Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
Switch82 · 19/11/2021 22:45

I’ve just looked over photos of my elder dc parties and their were plenty in Year 2 they weren’t invited to - invite who your DC wants - jobs a good ‘un

Cassandrainthenight · 19/11/2021 22:30

@Charleymouse @MadameGazellee,
@DraigFachd

Hear, hear!

Cassandrainthenight · 19/11/2021 22:19

@MadameGazellee, @Charleymouse, @d

Kitkat151 · 19/11/2021 17:40

Very mean

Treecreature · 19/11/2021 17:02

Invite the kids she wants. Dont worry about the rest.

Whitenoise123 · 19/11/2021 15:47

Please try to invite all the girls in the class OP. Yes your DD has said she doesn’t want a few of them there but it won’t hurt her to be inclusive and learn about trying not to hurt other peoples feelings. It could be be a good lesson for her.

When I was was about 10, I was the only girl not invited to a girls party even though I had invited her to mine. It really hurt and made me feel rubbish. I remember sobbing to my mum about it in the bathroom so clearly! It’s not something I think about a lot but that feeling of exclusion isn’t something you easily forget.

DGFB · 19/11/2021 14:58

Fab, sounds like a good plan

Fr0thandBubble · 19/11/2021 11:56

Thanks everyone! Really don’t want to upset anyone. I’ve decided to invite fewer girls plus some boys - will be about a third of the class in total (and less than half the girls) so I think that’s probably OK. May switch the planned activity in any event as, thinking about it, it might be more suitable for older children. It’s not until next year so I have some time.

OP posts:
TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 11:52

@hangrylady as pp mentioned you can’t not invite one person.
However in this case 4 kids aren’t being invited so nobody’s being excluded. They’re just not friends. It doesn’t matter why the DD doesn’t like them they’re not the only person.

Marynotsocontrary · 19/11/2021 11:50

She is inviting about 1/4 of the class - why is anyone considering that mean or unkind or any of the other words being used
Things are very much split along boy/girl lines at this age I find. Leaving out all the boys won't bother them, but the minority of girls excluded may well be upset
Rubbish. Of course they aren't.
None of my 3 only had friends that were the same sex as them. Nor is this what I see in any of the schools I have taught at in over 30 years.

It's very much the norm for many though Kite22, as evidenced here by the fact the OP was all about the girls in the class...it wasn't even mentioned there were boys in the class too until a later post.

Maybe some folks on here need to think about how they are responding and what that teaches their dc.
I agree with this statement, but probably for the opposite reason you do.

MissMinutes24 · 19/11/2021 11:50

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@vsgkitt That’s what I’m worried about! What age was your DD then? Sounds like she was a bit older? I would hope 5/6 year olds wouldn’t be painting ganja leaves Grin

Anyone who is mother to a 5/6 year old boy, please shout if they would enjoy a painting-related party! Would potentially solve my dilemma if so.[/quote]
We're having a painting party for my DS5's bday. He loves doing crafty/arty things.

Doomscrolling · 19/11/2021 11:49

@Fr0thandBubble, have you not invited boys because of your assumption they won’t like painting (at 5/6? Lots of them do!) or because your daughter doesn’t have any male friends?

All of my children played with both boys and girls at that age; the split down sex lines happened around 8/9 for a few years.

If there are boys your daughter likes, I’d suggest inviting a couple of them along with the 3-4 girls your daughter is most friends with.

She certainly shouldn’t have to invite someone she dislikes to her party!

Cherrytart23 · 19/11/2021 11:47

It's fine if there was 1 left out I would say different but no boys have been invited either I really wouldn't worry about it.

Kite22 · 19/11/2021 11:40

She is inviting about 1/4 of the class - why is anyone considering that mean or unkind or any of the other words being used
Things are very much split along boy/girl lines at this age I find. Leaving out all the boys won't bother them, but the minority of girls excluded may well be upset.

Rubbish. Of course they aren't.
None of my 3 only had friends that were the same sex as them. Nor is this what I see in any of the schools I have taught at in over 30 years.
I also agree with the thinking that why would people feel 'left out' unless the parents are stoking that thought ? If any of mine had ever been upset at not being invited somewhere, they would have had it explained to them that people can usually only invite a few people to an occasion and it just happened they weren't invited that time, then distract, distract, distract. 99% of the time though they wouldn't be aware if someone else were having a party - people don't come up to you and announce you aren't invited Hmm.
All my family are also able to look on FB or hear about friends going out somewhere and think "Oh, that's nice" rather than having a strop because they weren't invited to. Maybe some folks on here need to think about how they are responding and what that teaches their dc.

Allsortsofroses · 19/11/2021 11:11

But the activity is painting-related - not sure boys would be into it?

Hmm
hangrylady · 19/11/2021 11:11

@BigYellowHat

Why do kids have to invite people they don’t like? If you were leaving out one then I’d probably say you had to suck it up but four is fine.
I think it depends on why they don't like them. Absolutely don't invite the class bully but what about the child with additional needs who doesn't play with the others? Is it ok to exclude them? I don't think so personally. When kids get older parties get smaller, sleepovers, cinema trip etc and that's the time to just invite the closest friends, not in year 1 when friendships are changing constantly.
DreamerSeven · 19/11/2021 10:50

If you’re inviting more girls than you’re leaving out, I think there’s potential for hurt feelings. And boys absolutely like painting, might want to work on your unconscious bias a bit ;-)

BigYellowHat · 19/11/2021 10:43

Why do kids have to invite people they don’t like? If you were leaving out one then I’d probably say you had to suck it up but four is fine.

