Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be jealous of Amanda Owen (Yorkshire Shepherdess)

320 replies

AliceAbsolum · 19/11/2021 19:04

Her life just looks amazing. Yes obviously hard at times and not perfect. But 9 lovely children, she's gorgeous, kind husband, successful career, meaningful job and being able to spend time outdoors with her family. All the animals and space.
What I'd give for that life!

OP posts:
Kikkomam · 20/11/2021 20:08

Clearly they've survived so far!

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/11/2021 20:06

There's loads of things that kids are only allowed to do when their parents are around,aren't there?

littlemisslozza · 20/11/2021 20:00

I just get that impression! What happens when the camera team aren't there, which is surely most of the time? Maybe I'm wrong but they come across as quite free-range and there are pros and cons of that on a working farm.

Kikkomam · 20/11/2021 19:58

Quad bike no helmet was bad but nothing else bothered me

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/11/2021 19:53

[quote littlemisslozza]@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor things like climbing up tall, potentially unstable piles of bales. Wandering around a farm yard when machinery is working and lorries many turn up for deliveries. Bound to be chemicals around somewhere. Workshop with all the tools. I could go on. Farms are not playgrounds. Having said that, children often love helping out and it's important they can, but supervision is needed.[/quote]
Presumably they are supervised though- camera team are there. What makes people think they're alone when they do those kind of things?

littlemisslozza · 20/11/2021 19:48

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor things like climbing up tall, potentially unstable piles of bales. Wandering around a farm yard when machinery is working and lorries many turn up for deliveries. Bound to be chemicals around somewhere. Workshop with all the tools. I could go on. Farms are not playgrounds. Having said that, children often love helping out and it's important they can, but supervision is needed.

Malibuismysecrethome · 20/11/2021 19:47

Kids riding a quad bike with no helmet is shockingly neglectful.

elbea · 20/11/2021 19:44

@NeverDropYourMoonCup the farmhouse didn’t have any heating, I had an electric blanket for warmth and ice inside the windows.

I’m sure living on a council estate isn’t the most pleasant but I genuinely don’t think it is in anyway comparable to the graft that upland farmers put in.

My husbands family farms in the highlands, have an generator for electric. Most upland farmers aren’t living some life of luxury.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/11/2021 19:41

Apart from the quad bike riding with no helmets ( which is a huge bugbear of my dh's,he always mentioned it when he sees it in telly) what are the other dangers on the farm people have noticed,it's been mentioned a few times? I rember the pony being lifted and brought back in the land rover Shock

Kikkomam · 20/11/2021 19:12

I thought it was very poignant when Clive and Amanda walked through the field talking about the last of the kids going off to school and Clive said he'd go one way and Amanda should go the other

Yes! I noticed that

All their kids are stunning looking

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 20/11/2021 19:10

@ChessieFL

I am not at all jealous of her lifestyle, because I would hate it. I do find it fascinating, and I am a bit in awe of how easy she makes it all seem. However I am very well aware that we only see very edited highlights and the reality may be very different. I do think all the kids seem lovely and all seem to get on very well with each other. It’s very sad if they have split up, and I hope they can work it out.

I do think we have seen the last of the TV show though - obviously if they have split up then they won’t be able to make the programme any more, but even if they stay together I still think it’s finished - the end of the series last week definitely had an air of finality about it, more than just a usual end of series feeling, with lots of looking back at previous years.

I thought it was very poignant when Clive and Amanda walked through the field talking about the last of the kids going off to school and Clive said he'd go one way and Amanda should go the other.
ChessieFL · 20/11/2021 18:57

I am not at all jealous of her lifestyle, because I would hate it. I do find it fascinating, and I am a bit in awe of how easy she makes it all seem. However I am very well aware that we only see very edited highlights and the reality may be very different. I do think all the kids seem lovely and all seem to get on very well with each other. It’s very sad if they have split up, and I hope they can work it out.

I do think we have seen the last of the TV show though - obviously if they have split up then they won’t be able to make the programme any more, but even if they stay together I still think it’s finished - the end of the series last week definitely had an air of finality about it, more than just a usual end of series feeling, with lots of looking back at previous years.

A580Hojas · 20/11/2021 18:41

Are there a lot of mean comments? The meanest I can see is that she has become just another instamum. Which is the truth.

goldfinchfan · 20/11/2021 18:36

Maybe the mean comments about Amanda come from Jealousy because she is happy and her kids....all 9.... are happy.
She married Clive 21 years ago and the age gap is large.
They are in different stages of life really.

