Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
YoComoManzanas · 20/11/2021 09:09

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@vsgkitt That’s what I’m worried about! What age was your DD then? Sounds like she was a bit older? I would hope 5/6 year olds wouldn’t be painting ganja leaves Grin

Anyone who is mother to a 5/6 year old boy, please shout if they would enjoy a painting-related party! Would potentially solve my dilemma if so.[/quote]
My elder ds wouldn't have been bothered with crafting at that age, however my y1 ds2 loves drawing and painting. However both would be all over a bouncy castle if offered instead.
I think it's a shame to be so exclusionary in y1. My eldest ds has always been invited to girls parties (and boys) because he gets on with everyone.
Understand you can only afford a few though so maybe half the girls?

SquarePeggyLeggy · 20/11/2021 09:08

This was on response to the poster who said that children wouldn’t know, that it was parents being upset and making it an issue. My point is that children do know, and find it hurtful.

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2021 09:07

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@sunflowerroses. Yes there are boys in the class - it's a class of about 30 children. Sorry - should have said that in my initial post.

Urgh, I am panicking now! We could invite fewer girls and maybe a few boys? But the activity is painting-related - not sure boys would be into it?[/quote]
Good god.

Invite a sensible number of her friends without leaving out just a few kids.

6 or 7 including her for painting in your own home is about all you will manage.

And ditch your sexist attitude along with your unrealistic ideas of child management and rather mean attitude about leaving out just 4.

TableFlowerss · 20/11/2021 08:37

I’m talking about my experience of it. I’m not saying only popular kids are invited to parties, but that was my experience of it.m and my DC did feel shit.

TableFlowerss · 20/11/2021 08:35

@Cassandrainthenight

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads. And then they cry in their room while you falsely comfort them that it’s OK to not be invited while your heart is breaking for them.

If you couldn’t give a shit about them not being invited they wouldn’t care either!! Children(anyone really but esp. children) copy your energy and for years have to read you non verbally before they learn the language well enough. You can pretend but they follow your true feelings.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend. Don’t make yourself and your child into such a victim.

I disagree with this. Kids want to be included. They know who the popular kids are, though I agree, probably not at 5/6, though some will.

If they see all the cool kids going to a party that could easily reiterate that they aren’t part of it.

Some won’t be bothered but some will. It’s human nature to want to fit in

TableFlowerss · 20/11/2021 08:31

Hate is a strong word. Why would your DC expect an invite to this kid's party? Were they friends

@ThirdElephant

No they weren’t great friends but neither were most of the kids that were invited, it really was the ‘poplar’ group. My DC best friend was invited and didn’t play with the boy much either.

It’s not so much the not inviting, as I’ve explained you can’t go to all the parties, it’s the way the mother gave out the invites. They were given out in front of all the other kids. Most of them got one. She could have easily text the parents.

So yeah when I see her I think I can’t stand you! 🤣

Elsie296 · 20/11/2021 07:36

I always go with the 'less than half' or 'all' rule x

VividGemini · 20/11/2021 07:23

When I was growing up no one ever invited all the girls in the class to their party at any age you just invited the children you played with and hung out with.

This was what it was mostly like at my school. Unfortunately due to relentless bullying from year 3 onwards only had 1 or 2 friends so didn't get to go to many.

TheOriginalEmu · 20/11/2021 06:49

@Cassandrainthenight

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads. And then they cry in their room while you falsely comfort them that it’s OK to not be invited while your heart is breaking for them.

If you couldn’t give a shit about them not being invited they wouldn’t care either!! Children(anyone really but esp. children) copy your energy and for years have to read you non verbally before they learn the language well enough. You can pretend but they follow your true feelings.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend. Don’t make yourself and your child into such a victim.

