Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

legacy benefits court case

138 replies

Mychocolateteapotsmelted · 19/11/2021 06:26

Its for the 20 pounds uplift that universal credit claimants got and people on legacy benefits didn't get..the case started yesterday and ends today.

OP posts:
Bingbong21 · 19/11/2021 21:38

@Lancrelady80 you should not have got it. It was explicitly clarified those just on CTC were not eligible. I'm just on CTC and didn't receive it.

Lancrelady80 · 19/11/2021 20:37

[quote Bingbong21]@TheHateIsNotGood no they did not. People solely on CTC, ie those on these legacy benefits did not get it.[/quote]
We were on child tax credits only, and we got it. 500 equates to 25 weeks with an extra 20.

No longer eligible for anything now (just earning over threshold) so fully expect that we would be missed out if it is agreed that it was unfair and should be adjusted.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 18:33

I think contributions based are only for 12months aren’t they? After that it’s on household income. Technically you could also have a very high household income but claim contributions in your own right because of NI contributions and rightly so to get something back out system rather 100% relying on a partner.

But Maybe easier to include those who’s only income is ESA income support and play on the poverty income levels against similar UC. Only those groups have a cast iron this is blatant discrimination verses some government spokesperson saying ah ha some contribution based house holds had incomes of £50,000 and makes it sound like everyone was and no need. Although still unfair I agree

ChiefAdjusterOfRubensShorts · 19/11/2021 18:13

I’m on old style ESA but contributions based.

Why are they not including contributions based as well?

Genuine question and I really hope everyone gets what they do rightly deserve.

FaceFullOfCake · 19/11/2021 17:36

...Even if it goes in favour of the legacy benefits claimants, it cannot compel the government to give them backdated payments.

www.bigissue.com/news/social-justice/dwp-legacy-benefits-freeze-left-disabled-people-living-on-historically-low-payments-court-hears/

I'm not holding out any hope of the government making a single payment.

TheHateIsNotGood · 19/11/2021 16:46

Just those on WTC must have. Btw I do agree that all income-based benefit recipients should have received an uplift just as those on UC did.

Bingbong21 · 19/11/2021 16:19

@TheHateIsNotGood no they did not. People solely on CTC, ie those on these legacy benefits did not get it.

Tabbacus · 19/11/2021 16:14

I hope it gets approved, cynically seemed like a way to entice people over to UC, many or whom will have been worse off.

Amar8989 · 19/11/2021 16:12

@2020isnotbehaving

I imagine carers was excluded because very few people live on it as sole income. You still either claim old style income support alongside carers (I know they then deduct carers) in which case included in this claim or you get carers and your over all household budget means you don’t get any household benefits.

Agree though when carers did more than ever with little support it would made difference. The fact it’s still less than JSA is beyond belief

I didn’t realise you got income support as well as carers 🙈 We are a low income house, partner only works part time in a weather dependant job. We get Child Tax Credits, and Carers, but like you say @2020isnotbehaving Carers seem to be forgotten. We have 2 children with ASN and our costs have gone up dramatically over the past year. £20 a week would have been very handy, as would a lump sum! Xx
2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 16:04

I imagine carers was excluded because very few people live on it as sole income. You still either claim old style income support alongside carers (I know they then deduct carers) in which case included in this claim or you get carers and your over all household budget means you don’t get any household benefits.

Agree though when carers did more than ever with little support it would made difference. The fact it’s still less than JSA is beyond belief

OzziePopPop · 19/11/2021 16:03

This affects us too, (I’m severely disabled). So, so praying we get this… it’d make Christmas and beyond so much easier!!

OnyxOryx · 19/11/2021 16:03

@Mychocolateteapotsmelted

I know a out of work (never worked not claiming for any disability) adult male on universal credit Previously job seekers allowance, who got the 20 pounds uplift. My sister who has a severe disabled child is on income support and got nothing 😢 how is that fair 🤷‍♀️
The £20 thing aside, I'm wanting to point out that being disabled sufficient to qualify for disability benefits isn't the same as being unable to work due to long term illness. So being long term unemployed and not disabled doesn't necessarily mean he's playing the system.
TheHateIsNotGood · 19/11/2021 16:02

yes they did cat I was a CTC/WTC claimant at the time and I received the £500. It didn't come with much explanation but I assumed it equated to the £20 uplift received by UC claimants.

I thought IS was gone, but then I was a legacy TC Claimant and know nothing about any other legacy benefits.

I'm now a working(self-employed) UC Claimant, whilst still a Carer for disabled DS, no uplift and it's harsh.

Will be better come next April when they change the % of disregarded earnings to 2/3rds rather than the 1/3rd it is now.

Better still, hopefully I'll be earning enough to not be claiming UC at all, but so far no employer wants me. Who would want a 59 year old who's been self-employed (through necessity) for nearly 20 years when there's so many other options available? I understand that and don't take it to heart.

So, I'll just have to work at home some more, waiting for the Golden Ticket :)

Amar8989 · 19/11/2021 15:59

Ah, thanks for the reply, it’s all very confusing as the people involved in the court case are ESA, JSA and income support, however I wasn’t sure if they didn’t have representation for Carers, as some articles refer to Carers but most don’t 🤔

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 15:58

My Money is on poor government everyone is picking on them only doing their best and no rules were broken rubbish. But because they are so amazing caring they give everyone on legacy benefits £100 and half society will think we are money grabbing some scum bags and spent it all on fags. Grin

CorrBlimeyGG · 19/11/2021 15:56

It's estimated that the business bounce back loans will cost the government £27 billion due to fraud, businesses gone bust, and money that has just disappeared. Yet people are more bothered about those on the lowest incomes, getting an extra £20 a week.

FaceFullOfCake · 19/11/2021 15:56

@2020isnotbehaving yeah, the "computer says no" defence doesn't wash with me either.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 15:54

Just read article as well oh dear it’s to complicated card ha ha. As if some poor person at DWP would have to go through and Change the amounts on each person. They seem mange fine for pennies on any uplift or our fantastic £10 Xmas bonus or even cold weather payment which triggered “automatically” when your local area drops below 0c for 7 days in row. There is computer program for that ….

FaceFullOfCake · 19/11/2021 15:54

It's usually a couple of weeks before the judgment is given. After that the DWP may choose to appeal
Thanks for the info @CorrBlimeyGG
Will be keeping an eye out for it - I'm on ESA so have skin in the game, as it were.

CorrBlimeyGG · 19/11/2021 15:51

It's usually a couple of weeks before the judgment is given. After that the DWP may choose to appeal.

The argument that the legacy It system wouldn't be able to facilitate the increase is nonsensical. They can apply the annual uplift (when one is given), so no reason why this couldn't be done in exactly that same way.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 15:49

Fingers crossed here too but doubt it. On ESA can’t see it happening. It’s hard when a disabled people are routinely let down on purpose. There no really reason why couldn’t been included. The Gov couldn’t afford give me £20 week that bridge to far but you could been furloughed and got second job and had 2 incomes and this was total fine

FaceFullOfCake · 19/11/2021 15:47

Sorry @Amar8989 - I just re-read your post. As far as I know, CTC and carers are not the same thing as income support.

FaceFullOfCake · 19/11/2021 15:44

@Jagley www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/uk-news/dwp-court-case-benefit-claimants-22213866.amp

@Amar8989
The benefits involved in the court case are:
-Income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
-Income Support
-Income-based Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA)

Anyone know when the judgement/ruling is due?

Theunamedcat · 19/11/2021 15:43

I thought they gave people on tax credits £500 to cover some of this?

Richyg · 19/11/2021 15:40

Tell me when we’ve won