Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

legacy benefits court case

138 replies

Mychocolateteapotsmelted · 19/11/2021 06:26

Its for the 20 pounds uplift that universal credit claimants got and people on legacy benefits didn't get..the case started yesterday and ends today.

OP posts:
Colin7691 · 29/11/2021 17:20

meant to say CB ESA not IS

Colin7691 · 29/11/2021 17:19

@TimesAHero

Who would qualify for it? Is it for people who are on ESA contribution based too?

A lot of things only apply to income related ESA.

Only income based and only under certain conditions, ie disability premiums. If you have a low income and are on CB IS then you could claim UC too and you could have had the uplift.
TimesAHero · 29/11/2021 17:14

Who would qualify for it? Is it for people who are on ESA contribution based too?

A lot of things only apply to income related ESA.

Akire · 29/11/2021 16:50

I imagine it will be found as being discriminatory BUT they did it for financial
Reason so not to “sink” the pot so oh well never mind for the great good.

Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 29/11/2021 16:45

Still no newsSad It's shocking it's taking so long!.. Same money and circumstances =universal credit + 20 pounds a week extra.. Legacy benifits for the same circumstances =0 per week!. If you haven't been updated to universal credit from Income support to UC a big fat No! to 20 pounds per week extra!

Colin7691 · 29/11/2021 15:57

theres not a chance it will be before Christmas, the judgement might not even be done by then, but even if it is, the DWP will have time to consider an appeal before having to make a single payment, I would doubt any backpayments would be made by Easter, let alone in the next few weeks :(

TimesAHero · 29/11/2021 14:54

That’s a shame. Although I did also read even if the claimants win, it does not mean there will be back payments Sad

TurnUpTurnip · 29/11/2021 14:08

Doubt it will be before Xmas but we can dream 😏

TimesAHero · 29/11/2021 14:07

I read this case concluded on Friday. Does anyone know when we would be expected to find out?

If pay is backdated, it would come in handy for Christmas Grin

nosafeguardingadults · 28/11/2021 13:00

Thank u lakie. Am in that situation daily living enhanced but am frightened of revenge. Maybe cos of domestic violence experience yrs of it and used to revenge things. Thou should be honest that dwp were nicer than most support places on my area more than anywhere else except my doctor. Scared still they'll say it's time for reassessment.. Don't kno when is due anyway tho. Maybe is benefit cap cos don't understand it but in London so maybe housing benefit so much am not allowed extra ESA premium. Maybe will call after Christmas cos definitely don't want risk problem when everywhere closed.

They'll be more angry if lose court case tho.

My biggest worry is being forced to universal credit if domestic violence flee. Am still at risk. Was so upheaval and as traumatic as abuse experiences when tried to leave. If ha evto flee again, staying on legacy would help lots to be one less bad stress thing to be stressed on.

LakieLady · 28/11/2021 12:45

@nosafeguardingadults, if you are getting the daily living component of PIP, and providing that a) no-one claims carer's allowance for helping you and b) you don't live with another adult, you are absolutely entitled to the severe disability premium.

While the DWP are utter bastards, they don't do revenge reassessments on people who claim the premium. In fact, quite the opposite: a while ago they had to contact everyone on PIP/DLA and legacy benefits and start paying the premium to everyone who qualified for it, including thousands of pounds in arrears in a lot of cases.

Please claim it, if you are entitled to it.

nosafeguardingadults · 28/11/2021 12:36

Am legacy benefits person. Want case win but am frightened if case wins, cos scared they'll do something else nasty in revenge like early reassessments pushing more of us to kill ourselves.

Am so scared of reassessment especially cos live in very bad support area so have no support, am not getting the severe disability premium tho doctor said I should be. Too frightened to call DWP cos scared they'll be angry if I get more money so will do revenge and early reassessment and I no strength for that now.

Sorry another thing different thing but about legacy benefits.

Wish was allowed for domestic violence victims to stay on legacy benefits if have ti flee areas. Especially cos many of us need benefits cos of the domestic violence cos young children or cos physical or mental injuries.

Don't want to flee as had very bad experience trying to leave and strength gone at moment especially cos no help in my area but if emergency again, is so much to go through. Is so traumatic frightening so upheaval. Mean a lot to help tiny bit less stress if could stay legacy.

Maybe not long term cos kno be forced in end to do universal credit but need time to recover from domestic abuse first without extra problems. Is also possible some of us may not need stay on benefits forever if allowed safe homes and support to recover.

Sorry confused don't understand. Poster said if case wins, government fights it but is not cheaper giving us the money? Am not understanding maybe. Sorry just am very stressed and cynical and bitter about benefits and also domestic violence and people need to kno is big link.

LakieLady · 28/11/2021 12:32

@mumda

So why are people still on legacy benefits?
Because the DWP have only done an incredibly limited trial of "migrating" claimants from legacy benefits to UC and never got any further with it.

All of which leads me to suspect it didn't go well.

LakieLady · 28/11/2021 12:27

@TheHateIsNotGood

Just to clarify something with regards to being a Carer in receipt of Carer's Allowance and now claiming UC.

Although a Carer's Premium is added to the Standard Rate UC, this is mostly removed because any Carers Allowance received is deducted.

My criticism of this is:

If I didn't have to Care for a disabled child/adult I would be fully able now, and for the previous 15 years, to be a full-time participant in the workforce.

