Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say dd is not responsible for landlord's electricity bill

57 replies

Snozzlemaid · 19/11/2021 05:46

Dd is second year at uni and shares a flat with two others. Bills not included in the rent.

They signed up with an electricity supplier when they moved in at the beginning of September and have been paying this monthly.

The landlord has now messaged them saying she has received an electricity bill from the previous supplier that needs to be paid for the period up to the beginning of November. She wants them to pay it.

She has sent screenshots of the letter. It was addressed to her, the landlord, and posted to her address. It is from a different company than they have signed up with.

The flat was empty for months before dd and friends moved in so I'm guessing the landlord would have been responsible for electricity charges during that period. So surely she should have cancelled her contact when the flat was occupied again.

Sounds to me as if she hasn't cancelled her contract.

I've told dd she shouldn't be liable for this. They have no contract with the provider sending this bill. The landlord does, so she is responsible.
They are with another provider who they have been paying.

Any advice I can give dd for them to deal with this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chesirecat99 · 19/11/2021 14:34

I think as PPs have said, they probably set things up incorrectly. It isn't possible for 2 electricity suppliers to bill the same property (all though mistakes do happen).

They should have taken over the account with the old supplier, which it looks like they didn't as it is still in the landlord's name, then transferred to the new supplier. That can take some time so they would have to pay the old supplier in the interim. It has probably been delayed more than usual if they didn't do things correctly.

Normally, the new supplier asks for a meter reading on the day that they take over the account. Did they do that?

They need to check that the bill from the old supplier has the correct start reading, the correct dates (if there is a daily standing charge), and the correct final reading when the new contract started, and that the new supplier has the correct start reading.

Did they sign up to one of the suppliers that charge in advance rather than retrospect? I'm not sure they can take money before the supply has switched but they certainly will have had to pay money up front on the first day, if that is the case. It's possible that the money they think has been paying for usage is actually sitting with the new supplier untouched and they have a big credit balance.

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 19/11/2021 14:02

@EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall

Its probably a mess up on the old suppliers part, presuming they gave meter reading to both the old and new company then if it was money owed while the change over was taking place the bill should have gone to them not the LL.
No, they haven't paid this supplier at all so this will be the bill for the period between moving in and changing supplier.
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 19/11/2021 13:44

Its probably a mess up on the old suppliers part, presuming they gave meter reading to both the old and new company then if it was money owed while the change over was taking place the bill should have gone to them not the LL.

stingofthebutterfly · 19/11/2021 09:12

Two companies can't supply the same property. When they moved in, they changed supplier, but this can take weeks to sort. They should have taken a meter reading on the day their tenancy started.

They need to pay the old company whatever has been used from that meter reading to the end of the contract. They also need to pay the new company from that date onwards.

They are not responsible for anything used prior to the tenancy start date.

elbea · 19/11/2021 09:02

It sounds like the final bill from the other supplier which they’ll need to pay a proportion of. Accounts don’t switch over the day you move in, it takes weeks to complete.

They may have been paying since September but if they are just paying onto account they could be in credit.

Why don’t they just call their supplier and ask?

Snozzlemaid · 19/11/2021 08:51

Hoarding Thank you. That will be their next step.

OP posts:
SpamIAm · 19/11/2021 08:49

@FlowerArranger that's not entirely correct. There may be a daily standing charge, so the date their tenancy started also matters.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 19/11/2021 08:48

@A580Hojas

Well did they get permission from the landlord to switch energy supplier and who ended the contract with the previous supplier? Who read the meters on the day they moved in?
They don't need to. It has long not been legal for a landlord to insist or have any say on providers.

@Snozzlemaid your DD needs to provide the LL with their bills, the starting reading of the meters etc. Then the LL can go back to the provider she had a contract with and get it sorted. The LL should know how this works but has made an error that should be easily fixed.

Until that happens nobody can say what is owed by who?

Snozzlemaid · 19/11/2021 08:47

@Dacquoise

Also don't forget water meter readings if it's metered water.

There are utility providers that now use contracts for all students living in the property so it doesn't have to go in one name. Brilliant idea as it stops the arguments about who has used what when 'Sasha' decides to spent two months in Bora Bora for her hols and doesn't want to pay her share because she wasn't there All students equally liable for the bills and collected by the provider individually.

Thank you. Water is all sorted and okay thankfully.

There's only 3 of them and they're close friends so they've sorted one utility each which is working well for them.

OP posts:
Snozzlemaid · 19/11/2021 08:45

@ThePlantsitter

My advice would be don't panic. Don't get defensive/aggressive with the landlord just puzzled 'how strange let's work out what's happened'. So sending the paid bills and saying 'how strange, look!' rather than 'no we're not liable.' you can always get tough further down the line if appropriate.
Thank you. That's how I have been suggesting they speak to landlord.

They don't want to fall out but are confused by this at the moment.

OP posts:
Snozzlemaid · 19/11/2021 08:44

ThirdElephant thank you. That's really helpful to know there is a national database so they should only need to pay one supplier.