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 10:42

@asprinklingofsugar

The comments on this thread are ridiculous - a total of nine out of thirty people attending a party is not a big deal. That means less than one third of the class will be there. And in terms of only girls, it’s still only two thirds who will be there so a fairly significant portion will not have been invited. If it was just one person that would be different but four girls and seventeen boys missing out is fine!
I can see why so many kids grow up to become entitled - or taking offence at every small thing (and posting on MM about it) Also pp have suggested having a small party (4/5) - so it’s fine to make DD choose between her friends and hurt a couple. But not fine to leave out people whom she might not even talk to? Mind boggling!

The whole ‘if you can’t afford everyone don’t have it’ for fear of offending other people is arrogant and privileged. People budget for their kid to do an activity they enjoy with their friends - if they can’t afford to pay for the whole world they should just not do it? That’s more mean and cruel

IWishToAnswerInTheAffirmative · 19/11/2021 10:40

Two parties is ridiculous. Total overkill.

MargaretThursday · 19/11/2021 10:38

My experience of boys and painting is my ds, who used to go out of his class in year 1 to do extra maths instead of the craft afternoon they had once a week. he thought he'd got a better deal. Grin

If he'd been invited to a painting party, I'm not convinced he would want to go at that age (he definitely wouldn't now!). If he had gone then I don't think the painting would have kept him engaged for very long.
I think if you'd asked me as a parent I'd have said for your own sanity don't invite him Grin

There is a gender split often at primary, although my dc always had friends of both girls and boys.
I used to see it with the swimming pool (yes, this was a state school) at the infants. We had a social time after school and I used to supervise. I did it for 9 years (summer term only as outside!). Almost every day (and it would be different children, so not that some children pushing their choice) you ended up with the boys in one group playing one big game and the girls split into smaller groups of 2-3. You could encourage them to join all together, but then they'd gradually split back again.

I think when a child is left out of a party once it is something they pick themselves up from, even if they're upset at the time.
Problem comes when it happens time and time again. That's when it hurts. And one of the issues is that if a child isn't at the parties, then they seem to get forgotten about because the other parents don't think of them.
One of mine got missed out in year R because she had a very similar name to another. And the parents kept saying "but I know there's only one Sophie in your form isn't there?" and not thinking to check if there's a Sophia.

  • Not actual name.

I know this because it came out in year 1 when she had her party (early in the academic year).

OP, totally get what you say about space. Have you thought about doing 2 parties? Your dd will love having two parties, and you can have half at each. I'd not have them back to back, but maybe one in the morning ending with lunch and other in the afternoon. They can do the same painting at both.

Nearthelooplease · 19/11/2021 10:37

@1u1a

OP, don’t do this. You are effectively relegating the 4 non-invited girls to the ‘unpopular group.’ These divisions are damaging and it sets a precedent. Also in Year 1, friendships are very fluid. It’s likely that one of the non-invited girls may be your DD’s best friend this time next year. Kept your options open with all the girls at this early stage. I don’t see why you can’t just squeeze 4 more in? Also, it’s teaching your daughter to be inclusive, rather than mean and selective. Just have all the girls and be done with it. It’s only a few hours.
It’s not mean and selective to only want to invite your actual friends to your party. Especially when you’re 5 Hmm

Also I’m genuinely confused how it’s teaching her to be inclusive by saying that she’s got to invite all of the girls (even if she doesn’t play with them and she actively doesn’t like one of them) but none of the boys?

1u1a · 19/11/2021 10:23

OP, don’t do this. You are effectively relegating the 4 non-invited girls to the ‘unpopular group.’ These divisions are damaging and it sets a precedent. Also in Year 1, friendships are very fluid. It’s likely that one of the non-invited girls may be your DD’s best friend this time next year. Kept your options open with all the girls at this early stage. I don’t see why you can’t just squeeze 4 more in? Also, it’s teaching your daughter to be inclusive, rather than mean and selective. Just have all the girls and be done with it. It’s only a few hours.

asprinklingofsugar · 19/11/2021 10:22

The comments on this thread are ridiculous - a total of nine out of thirty people attending a party is not a big deal. That means less than one third of the class will be there. And in terms of only girls, it’s still only two thirds who will be there so a fairly significant portion will not have been invited. If it was just one person that would be different but four girls and seventeen boys missing out is fine!

VitalsStable · 19/11/2021 10:09

Just invite the whole ones she wants to invite.

Id not invite people I didn't want at a party because they feel they should go. It's my party I should have who I want and definitely not someone I didn't particularly like. Especially in my home which is supposed to be where I feel comfortable with people I get on with.

DD is just 8 and knows when others in her class have a party, she's not in the least bit bothered. If she was excluded from someone's party who she was very close to I imagine she'd be hurt but that's not happened.

As for the whole class parties, it's a huge amount of money for the parent of the birthday child and a bloody nightmare for us parents having to ferry the kids about and get a gift for a kid that your own child is only on polite nodding terms with because they happen to be put in the same bloody class.

Swipe left for the next trending thread