing as magic or psychics, and to believe in them means ignoring logic.

Oh, I’m sorry it’s so tiresome! You don’t have to engage, you know. I’m not going to just go ‘yup, you’re right pumper, we already know everything about human experience’ and give up my curiosity about the world. I thought it was interesting to discuss but you clearly don’t find it so.

Logic does mean facts, yes, but can you see that sometimes it’s hard to find a satisfactory logical, factual explanation for something. Clearly it’s never happened to you, but some people do find themselves in that situation. You must be aware of that? Do they’re not ignoring facts; they start with facts, the same way we all do. When I see the sky darkening in the evening, I don’t panic and think the world is ending; I work with the facts I have about the world to process what is happening. When the pp had a total stranger in a random village give her an as hoc and apparently accurate reading, that pp didn’t have a set of facts to work with; her visit to that place was unplanned, the woman was a stranger etc etc. Of course there could be a Jonathan Creek style explanation- but she hadn’t had that explanation, do it remains unexplained - the very definition of unexplained. Doesn’t mean can’t ever be explained 🙄

There is a wealth of this sort of stuff. Scratch the surface of any friendship group and one or two will have a weird experience to relate.

I think it’s interesting. I can totally see why people don’t want to pay money to be exploited by bullshit ‘psychics’ but I can’t quite see why some people are similarly angered by people like me offering a ‘jury’s out’ on absolutely everything that isn’t currently explained in a science text book.[/quote]
It was a guess.

A guess.

She guessed.

She happened to be correct.

That’s it. That’s the unexplained factor between all these stories of spooky women in pubs and woo old ladies in the street and psychic colleagues.

A guess that landed. Mystery solved.

Kanaloa · 21/11/2021 11:41

So basically ‘I have proof of definite psychic evidence but I won’t share it!’

Why post then? Because realistically you know there is no way you have actual concrete evidence of this type of phenomena or you’d share it and make your millions.

Swipe left for the next trending thread