Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

legacy benefits court case

138 replies

Mychocolateteapotsmelted · 19/11/2021 06:26

Its for the 20 pounds uplift that universal credit claimants got and people on legacy benefits didn't get..the case started yesterday and ends today.

OP posts:
Akire · 18/02/2022 14:17

Did they just happen to release this today when the storm be all over the news?

Akire · 18/02/2022 14:12

Was thinking about this the other day. So the £20 was for new people suddenly lost jobs and can’t expect people to suddenly cope with pittance level? Then why did everyone get it not just those from start of covid and furlough? I don’t understand why no reason to appeal given their own reason wasn’t true as giving to everyone on UC even if been on it years.

FaceFullOfCake · 18/02/2022 14:07

The claimants have lost the case Sad

www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/breaking-dwp-benefit-claimants-lose-26266677

MatildaIThink · 07/12/2021 07:43

@Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker

Still no outcomeXmas Sad
As I and others have said there will not be for weeks, 2-4 weeks was the best case scenario for the judgement, January would not be surprising. In the unlikely situation that the case succeeds, either in full or in part, then payments would be late Q1 at the earliest.
Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 07/12/2021 04:15

Still no outcomeXmas Sad

FaceFullOfCake · 06/12/2021 13:15

Not yet @Jeszi35 - it's likely to take another four or five weeks AFAIK.

Jeszi35 · 05/12/2021 22:30

Did we get an outcome for this case

Dontbeamugallyourlifesucker · 02/12/2021 02:59

I can't see it being decided before Christmas Sad

TimesAHero · 30/11/2021 21:15

@Colin7691 “People get confused with something being discrimination and something being unfair. I completely agree it's unfair that you didn't get it, but the main thing is, something being unfair isn't against the law, whereas discrimination is”

I agree with you; yes it’s unfair for people on CB ESA , but I agree it’s very different to being discriminated against.

You’ve explained the concept of the case a lot better than my online reading, thank you Smile

Colin7691 · 30/11/2021 17:23

@TimesAHero

“The case wasn't heard yesterday? CB legacy benefits are not included, if you were on a low income you could have claimed UC and therefore could have had the uplift. Those on income based with disability premiums could not migrate to UC therefore had no way of getting the uplift. Thats why it was discriminatory, as disabled people were not able to get it due to government policy at the time.”

I may have misunderstood what I read; online it says the case was concluded on the 29th but my sources are probably not reliable fodder Grin

Although people on CB ESA could move over to UC , they would lose the right to transitional protection and would be worse off . Technically although the option was there, we would still lose out. It just seems very unfair to exclude ESA CB and I can’t see anywhere it says this.

I am not disagreeing with you, you sound like you have a lot more insight than I do. I just don’t understand the thinking behind it because as an ESA claimant you would be mad to move to UC, lose your transitional protection and then wait 5 weeks for UC to process your claim.

The issue of transitional protection and not wanting to be moved over to UC has been mentioned at some point in the case, I’m sure. (Again, don’t quote me on this Blush ).

You can't move to UC if you are on CB ESA, but you can claim UC at the same time if your income is low enough. So you could have claimed UC and not been worse off, and got the uplift. Thats why it isn't included in the claim, as there was no discrimination. However you could not move from IB ESA if you had disability premiums to UC, that was blocked completely before the first lockdown, so even if you wanted to you couldn't. As a result, it was impossible to do anything that would result in you getting the uplift. That only applied to disabled claimants, and why the case is about discrimination.

People get confused with something being discrimination and something being unfair. I completely agree it's unfair that you didn't get it, but the main thing is, something being unfair isn't against the law, whereas discrimination is.

Akire · 30/11/2021 14:06

The protection doesn’t last forever either. We don’t get a single penny more until our levels are same as someone not on the old rates. So if your rent and council tax goes up no increase. Not sure how many years it will take before it matches the current level. It seems big difference at moment but will erode quickly over time as we grow poorer and poorer and everything goes up. Oh joy!

TimesAHero · 30/11/2021 14:04

I have found a reliable source outlining that it is only income related ESA which qualifies. I best reel in my virtual spending of a windfall I will never receive Grin

Good luck to all those hoping for it . It’s only fair you should be included .

