Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits

116 replies

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 10:53

Posting for traffic!

I am an expat and just really don't understand benefits at all and have no idea of how much people get (I moved pretty much right after uni and my kids were born abroad so never really was entitled to them).

One of my good friends here is planning to move back to the UK with her two children. She has been living abroad for a few years but is British. She wants to claim benefits until she gets herself sorted with a job and we have just used a gov.uk benefits calculator and it tells her she can get almost £1700 a month 😳 This can't be right, can it? It seems like a awful lot more than we were expecting! She filled in her details accurately (twice!) and this is what it came up with. Is this an average sort of amount? I always assumed benefits like like, a third of this maximum!

(Please be kind, she's leaving due to a very sensitive situation and needs to leave urgently so doesn't have time to find work etc first. But will get started with the job search when she's safely back.).

OP posts:
BrilliantBetty · 19/11/2021 16:02

Yes it is loads. Where I live Housing Benefit rate alone is £1,595 per month. For a three bedroom house or flat.
Then there would be all the other benefits on top.

I work incredibly hard to earn that. It's hard to stomach that some people just take it and give nothing back.

gogohm · 19/11/2021 15:59

@MadameGazellee

Please do wish her well from me, it's hard, I know of a man who fled dv married to a diplomat, she's certainly not alone in being posted overseas and the situation being abusive. Ignore the nasty comments.

gogohm · 19/11/2021 15:52

Her biggest problem is the habitual residence test. It varies depending on the type of benefits eg I could register for a gp but couldn't get a cancer referral 9 months after arriving back. We could claim child benefits and child tax credits straight away (this was before uc) but I didn't try for out of work benefits. If the move is due to bereavement, domestic violence or other life changing situation make sure she has evidence to prove her situation. She will need two ideally three months rent (one month deposit plus first months rent whilst she seeks financial help.

Best of luck to her whatever the reason

Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 15:51

@fournonblondes

I can’t believe people who live abroad for years can come back and get benefits. Anyway enjoy while last because this pretty sure is unsustainable.
If you knew what the job was, you wouldn´t say this.
OP posts:
Shasha17 · 19/11/2021 15:49

Hello all,

I just came back because I´m genuinely really shocked and upset to have basically been called a troll when I´m honestly just looking for advice, and I just wanted to clear it up because I am a regular poster on here and it bothers me that people might think I´m a troll. Sad, yes, that I care about the opinions of anonymous Mumsnetters, but apparently I do.

So to clear it up: YES; my friend and I were DELIGHTED to see that she was entitled to enough money for her to escape her situation. I was in NO way commenting on benefits in general, or saying that this is a lot of money IN GENERAL. But for my friend´s specific situation, when she thought she would get NOTHING, to find out she can get enough to pay rent and at least survive, means the ABSOLUTE world. I didn´t say it was going to give her a life of luxury. I didn´t say she wouldn´t struggle. But she can survive! In this situation, that´s all that matters.

Having this information is enough to help her, her family, and us, her friends, to start to make plans to get her and her children out of danger and away from the reason she is in danger. So yes. We were really happy that this might be possible. And obviously that comes across in the post because I didn´t think it was something I needed to hide.

If ANYONE genuinely suspects me of being a troll or making up a situation, please report me to Mumsnet HQ ASAP. Mumsnet will be able to verify that I am a regular, active poster and have been using Mumsnet for years now under different usernames. My life as an expat has been mentioned numerous times under both this username and my others. The only thing that MNHQ cannot confirm is that my friend is trying to flee abuse, but I can guarentee you that I am not sick or twisted enough to make this horrible situation up just to make some kind of dig at a benefits system that I don´t even understand, in a country where I don´t even reside.

For those of you implying that I´m lying because I have said that my friend will be entitled to claim immediately - you can research for yourselves that there are many people who are able to do this. Those of you who mentioned the forces are on the right track, it is for this type of reason. We didn´t miraculously get a consultation in the space of time that it took me to write this thread, but we found information online stating that people IN HER SPECIFIC SITUATION (like that of military spouses) are entitled to claim without going through the normal processes that other Brits returning from abroad might.

