Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
ThirdElephant · 21/11/2021 08:32

Some parents try to teach kids how ‘being kind’ works from an early age, some don’t….

Some parents try to reach kids to be inclusive, sons don’t….

Some people give a shit about others, some don’t….

None of the fans of the 'less than half or all' mantra have explained how that is kind to a child who the birthday kid is actually friends with who doesn't make the cut in a 'less than 50%' party. Kid who OP's kid doesn't like is unlikely to give a monkeys about the party. The 8th friend that doesn't make the grade because of some arbitrary ruling ia actually the only one of the friendship group being left out. In my eyes, that's orders of magnitude more unkind than not inviting 4/5 kids who aren't actually in the friendship group anyway.

Marynotsocontrary · 21/11/2021 08:31

And teaching children to 'be inclusive' and 'bekind' and 'be the bigger person' is very harmful and detrimental and I feel sorry that you teach your children that their comfort and wishes come last. It's the wrong message and it needs to stop.

Ah now. I see your point TheGirlCat, but I think you've gone too far with it. If my children are fighting, I do need to ask them to stop, to think a bit about how their sibling may be feeling too, to try seeing things from a different point of view, to be kind and share. Young children can be selfish little buggers sometimes, to some extent they need to be taught that not everything is about their comfort and wishes (or I'd be a complete doormat at this stage). It's all about balance, as always.

I don't think there's been any suggestion that the OP's daughter is being bullied by a classmate as you have suggested...that would, of course, result in different decisions being made.

Moulesvinrouge1 · 21/11/2021 08:24

[quote Fr0thandBubble]@sunflowerroses. Yes there are boys in the class - it's a class of about 30 children. Sorry - should have said that in my initial post.

Urgh, I am panicking now! We could invite fewer girls and maybe a few boys? But the activity is painting-related - not sure boys would be into it?[/quote]
Why wouldn’t they?! I don’t know any boys that don’t like painting.

TableFlowerss · 21/11/2021 08:23

[quote TheGirlCat]@Fr0thandBubble You don't explain if it's 4 girls or 5 girls left out. It reads like as your title says, 5 girls out of a total of 13 are being left out.

Regardless, I find this thread deeply, deeply horrifying and concerning on so many levels. We wonder why #MeToo happens, why women are told to #BeKind , even at their own expense.

This thread, shows how the conditioning starts early. I am lucky I grew up in a time and country where if you received an invite, you received one. It was never a big deal, and as young as 5 you knew who your friends were so would never expect an invite from a classmate you weren't good friends with. What this thread shows, is these days children are conditioned to sacrifice their own happiness - told they have to invite the whole class - even children they don't get on with or who BULLY THEM, or they risk not having 8 of their friends so then run the risk of upsetting a couple of close friends, all for the sake of not having an entire class there.

Children as this thread shows, are conditioned that their rights don't matter, their wants ON THEIR OWN BIRTHDAY don't matter. They have invite people they don't like. This, has a serious affect, especially with girls and women later on, who feel they have to be around people they are uncomfortable with or don't like, just to be seen to 'bekind'. Their own wishes don't matter, they must 'bekind'. No matter the cost to them.

This thread and it's subliminal and outright messages that children have no choice in who they have in their own homes and who they associate with, is so deeply, deeply disturbing to me, and more so because many of you simply can't see it. You are too caught up in the shallow 'bekind' to see what the undercurrent of the message is you are sending out. This thread has such sinister undertones and while I'm glad some others see it, I am very saddened and disturbed not enough others see the sinister messages this 'bekind' and put your own wishes and happiness last has on a girl who will grow up.

