Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits

116 replies

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 10:53

Posting for traffic!

I am an expat and just really don't understand benefits at all and have no idea of how much people get (I moved pretty much right after uni and my kids were born abroad so never really was entitled to them).

One of my good friends here is planning to move back to the UK with her two children. She has been living abroad for a few years but is British. She wants to claim benefits until she gets herself sorted with a job and we have just used a gov.uk benefits calculator and it tells her she can get almost £1700 a month 😳 This can't be right, can it? It seems like a awful lot more than we were expecting! She filled in her details accurately (twice!) and this is what it came up with. Is this an average sort of amount? I always assumed benefits like like, a third of this maximum!

(Please be kind, she's leaving due to a very sensitive situation and needs to leave urgently so doesn't have time to find work etc first. But will get started with the job search when she's safely back.).

OP posts:
LanaDelBoy · 19/11/2021 13:58

As if anyone would make this up? What a hilarious joke it would be, women and children fleeing domestic abuse is so funny and lighthearted

You must've been on MN long enough to know that people do make this stuff up, daily.

People aren't being sarky because they hate women, but because your post is worded like the posts that are removed for being made up to generate froth.

It sucks that we have to adjust to the atmosphere of an online community when posting, by actively posting in a way that communicates a genuine circumstance without being specific enough so as to be outing, but that's where we are. And you posted this in AIBU!

rainbowdashsneeze · 19/11/2021 13:55

@CorrBlimeyGG

As she has been living abroad it's highly likely she'll be entitled to nothing until she passes the habitual residence test. Look into this, it's not as simple as turning up and expecting to claim.

How much rent does she expect to pay? A good chunk of that amount will be housing costs. £1700 a month is not a vast amount at all.

She's British she will be entitled.
Appleseesaw · 19/11/2021 13:51

Your friend will need to apply to her local council for help with council tax. If there’s a shortfall in her rent, she can ask the council fir a discretionary housing payment. She can also check with her council to see what other help is available eg household support fund.

Finknottlesnewt · 19/11/2021 13:33

@BoredZelda

Gosh, there have been a lot of people recently posting on here who are surprised about the amount of benefits their friends and neighbours can get.

It's surprising, isn't it. And with the amounts that are apparently claimable I'm amazed the food banks are reporting record numbers of referrals. If this is Tory austerity, let's have more of it!

What a crass and idiotic post . Demonstrating absolutely NO understanding of what it is like to live in abject poverty.

Try engaging brain. !

It is not even remotely impossible for £1.1k of that amount to be for rent (that would be cheap in my area)
She could then have £ 600 to pay for 3 children. (Nothing for a third child since 2017) ALL bills, food, clothes, nappies. Transport. - oh and furniture!!

The VAST majority on benefits have zero savings. One disaster and they are fucked. All it takes is a broken washing machine and you are at the prey of high interest lenders.... starting at 49.9% upwards.. whittling your £600 a month down to £500 rapidly.

Actually your post isn't just crass it's offensive.
Educate yourself. Step away from your comfortable life and find out what living with no financial backing is really like.

Spiceup · 19/11/2021 13:31

Is she overseas with a serviceman (and that's why she's eligible)? If so the Army should make sure he supports her. They'll deduct from wages if need be.

TheMaddingCrowd · 19/11/2021 13:28

You sound a bit stressed OP. Try yoga.

knittingaddict · 19/11/2021 13:27

Lovely, a benefits bashing thread.

Do you really think that the government, which a large majority/minority on here think are evil, uncaring bastards, are going to be overly generous with the money they give people? Doesn't quite ring true does it?

Whammyyammy · 19/11/2021 13:23

£1700 per month. I didn't realise it was that much. I hope your friend and her children escape the situation they're in.

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 13:20

@oviraptor21

As a returning British citizen she needs to show intention to settle. Complete nonsense about a six month wait. Also nonsense about LHA being 1/3 of rent. Of course she will be looking at the very cheapest rentals and it's likely that the LHA will be short of that but nothing like the scaremongering 1/3 quoted. Contact Citizens Advice.
Thank you for the helpful post 😊

And thsnk you to the two posters also above my previous post who were also helpful - I wasn't having a go at you with my last reply! It was the sarcastic poster who seems to be implying that I'm lying who I was snapping at. As if anyone would make this up? What a hilarious joke it would be, women and children fleeing domestic abuse is so funny and lighthearted 😒

Sorry, just wanted to say that my last post wasn't directed at you as it looks like it was - my MN kept crashing and it didn't post when I wanted it to!

Actually off now! Bye again Grin

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 19/11/2021 12:46

As a returning British citizen she needs to show intention to settle. Complete nonsense about a six month wait.
Also nonsense about LHA being 1/3 of rent. Of course she will be looking at the very cheapest rentals and it's likely that the LHA will be short of that but nothing like the scaremongering 1/3 quoted.
Contact Citizens Advice.

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 12:45

We haven't contacted DWP for goodness sake. She was out of the country but the nature of her being so was very much connected to the UK. Hence the fact it's a STRESSFUL FUCKING POTENTIALLY LIFE THREATENING EMERGENCY FOR HER AND HER TWO YOUNG CHILDREN she has family and friends at home trying to find out as much as possible too/making calls/finding information

So disappointed with Mumsnet today. I thought a forum of women, for women, would be more supporting of a young mother trying to escape abuse and return to her family because her actual fucking life is at risk, but it seems like some people are bitter and bored and have nothing better to do than be bitches online.

