Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 08:00

My daughter has only ever played with the girls. They both have. Come to think of it.

I have absolutely no idea why that is Hmm

Bluntness100 · 19/11/2021 07:58

That’s quite unusual, why does she only play with the boys? And why would you think boys don’t like painting?

muddyford · 19/11/2021 07:58

Either invite them all or tell her she has to choose five.

Nietzschethehiker · 19/11/2021 07:58

Well this thread is incredibly eye opening. I'm genuinely amazed at some of the views held and suddenly appreciating my DC school a bit more.

In all honesty I think its more about how its done. There have been some cases where the parent can't accommodate all the DC in a class and it's fair enough but it's how it's done. Handing out invitations ostentatiously outside pickup whilst excluding some children has been done in a previous school and its rubbish, cruel and unfair. It tells you more about the parent then. In this school the parent gently reminded the child not to make a fuss at school about it and encouraged the child to be considerate.

I will say we had one parent who thought they were the big I am and made a giant fuss and performance about it announcing loudly in front of the DC and parents she had agonised about who would make the cut. That performance didn't go down well and I know another parent asked her to tone it down with the performance in the playground because it was performative wringing of hands which was making it far more visible. Mostly the dc were quietly reminded that you can't be invited to everything and the drama was creating the problem not the other parents.

I'm going to be honest some of the wittering about all girls and boys separating on this thread would get mocked heavily in ds2 class. They have not remotely split into boys and girls. My ds2 who is 5 would absolutely love a painting party. There's a long running joke about three of the boys trying to spend most of their time at the art table.

We are not remotely an affluent or woke school group , we are in a poor area but splitting on sex is met with some hilarity.

It's definitely not all classes or schools that do this and I genuinely am smiling at the fact that some PP think this is the case.

In truth whilst noone would be mean outright there would be some wry smiles and eye rolls at a parent who verbalised this. One parent newly transferred started making comments about one of the 5 year old dc Boys who had longish blond hair and rather than met with anger the waiting parents just laughed and she was told not to be so ridiculous. Not met with ire but certainly met with hilarity that anyone would think it was a thing.

Wow some pp on here would be shut down from a great height.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 07:57

Also I find with January/February birthday parties that they all DO come. Because there’s not much else going on.

5lilducks · 19/11/2021 07:57

Disappointment and the pain of being excluded from things will no doubt come later for some children but it's not something I want any part in.

❤

Dancingonmoonlight · 19/11/2021 07:56

I am saying they mostly won’t be interested to be one of a few boys at a girls painting party. The activity itself doesn’t matter. If it was a girls football party it would be no different, most little boys wouldn’t care for it.

You are projecting your own gender stereotypes.

Dancingonmoonlight · 19/11/2021 07:53

@Dalalalada

And now, having moved schools, I see parents are at it again inviting select numbers out of a relatively small year group - and quite happy to accept invites to the lovley whole group parties of other kids. Rant over!
This has been my experience too.

The clique of girls trot off to whole class parties yet stick to their own clique for all their own celebrations. The parents of these girls have brass necks. It’s absolutely learned behaviour - the mothers of the clique of girls huddle together everyday at the school gates.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 07:53

My daughters birthday is in February. She will be 7.

She’s in a new class this year. I don’t know them/their parents. I do know she has 4 or 5 pals (all girls) that she plays with and those are the girls she wants to invite round for pizza. So that is what we will do.

I’ve done big parties with the whole classes at venues etc plenty of times and frankly I can’t afford it this year. Also, we find there is a party almost every week at this time of year. No kids are obsessing over them and going on about them at school because they are happening all the time.

What this thread has made me think though, is that maybe we won’t hand out invitations at school. I think I’ll just track down the mums on social media and invite them that way. I guess it isn’t really a party.

5lilducks · 19/11/2021 07:53

I think it's a bit mean.

NewbieAlert · 19/11/2021 07:52

I’d invite them all if it were in my home.
You could always leave the invites to the last minute so the chances are some won’t be able to some…

My DC is having (what I consider to be) an expensive activity for their birthday. I said they could have 10 children as that’s the minimum booking. She’ll be inviting 6 girls from her class. That leaves 7 girls from her class not invited. I’m comfortable with that balance.

Chasingaftermidnight · 19/11/2021 07:51

I think it’s ok. Obviously you have to be prepared that there could be some consequences (ie your DD might be the one left out when one of the other girls has a party) but presumably you can live with that!

CampagVelocet · 19/11/2021 07:50

Why on Earth wouldn't boys be interested in painting? Getting those gender roles nailed down early doors there

Japingjaponica · 19/11/2021 07:50

They won't all come anyway. And if dd is Year 1 you have a LOT of years to live out with the mums of that class.

