Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

2nd marriage. Learning to be better or keeping up appearances

32 replies

Chchchanger · 19/11/2021 08:43

Do men try harder in second marriages?
Or do they try harder to not let another woman tell everyone they're still a twat?

Just wondering if men really learn and change or if they're just more aware that if they get divorced a second time it'll look really bad.
I mean you can pretend once your ex wife was 'crazy' and you were the victim because you have a new wife that is still there. If the second wife leaves or marriage breaks down, your story of being a victim starts to look less plausible.

I guess I just wonder how many second marriages are built on more understanding and less thoughts of leaving because of this.
Whether it's really because they don't want a failed marriage again or because they genuinely learn from the first.

Look at Ross from friends. 3 failed marriages.
What draws a woman to someone on their 3rd marriage? Does it happen in real life?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 19:41

Can't really generalise: there are as many second marriages as there are first marriages.

Your post is a bit loaded: it seems to imply firstly that all first marriages fail because of men's infidelity and secondly that people whose first marriages have failed have done so because they are not good people. In fact there are a million reasons why a marriage can break down and while cheating certainly plays a part in some its not always the case.

FWIW I think quite a lot of people marry (the first time) far too young, before they really know themselves or what they want when they would have been better off staying single longer.

I've seen plenty of serial cheaters who can't make a committed relationship work and I'm sure a lot of men in particular fail to learn these lessons from a failed marriage. But I've also seen people use a first marriage to learn about themselves and what they actually need from a relationship and try to build on it.

iheartredsquirrels · 19/11/2021 19:29

I was widowed young at 19 [5 months], divorced [6 years], widowed during divorce proceedings [14 months] and now been married very happily for 20 years.
Finally found THE ONE, his 3rd marriage too,Smile

TroublesomeTrucks · 19/11/2021 19:00

I am my husband's 4th wife. I've lasted longer than any of the others - but each marriage ended for different reasons, rather than there being a repeating pattern. I knew when we got together how bad it looked on paper but I was certain we would work. And we do.

DrSbaitso · 19/11/2021 18:39

@thepinknecklace

Interesting....

I worked with for woman who was married to a man who’d left his first wife because apparently she was “a slob” who wore her pyjama bottoms about the house Hmm

His second wife (my boss) always wore jeans, nice top around the house and negligees to bed etc. I thought the husband sounded like a prick and she was trying to keep up appearances. She was a dick as well tbh.

How do you know what your boss wears to bed?
frazzledasarock · 19/11/2021 15:23

When ex remarried he picked his wife very carefully, she speaks no English, has no family here and believes, according to the letter she wrote to court that the survivor of DV is 50% responsible.

Chchchanger · 19/11/2021 10:50

@SweeneyToddler

Based solely on my personal observations of marriages around me-

I think women are much more likely to justify things to themselves. Man married multiple times? Poor lamb obviously unfortunate to have met psycho women. Man ruined his marriage(s) due to his own shitty behaviour? Well, he obviously didn’t love those women enough to change but this time it’s different…

I really think this is true. Women can be so horrible about other women and lacking in self esteem that I think they might believe him when he says his ex was crazy, or if he says that then they spend so long trying to be the opposite, squeezing and altering themselves into the cool girl role. Like the example above about ex being in pjs all day so new wife in lingerie all day. Maybe second wives feed this narrative by being or trying to be 'better'. Not so much a pick me dance but a keep me one.

Probably starts to crack when they hear the same stuff the man said about his ex, now being said about them.

OP posts:
Chchchanger · 19/11/2021 10:44

@Santaischeckinglists

My dh is my 4th dh. He knows I now accept no shit.. So he gives me none! Grin He knew in our first conversation I had been married 3 times. He didn't judge me.
🤣🤣 I'd wonder what you were doing at no 2 never mind 4!!! That's a lot if self punishment
OP posts:
SweeneyToddler · 19/11/2021 10:43

Based solely on my personal observations of marriages around me-

I think women are much more likely to justify things to themselves. Man married multiple times? Poor lamb obviously unfortunate to have met psycho women. Man ruined his marriage(s) due to his own shitty behaviour? Well, he obviously didn’t love those women enough to change but this time it’s different…

Santaischeckinglists · 19/11/2021 10:39

My dh is my 4th dh. He knows I now accept no shit..
So he gives me none!
Grin
He knew in our first conversation I had been married 3 times. He didn't judge me.

GoodnightGrandma · 19/11/2021 10:38

Yep, I going to be worse off but I’m still doing it !
To be emotionally and financially free will be great.