Okay yeah I'm definitely going now, I am done with this. thanks again to the helpful ones. To the nasty posters, I hope you sort out whatever is going on with you that makes you behave like hugh school bullies.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 19/11/2021 12:42

@CorrBlimeyGG

We have just found out that she is immediatley eligible for everything, without giving away too much details, due to the nature of her being abroad. What a relief!

Well that's an amazing surprise. How did you get the DWP to make that decision in such a short time?

It could be because the person has returned from Afghanistan, or there are arrangements for EU citizens who have lived in the UK for over 5 years but haven't sorted out their settled status.
Dishwashersaurous · 19/11/2021 12:40

Is she a military spouse?

Sometimes different rules apply. And I can understand why she won't want to contact military support but she should

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 12:39

@loislovesstewie

She will have to be habitually resident even if she holds a UK passport. No-one can advise when that will happen as it is a case of re-establishing herself in the country. If she does come back then she needs to be aware that she might not be eligible straight away.
We have checked and it seems she is immediately eligible due to the nature of why she has been living abroad. (Very much connected to the UK.) Thank you for the advice though.

I'm leaving this thread now because we've got the information we need and dealing with AIBU on top of a stressful situation is a bit too much. Thanks to those who were helpful and gave advice!

OP posts:
CorrBlimeyGG · 19/11/2021 12:36

We have just found out that she is immediatley eligible for everything, without giving away too much details, due to the nature of her being abroad. What a relief!

Well that's an amazing surprise. How did you get the DWP to make that decision in such a short time?

loislovesstewie · 19/11/2021 12:34

She will have to be habitually resident even if she holds a UK passport. No-one can advise when that will happen as it is a case of re-establishing herself in the country. If she does come back then she needs to be aware that she might not be eligible straight away.

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 12:26

Genuine apologies as it seems you are a regular poster, but really you could have realised that your post and thread title is worded almost exactly like the benefits outrage troll posts we see very often.

Thank you for the apology, I'm sorry to be snappy but I'm worried for my friend and we are trying to get as much info as quickly as possible with very little knowledge, so thought MN would be a good place to turn. I have no problem with anyone on benefits (or why would I be helping someone to try and get them?) and I obviously didn't mean that 1700 is enough for a luxurious lifestyle, but it can really make the difference between escape being possible or being impossible. We genuinely thought she'd get far smaller of an amount and so were obviously pleasantly surprised to find she can rent and live, however frugally, she can physically survive, and for now, that's enough.

I am a regular poster and have actually been on MN for way longer, with many name changes. If anyone doubts me please as MNHQ to verify. But what a sad thing this would be to lie/troll about 😢

OP posts:
Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 12:21

Thank you for the helpful posters. I wasn't looking to enter into a debate with anyone about whether the amount is big or small. Like I said, compared to nothing, 1700 is a huge amount and will allow her to set herself up and get sorted with her own work etc. If her payments dont come in for 5 weeks it's no problem, my husband snd I can support her for a while/give her some money for them she first arrives, and she has close friends and family at home who will also help.

All we wanted was an idea of if this amount the caculator came up with is accurate as we have no history with or knowledge of this sort of thing. I don't want to start a debate about food banks or the bloody tories so save it for another thread please. It's not the time or the place. This is about helping a woman and her children out of a horrible situation. I couldn't care less about any else that's been mentioned snarkily, just need to help a friend.

OP posts:
TheMaddingCrowd · 19/11/2021 12:15

We have just found out that she is immediatley eligible for everything,

Handy.

Akire · 19/11/2021 12:13

Just checked mine give you an example
Council rent £80 week one bed
I’m in housing association mine is £125 week
Local private rent around £270 week

Max my council pay is £212 a week so I would have find extra £232 extra per month.
Out of other benefits, luckily I don’t have to but for many people huge struggle.

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 12:13

We have just found out that she is immediatley eligible for everything, without giving away too much details, due to the nature of her being abroad. What a relief!

To the melodramatic person who called me ridiculous - in what way is anyone being ridiculous? My friend has had an absolute crisis and needs some help to rebuild her life due to escape abuse. She isn't able to access her finances here due to said abuse and needs to exit quickly and discreetly for her safety. I can't go into more detail as it's not my story to tell, the whole situation is pretty outing, and frankly it's none of your damn business. She thought she'd get NOTHING, so knowing she will get SOMETHING while she and her children rebuild their lives is a HUGE relief for her and yes, compared to nothing 1700 is a HUGE amount. Okay?

If you don't have anything nice to say then don't say anything, as you don't know what other people are going through.

OP posts:
TheMaddingCrowd · 19/11/2021 12:09

Really it's much easier to get a job than it is to claim benefits.

I mean it is anyway full stop LOL, but especially for people coming from outside the UK it's crackers to come here without work.

Can't she just apply from where she is?

Chloemol · 19/11/2021 12:05

She won’t get benefits, if she is entitled to then, straightaway

She may not be entitled to benefits having been abroad

It’s not as simple as coughing up £800 for rent, as she has no history references may be required, a guarantor may be required, private renters don’t always like benefit recipients. Added to which she will need deposit and rent money up front, never m8 d furniture etc

Surely she is better coming back and staying with family first

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 12:04

As others said housing allowance is MAX of 30% local rents. So mostly only covers the social council housing stock. Great if you have one but private rents are often double council rates. If you go on the council website and follow links it will give max amount per area which may give you more realistic idea.

Ponoka7 · 19/11/2021 12:03

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons, I've known families to be funded via SS and given hostel accommodation, but it's been an absolute crisis. That's why I said that departments argue whose responsibility it is.
Were the families who you dealt with put back on a plane?