Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Birthday disparity...

108 replies

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 22:27

Been together with someone for 10 months. Oct is my birthday - I wasn't expecting much as I know he doesn't really do birthdays. So tiny bit disappointed with the generic present and card but wasn't really expecting more.

Fast forward to his birthday and I bought some gifts which were mostly personal to him/his hobbies, made his favourite cake and paid for a night out with a meal and cocktails. Did it entirely because I wanted to celebrate.

It all got a very lukewarm reception, I really don't think he was bothered by what I'd done at all. I think he probably said thank you for the presents but didn't comment on the night out at all, though we both enjoyed it.

So AIBU to be upset, or is it something I should just put up with because it was my choice to push the boat out for him?

OP posts:
thegreenestbear · 20/11/2021 08:11

Surely it makes no difference? We often go out for meals and cocktails and split 50/50. He likes going out; he's not a hermit. It's not like I got the restaurant to sing to him, or presented him with a cake or balloons. It was just a regular night out. Why is it okay not to say thank you?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 20/11/2021 08:09

But did he actually want to do those things or did he go along with it for you?

If you know he doesn’t like a fuss about birthdays then surely making a fuss is making it about you not him?

thegreenestbear · 20/11/2021 08:05

I think some posters are missing the point of my post.

Absolutely fine with minimal thanks for presents - was expecting no more, no less.

Not fine with no thanks for paying for meal/cocktails/taxi. Which he agreed to two weeks ago.

If I'd posted saying nothing about about his birthday, just that I'd paid for a night out but not been thanked would half of you still think that was okay? When did not having basic manners become acceptable?

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 20/11/2021 07:49

So you knew he isnt a birthday person yet you went on and pushed the issue hard by the cake and the night out and the thoughtful gift....
And then you got disappointed that he wasnt more enthusiastic/say thank you.

Right..

SummerWhisper · 20/11/2021 07:21

The bottom line is that he accepted the night out, therefore, he does do birthdays, otherwise he'd have said "perhaps you should take a friend who will love this" rather than hoovering up every gift and night out you shoved his way with less than minimal thanks. He used the classic and pathetic 'I don't really do birthdays' so that he won't have to make an effort with you and ishowing gratitude would mean that he has to reciprocate and he's too tight for that, hence you will never get a thank you.

Please, please, please do not get him a single thing for Christmas and I mean nothing at all. He'll already be expecting red carpet treatment, thinking he doesn't have to do a thing in return or thank you for your effort. I bet you any money he'll show you how pissed off he is when Santa fails to deliver...

Shasha17 · 20/11/2021 02:59

I'm not saying your heart wasn't in the right place, but to play devil's advocate:

He doesn't 'do' birthdays. I don't either. I understand this, although a lot of people think it's odd.

Therefore the genuinely thoughtful thing to do would be to celebrate birthdays how HE wants and how HE feels comfortable.

To have a big celebration with gifts in the style that you like, well, that's not really making his birthday about him. That's making it about you.

My DH does this too and I find it tough to explain. It's just an awkward situation because my preference would be to do nothing/everything just super low key/no presents/just a token. It's almost impossible to explain this without seeming super ungrateful. And I'm not trying to be horrible. I'm just trying to show an alternative point of view. Maybe he also wishes you just did it the way he'd like, as it was his birthday?

I understand it's a difficult issue though as obviously you clearly do like birthdays and celebrating in a traditional way and so I can see why you don't want to give that up.

Maybe you can have a talk about it. Make it clear what you want for your birthday, in terms of planning and presents - and ask him how he wants you to celebrate his. If he insists on somethibg more low-key, or no celebration/acknowledgement at all, then just go along with it and save birthday effort for your other friends and family.

madisonbridges · 20/11/2021 02:00

If I go out and someone buys me a drink, I say thank you. If they then pay for the meal, I thank them for that too. If they then drive me home, I thank them again. Oh how excessive of me! Really, I never knew you just say thank you at the start of your date and that covers you from showing any manners for the next four hours.

If I really didn't enjoy being treated well and having money spent on me, I would still say thank you and then later, at an appropriate time, say it's not necessary. But, honestly, in the ops position, I'd be looking at socks and expecting them to be pulled up pdq. 🐗 🐗 🐗

ddl1 · 20/11/2021 00:47

If he made a big fuss of his own birthday, but ignored yours, you would have grounds for complaint.

But if you know that he doesn't do birthdays, I don't think it's really fair to expect him to be enthusiastic about things that you do for his.

Personally, I hate my birthday than almost anything in the universe. I want it totally ignored by everyone; try to keep the date secret; and would be really upset if anyone pressed birthday celebrations on to me. I assume that your dp doesn't feel as strongly as I do, or he would have explicitly told you some time ago; but it sounds as though his feelings are somewhere between uncomfortable and 'meh'.

He did thank you for the presents.