So, what little earnings I can muster within my caring responsibilities, are deducted as well as my Carers Allowance too.

Given I'm an LP and have been throughout, so no other income to back up the bills, there is something fundamentally wrong with the UC system as it stands.

Although I do appreciate that some of the changes to the IS/JSA system with regards to employment flexibility are very good.

The carer's element is the UC equivalent of the carer's premium under legacy benefits. That was only payable in means-tested benefits, and the CA was treated as income and deducted.

The UC system treats carers just like the old system did and, while I agree that carers are treated abominably by the benefit system, they haven't actually made it any worse.

Mychocolateteapotsmelted · 28/11/2021 12:11

Still no news..I wonder when the decision will be made.It will be a great help for peoples heating etc this year.

OP posts:
Moonemoji · 23/11/2021 20:10

It is so helpful just to hear of others left out of this sad system. The £1550 is being waved about in the press but the ESA and legacy benefits have always been given a hard time. :( Zero points assessments, brown envelope sanctions, benefits freeze for five years. It is an old Labour Party benefit that they just put the boot into all the time. Their argument is probably that we have been claiming longer than UC cohort. I admire the legal fight and the patience shown by so many people.

Dishwashersaurous · 23/11/2021 08:15

You can't claim income based esa or jsa and UC.

But you can claim contributions based esa and jsa

Colin7691 · 22/11/2021 21:13

@Musereader

Point of fact, not everyone on UC had the benefit of the uplift, anyone affected by the benefit cap while they had it added in the entitlement, had it deducted in the cap.

Also anyone on transitional protection due to having the premiums on legacy benefits had the transitional element reduced by it, so that means anyone blocked from applying for UC because of the premiums, would not have had the uplift either. Even if they switched.

Also some people have dual ESA/UC claims or dual JSA/UC, so you would have to exclude those people from getting any of the backpack (or more likely give them back pay and then charge and overpayment on UC to get it back)

Neither of those things affect the current case though, as in both cases the entitlement was there, whereas it wasn't for legacy benefits.

The dual claims wouldn't be affected by this ruling if the claimant succeeds surely, as aren't all dual claims contribution based on the legacy benefit side of it? As far as I'm aware you cannot claim income based JSA or ESA whilst claiming UC?

Musereader · 22/11/2021 20:54

Point of fact, not everyone on UC had the benefit of the uplift, anyone affected by the benefit cap while they had it added in the entitlement, had it deducted in the cap.

Also anyone on transitional protection due to having the premiums on legacy benefits had the transitional element reduced by it, so that means anyone blocked from applying for UC because of the premiums, would not have had the uplift either. Even if they switched.

Also some people have dual ESA/UC claims or dual JSA/UC, so you would have to exclude those people from getting any of the backpack (or more likely give them back pay and then charge and overpayment on UC to get it back)

takingmytimeonmyride · 22/11/2021 20:31

I'm on income support, carers allowance and tax credits as I care my 19 yo son. I'm sure the government will do their very best to wheedle their way out of paying so I'm not holding out any hope of getting any money from them.

RandomLondoner · 22/11/2021 18:43

@Dishwashersaurous

The argument for it being UC is that UC is an in work benefit and that furlough only paid 80%. So in theory it's to make up for the difference in being furloughed
This reason doesn't make sense to me. UC is by design a benefit that is supposed to accommodate itself to month-to-month fluctuations in work income.

Also the amount, was £20, not 20%, and it went to everyone, not only furloughed worker, so there's really no match between the uplift and work income reductions anyway.

Colin7691 · 22/11/2021 18:36

@Dishwashersaurous

The systems wouldn't allow UC to differentiate between not working and working. Hence everyone got it.

(I'm just explaining the logic not agreeing)

Unless UC have the most rubbish computer systems in the world, and have less power than a Commodore Pet, then I think most people know that is bull :)

if income > 0.00 then +80.00 basic allowance

there you go Sunak, fixed it

Colin7691 · 22/11/2021 18:32

Everyone claiming UC got the uplift, not just people that are working. I got it (am in LCWRA) despite my costs not increasing due to being stuck at home (because I was always home anyway).

For anyone unsure what this is about, thats the crux of this case.
Someone on UC with LCWRA got the uplift. Someone on ESA with LCWRA didn't. Now while someone only claiming ESA (ie now DLA or PIP) could have transferred to UC at any point, someone who also got PIP or DLA could not move over at the start of the pandemic, and couldn't until January of this year.

So the argument is, it is discriminatory as anyone who had already transferred from a legacy benefit to UC got the uplift, or anyone who didn't have any disability premiums could do so immediately, and would get the uplift.
If you are disabled the you couldn't migrate to UC, and therefore couldn't get the uplift. That is, on the face of it, discrimination against disabled claimants and what this case is about.

CorrBlimeyGG · 22/11/2021 18:26

@Dishwashersaurous That was not what Sunak said at the time:

"We are starting a great national effort to protect jobs. But the truth is we are already seeing job losses. And there may be more to come.

I cannot promise you that no one will face hardship in the weeks ahead.

So we will also act to protect you if the worst happens.

To strengthen the safety net, I’m increasing today the Universal Credit standard allowance, for the next 12 months, by £1,000 a year."

He specifically referenced UC increasing to help people when they were out of work.

www.gov.uk/government/speeches/the-chancellor-rishi-sunak-provides-an-updated-statement-on-coronavirus