OP, allow your daughter the safety, the freedom, and the happiness to CHOOSE who SHE wants and HER OWN BIRTHDAY. Other people's responses is NOT YOUR DAUGHTER'S RESPONSIBILITY. The reaction of another child, parent, or ultimately man, is not your child's responsibility, and she shouldn't have to sacrifice a couple of her friends, just to be seen to be kind, at her own expense and happiness. Please, think about what message you are sending to your daughter, that appearances matter more than her own wants and needs on her own special day. You are like other posters on here, teaching her to put herself last, and to be responsible for the reactions and happiness of others, at the expense of her own. Just think about it. You don't have to make yourself miserable and axe a few of your friends, just to be seen to 'bekind'. You don't have to invite everyone to be a decent person. Just think about what message you are giving her, when you are telling her that her own happiness matters less than numbers and the reactions of others. Please, just think about it, and make that positive change to be a positive parent who lets her daughter know it's ok to make choices that make her happy.[/quote]
Well thankfully it looks like your opinion on the matter is in the minority!!

Most people appreciate empathy, clearly some don’t….

Some parents try to teach kids how ‘being kind’ works from an early age, some don’t….

Some parents try to reach kids to be inclusive, sons don’t….

Some people give a shit about others, some don’t….

Swings and roundabouts!!

TheGirlCat · 21/11/2021 08:17

@84wood

I think you’re teaching social skills with this type of event. You either invite all or a very small number of best friends. Can you move venues?

Tbh - the message is very important. I teach mine to become inclusive and the bigger person if there is someone she’s not that keen on.

You either invite all or a very small number of best friends.

That is the WRONG message to send.

The message is very important. And teaching children to 'be inclusive' and 'bekind' and 'be the bigger person' is very harmful and detrimental and I feel sorry that you teach your children that their comfort and wishes come last. It's the wrong message and it needs to stop.

TheGirlCat · 21/11/2021 08:15

@Figgit

Oh FFS, this is not the office groper, it’s 6 year old girls. Sorry, OP, it may not be your intention, but it will look mean to the teacher, other parents, and most importantly the girls who are left out. I always think when people posts these kinds of things here, they know that, they’re just looking for validation.
If that's your only take away from it, you clearly missed the wider point, that we are sending the message that 'bekind' is more important than how a child feels and their needs and wishes. Your attitude is exactly what leads to posters feeling like they have to invite everyone out somewhere. Because they've been conditioned to.
CecilyP · 21/11/2021 08:07

Not a primary teacher, but if I was, I wouldn’t think anything of it. I’d just see it as inviting 8 pupils out of a class of 30. This seems a perfectly manageable number for an activity party or one in someone’s home. I don’t understand the girl/boy thing at all; at this age I had (very small numbers) of boys and girls at my parties and was invited to both boys and girls. It tended to be in upper primary when kids tend to split off into sex-segregated groups. If it was my class, I would just see it as 21 out of 30 not going. I can’t see 6 year old children noticing that it is only 4 girls.

ThirdElephant · 21/11/2021 08:07

@84wood

I think you’re teaching social skills with this type of event. You either invite all or a very small number of best friends. Can you move venues?

Tbh - the message is very important. I teach mine to become inclusive and the bigger person if there is someone she’s not that keen on.

I prefer to teach kids that, while they have to be polite to everyone, there is no need to bend over backwards for people who aren't considerate of you, and no obligation to invite those who upset you into your home and personal life. And also that you've no right to expect an invite to any gathering.
TakeMe2Insanity · 21/11/2021 08:01

Don’t do this in year 1. Hire a hall. Do something less messy if that’s what you are worried about. It’s a horrible precedence to create. Imagine being the girls left out.

84wood · 21/11/2021 07:59

I think you’re teaching social skills with this type of event. You either invite all or a very small number of best friends. Can you move venues?

Tbh - the message is very important. I teach mine to become inclusive and the bigger person if there is someone she’s not that keen on.

ThirdElephant · 21/11/2021 07:47

@Figgit

Oh FFS, this is not the office groper, it’s 6 year old girls. Sorry, OP, it may not be your intention, but it will look mean to the teacher, other parents, and most importantly the girls who are left out. I always think when people posts these kinds of things here, they know that, they’re just looking for validation.
As a teacher, I wouldn't for a second think it was mean. I also wouldn't participate in handing out invites though- that needs to happen beyond the school gates, no matter how many kids are invited.
Figgit · 21/11/2021 07:45

Oh FFS, this is not the office groper, it’s 6 year old girls.
Sorry, OP, it may not be your intention, but it will look mean to the teacher, other parents, and most importantly the girls who are left out.
I always think when people posts these kinds of things here, they know that, they’re just looking for validation.

