Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 10:09

@TheTurn0fTheScrew

going against the grain, I think this is ok. you are inviting less than half the class, which is fine. The girl/boy thing is a red herring. I would add that at this age if she's friends with boys, invite them, even if you think the activity might not be their first choice. my very non-sporty DC2 was often one of just two girls at football parties, and had a blast with her friends even though she'd not have chosen the activity herself.

the MN orthodoxy that all of the class or all of one sex must be invited is very skewed towards those with massive houses or cash to hire big venues, which is not the norm where I live.

Exactly - and we wonder where sexist stereotyping comes from 😂

It’s about friendship group - not sex. There maybe be for example 10 girls but if one of them has an all male friend group I’d expect them to be invited to the boys’ parties. Which the other girls don’t get invited to - fair enough.
I had a good mix growing up so I don’t know why people are segregating!

flatclearancehelp · 19/11/2021 10:06

Invite them all, they probably won't all come so it won't be an issue

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 10:06

Also maybe I have a different experience but do all these girls hang out together?

If the 4 girls in question don’t even talk to your DD they’re unlikely to care about her party.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 19/11/2021 10:05

going against the grain, I think this is ok. you are inviting less than half the class, which is fine. The girl/boy thing is a red herring. I would add that at this age if she's friends with boys, invite them, even if you think the activity might not be their first choice. my very non-sporty DC2 was often one of just two girls at football parties, and had a blast with her friends even though she'd not have chosen the activity herself.

the MN orthodoxy that all of the class or all of one sex must be invited is very skewed towards those with massive houses or cash to hire big venues, which is not the norm where I live.

Vanillaradio · 19/11/2021 10:04

I would either do fewer or the whole class. I think for ds's y1 party we invited 10- a mixture of boys and girls ,(that was out of 60 as well as they mixed the classes at end of reception so they all had friends in both classes) And yes boys, particularly at that age do like painting, my 8 year old boy would still love a painting party- also I think ds has only ever been to one party that was all boys since he started going to parties at age 3!

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 19/11/2021 10:03

My autistic dc was always one of the four. I lost count of the 'kind' messages from other mums explaining how they were sure the party wouldn't be my dc's sort of thing and that they'd arrange a play date to make up for it. I sent breezy replies, plastered on a smile for everyone and knew that the play date would never happen.

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 10:01

Haven’t RTFT but If it’s 9 out of 30 people what’s the problem? Why do all the girls have to be invited?

Does this mean only rich people can have parties

hangrylady · 19/11/2021 09:59

"Do the girls only play with other girls and the boys only play with other boys?
Why send them to a co-educational school if this is the case?
Genuinely curious"
You do realise that state schools are nearly always co-ed don't you? Confused

Pinkandpink · 19/11/2021 09:59

Cassandrainthenight
She was gutted as she heard all the girls talking about it and the girl handed out invites. I never acted gutted in front of her

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 19/11/2021 09:59

My Ds would love a painting party!

I agree with others - invite 6 girls, and maybe a couple of boys if she’s friends with them (or just have the 6)

yogafairy · 19/11/2021 09:56

My dd was one of 2 girls left out of a girls party in year 1. My daughter (asd) hates parties and wasn't bothered but the other little girl was devastated. She begged the party girls mum to let her go every day at school pick up leading up to the party and the mum steadfastly said no.

The girl was left out of groups in school in the lead up to the party as all of the girls were talking about what they would wear/do etc.

Unnecessarily cruel.

shouldistop · 19/11/2021 09:55

I have a 5yo boy and he likes painting.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 09:54

I can still recall how hurt I felt when I was one of only two children in the class not invited to someone’s birthday party (aged about 10). Please don’t do it

I mean, I’m sorry that this happened to you. But it’s not what is happening here, is it.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 09:53

Like you say hire a hall and invite the lot of them. And do what with them? Some people don’t want to stand up and try to control a room full of kids. Some people (like me) do not have that sort of confidence. Some people (again like me) simply don’t want the responsibility.

bookworm14 · 19/11/2021 09:53

I can still recall how hurt I felt when I was one of only two children in the class not invited to someone’s birthday party (aged about 10). Please don’t do it.

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 09:51

If my daughter didn’t ever play with someone though I wouldn’t expect her to be invited to their party (unless it was a whole class party or all the girls party - that’s clearly different and no one should be excluded in that way). I would explain that to her as well.