Clive was divorced before he met Amanda so an adult step daughter is not really a step daughter imo.
I love watching the kids interact and I never see kids so happy while not clamouring for material goods.
I don't care if some moments are edited out But you can't tell me those young ones are acting! They are happy.
They don't moan at their mum to do everything for them. And they love being independant.
Clive is a wonderful father to them and that is something mnay kids would love, a Dad who is with them and loves them and talks to them.

I think Amanda has done a great job with her brood and I wouldn't care if we don't see the "bad" times.

Whitefire · 20/11/2021 18:36

Are they a bit like the Radfords? As in the first series is a nice insight into their lives, but then it becomes more about them as a brand.

PickupaPenguin8 · 20/11/2021 18:25

I just realised there were two children from his first marriage. His daughter from that marriage seems to be pretty bitter, although it seems her mother left Clive .

GoGoGretaDoll · 20/11/2021 18:22

I didn't know the dad also had - what? Another 2 kids? So he's fathered 11 weans? If he lived on a sink estate the programmes they'd be making about him would have a slightly different angle, wouldn't they?

londonrach · 20/11/2021 18:21

Love this series. The children are so lovely..the parents done a good job and all go to school. Don't think the youngest (Nancy) was ready last year and seeing her in series 5 she benefited from an extra year with her parents

PickupaPenguin8 · 20/11/2021 18:18

I think there is so much to admire about the whole family, their values, what they teach their kids, how they interact with them. The relationships their kids have with each other. Their work ethic. I think Amanda is an amazing woman, and Clive is a great Dad. However I struggle to understand why they just kept having kids and not using contraception. They are providing for them, but that many children in the modern world is just crazy.

BoredZelda · 20/11/2021 18:14

I have had experience of SCBU and I will judge if I like thank you, I don’t need your permission

Then you should know better.

MoomaidAhoy · 20/11/2021 18:13

I think they’re a lovely family. Amanda does seem a bit cold, but I often watch Clive’s interactions with the children and think how natural and encouraging and loving he is.

The children all seem happy and busy. As a mother, I really don’t think that level of secure attachment and happy behaviour can be faked.

I’d be really sad for the children if their parents did separate. One of the great joys of not reading tabloids is that I have no idea about that (other than what I’ve read on this thread).

I think pp have made a valid point about health and safety - I have been a bit alarmed at seeing so many children on quad bikes without helmets. But there we are. I’m nit a farmer and none of them seem to have been harmed so far!

I love seeing the happy and loving relationship between the children. I love seeing how they help each other out. They have admitted to fighting sometimes, it all seems quite normal to me.

WinterFirTree · 20/11/2021 18:01

@Bichette

The Strawbridge family in their french chateau have quite an enviable lifestyle imo. Dick and Angel have a similar age gap but seem more compatible and definitely more affectionate than Clive and Amanda. They have also exploited their lifestyle for financial gain but seem genuinely content even if it's all highly edited.
I adore escape to the Chateau. But every time I become too envious i recall just how hard they work and how unlikely it is they ever have the time to go on holiday.
thedarkling · 20/11/2021 18:00

I got as far as nine children! Fuck that.

Although I did read that she was pretty awful to her stepdaughter (in her stepdaughter's opinions.) Seems like lots of family problems behind the tv facade.

AuntMasha · 20/11/2021 17:58

@EdenFlower

Locals disliking her doesn't really say a lot. She is a Dales incomer, has made a lot of money and a name for herself in the media, and she is not your typical sheep farmer. They were bound not to like her!
I watch and enjoy the programme. I had a similar upbringing though my parents weren’t farmers. They were incomers like Amanda though and the locals were extremely unpleasant and hostile towards us, including encouraging their children to bully us. So I agree — the fact that some locals don’t like her doesn’t necessarily mean much, imho.
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 20/11/2021 17:52

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

I'm not sure what's wrong with looking after younger siblings, it's a good thing in the main.
The threads on here about growing up in large families suggest that many of the kids who have to do it disagree. It's one thing keeping an eye on a younger sib for an hour while your parents are cooking. It's another having 7 or 8 sibs and parents who are continuously busy on a farm.

Having childcare responsibilities is a choice for adults, and we still often find it hard. It shouldn't be foisted onto children because the parents have had more kids than they can personally handle.