Thank you to those of you who explained to me why everyone was being so horrible. I was really shocked and upset, because I really thought that Mumsnet would be supportive. I have seen victims of domestic violence counselled through how to leave their abuser on Mumsnet, with posters who had been through a similar telling them step by step what to do and helping them to escape. That is a wonderful side of Mumsnet. I had hoped and even expected for that from this post, which is why I was so angry and snappy and upset. This is a stressful time anyway. I honestly didn´t even know that there were people who made up fake situations to criticise benefits. I generally don´t open benefits threads because they don´t interest me as I don´t know what they´re talking about so I haven´t seen this personally and didn´t know it was something I need to actively show I´m NOT doing.

Yes, I posted in AIBU for traffic because this is quite literally an emergency and I needed quick responses.

Anyway, there you go. If you still think this is all a big lie then please hit the ´report´ button.

Thank you again to those of you who are helping. Any information is useful, even saying it will be difficult. We need to know the realities of the situation so we can make a plan.

OP posts:
fournonblondes · 19/11/2021 15:30

There are plenty of jobs at the moment btw

loislovesstewie · 19/11/2021 15:28

I don't know where the '6 months' thing comes from either.

fournonblondes · 19/11/2021 15:26

I can’t believe people who live abroad for years can come back and get benefits. Anyway enjoy while last because this pretty sure is unsustainable.

butterpuffed · 19/11/2021 15:24

@2020isnotbehaving

Water bills? Not in Uk cheap nothing same price anyone often higher if forced use pre paid meter for gas and electric that will cut you if run out credit.
You can get reductions in water and sewage bills if you receive certain benefits. It's called Social Tariff.
RaisedByPangolins · 19/11/2021 15:17

It was the sarcastic poster who seems to be implying that I'm lying who I was snapping at. As if anyone would make this up? What a hilarious joke it would be, women and children fleeing domestic abuse is so funny and lighthearted

There are threads almost weekly doing exactly that OP.

Those of us who rely on benefits are pissed off at having to try and defend this to the bloody trolls and their supporters who crow about how much free money we’re getting for popping out babies and sitting on our arsed all day, all the while conveniently ignoring the fact that most benefit claimants are actually IN WORK but just not earning enough to support a household on their one low wage and that many of us had our children with a husband who we thought would be there to support us.

Please don’t be offended that people immediately jumped to the conclusion that you are one of them.

Your thread title and subsequent “delight” at realising how much lovely money your friend would be getting for free whilst also (shock horror!) not even being a UK citizen at this point, is the absolute blueprint for these arseholes who come on here and passive aggressively berate anyone who’s not on a 6 figure income in a settled marriage for their poor life choices.

oviraptor21 · 19/11/2021 15:10

Let's put to bed this idea that you have to be in the UK for six months.
The claimant is a returning British Citizen so she fulfills the right to reside part of the habitual residence test. She then has to fulfil the habitually resident test. Details here -
www.citizensadvice.org.uk/benefits/claiming-benefits-if-youre-from-the-EU/before-you-apply/check-if-you-can-pass-the-habitual-residence-test-for-benefits/#h-showing-you-re-habitually-resident
Some claimants have been able to show this from day 1. OPs friend's circumstances seem to indicate that they are likely to be in a 1 month or less category.

loislovesstewie · 19/11/2021 14:53

To clarify, if the person keeps a property in the UK then they might still be considered to be HR. It’s moving out of the UK, lock, stock and barrel that causes the issue. So, if I moved to Greece, took all my stuff, lived there, settled there and then came back I might well not be HR. If I kept my house in the UK but went to Greece for 6 months and then back to the UK I would still be HR. There are always exceptions though, and it's possible that some extenuating factor would cause a person to be HR. I would say to anyone though, if you move out of the UK, you might not get the answer you want if/when you return.

rainbowdashsneeze · 19/11/2021 14:45

[quote loislovesstewie]@rainbowdashsneeze, sorry but a UK citizen still has to be habitually resident. I have had this conversation so often over the years with people who are UK citizens, lived abroad for years and then return to the UK and are furious because they are not habitually resident and don't qualify for benefits or social housing. In the fulness of time, if they stay in the UK, then they will be HB, just not straight away.[/quote]
A friend of mine is resident in Spain and she claims every time she returns for a couple of months. I wonder if she is defrauding the system.

loislovesstewie · 19/11/2021 14:43

@rainbowdashsneeze, sorry but a UK citizen still has to be habitually resident. I have had this conversation so often over the years with people who are UK citizens, lived abroad for years and then return to the UK and are furious because they are not habitually resident and don't qualify for benefits or social housing. In the fulness of time, if they stay in the UK, then they will be HB, just not straight away.