TimesAHero · 30/11/2021 13:51

“The case wasn't heard yesterday?
CB legacy benefits are not included, if you were on a low income you could have claimed UC and therefore could have had the uplift. Those on income based with disability premiums could not migrate to UC therefore had no way of getting the uplift. Thats why it was discriminatory, as disabled people were not able to get it due to government policy at the time.”

I may have misunderstood what I read; online it says the case was concluded on the 29th but my sources are probably not reliable fodder Grin

Although people on CB ESA could move over to UC , they would lose the right to transitional protection and would be worse off . Technically although the option was there, we would still lose out. It just seems very unfair to exclude ESA CB and I can’t see anywhere it says this.

I am not disagreeing with you, you sound like you have a lot more insight than I do. I just don’t understand the thinking behind it because as an ESA claimant you would be mad to move to UC, lose your transitional protection and then wait 5 weeks for UC to process your claim.

The issue of transitional protection and not wanting to be moved over to UC has been mentioned at some point in the case, I’m sure. (Again, don’t quote me on this Blush ).

MatildaIThink · 30/11/2021 13:49

@TimesAHero

I read this case concluded on Friday. Does anyone know when we would be expected to find out?

If pay is backdated, it would come in handy for Christmas Grin

It is estimated that the judgement would take 2-4 weeks. In the unlikely scenario that it succeeds then there is no way it would be paid before Christmas, late in Q1 next year would be the earliest a payment would happen and that is only if and it is a very big if, he case were to succeed.
TurnUpTurnip · 30/11/2021 13:39

Oh ok thank you I didn’t know people were stopped from moving, I’m on income support as a carer for my disabled child, but been too scared to go on to UC as heard so many horror stories so been trying to stay on IS for as long as possible!

Akire · 30/11/2021 13:34

The benefits involved in the court case are:
-Income-related Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
-Income Support
-Income-based Jobseeker's Allowance (JSA)

As said above if you were in JSA or income support you could move over to UC it’s just disabled people were stopped from doing so. Plus when you already live on benefits having everything stopped for mim 5 weeks isn’t something people wanted to do in a pandemic.

TurnUpTurnip · 30/11/2021 12:59

I’m confused does it include those on income support or is it just esa then? 🤔

Colin7691 · 30/11/2021 10:02

@TimesAHero

The case was heard yesterday.

I can’t see anything to say it’s only for income related ESA and I do hope contributions based is included. It would not be fair to exclude it . ESA either way is a disability benefit Confused

The case wasn't heard yesterday? CB legacy benefits are not included, if you were on a low income you could have claimed UC and therefore could have had the uplift. Those on income based with disability premiums could not migrate to UC therefore had no way of getting the uplift. Thats why it was discriminatory, as disabled people were not able to get it due to government policy at the time.
TimesAHero · 30/11/2021 06:48

The case was heard yesterday.

I can’t see anything to say it’s only for income related ESA and I do hope contributions based is included. It would not be fair to exclude it . ESA either way is a disability benefit Confused

Colin7691 · 29/11/2021 19:12

@raviolo

There is another adult but he also gets pip - my son. he's also in full time education. It is income esa
No carers being paid to anyone for you either? Unless it's changed you used to have to ring and apply for it, I would give them a ring and ask why it isn't being paid
raviolo · 29/11/2021 19:06

There is another adult but he also gets pip - my son. he's also in full time education. It is income esa

Colin7691 · 29/11/2021 19:02

@raviolo

Do you know how long they take to pay sdp? *@lakielady*

I started getting pip as well as my dp and have written to them twice but haven't seen anything yet.

They noted the pip as they sent a change of circs calculation but no additional payment.

Do you both live alone with no other adults in the house and get income based ESA?
raviolo · 29/11/2021 18:32

Do you know how long they take to pay sdp? @lakielady

I started getting pip as well as my dp and have written to them twice but haven't seen anything yet.

They noted the pip as they sent a change of circs calculation but no additional payment.

LakieLady · 29/11/2021 18:01

@nosafeguardingadults, it shouldn't be the benefit cap, because you get PIP. Getting PIP exempts you from the benefit cap.

Is there another adult living with you? That would mean the premium isn't payable.

If you should have been getting it, they will pay you the arrears.

TimesAHero · 29/11/2021 17:39

I am on ESA in the support group but mine is “new style ESA” . It sounds like I won’t qualify Confused