Bullshit. If it were the case that it was DIFFERENT kids left out each time so everyone got an invite, then maybe that would be true. But that’s not what happens. The same few kids- Often the ones who are disabled different in some way are the ones left out. My son was almost always left out. He’s autistic, but not stupid. He noticed and it made him sad.
MaryShelley1818 · 20/11/2021 06:46

No I wouldn't do that.
It's strange that some posters really can't see the difference in a minority being invited and a minority not being invited.

VitaminA · 20/11/2021 06:38

What's wrong with inviting just friends? I definitely couldn't afford to host a whole class of kids. It's crazy that children can't just invite who they want without being sworn to secrecy.

SilverThread · 20/11/2021 05:13

Son recently left off an all boy party too, and he was pretty upset.

SilverThread · 20/11/2021 05:10

I would invite all the girls.
You do realise parents probably won’t want to leave their kids in your house, so it’s going to be very full.

I once had a party for my daughter, invited all the girls and accidentally left one off the list, my daughter forgot, and I did too.
I was horrified after the party, and her Mum never spoke to me again.

ThirdElephant · 20/11/2021 04:53

@SquarePeggyLeggy

Wholeheartedly disagree. Maybe they don’t all feel that way, but if you were the kind of child who always felt different, and wasn’t generally liked, by the age of 6, you know. You know that’s you, and this kind of thing just confirms it. Teachers never choosing you, last to teams, in the minority not invited, you know. I think if you don’t believe a child knows this feeling, you were perhaps fortunate or likeable enough to not have it happen to you repeatedly.
If you weren't generally liked, would you have wanted to be invited to a party by/with people who didn't like you?

If you had a peer group of 8 girls that you hung out with but were one of the social runts, so to speak, how would it feel being left out because your inclusion would have made your friend's mother fall foul of an arbitrary 'less than half the girls' rule, and that friend's mother didn't have the capacity to invite the whole class?

SquarePeggyLeggy · 20/11/2021 04:26

Wholeheartedly disagree. Maybe they don’t all feel that way, but if you were the kind of child who always felt different, and wasn’t generally liked, by the age of 6, you know. You know that’s you, and this kind of thing just confirms it. Teachers never choosing you, last to teams, in the minority not invited, you know.
I think if you don’t believe a child knows this feeling, you were perhaps fortunate or likeable enough to not have it happen to you repeatedly.

ThirdElephant · 20/11/2021 04:04

@TableFlowerss

There was a mother who done this twice, at my DC school. She invited say 8 boys and left out 4.

Funnily enough, it was all the ‘cool’ kids that were invited and the ‘uncool’ kids were left out. Yes she didn’t single out 1/2 but you could clearly tell it was only a party for the popular boys.

She would hand out the invites like Willy Wonkas golden tickets and I remember my DC asking the birthday boy where his invite was? Well he didn’t have one because he wasn’t deemed cool enough 😥

To this day, I can’t stand that mother. I hate that she dove it in front of everyone and all the kids. The worse of it is, she was unpopular at school and was in the ‘alternative crowd’ so she’ll know what it’s like to not be invited to parties etc….

I hate her for the way she made my little one feel.

So no, I wouldn’t leave 4 out.

Hate is a strong word. Why would your DC expect an invite to this kid's party? Were they friends?
ddl1 · 20/11/2021 00:55

No. Either invite a smaller number (no more than 6 at maximum; probably 5 or less is best) or invite all, perhaps to an activity outside the home.

I'm guessing that this is her 6th birthday; and at that age, a huge party is probably not needed - a small group is best IMO. Especially as primary school at the moment seems to be superspreader central; but even if this doesn't worry you, at this age informal parties tend to be more enjoyable if kept small. And less work for you.

Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 00:45

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads. And then they cry in their room while you falsely comfort them that it’s OK to not be invited while your heart is breaking for them.

If you couldn’t give a shit about them not being invited they wouldn’t care either!! Children(anyone really but esp. children) copy your energy and for years have to read you non verbally before they learn the language well enough. You can pretend but they follow your true feelings.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend. Don’t make yourself and your child into such a victim.

