Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 12:15

@Marynotsocontrary I agree there should basically be balance when taking those decisions, I just think there was enough balance in the OP's situation - where parents and children feel guilt tripped into something which isn't enjoyable or convenient (less alone affordable) for them, that's surely lack of balance as well!

Marynotsocontrary · 20/11/2021 11:57

Thank you for the further explanation Cassandrainthenight.
I'm not saying that people don't have trauma in their lives (especially in the way you've further described), but that, even if they do, that's probably not the reason they've voted YABU. Being one of a small number excluded does make it about you personally to some extent, and even a child can see that. It's simply unkind to hurt children in this way unnecessarily, that's why I voted the way I did. It's important for parents to teach resilience as well, of course, but I think being thoughtful in our treatment of others is really important and something that should be modelled to our children too.

Scarlettpixie · 20/11/2021 11:41

If there are 30 in the class inviting 8 girls is fine.

While I agree boys would love a painting activity, you should invite the children who you child wants to invite. You don't have to invite boys if she isn't friends with boys.

My son at 5/6 and to be fair quite a bit older would have enjoyed a party involving painting.

EnglishRose1320 · 20/11/2021 11:40

I think in your situation I would let her invite 5 friends, then including her the total is 6 for her 6th birthday, definitely not excluding people then and a manageable number for a craft party but enough people for it to feel like a birthday treat.

autumnalvibes · 20/11/2021 11:36

This is normal in my son's class and I think it's fine but it has led to some feeling left out. My son's class (y1) has 30 but only 11 boys and the girls tend to have parties for just the girls and the boys just invite around 6/8 boys, lots put photos on Facebook so not very discreet. My sons been left out but doesn't seem to care at the moment but he's going to a party next week where 9/11 boys have been invited which I do think is a bit mean.

Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 11:34

@Marynotsocontrary

Sorry, I should have probably worded it differently. By childhood trauma I probably just meant "childhood", because trauma is inevitable and fairly normal in our development.

I don't mean abandonment or abuse or anything like that, there is a joke that goes - if you have parents you have something to discuss with a shrink.

But these sort of attitudes (where people take stuff personally which is not about them etc) are a result of certain conditioning, as 90% of all our attitudes and beliefs are. That can be reversed/unpicked if somebody wasn't very happy with how their life turns out. For people who are entirely content with how everything has turned out in their life of course there's no need to dig deeper...

Sunsetttt · 20/11/2021 11:27

@wouldthatbeworse

The numbers are ok as long as youre discrete. Why anyone thinks 5/6 year old boys don’t like art is a mystery. No wonder so many kids think they are trans if a little boy can’t pick up a paintbrush (let alone enjoy dancing Or a doll)
I don’t think anyone is saying boys at this age don’t like art. But having worked with children, my experience is that 5/6 year old boys are less likely than 5/6 year old girls to be able to sit and do something quietly on task. It doesn’t mean all can’t and it doesn’t mean it will last forever. But generally, at this age, if you want that kind of party, boys of 5/6 will find it harder to sit.
Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 11:26

Also to be honest if your child is continuously excluded you need to ask yourself why and not blame other parents.

There is a girl in my daughter's class who is a bully and making my daughter's life a misery to the point where she doesn't want to go to school some days. She constantly secretly pinches, scratches, kicks my daughter under the table etc, also she name calls her. As far as I know she does it to the majority of girls, to whoever is not feisty and she feels she could get away with. She only has one semi-friend, and I wouldn't be surprised if she wasn't invited to birthday parties.

I had to tell the teacher a few times, but I'd never approach the parents, and to be honest I have no idea if they are at all aware that their daughter is a bully, they could well be wondering why she isn't popular...

I'm not blaming the child btw, she obviously has issues and needs help, but I'm not throwing my child under the bus and ever inviting this girl to any parties or playdates.

Another thing could be that your child is just very introverted, quiet, special needs, etc, shy, doesn't make friends easily etc. Then don't get dramatic on their behalf, and create a plan where you expand their circles and meet as many people as possible at other activities similar to the ones that your child enjoys. There would be a similar child or two out there somewhere, they don't have to have friends only at school. Though even at school if I was a mother of such a child I'd probably would try one on one playdates with every child in the class that my child would want to have round, and see if they could build a friendship outside of a classroom initially.

And have things in their life for them to look forward to, have stuff to do at weekends even if it's flying a kite in the park or getting a hot chocolate somewhere, don't rely on other parents and kids to organise a social life for your child and then seethe that they don't! Nobody owes you and your children anything.

