Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just found out that puppy is partly a banned breed

382 replies

EvilGoldfish · 19/11/2021 14:43

(Reposted from dog section as I didn’t get any replies yet and I’m really anxious!)

I know we should have done things properly to start with but my heart completely over ruled my head sad

We were on a waiting list for a Staffordshire bull terrier puppy, when my niece told me of a family she knew giving their 10 week old staffy female away as they couldn’t cope.

I went with full intentions of taking her to a local rescue as the details sounded dodgy (no microchip, no vaccinations, no contact details for who sold her to them) but I couldn’t bear the thought of her being picked duo as a bait dog. They had her in a tiny cat cage, no toys/bed and on adult butchers food. The first thing she did when they let her out was run up for a belly rub.

Obviously, she is completely adorable and I ended up taking her to the vets to be chipped, 1st vaccinations and to get checked over.

I know all puppy owners can say this but she is so responsive to positive training, loving and eager to please. She has only had two accidents in the four weeks we’ve had her, she sleeps at the foot of our bed and usually only needs to get up once in the night. Her little tail wags like crazy the second she sees anyone, including strangers and other dogs (dogs from a distance as her second vaccination is next week) but especially children. We are starting KC puppy scheme classes in a few weeks.

I feel like I have to predefend her as we have just received the wisdom panel DNA results. The breakdown is as follows (can’t post pictures yet?)

36% American Pitbull Terrier
21% Staffordshire Bull Terrier
18% American Bulldog
15% Rottweiler
3% Presa Canario
2% Boston Terrier
1% Bulldog
1% Dalmatian (?!)

I’m absolutely distraught. I’ve contacted the RSPCA (anonymously) for advice but wanted to know what others would do in my position? While I wait for the RSPCA response I wanted to try to figure out what my options are (google returned a LOT of conflicting advice).

Is she going to be taken from me when she gets bigger, even if she is a perfect family pet?

What are the chances of her suddenly turning into a rampaging beast, despite her being a very good natured puppy, and will be trained/socialised well?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
WiddlinDiddlin · 19/11/2021 19:12

Whilst the DNA tests aren't exactly 'rubbish'...

The database info used is American, so the marker that shows up 'american pitbull terrier' is actually almost certainly showing up the genes for 'bull & terrier' that was the ancestor of the american pit bull terrier... and originated in the UK and is also behind our staffordshire bull terriers.

For the same reason, UK dogs will come back with markers for 'Rat Terrier' when we don't have Rat Terriers here.. but we do have parson russels, jack russels, etc.. who share the same ancestors as the american 'Rat Terriers'...

So no she isn't a pit bull.

However, if she grows up to look like defras guidelines on what a pitbull or ptbull x 'type' dog looks like you risk trouble and it makes no odds at what her genetics say or whether she's got paperwork going back centuries saying shes some other breed.

Be a responsible owner, keep documentation of insurance, training classes, training certificates, register at a vets etc etc, and she's as safe as any potentially 'type' looking dog can be. The only way to avoid the risk of someone claiming she is 'type'.. is not to own her unfortunately :(

MauraandLaura · 19/11/2021 19:10

OP my bestest ever dog was a Pitt/staff cross. She was quite tall and blue/grey.

She was very easily trained.She was scared of next doors cat and let my eldest dd dress them up in outfits. They honestly were the most loving intelligent dog I have ever had and I am certain they new human language. My girl would take the sky card out of the box with her teeth if I was on the phone too long not giving her attention.

If I was talking them to the park I had to spell it out - in fact trips to the vet or to my nanas had to spelt out too Grin

They were never any trouble. Never had a dog fight. Never pulled on the lead.

She eventually went to go and live with my elderly nana as I was working a lot and she would go there during the day to keep them both company. Then one day she just didn't cross the door when I went to collect her -the dirty sell out. And spent the rest of her days with my 80+ year old nan.

She got a bit over weight as my nan fed her liver patte on toast but she was very gentle with my nan and would sit under her legs by the chair. She died when she was 14 from leukaemia. My nan still has her ashes.