TableFlowerss · 19/11/2021 23:48

There was a mother who done this twice, at my DC school. She invited say 8 boys and left out 4.

Funnily enough, it was all the ‘cool’ kids that were invited and the ‘uncool’ kids were left out. Yes she didn’t single out 1/2 but you could clearly tell it was only a party for the popular boys.

She would hand out the invites like Willy Wonkas golden tickets and I remember my DC asking the birthday boy where his invite was? Well he didn’t have one because he wasn’t deemed cool enough 😥

To this day, I can’t stand that mother. I hate that she dove it in front of everyone and all the kids. The worse of it is, she was unpopular at school and was in the ‘alternative crowd’ so she’ll know what it’s like to not be invited to parties etc….

I hate her for the way she made my little one feel.

So no, I wouldn’t leave 4 out.

YouokHun · 19/11/2021 23:38

[quote TeenTitan007]Yes, invite

BurntO · 19/11/2021 23:22

I think it’s shitty. Like it or not many friendships groups at that age are already naturally segregated by sex so there will be a few who feel shit because their friends are invited to X party and they aren’t. I’d whittle it down or invite them all

TractorAndHeadphones · 19/11/2021 23:17

@fiasco2021111

Yes it's mean. A child in my daughters class had a party and invited all class apart from the 4 new kids and my daughter and then sent my daughter pictures & videos of them at the party. My daughter said she wasn't bothered but it pissed me off so much. It's wicked. Either invite a few, all the girls or the whole class.
Surely your problem here is the kid gloating over your daughter and not the party itself
fiasco2021111 · 19/11/2021 23:05

Yes it's mean. A child in my daughters class had a party and invited all class apart from the 4 new kids and my daughter and then sent my daughter pictures & videos of them at the party. My daughter said she wasn't bothered but it pissed me off so much. It's wicked. Either invite a few, all the girls or the whole class.

Cassandrainthenight · 19/11/2021 22:59

@Morph2lcfc, too many invitations (for my taste) for 2 younger kids (now y2 and 6) but barely any (a couple a year) for two elder ones (finished school, big age gap)
Never was bothered with the older ones. Now come to think of it must have been much rarer because there were no expectations placed back then on the parents to invite only a couple or the whole class, people just invited who THE CHILD wanted to see at their party.

For everyone who is doing Helen Lovejoy impression on this thread and pleading “won’t somebody please think of the children?!” and claiming any girl would be devastated to be left out of a classmate’s home painting party, it’s not true.

My kids 100% would not be devastated, would probably be relieved. We went to one of my daughter’s best friend’s birthday party in a church hall with a bouncy castle, it was a 2 kids joint party and the mother of the best friend told me she felt pressed into inviting the whole class (by the other mother). My DD heard it was everyone invited and immediately said she didn’t want to go.

In the end we only went because one of the girls’ was one of my DD’s best friends, turning 6 and we are sort of friends with the mum and I felt uncomfortable saying no.
My DD hated the idea of being a part of the writhing mass of screaming kids in the bouncy castle and actually spent most of the time outside on the lawn with a few kids like her who don’t enjoy noisy boisterous mass gatherings. She begged to leave after an hour, we left, lesson learned to actually listen to my own child and not to the voice of convention.

Anyway, what I’m trying to say, don’t assume everyone is devastated not to be at a party, plenty could be happy about not having to turn down an invitation! Or they might have better plans Grin and couldn’t care less.

P.S. of course I always invited the kids via texting the parents direct or handing them the invitations privately.

Xmasbaby11 · 19/11/2021 22:57

It would be fine in my dc school. My dc are 7 and 9 and only seen one girls only party, age 8. Others all mixed and never a whole class. When there were big parties in reception or y1, there were guests from other classes and other randoms, never a whole class / all girls. It might not be good to invite 75% of the class, but what you're doing is fine!

Swipe left for the next trending thread