Frazzled2207 · 20/11/2021 11:24

I think at that age you either limit it to a really small number say 5-6 max or invite the whole class

Woohooforwine · 20/11/2021 11:21

I think it’s fine. It’s not a whole class party and you can only accommodate X amount. It’s not like there’s a group of 7 that are all best friends and you’re excluding one. Even at that age I think kids understand that if your not some ones particular friend you wouldn’t be invited their small party.

Marynotsocontrary · 20/11/2021 11:13

@Cassandrainthenight

All the posters who voted YABU, if you walked into a room where was a group of people you knew were expecting you, and everyone was laughing loudly the moment you walked in, and they all stopped when you walked in, I bet you would have made it all about you, that it must have been that they were laughing AT YOU, and they stopped because you caught them.

If you would have (and obviously passed the same attitude to your kids) then don't worry, you are in good company (it's a real life story which happened to young Dostoyevsky being introduced to the literary cream of society, he stormed off and never even talked to the host again! People were laughing at a funny joke when he walked in, and stopped because he was new to the company, out of politeness)

But if you would have, all it is is childhood trauma, and it can be dealt with by attending sessions with a therapist. Because it would have affected all areas of your life and is worth unpicking.

Oh, for heavens sake! I'm willing to bet that the vast majority of people who voted YABU didn't do so because they have unaddressed childhood trauma issues!
Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 11:11

@RedToothBrush

Was in that position between ages of 8 and 11 but to be honest was bookish and was barely paying attention that I had few friends/invitations.

Moved schools at 12 and the most popular boy in the class fell for me which changed the dynamics...but one thing I'm grateful to my parents for was I knew not to measure my value by other people's expectations, and knew that a certain amount of "exclusion" and judgement would always happen in life, and it's not about me.
There's plenty of people who genuinely don't care about peaches or diamonds, for instance, and it's not that peaches are not good enough fruit or diamonds are not pretty enough...

Nobody could be themselves if they tried to be everybody's friend and it would be a miserable life.

wouldthatbeworse · 20/11/2021 11:08

The numbers are ok as long as youre discrete. Why anyone thinks 5/6 year old boys don’t like art is a mystery. No wonder so many kids think they are trans if a little boy can’t pick up a paintbrush (let alone enjoy dancing Or a doll)

Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 11:02

All the posters who voted YABU, if you walked into a room where was a group of people you knew were expecting you, and everyone was laughing loudly the moment you walked in, and they all stopped when you walked in, I bet you would have made it all about you, that it must have been that they were laughing AT YOU, and they stopped because you caught them.

If you would have (and obviously passed the same attitude to your kids) then don't worry, you are in good company (it's a real life story which happened to young Dostoyevsky being introduced to the literary cream of society, he stormed off and never even talked to the host again! People were laughing at a funny joke when he walked in, and stopped because he was new to the company, out of politeness)

But if you would have, all it is is childhood trauma, and it can be dealt with by attending sessions with a therapist. Because it would have affected all areas of your life and is worth unpicking.

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2021 10:59

@Cassandrainthenight

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads. And then they cry in their room while you falsely comfort them that it’s OK to not be invited while your heart is breaking for them.

If you couldn’t give a shit about them not being invited they wouldn’t care either!! Children(anyone really but esp. children) copy your energy and for years have to read you non verbally before they learn the language well enough. You can pretend but they follow your true feelings.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend. Don’t make yourself and your child into such a victim.

I was the 'left out' one from an early age. Kids will say 'your not my friend' or doing a big show of the 'this is my best friend'.

Believe me, you don't need an adult to tell you this stuff, the kids are fantastic at managing it themselves.

You show up the fact that you were never in this position yourself.

Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 10:52

@SilverThread

^^I once had a party for my daughter, invited all the girls and accidentally left one off the list, my daughter forgot, and I did too.
I was horrified after the party, and her Mum never spoke to me again^^

This is a PERFECT example. You didn't do it to exclude the girl, and the mother made it all about you purposefully excluding her! Like loads of the posters on this thread. It's very peculiar or I guess typical example of basic insecurity. Though to never speak to you again!!! I understand if you snogged her husband or something, talk about creating lifetime issues for her daughter out of nothing! She probably impressed it on her daughter, that feeling of being excluded purposefully...Though to be honest if I cared I'd have approached the mother straight away and explained the situation and maybe organised a playdate or something...

You say later your son got left out, did it occur to you after your own mistake that it might not have been intentional or had nothing to do with your son specifically?