ThirdElephant · 21/11/2021 06:02

I agree with @TheGirlCat

TheGirlCat · 21/11/2021 02:15

How many threads have we read on here where women post that they feel obliged to invite the office groper or perve or even office bully to drinks, to 'bekind' otherwise they will look bad?

This, is how it starts. Please people, wake up. This thread shows clear and simple, how early the conditioning to accept being around people you don't like or who make you feel uncomfortable starts. All for the sake of keeping up appearances and being 'seen' to 'bekind'. If anyone wanted to know how it starts and how early and easily we are conditioned, this thread is the 101.

TheGirlCat · 21/11/2021 02:07

@sweatervest

hopefully the kid she doesn't like won't be free anyway?

i have seen kids faces drop, literally, when they don't get an invite to a party. which is not very helpful advice from moi.

I've literally seen kids faces drop when they came fourth in a race, and didn't get a ribbon. We don't go giving 1st place ribbons to everyone to spare feelings.

I've literally seen kids (mine especially) faces drop when told no they cannot have their best friend stay over on a school or night, or cannot eat ice cream when they've only taken 2 bites of their dinner. It's called raising children properly to know they can't get their own way all the time. If we caved every time a kids' face dropped over something they wanted and didn't get, what would kids be learning?

Kids faces drop any time they are told no or they can't have something. They get over it quickly, and learn they want get everything they want when they want. They grow up to be well-adjusted adults.

The bottom line though, is that the OP's girl is only responsible for her and her friends happiness on her birthday. The OP's girl is not responsible for the reactions of anyone else. Nor should she be made to feel she should be. Because that, is what led to the MeToo movement. Women putting themselves and their wants, wishes and needs last, and others first, to be seen to be nice, to be seen to be 'kind', to be seen to be doing the right thing, for appearances. When does individual welfare and happiness become important? When do we teach our children that they are not responsible for the reaction or actions of someone else? As long as children are taught to be respectful, not bully, to not be mean and to be civil with others, they shouldn't be told they cannot invite who they want on their own birthday. When will we tell our children they have a right to be happy and are not responsible for the thoughts and reactions of others?

TheGirlCat · 21/11/2021 01:58

@Fr0thandBubble You don't explain if it's 4 girls or 5 girls left out. It reads like as your title says, 5 girls out of a total of 13 are being left out.

Regardless, I find this thread deeply, deeply horrifying and concerning on so many levels. We wonder why #MeToo happens, why women are told to #BeKind , even at their own expense.

This thread, shows how the conditioning starts early. I am lucky I grew up in a time and country where if you received an invite, you received one. It was never a big deal, and as young as 5 you knew who your friends were so would never expect an invite from a classmate you weren't good friends with. What this thread shows, is these days children are conditioned to sacrifice their own happiness - told they have to invite the whole class - even children they don't get on with or who BULLY THEM, or they risk not having 8 of their friends so then run the risk of upsetting a couple of close friends, all for the sake of not having an entire class there.

Children as this thread shows, are conditioned that their rights don't matter, their wants ON THEIR OWN BIRTHDAY don't matter. They have invite people they don't like. This, has a serious affect, especially with girls and women later on, who feel they have to be around people they are uncomfortable with or don't like, just to be seen to 'bekind'. Their own wishes don't matter, they must 'bekind'. No matter the cost to them.

This thread and it's subliminal and outright messages that children have no choice in who they have in their own homes and who they associate with, is so deeply, deeply disturbing to me, and more so because many of you simply can't see it. You are too caught up in the shallow 'bekind' to see what the undercurrent of the message is you are sending out. This thread has such sinister undertones and while I'm glad some others see it, I am very saddened and disturbed not enough others see the sinister messages this 'bekind' and put your own wishes and happiness last has on a girl who will grow up.