I don’t see the issues with just inviting their own friendship group though, to a small party. Some people can’t afford/cope with more than that. And that’s ok.

CasaBonita · 19/11/2021 09:51

I hate the politics involved in parties and yes there are some parents who get VERY upset if their kids aren't invited, even if they were one of several not invited. So just be prepared for a bit of backlash.

Personally what I've done is whole class party in reception. Year 1 birthday we were in lockdown. Year 2 just invited 3 kids that are his best friends. I much prefer this to be honest and it's what I will do going forwards. A small gathering means that (generally) nobody is offended and also massively keeps the cost down. Win/win.

hangrylady · 19/11/2021 09:48

My son would like a painting party, especially at that age. If I were you though I'd hire somewhere, like a village hall and have the party there instead and just invite all the girls. It gets easier as they get older and have more established friends, but at this age I used to do whole class parties.

Hankunamatata · 19/11/2021 09:47

@IHateCoronavirus

As a teacher of young children, I have seen far too many hurt little faces, left out from selective parties. Kids this age are such little innocents, they approach life with so much excitement, parties get spoken about a lot.

Then once a few kids get stung by rejection, they realise how much power having a party has and can use it as a play for power and often as a weapon. “Do x,y,z or your not coming to my party!” “Don’t play with her, or your not coming to my party!” It becomes the bullying tactic of choice with this age group.

Not going to a party IS HURTFUL at this age. They feel it.

As such I warn my parents at the start of the year that I can only facilitate invitation giving out for class invites, if they are inviting specific kids invites must be given out sensitively away from the class. The parents a great and do this, but kids still talk. Birthdays are exciting.

Really insightful 🧡
Hankunamatata · 19/11/2021 09:45

@Dancingonmoonlight

The other (five!) girls who aren't close to the OP's daughter won't even know about it because they won't be close enough to the girl to even discuss it or even care either way.

Come back when your child first comes home first in tears at not being invited. When you attempt to make light of it and then it happens again. When you have chats about how not everybody can afford to invite everyone. Then it happens again. When you attempt to teach your child 'resilience' and not everybody can be popular and in this case its her and three others. When your child tells you that the majority of the girls are going to a party they have spoken about excitedly for the week running up to it. When they return to school on Monday telling the teacher and everyone else what a wonderful party they had. When your child tells you about the parties, sleepovers and outings the other girls are going on. Worse when she stops telling you about them. When she comes home and you find her crying by herself in her room brushing away tears trying to assure you she knows it isn't a big deal and she is trying hard to accept her fate is not being included with the majority of girls because for some reason she isn't 'liked enough'. When you find your child hitting herself in her room because she must be 'ugly' and that must be why she is left out.
Come back after six years of dealing with all the above. It never gets easier for the child. Never.

That broke my heart 😥
Hankunamatata · 19/11/2021 09:44

That's broke my heart 😥

Runnerduck34 · 19/11/2021 09:40

Echoing it's going to upset the 4 girls not invited. I understand your dilemma but do think it's a mean thing to do.
This happened to me when I was about 8, only me a one other girl in our class weren't invited to a party, everyone in class talked about it in school for days beforehand and for days afterwards, it was miserable and felt so left out and frankly rejected and unlikeable. Having experienced it myself I wouldnt inflict it on another child.

RealBecca · 19/11/2021 09:40

I wpuld let your dd choose who to invite anf use this as a chance to explain that anyone who isnt invited is unlikely to invite her back and that just how these things work (explain it nicer though so its more setting a realistic expectation than a threat!)

Alternatively consider renting a village hall amd inviting the class? They aren't dear and you'll probably get fairly low attendance anyway if the activity isnt to their liking. Shame to have an early term birthday and have to navigate this stuff!

Marynotsocontrary · 19/11/2021 09:39

How much of this (gender segregation in young children) is typical child development, and how much is learned behaviour, I don't know

Its learned and it depends a lot on parenting where you live. My son is friends with lots of the girls, playdates of either sex, parties very mixed.

He is having a whole class party but when he listed names of children he wanted at his party the first 8 he listed were 4 boys and 4 girls!

Hmm.. this could be learned behaviour too, of course @DeepaBeesKit. You said yourself it's encouraged by the parents in your area. If the children weren't guided by parents in this manner, what would happen, I wonder?

I'm sure there's lots of research done in this area, haven't time to look for it right now though. It's an interesting topic.

Staryflight445 · 19/11/2021 09:33

In what reality do boys and girls not be friends or go to one another parties?