Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

legacy benefits court case

138 replies

Mychocolateteapotsmelted · 19/11/2021 06:26

Its for the 20 pounds uplift that universal credit claimants got and people on legacy benefits didn't get..the case started yesterday and ends today.

OP posts:
2020isnotbehaving · 22/11/2021 18:19

UC and furlough totally different things. Many on furlough would not been able claim a penny. Maybe if you had few kids and very low wage so 80% mim wage would leave you short. The point of furlough was stop millions piling on the benefit system and frankly holding up the notice that hard working people don’t claim benefits.

Dishwashersaurous · 22/11/2021 18:17

And technically someone can be LCWRA and working as well

Dishwashersaurous · 22/11/2021 18:16

The systems wouldn't allow UC to differentiate between not working and working. Hence everyone got it.

(I'm just explaining the logic not agreeing)

XenoBitch · 22/11/2021 18:13

@Dishwashersaurous

The argument for it being UC is that UC is an in work benefit and that furlough only paid 80%. So in theory it's to make up for the difference in being furloughed
Everyone claiming UC got the uplift, not just people that are working. I got it (am in LCWRA) despite my costs not increasing due to being stuck at home (because I was always home anyway).
Dishwashersaurous · 22/11/2021 18:09

The argument for it being UC is that UC is an in work benefit and that furlough only paid 80%. So in theory it's to make up for the difference in being furloughed

JustLyra · 22/11/2021 17:42

@Thehop

Why did people on UC get the extra £20 a week in the first place? I never read the reason.

If there was good reason for it I honestly don’t see the difference and it should have been across t board.

It was to help people with the lowest incomes cope with the extra costs of the pandemic.

Things like suddenly being home all the time and needing to heat their house rather than being at work and kids at school.
Extra food costs. Extra electricity costs.

It should have been across the board, but the government will take any opportunity to try and force people to choose to switch because they'll lose their migration protection.

Thehop · 21/11/2021 16:33

Why did people on UC get the extra £20 a week in the first place? I never read the reason.

If there was good reason for it I honestly don’t see the difference and it should have been across t board.

Jhon5912 · 21/11/2021 16:32

"Tell him to check out of he is entitled to Pension Credit too, especially if he has any disability premiums on his ESA, or gets PIP or DLA."

Edit, Not he did not originally have any of these.

Jhon5912 · 21/11/2021 16:27

"brain bleed Opration" ^

Jhon5912 · 21/11/2021 16:23

Hi Colin

I see that's grate many thanks for your answer, sadly he's bean through the works over pass 7 weeks in hospital with pneumonia, liver issues, and a brain bleed that had an brain bleed, glad he's with me / us and lucky to have survived, meaning he's still can't talk on a normal level.

And thanks, me and me sister also applied for pip for him however he may get backpay and then put on attendance allowance, we will see

Mummysgoingcrazy · 21/11/2021 16:15

I had to leave work to care for hubby and kids. Legacy benefits but obviously lost the wtc. We get CTC, pip, and my carer's allowance. No £500 for us so that must have just been on WTC. Really hoping we get awarded something, money's so tight.

Colin7691 · 21/11/2021 15:46

@Jhon5912

My dads Income Support was cut off on 30th November at 66 bithday Now waiting his first state pension, I guess if they win this uplift and good luck and thanks to them for fighting this, They will be no uplift backpay for him?
He will still get it if he were entitled to it as it would cover the period up to the uplift ending earlier this year. Tell him to check out of he is entitled to Pension Credit too, especially if he has any disability premiums on his ESA, or gets PIP or DLA.
Jhon5912 · 21/11/2021 14:22

My dads Income Support was cut off on 30th November at 66 bithday Now waiting his first state pension, I guess if they win this uplift and good luck and thanks to them for fighting this, They will be no uplift backpay for him?

Lancrelady80 · 19/11/2021 22:42

Ah, that sounds about right.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 22:41

I read was to technically difficult and it wasn’t in the aims of fiscal plans. So basically if it didn’t keep the economy afloat and get people “back to work” it didn’t matter as majority us couldn’t and not expected to work. So that was aim
Of £20 lift not to provide people with practically support for high bills.

It’s travesty that disabled people on UC are worse off if they can’t work and if they can. What way screw the system.

Wtfdoipick · 19/11/2021 22:39

Lancrelady80

Although you only received ctc it sounds like you were entitled to wtc because you have earned income you would get allowance for working and the children then it would be reduced due to the amount you earned so you may only get the ctc amount. It would all be laid out on your award notice but the critical bit for the uplift was that you were entitled to the working tax credit allowance.