She was an awesome dog and I would have one again.

PinkMochi · 19/11/2021 19:09

His dna is a third pit bull, mixed with 20% American bulldog. There’s a reason why pit bulls are banned and Staffies aren’t. His pit bull dna may become more apparent when he’s fully grown, as in he will be larger and bulkier. His temperament will be unpredictable.

Even if you keep him, he cannot be anywhere near children. He must wear a muzzle in public. Loads of people will say “my super large bulky Staffy cross is so docile and wouldn’t hurt a fly.” Any breed can turn, but I would rather be bitten by a small dog than a dog with a super strong jaw and an unpredictable temperament.

Douchebaggette · 19/11/2021 19:03

Those same DNA tests told me this 5kg dog was 75% border collie, 25% corgi.

I would take what they say with a huge pinch of salt.

How does the law define it banned breeds? Is is purebred only or does it need to be a certain percentage? I mean, surely a 1% isn’t a banned breed?

It doesn't define this way. It has a list of very specific meaurements (e.g. hock length vs total leg lenth) and the dog must fit within a number of them to be considered a banned dog breed type. It's not about the breed, it's about the type. Regardless of genetics, it's all about how the dog's actual body looks.

Just found out that puppy is partly a banned breed
Angliski · 19/11/2021 19:03

I just also want to stay that DB had Staffies all his life- gorgoeus dogs so soppy and sweet that he trained well. As a puppy his American pit cross didn’t look any different it was just later in life it was clear he was a lot more powerful and less smart or gentle than his staff peers. It isn’t hysterical at all - look at the little boy in wales. It only takes once.

Unsure33 · 19/11/2021 19:01

Actually the wisdom tests are not all rubbish . They were very good with one of my spanish rescues because I knew the background . Usually there is a family tree which shows you how far back each breed is . I think you are right to get advice from professionals though and I am sure with the correct training it will be a lovely dog .

29ac · 19/11/2021 19:01

These DNA tests are really inaccurate. Pup looks adorable!

I really hope the OP went before the hysterics began.

Pipplekins · 19/11/2021 18:57

OP I have 1 of those!
My girl ( 2 now) is staff, spaniel mix, with probably a little bit of others too.

Just found out that puppy is partly a banned breed
Welshiefluff · 19/11/2021 18:48

If you have to ask the question you already know the answer. If you insist on keeping the thing make sure it is muzzled when older. All the training in the world will not remove the natural instincts of a pitbull.

Lady08 · 19/11/2021 18:48

I don’t think USA statistics are reliable, the majority of owners who own these dogs in America are drug users, or train them to be aggressive to frighten rival gangs, also they are used for dog-fighting. They are also predominantly chained and kept outdoors, so lack the socialisation that the dogs in the UK have which will impact their behaviour.
Dogs are very much like children, if you don’t have boundaries, or rules in place, then their behaviour will be challenging.

BoredZelda · 19/11/2021 18:42

The dangerous dogs act with 4 banned breeds was a knee jerk legislation anyway to pacify the public after fatalities, its not solved anything just many innocent dogs losing their lives or having to live very restricted lives. Any dog has potential to be dangerous much same way as humans, although I'm sure the stats would make us the higher risk to be around

I think the ban was more complex than that. The ban was as much about the owners as the dog.

BoredZelda · 19/11/2021 18:40

How does the law define it banned breeds? Is is purebred only or does it need to be a certain percentage? I mean, surely a 1% isn’t a banned breed?

nancybotwinbloom · 19/11/2021 18:38

Oh op she's gorgeous I think she looks a bit like a patterdale

Scattyhattie · 19/11/2021 18:36

Surely the police would just use DNA tests rather than the more expensive expert to do various measurements to determine if fits a banned breed type if it was reliable evidence. The dangerous dogs act with 4 banned breeds was a knee jerk legislation anyway to pacify the public after fatalities, its not solved anything just many innocent dogs losing their lives or having to live very restricted lives. Any dog has potential to be dangerous much same way as humans, although I'm sure the stats would make us the higher risk to be around.