Chchchanger · 19/11/2021 10:36

@BlueTouchPaper

You’re making the assumption that a marriage has failed because of the man’s behaviour Exactly what I was going to say. Two marriages of my acquaintances failed because of the wife's affairs.
Yes of course women cheat. In my experience though in an office full of men, most were or thinking about cheating. They're not trustworthy
OP posts:
Chchchanger · 19/11/2021 10:34

With so many divorces orchestrated by women even though they'll be usually the worst off and men usually quickly remarrying citing 'crazy ex'.
It's just a thought that maybe second time around they're more careful to not have that story questioned.

And wait. Friends isn't real? 🤣

OP posts:
BlueTouchPaper · 19/11/2021 10:12

You’re making the assumption that a marriage has failed because of the man’s behaviour
Exactly what I was going to say. Two marriages of my acquaintances failed because of the wife's affairs.

Hospedia · 19/11/2021 10:04

A friend of mine has been married three times. First marriage they were both 18 and, in her words, stupid. They got married because she was pregnant, both very quickly regretted it and were living apart before their DC was even a year old. Around ten years later she got married again, they had a really good relationship, it all seemed fine until around four years after the wedding (roughly six or seven years into the relationship) when he lost his job, started doing drugs, and then started dealing drugs. Then around three years ago she married her current husband, they've been together around five years and in all honesty I've never known her to be as happy as she is now.

My father was married before he met my mother, married at 17 with parental permission, she was 16. Shockingly it didn't work out. He's been with my mother for over 40 years.

DrSbaitso · 19/11/2021 09:57

@PinkWednesdays

You’re making the assumption that a marriage has failed because of the man’s behaviour.

In reality, marriages fail for a variety of reasons, so there isn’t necessarily something to learn or change in the second marriage.

I believe most divorces are instigated by women.

I know that doesn't necessarily translate to it being as simple as "the man's fault", but it does suggest that in most cases, the man was satisfied with the situation as it was and preferred to retain it than to divorce, but the woman felt very differently.

LucentBlade · 19/11/2021 09:54

A lot of people settle down at too young an age and don’t do enough stuff as an individual. Having a partner means making compromises. It’s the reason I chose to not to bother with men much at all. I loved being able to do just what I wanted when I wanted with zero consideration as to consequences because I could just please myself.

So many women I worked with and even a lot of my friends were worrying about The One. I found it alarming how much they yearned for a partner. My Mother was married four times I just remember thinking was it worth all the hassle and to rely on myself only. I did to my utter shock meet someone, I wasn’t looking and surprisingly to me we have been married for almost 23 years.

DrSbaitso · 19/11/2021 09:53

I think a lot of it depends on why the first marriage ended.

If they were just incompatible, married too young etc then they’ll probably go into the next one a bit wiser.

If they ended because the man was absent as a partner and father and let the woman carry everything - or vice versa, of course, though that's less likely - then that seems to repeat itself. Some women are prepared to put up with it. He's lovely, really. Such a great dad.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/11/2021 09:52

You’re making the assumption that a marriage has failed because of the man’s behaviour.

^^
I bet in reality the majority do - either behaving unreasonably to their wife - being unkind or abusive, not doing their fair share etc - or infidelity

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/11/2021 09:51

Yes I’m sure my ex thinks he’s the “winner” and everyone will think he’s the reasonable one because he has a new partner (and child) and I’m single

Doesn’t take into account personal choice of course!

PinkWednesdays · 19/11/2021 09:49

You’re making the assumption that a marriage has failed because of the man’s behaviour.

In reality, marriages fail for a variety of reasons, so there isn’t necessarily something to learn or change in the second marriage.

beingsunny · 19/11/2021 09:35

Nope, these men still have the same issues.

Not married but but now very recent ex of six years repeated the same patterns with me as his ex wife. I was crazy, unstable and everything was my fault.

The issues are his and his alone, until he can accept and get help for them he is sadly likely to repeat this in his next relationship.

However some people can change, I know I have, I learnt a lot from my relationship with him and am able to reflect on my marriage I had before we met (with the help of a good therapist)

thepinknecklace · 19/11/2021 09:34

Interesting....

I worked with for woman who was married to a man who’d left his first wife because apparently she was “a slob” who wore her pyjama bottoms about the house Hmm

His second wife (my boss) always wore jeans, nice top around the house and negligees to bed etc. I thought the husband sounded like a prick and she was trying to keep up appearances. She was a dick as well tbh.

ProudAlly · 19/11/2021 09:31

My ex is on his fourth marriage having been divorced three times for adultery. Draw your own conclusions.

wizzywig · 19/11/2021 09:28

I'd say after an hour on mumsnet, yyou'll see people making the same mistakes in their relationships.

Spiceup · 19/11/2021 09:25

If you're going to use Ross as an example he was always in love with someone else and should never have married the first two.