Gliderx · 19/11/2021 07:47

I wouldn't do it. From a purely pragmatic perspective, it's not good for your DD to be seen to be 'excluding' others and may be reflected when other children have birthday parties later in the year. Also, I know it's soft but I couldn't bear to think of children that age being disappointed. Disappointment and the pain of being excluded from things will no doubt come later for some children but it's not something I want any part in. We'll be doing whole class parties here until my DS is old enough to pick a few close friends to celebrate with (though I recognise we're lucky to be able to afford to do that).

In your shoes, if I didn't want to hire a hall and couldn't fit them all in, I'd hold 2 parties. One for most of the school friends and one for the remaining school friends and family friends. I'd also ask DD to invite a couple of the boys she plays most with since I don't think we should be encouraging kids to have gendered friendships at that age. But we've had to do the two-party thing anyway for the past couple of years since we have lots of family friends and can't fit them all in alongside DS's nursery/pre-school friends. We view it as getting all our playdates for the next few months out of the way in a couple of afternoons.

Vickstory79 · 19/11/2021 07:47

Why choose an activity that will exclude a few kids? It's not hard, they really don't care what they do at this age, they just want a party bag and cake.

It's not hard to be kind.

Madmog · 19/11/2021 07:47

I guess you have a limit due to house size, costs and the number of children you can manage (some will leave them!), so that's fine. Also, your DD has chosen the ones she clearly plays with, or likes as a person.

NinaProudman2022 · 19/11/2021 07:46

We had this with Dd’s class and it went on until year 6. Invite say 6, none or all. DD was one of the ones left out. By year 6 parents were posting on sm about having a sleepover for all the girls in X’s class etc xx

SaltyPepper · 19/11/2021 07:42

@DoubleDeckerSwimmer

Again to make it totally clear, I am not saying boys don’t enjoy painting. I am saying they mostly won’t be interested to be one of a few boys at a girls painting party. The activity itself doesn’t matter. If it was a girls football party it would be no different, most little boys wouldn’t care for it.

Nearthelooplease · 19/11/2021 07:36

Is she ‘friends’ with the 4 girls who aren’t invited though? If she’s not then I don’t see why it’s any worse for them to not be invited than it is the boys. I don’t remember girls or boys only parties being the norm until a bit later than Yr1 when I was growing up, you just invited your friends.

I’d just pick a set number of people that you’re happy to have in the house and let her invite that many people, regardless of whether they’re boys or girls. I think the boys are likely to enjoy a painting party and if anyone of the children don’t enjoy it then it’s not the end of the world as long as your daughter does!

MissCrowley · 19/11/2021 07:36

In relation to your question my 6 year old son will do anything at a party as long as he's invited. He has severe FOMO though 😂 He'd happily join in with some painting.

With regards to leaving some girls out, I get it, it's difficult with having the party in your home. I think what other pp have said may work better- ask a couple of boys/ drop 1-2 of the girls.
I personally wouldn't invite a child that my DD didn't get on with for the sake of not upsetting the child/ mum.
We have a situation like this at the moment where my daughter was pretty much bullied by a girl, only for her to now want my DD to play with her all the time and my DD doesn't want to because she doesn't forget how this child has treated her in the past.

cookiemonster2468 · 19/11/2021 07:34

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@sunflowerroses. Yes there are boys in the class - it's a class of about 30 children. Sorry - should have said that in my initial post.

Urgh, I am panicking now! We could invite fewer girls and maybe a few boys? But the activity is painting-related - not sure boys would be into it?[/quote]
Y1 boys? Like, 5 and 6 years old? Why on earth would you assume that they would not be interested in painting Hmm

Onatree · 19/11/2021 07:33

my 6 year old's Year 1 class is doing all manner of festive arts and crafts and painting.

This week alone it was painted lighthouse keeper's lunch basket, stuck-and-glued-on festive decorations, and repeated whines to get a massive Crayola art set for christmas.

This is from a boy who enjoys his massive hot wheels garage, his dinosaur trucks and is currently sticking tissue paper to the underside of a writing notebook to "make it beautiful".

I just dont understand why on earth things need gendering this early in life- when - lets face it - it begins when they are in the womb with pink and blue announcements at 20 weeks.

Dalalalada · 19/11/2021 07:30

And yes that's also a very good point about the activity. Since when was paining a girls activity!! Boys won't be into it?? Wtaf?

Dalalalada · 19/11/2021 07:29

And now, having moved schools, I see parents are at it again inviting select numbers out of a relatively small year group - and quite happy to accept invites to the lovley whole group parties of other kids. Rant over!