I would suggest that in the future, you only celebrate things with him that you know he would want to celebrate.

toastofthetown · 19/11/2021 23:44

He thanked you for the presents. Did you say then you were taking him out that night. If he thanked you for everything then, then he might have considered the thanks given.

Clearly you don’t think your being unreasonable, but I don’t think he is being unreasonable either. He has told you he doesn’t care about birthdays. I don’t think that’s just to lower you expectations as a PP said as he doesn’t seem to care about his own either. You either need to accept that about him and move on, lower your expectations or decide it’s a dealbreaker and move on. Expecting gratitude from someone for celebrating something who didn’t really want to celebrate in the first place is only going to lead to disappointment from you

Kite22 · 19/11/2021 23:40

But you said he did say thank you.

I often see comments on here about how the giver 's "thoughtful" presents ought to be better received, but birthdays should always be about the recipient.

If the person asks for a surprise, or a fuss, then that is what you should try and do
If the person wants money towards something they are saving for / want to buy with all the birthday money put together
If the person wants something practical, then get them that, even if it isn't what you would want for yourself.

Of course, that works both ways - he ought to get you what you like for your birthday too.

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 23:37

I'm upset because he didn't say thank you. Does it make a difference that it was his birthday? I'd paid for a nice night out. Surely you just say thank you?Hmm

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/11/2021 23:33

I'm torn. Obviously it is basic manners to say thank you. However, he told you he doesn't like celebrating his birthday so maybe he felt really uncomfortable with the big song and dance you made of his birthday. You say you wanted to celebrate bit sounds like he didn't. There could be a reason behind it all.

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 23:29

@whippetwoman

I do really like the feral hogs comment! I think he was very rude not to thank you for a night out. That’s just basic manners.
I agree. And I love the feral hogs comment too Grin
OP posts:
toastofthetown · 19/11/2021 23:28

@thegreenestbear

A8mint I'm not. I said I did it entirely because I wanted to. I'm not changing me either - if I want to buy someone a personal present rather than a 4 pack of Stella I will.
You said you did it entirely because you wanted to, but you’re posting because you were upset that you didn’t get more than a lukewarm reaction for something he told you he didn’t want in the first place. If it really was just because you wanted to then surely you’d have just enjoyed the day and move on.
whippetwoman · 19/11/2021 23:26

I do really like the feral hogs comment!
I think he was very rude not to thank you for a night out. That’s just basic manners.

Justmuddlingalong · 19/11/2021 23:26

He said thank you though. If you know he's not big on birthdays or particularly thoughtful buying gifts, you already knew the reaction would be lukewarm. You've both now had a birthday since getting together, so he'll either up his game next year or you don't make such an effort.

Notbornwithit · 19/11/2021 23:23

He’s told you he doesn’t ‘do’ birthdays and ‘Christmas’ ? These types that issue disclaimers early on are bad news. They want to lower your expectations and see what other crap you’ll put up with until. Throw the whole man away before Christmas and more disappointments

oviraptor21 · 19/11/2021 23:22

@Notbornwithit

Being too ‘thoughtful’ doesn’t really work in dating unfortunately. Men react better when they think they need to do a bit more work to get into your thoughts.
NAMALT.
madisonbridges · 19/11/2021 23:19

Yes, you DO just say thank you. If you gave someone a lift, would you expect them to get out, close the door and just walk off? No. When someone says or does something nice for you, you say thank you. Who brought him up? Feral hogs?

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 23:11

@madisonbridges

How rude. Whatever his feeling about annual events, saying thank you is free, it's quick, it pleases others at no cost yourself and takes very little effort. And it's just good manners.
I think this is where I'm at. Completely appreciate all the other pov, but you just do say thank you, don't you?
OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 23:03

@thegreenestbear

A8mint I'm not. I said I did it entirely because I wanted to. I'm not changing me either - if I want to buy someone a personal present rather than a 4 pack of Stella I will.
But it's not about you, it's about him and he doesn't do birthdays Confused

Perhaps he thinks you went OTT to 'show him how you want it done'?

madisonbridges · 19/11/2021 23:03

How rude. Whatever his feeling about annual events, saying thank you is free, it's quick, it pleases others at no cost yourself and takes very little effort. And it's just good manners.

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 22:58

@Notbornwithit

Being too ‘thoughtful’ doesn’t really work in dating unfortunately. Men react better when they think they need to do a bit more work to get into your thoughts.
Thanks - will bear this in mind and get him FA for Christmas as he doesn't really do that either Grin
OP posts:
Notbornwithit · 19/11/2021 22:49

Being too ‘thoughtful’ doesn’t really work in dating unfortunately. Men react better when they think they need to do a bit more work to get into your thoughts.

thegreenestbear · 19/11/2021 22:44

@Sirzy

You know he doesn’t do birthdays so you can’t expect him to get excited by his own
Good point, I thought he might have said thanks for me paying for a night out though.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread