Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is this just horrible to think about?

60 replies

fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:00

My niece had her 15th bday today. We caught up with her via fb to ask what she wanted for her bday and had she had a nice day. We asked for her personal bank details to send her money as her mum has form for pocketing bday money to fund "big presents". I was very saddened to hear that her parents got her no bday presents this year because they forked out £600 privately for foot surgery on her. Aibu that vital surgery does not constitute a bday present?! Waiting times with NHS ate ridiculous at the moment so they went private but intimately billed her as bday and Christmas presents on this! Whattttt?

OP posts:
MadAntonia · 19/11/2021 00:50

Yes, it’s horrible.

Giving her some money was the right thing to do.

You’re a good aunt.

WrongWayApricot · 19/11/2021 00:44

So send your brother a tenner and tell him to get her a present tomorrow morning then? But I'm wondering if she actually has had what I had as a kid... 100 things bought at the shops in the run up to my birthday because I'd begged to have an early present. Then when asked how many presents I got on my birthday I wouldn't remember the 100 things I'd been given early.

CharlotteRose90 · 19/11/2021 00:44

@fluffyatemycake if she can walk then yeah it’s cosmetic. The nhs have more priorities right now sorry. She should have waited or be grateful they’ve spent that money on her. Mind your own business.

WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 00:44

Apart from wanting another story in the Daily Mail? 🙄

WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 00:41

Yes, because everyone tells their relatives their exact financial circumstances 🙄🙄

Look, this thread says far more about you than this girl's parents.

You're taking a 15yr old's exact word for the fact they didn't make it clear she wouldn't be getting an expensive birthday present and Christmas present on top of the surgery (although you seem to have forgotten you added the Christmas bit to the story).

You're taking her word for the fact they didn't buy her a box of chocolates or 'smellies' to open (when she may not have wanted them anyway).

And not only did you not bother buying her something to open either, but you didn't even bother ringing her on her birthday...you used Facebook instead. Would you even have remembered it was her birthday if Facebook hadn't sent you a notification informing you?

Then to top it all, apart from claiming you know all about her parents personal financial circumstances, you've started a thread on a public forum, inviting people to criticise her parents too.

What's missing from your life that you feel the need to do this?

cruzrack · 19/11/2021 00:41

YABU

Mind your bloody business and if you can't because you've got nothing going on in your own life, speak to the parents to get their version of events.

fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:35

@WTGN

How can you judge if you don't know their financial circumstances? Yes it's a shame but she obviously needed this foot surgery. How do you know they aren't down to the last pennies?

You sound horribly judgemental.

I am related to them and I know very well what their finances are. They are not shy of a few bob...at all.
OP posts:
WTGN · 19/11/2021 00:33

How can you judge if you don't know their financial circumstances? Yes it's a shame but she obviously needed this foot surgery. How do you know they aren't down to the last pennies?

You sound horribly judgemental.

Geppili · 19/11/2021 00:30

So so mean and cheap.

WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 00:30

@fluffyatemycake

I'd rather it didn't!
Aye
fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:30

@CharlotteRose90

Was it necessary life or death surgery because if it was cosmetic then sorry but I’m with the parents. Why shouldn’t it be a gift for birthday or Christmas. Surgery isn’t cheap and if they aren’t made of money then I get it.
Is foot surgery cosmetic? She broke her toes in a tournament
OP posts:
Geppili · 19/11/2021 00:30

Op referred to it as vital surgery.

Geppili · 19/11/2021 00:29

I think that is incredibly mean.

CharlotteRose90 · 19/11/2021 00:28

Was it necessary life or death surgery because if it was cosmetic then sorry but I’m with the parents. Why shouldn’t it be a gift for birthday or Christmas. Surgery isn’t cheap and if they aren’t made of money then I get it.

fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:28

I'd rather it didn't!

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 00:28

I clearly said bday. Read again.

Waiting times with NHS ate ridiculous at the moment so they went private but intimately billed her as bday and Christmas presents on this! Whattttt?

And you're telling me to read again? Confused

LizBennet · 19/11/2021 00:27

@Anordinarymum

I don't like this thread. Asking people to comment on one situation and then adding stuff in. I wonder what OP hopes to gain from this?
Another thread in the Daily Mail I'd guess.
Anordinarymum · 19/11/2021 00:26

I don't like this thread. Asking people to comment on one situation and then adding stuff in. I wonder what OP hopes to gain from this?

fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:25

@WorraLiberty

Stocking fillers for her bday? Nope she's getting nothing at all.

Birthday? Confused

Did you forget that you included Christmas in your opening post?

Either way, you clearly hate the girl's mother so there's no point in me suggesting you find out her version of events.

I clearly said bday. Read again. I don't hate the girls mother at all but she is a standard CF in every sense of the word and I feel very sorry for the situation that has left her daughter in.
OP posts:
Crazycakelady17 · 19/11/2021 00:24

That’s awful fair enough if she was a adult and they agreed it between themselves but to say to the child AFTER the surgery that it will be replacing birthday and Christmas
I wouldn’t even do that to my 20 year old child

fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:24

@Cocopogo

So you didn’t get her anything to open either? What a shame.
...we asked her what she wanted and she said money. How many 15 year olds do you know what want random gifts from their aunts that don't know what's cool?!!
OP posts:
fluffyatemycake · 19/11/2021 00:23

@Porcupineintherough

£600 doesn't seem enough to pay for any surgery. Are you sure that's the correct amount? A couple of grand would be more like it.
This is what my niece said!
OP posts:
LizBennet · 19/11/2021 00:22

@fluffyatemycake

I will preface with when I say her mum has form for this...she had the family over for Xmas a few years ago and charged us all £100 a head when she got all the food for free from her volunteer job. It was in the daily fail...
Do you mean a thread started by you and lifted by the Daily Mail?
Cocopogo · 19/11/2021 00:19

So you didn’t get her anything to open either? What a shame.

WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 00:19

Stocking fillers for her bday? Nope she's getting nothing at all.

Birthday? Confused

Did you forget that you included Christmas in your opening post?

Either way, you clearly hate the girl's mother so there's no point in me suggesting you find out her version of events.