Colin7691 · 19/11/2021 22:36

@2020isnotbehaving

It’s hard believe any legal bod can stand in defence of Gov and argue with all sincerity that they would loved to given it but oh dear computers bit slow. They can tell by few strikes of keyboard who was on what benefit for right time so why not send us all a cheque? They seem manage letters in post easily enough. Love to see how they explain why can’t be fixed after.

But agree I’m not getting my hopes up. They showed us time and time again how treat those at bottom of ladder, can’t see changing any time soon.

Thats not the main defence though, or at least from whats been written so far, and it would be a stupid one to rely on too, which is probably why they have changed the initial way it seemed to be going.

@mumda people are still on legacy benefits as the full migration hasn't been completed yet. Add to that, legal challenges have stopped some migrations, and covid, have massively impacted the time it should have taken. For example, despite what the DWP are saying, if you had disability premiums on ESA at the start of 2020, you could not transfer to UC, and that restriction wasn't lifted until January this year (so despite the DWP saying anyone who wanted the uplift could have claimed UC, they couldn't). That was because the disability premiums don't exist on UC, and anyone moving over was significantly worse off. A court case that the DWP lost, stopped that, and was why they stopped any migration at that time.

Lancrelady80 · 19/11/2021 22:30

From the gov website:

"You may get a one-off, tax-free payment of £500 if, on 2 March 2021, you were getting either:

Working Tax Credit

Or

Child Tax Credit and were eligible for Working Tax Credit but you did not get a payment because your income is too high to get Working Tax Credit payments

You do not need to contact HMRC or apply for the payment. HMRC will contact you by text message or letter in April to confirm you are eligible.

If you are eligible, you should get your payment direct to your bank account by 23 April 2021. The payment will appear in your bank statement as ‘HMRC C19 support’. You will not see the payment on the online tax credit service"

We fell into the second category.

mumda · 19/11/2021 22:28

So why are people still on legacy benefits?

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 22:13

It’s hard believe any legal bod can stand in defence of Gov and argue with all sincerity that they would loved to given it but oh dear computers bit slow. They can tell by few strikes of keyboard who was on what benefit for right time so why not send us all a cheque? They seem manage letters in post easily enough. Love to see how they explain why can’t be fixed after.

But agree I’m not getting my hopes up. They showed us time and time again how treat those at bottom of ladder, can’t see changing any time soon.

JustLyra · 19/11/2021 22:09

@2020isnotbehaving

Thanks I wonder why I’m on income based ESA when I was working full time before hand so had enough NI. Maybe only applies when you live with someone else and in support group that rings a bell as before you had nothing.
You can get both. Those on conts based can get an income related top up.

Also if you are in WRAG group then after 12 months you move onto income related.

Colin7691 · 19/11/2021 22:03

I wouldn't hold out much hope on winning this due to the judge who was allocated.
I thought this was 100% a DWP loss when the case was started, but from the (very limited) press reports, it seems as though the claimants have concentrated on the human rights aspect of it rather than discrimination, which I personally think is the wrong way to have gone about it.

However, it is very hard to get a clear picture of what went on as there has been very little published about it so far, the judgement, when published, will be interesting reading whichever way it goes.

I think if the DWP win, then we will find out in the next 7-14 days. If the claimants win, then more likely 3-4 weeks.

TheHateIsNotGood · 19/11/2021 21:51

Just to clarify something with regards to being a Carer in receipt of Carer's Allowance and now claiming UC.

Although a Carer's Premium is added to the Standard Rate UC, this is mostly removed because any Carers Allowance received is deducted.

My criticism of this is:

If I didn't have to Care for a disabled child/adult I would be fully able now, and for the previous 15 years, to be a full-time participant in the workforce.

So, what little earnings I can muster within my caring responsibilities, are deducted as well as my Carers Allowance too.

Given I'm an LP and have been throughout, so no other income to back up the bills, there is something fundamentally wrong with the UC system as it stands.

Although I do appreciate that some of the changes to the IS/JSA system with regards to employment flexibility are very good.

2020isnotbehaving · 19/11/2021 21:48

Thanks I wonder why I’m on income based ESA when I was working full time before hand so had enough NI. Maybe only applies when you live with someone else and in support group that rings a bell as before you had nothing.

JustLyra · 19/11/2021 21:42

It’s nowhere near as complicated to pay it as the government are claiming. They manage with the £10 Christmas bonus every year.

It was a blatant and cynical attempt to get people on legacy benefits to move onto UC without the income protection they’ll get when they are moved by the DWP.

I think contributions based are only for 12months aren’t they? After that it’s on household income.

For ESA it’s only 12 months for those in the WRAG group, for those in the higher support group (so basically the most disabled) there’s no limit to Conts based ESA.