Concestor · 20/11/2021 10:51

Low level, not more level

Concestor · 20/11/2021 10:50

@SquarePeggyLeggy

Wholeheartedly disagree. Maybe they don’t all feel that way, but if you were the kind of child who always felt different, and wasn’t generally liked, by the age of 6, you know. You know that’s you, and this kind of thing just confirms it. Teachers never choosing you, last to teams, in the minority not invited, you know. I think if you don’t believe a child knows this feeling, you were perhaps fortunate or likeable enough to not have it happen to you repeatedly.
Totally agree. I was always left out of things, I knew I wasn't popular or cool but I didn't know why. My childhood was full of more level bullying like this and I was miserable and tried to commit suicide when I was 13. Last year I was diagnosed autistic.

I do wonder where all the #bekind is now? Of course it's not ok to leave such a small percentage of the girls out, I can't believe anyone thinks it is. But it explains a lot. Many people just aren't kind people.

BungleandGeorge · 20/11/2021 10:48

@Cassandrainthenight you come across as someone who doesn’t understand child development and behaviour at all

BungleandGeorge · 20/11/2021 10:46

The other thing is that when parents put an arbitrary limit on numbers some of those excluded are actually friends. It’s not just that they’ve excluded people they don’t get on with. And parents tend to invite children of parents that are friends. So it’s not even totally the child deciding. And then the excluded child questions why a friend has excluded them for no reason. You’ll see many posts from adults wondering why their ‘friend’ has excluded them it’s not a nice feeling for anyone. Either a small group or all the girls largely avoids all these issues

Cassandrainthenight · 20/11/2021 10:45

@TableFlowerss

I agree it's human nature to want to fit in, but at age 5-6 clues from the parents should far outweigh social clues.
It's basic psychology, to belong to your parents and not be rejected by them for a small child is far more important than not be "rejected" by society.
For a small child to belong to their parents means to think and act like them. Not to copy their false words, exactly how the poster @JohnStonesMissus above demonstrates, she PRETENDED she didn't care that her daughter wasn't invited, and her daughter reacted exactly as her mother would have. The kids would follow the parents' true attitude.

JohnStonesMissus · 20/11/2021 10:28

@Cassandrainthenight

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads. And then they cry in their room while you falsely comfort them that it’s OK to not be invited while your heart is breaking for them.

If you couldn’t give a shit about them not being invited they wouldn’t care either!! Children(anyone really but esp. children) copy your energy and for years have to read you non verbally before they learn the language well enough. You can pretend but they follow your true feelings.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend. Don’t make yourself and your child into such a victim.

You're talking rubbish, my DD noticed in Y2 she wasn't invited to the class party, I never said a word about it although I was sad for her inside, I acted all breezy and didn't make a big deal of it I never ever mentioned the party, but my DD did, she kept on asking why she wasn't invited. Kids aren't stupid, they know who the popular children are, they want to be part of that and it really stings when they're not..
Sunsetttt · 20/11/2021 09:34

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@vsgkitt That’s what I’m worried about! What age was your DD then? Sounds like she was a bit older? I would hope 5/6 year olds wouldn’t be painting ganja leaves Grin

Anyone who is mother to a 5/6 year old boy, please shout if they would enjoy a painting-related party! Would potentially solve my dilemma if so.[/quote]
My friend invited my son and another boy to her daughter’s very calm and sweet art party. The boys were wild and not into the painting and i think they kind of ruined it. I didn’t say as much to the boys, and neither did she, but boys’ energy levels at that age are generally different. (A reason why girls tend to do better in school when they’re younger.)

Of course not all boys find sitting still and drawing difficult, some totally love it, but I would say that more girls are able to at this age than boys.

I think if you invite fewer girls - 6 in total -offending people won’t be a problem.

Marynotsocontrary · 20/11/2021 09:21

Oh my God, the children are not born with the idea that not being invited to a birthday party equals being unworthy or unpopular. You, parents, put that idea into their heads.
I really disagree with this. Wanting to fit in, to be accepted, to belong, is a basic human instinct (though some will feel it more keenly than others). It's not parents' fault that their children feel sad if excluded by classmates.

And if you want your child to have fun and feel they are not invited enough to places, then solve that problem by being the party starter. Organise parties to celebrate 6 and a half birthday or to celebrate anything you can think of, -and then your kids will have as many parties as they want to attend.
I do like the idea of creating a joyous household Smile

ddl1 · 20/11/2021 09:09

She said to invite 8 out of 13. 13 - 8 is 5. So it's 5 girls left out.

I assume that No. 5 is the birthday girl herself, who won't be a guest as she's hosting the thing!

Swipe left for the next trending thread