The US bite statistics are probably not useful as those dogs likely aren't pets in the home with responsible owners, its also more common dogs are kept outside on chains as protection or left to own devices all day than in UK. Many people also don't recognise dog breeds correctly when reporting.

Slowfoxfast · 19/11/2021 18:34

I would just think forward to how you might feel if your dog ever attacked someone, particularly a child. It's really not worth the risk.

QuestionableMouse · 19/11/2021 18:30

@yikerspipers

All these posters mentioning being bitten by jack russells and chihuahuas amd poodles and the like are winding me up. No one ever lost their face in a frenzied jack russell attack. Who cares if they note more, they don't kill children.
Unfortunately that's not true www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/9692454/One-week-old-baby-boy-dies-after-attack-by-pet-dog.html

Any dog has the capacity to bite and to potentially kill.

The hysteria on this thread over a DNA test that are notoriously inaccurate is ridiculous.

user1471453601 · 19/11/2021 18:29

We had a staffy x breed that our vet was a bit iffy about. He eventually decided she was a staffy crossed with a Rhodesia ridge back - she had the tell tale ridge running down her back.

Like you, we took her on in dubious circumstances, a friend of a friend could no longer look after her. Like your lovely dog, ours was as soft as anything. She was other dog reactive. And the vet did warn us that if someone showed an interest in her, we should stress that she'd been spayed, as our vet felt she would be "popular" with the scum who breed dogs for fighting.

Blueberry12345 · 19/11/2021 18:22

Ignore the test and enjoy your dog and don't worry!

I never understand why people get these tests done. It is such a waste of money.

shiningstar2 · 19/11/2021 18:19

wait and see what RSPCA say. Socialize her carefully with people/other dogs while she is still a puppy. Very important to do this. Always take her our muzzled. If you do this from the start she will not know any different and will get excited to go out for walks when you show her the muzzle in the same way that most dogs get excited when you show them their lead. If she shows any concerning signs of aggression as she grows you might have to rethink but I would start as above. Rule nothing in or out in your mind regarding having to have her pts if it doesn't work out but never left alone with kids, always taken out muzzled should ensure she can't do any harm. Hope it works out Flowers

KurtWilde · 19/11/2021 18:19

@PinkSparklyPussyCat

Indeed. The fatalists have turned up. I wondered how long it would take for them to put their hysterical tuppence in.

It started off quite well but then it was though a klaxon sounded somewhere and they all appeared. OP's puppy looks nothing like a pit bull, she's more like a Labrador puppy.

Yes that's what I thought. Before pits were banned in the U.K. my uncle had an absolute beauty and OPs pup looks nothing like it. He was a big soft sod, us kids used to cuddle him to bits.
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 19/11/2021 18:17

Cross post @KurtWilde!

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 19/11/2021 18:17

@icelolly12

But unfortunately for op there's no labrador in the DNA test.
There was no collie in a previous poster's pedigree collie either.
KurtWilde · 19/11/2021 18:17

@icelolly12

But unfortunately for op there's no labrador in the DNA test.
But if you've read some of the other posts on this thread read you'll see there was no corgi dna in a corgi dog and no border collie dna in a pedigree border. Which juts goes to show the dna tests aren't worth the paper they're printed on.
icelolly12 · 19/11/2021 18:16

It's not my problem @kurtwilde, I'm merely sharing an opinion on a public forum called AIBU. Stop attempting to shut me down because I don't agree with you.

FOJN · 19/11/2021 18:16

icelolly12

I believe your figures for US fatal dog attacks are correct in that they resemble the figures I've seen but I dug a little deeper so there are few things I would question. There are lots of abandoned and stray pitties in the states and lots bred in the back of beyond for dog fighting so what percentage they contribute to the overall dog population is almost impossible to determine.

The wiki page which details the attacks lists a fair few fatal attacks by packs of wild dogs (the stray and abandoned pitties) rather than family pets which does change the stats on the risk of being attacked by one you own.