KevinTheKoala · 19/11/2021 14:41

Rent £800 + Council tax let's say £120 + food £300? + gas and electric £80? + any car/travel expenses? + Internet package? + hygiene products etc. It really won't leave your friend with much at all and benefits are not an easy life for anyone.

WhenZoomWasJustAnIceLolly · 19/11/2021 14:28

Go to citizens advice for proper reliable advice. There’s a lot of misinformation here.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 14:23

Water bills? Not in Uk cheap nothing same price anyone often higher if forced use pre paid meter for gas and electric that will cut you if run out credit.

MoodyMooTutu · 19/11/2021 14:20

@Ghoulette

1800, minus rent, minus council tax even at the discounted rate, minus electricity, gas and water, munis food for her and the kids on top of that will leave her with NOTHING.

All you you who are sitting on your middle class thrones saying 1700 is plenty can fuck right off unless you have actually lived it and had to make the choice between paying the water bill or feeding your children. You all disgust me.

£1700 can be plenty for you to live off. This benefit amount is including rent, but; You get reduced or exemption to council tax, cheaper water rates, free school meals, free prescriptions, free dental. Now compare that to some poor bastard that’s worked hard, bought a house and then lost their job through no fault of their own so will have no direct help with mortgage so having to find that money before they even think about the poxy water bill being paid. Which camp are you in?
shouldistop · 19/11/2021 14:18

I'm assuming ops friend is either an army wife or was in the army so will be entitled to benefits immediately.

Lostmyheart101 · 19/11/2021 14:18

I think your friend should be careful OP.
Such as it goes “if it’s too good to be true”.

The benefits system is no walk in the park.

£1700 might sound like a lot, but if your near minimum monthly expense is £1650, then it’s not a lot os it, especially if something goes wrong or needs repairing.

Itsjustrenee · 19/11/2021 14:16

@Willyoujustbequiet

Don't be so bloody ridiculous. A life on benefits is incredibly hard. People literally starve and others take their own lives as they can't face their living conditions.

I have a disabled friend who is losing her home that she's worked all her life for as she's entitled to the princely sum of approx £500 on Universal Credit. No help with her mortgage when she lost her job due to Covid and she's been waiting a year for a disability assessment.

This is the reality of Tory Britain fgs.

It’s so hard people manage to have big fuck off tv’s, sky television, mobile phones and smoke like troopers.

I’m generalising of course, but this was frequently the situation with the people on benefits that I came across in my law enforcement career.

I’m sure some struggle, particularly post Covid, but many see benefits as their wages and refer to it as their ‘pay’. If people are getting nearly 2 grand a month it’s no wonder some people don’t want to work.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 19/11/2021 14:10

It depends on what her local housing allowance is and whether she can find anywhere to rent within that limit.
But yes, people can get their rent paid which obviously increases the amount you can claim significantly.

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/11/2021 14:09

I think it's the opposite of a benefits bashing tbh. I took the original post to be a bit of a snide dig at the amounts available but the vast majority are rightly pointing out how difficult the system is

How wonderful that the OP has found out her friend is immediately entitled to everything.

Skyechasemarshalontheway · 19/11/2021 14:08

Lot of people living abroad who return to the uk do not need to wait for benefits.

Its not only military jobs included in that.

LakieLady · 19/11/2021 14:05

@BoredZelda

Gosh, there have been a lot of people recently posting on here who are surprised about the amount of benefits their friends and neighbours can get.

It's surprising, isn't it. And with the amounts that are apparently claimable I'm amazed the food banks are reporting record numbers of referrals. If this is Tory austerity, let's have more of it!

Unless you know how much someone's rent is, you can't possibly know how much of that money is actually available to them to spend.

The basic amount for a couple is £403.93 a month. That's less than £100 a week to pay all their bills, feed and clothe themselves, and probably pay something towards their rent and council tax.

It's doable, but they're not going to be living in the lap of luxury. And at that level of income, they're not going to be able to build up savings so that they can replace essential household items when they break.