As I've said one of the other flatmates took on sorting electricity so I'm not sure what she did and whether or not she would have thought to notify previous supplier. I'm not sure she would have known who that was either.
Landlord expected them to sort own supply and account when their tenancy started so I would have thought (maybe wrongly) that she would or should have told previous supplier.

OP posts:
Dacquoise · 19/11/2021 08:36

Also don't forget water meter readings if it's metered water.

There are utility providers that now use contracts for all students living in the property so it doesn't have to go in one name. Brilliant idea as it stops the arguments about who has used what when 'Sasha' decides to spent two months in Bora Bora for her hols and doesn't want to pay her share because she wasn't there All students equally liable for the bills and collected by the provider individually.

ThePlantsitter · 19/11/2021 08:36

My advice would be don't panic. Don't get defensive/aggressive with the landlord just puzzled 'how strange let's work out what's happened'. So sending the paid bills and saying 'how strange, look!' rather than 'no we're not liable.' you can always get tough further down the line if appropriate.

ThirdElephant · 19/11/2021 08:33

@LawnFever

Why did your DD change supplier? They should’ve transferred the current one to their names, did anyone let the old supplier know?

I think they’ve caused some confusion here, if the old supplier was still associated with the address with an account in the landlords name.

They shouldn’t be paying two suppliers, but if the original contract wasn’t cancelled/swapped with final meter readings given I think it could easily cause confusion which it what it sounds like has happened.

Legally, you can only have one energy supplier at a time. There's a national database to see who supplies your property- if you call, they might be able to say who was supplying the property from September to November. She should only have to pay one supplier- if she's paid the wrong one, it's up to them to return the money and your DD will need to pay the correct supplier.

www.uswitch.com/gas-electricity/guides/who-supplies-my-electricity-and-gas/

LawnFever · 19/11/2021 08:32

This. There should not be two supplies at the same time, so they should investigate what’s happened.

I agree, I think perhaps the former supplier wasn’t informed properly of the switch?

When I’ve rented I’ve always initially taken over the account already set up, or had to get permission from the landlord to change supplier.

LawnFever · 19/11/2021 08:31

@furbabymama87

She needs to email over a tenancy agreement to prove she's not liable.
How does this prove anything if the bill is for during her tenancy period?
furbabymama87 · 19/11/2021 08:26

She needs to email over a tenancy agreement to prove she's not liable.

MajorCarolDanvers · 19/11/2021 08:16

She needs to pay from the date her tenancy started.

PinkWednesdays · 19/11/2021 08:12

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

They can't have been paying new supplier from 1/9 if this was a change of supplier. If this supplier was already supplying the house then there cannot be two supplies to the same house so something has gone wrong, but if they changed supplier then there will have been a delay during which period they will have accrued a debt with the previous supplier.
This. There should not be two supplies at the same time, so they should investigate what’s happened.
gogohm · 19/11/2021 08:11

It also takes a while to switch so expect a bill until the switch date

gogohm · 19/11/2021 08:09

They are responsible from the first day of their tenancy eg the summer holidays even if they hadn't moved in

Dacquoise · 19/11/2021 08:07

I work for a landlord. The tenant is responsible for utilities from the date their contract starts. Final meter readings should be taken on the date the previous tenant leaves. Any period between contracts, the void period, the landlord is responsible for standing charges and any usage. The new tenant takes over on the start of contract date whether they live there or not. This also includes periods when they may be back living at home.

Unfortunately landlords do not have access to contracts that tenants take out with utilities companies so have to wait to be contacted by them with any void period bills. Also previous tenants are not always diligent about telling their company they are leaving or supplying final meter readings, hence bills addressed to the 'landlord'. I often have to provide final meter readings from the check out inspection when previous tenants leave for the company to calculate the void period. It is up to the utility company to chase the previous tenant for findl unpaid bills.

In this case the Op needs to provide initial meter readings from the start date on the tenancy agreement. These may be in an inventory provided at check in. An inventory is done, usually by a third party, as it's the landlords evidence to claim any dilapidations from the tenants deposit. Hopefully this should be fairly straightforward to sort out.

Swapping over utility companies is fairly standard for tenants and is usually mentioned in the tenancy agreement.

CSJobseeker · 19/11/2021 08:05

Unfortunately the bill is for the period of their tenancy

The tenant is responsible for the bills from the date they move in. There is always a time lag with changing suppliers etc, but they used the electricity so they should pay for it.

Lime37 · 19/11/2021 08:04

You need to go off the meter readings not the dates. If she hasn’t got meter readings then she will need to pay the bill

LawnFever · 19/11/2021 08:01

Why did your DD change supplier? They should’ve transferred the current one to their names, did anyone let the old supplier know?

I think they’ve caused some confusion here, if the old supplier was still associated with the address with an account in the landlords name.

They shouldn’t be paying two suppliers, but if the original contract wasn’t cancelled/swapped with final meter readings given I think it could easily cause confusion which it what it sounds like has happened.