OP, allow your daughter the safety, the freedom, and the happiness to CHOOSE who SHE wants and HER OWN BIRTHDAY. Other people's responses is NOT YOUR DAUGHTER'S RESPONSIBILITY. The reaction of another child, parent, or ultimately man, is not your child's responsibility, and she shouldn't have to sacrifice a couple of her friends, just to be seen to be kind, at her own expense and happiness. Please, think about what message you are sending to your daughter, that appearances matter more than her own wants and needs on her own special day. You are like other posters on here, teaching her to put herself last, and to be responsible for the reactions and happiness of others, at the expense of her own. Just think about it. You don't have to make yourself miserable and axe a few of your friends, just to be seen to 'bekind'. You don't have to invite everyone to be a decent person. Just think about what message you are giving her, when you are telling her that her own happiness matters less than numbers and the reactions of others. Please, just think about it, and make that positive change to be a positive parent who lets her daughter know it's ok to make choices that make her happy.

sweatervest · 20/11/2021 17:46

hopefully the kid she doesn't like won't be free anyway?

i have seen kids faces drop, literally, when they don't get an invite to a party. which is not very helpful advice from moi.

phonetica · 20/11/2021 17:40

lso not quite sure why boys wouldn’t be into painting…you might want to rethink your attitudes there.

Don’t you know painting and anything crafty or creative are obviously only for girls. Boys are just interested in mud and dirt and wrestling.

Blondeshavemorefun · 20/11/2021 15:09

@withgraceinmyheart

I think it’s fine. Kids need to get used to the idea that they won’t be invited to everything. If you were inviting 25 out of a class of 30 that’s mean. 8 of a class of 30 is a pretty normal number.
This
TableFlowerss · 20/11/2021 14:57

[quote Cassandrainthenight]@TableFlowerss

I agree it's human nature to want to fit in, but at age 5-6 clues from the parents should far outweigh social clues.
It's basic psychology, to belong to your parents and not be rejected by them for a small child is far more important than not be "rejected" by society.
For a small child to belong to their parents means to think and act like them. Not to copy their false words, exactly how the poster @JohnStonesMissus above demonstrates, she PRETENDED she didn't care that her daughter wasn't invited, and her daughter reacted exactly as her mother would have. The kids would follow the parents' true attitude.[/quote]
I’ve also been at the other end of it, as I have one ‘popular child’ (kids used to fight over them, though they’re older now and understand people can be shallow etc and understands the meaning of true friends) and one that’s whilst not typically popular, has a group of core friends so is popular in their own group and that’s all that counts.

Having a ‘popular’ child comes with issues too. Ive had 5 parents, over the years, message me asking about their DC friendships with my DC and if my DC is ok as DS doesn’t seem as interested in the DC as much and their DC is upset etc…It’s because they all become too much for my DC and don’t like my DC to have other friends.

I’ve got no issues with my child not being invited to a party as they can’t be invited to all the parties all the time and I do explain that to my child.

My gripe is when it’s the same kids left out each time, the small minority. When there’s 9 kids going and 4 aren’t. It’s just a bit of a shitty thing to do…..

BungleandGeorge · 20/11/2021 12:48

Children do learn from parents. I try and model kindness and empathy. I’m not personally prepared to upset a 6 year old and make them feel bad over a party when it’s totally unnecessary. I think all the evidence shows that personality traits/ SEN/ mental health problems are not caused solely by parenting style.

AuntieMarys · 20/11/2021 12:45

My dcs are in their 20s now but we only had small parties, either at home or a venue. I never invited more than 6 children, and they were all children who had been to our house for tea.
I found the endless party invites a nightmare, and we declined most whole class parties .....weekends were busy enough without parties taking up more time.

ikeptgoing · 20/11/2021 12:39

My DCs had varying levels of popularity snd who they played with in class at school . Youngest got invited to most of parties, eldest got invited to few. Middle one had varying years.

Not one of them were invited to every party held throughout the year.

None of my DCs are traumatised , not even the eldest one who maybe went to 2 - 4 parties a year of about 20+ parties a year from yearR onwards when his sister was easily going to 10 or more parties a year.

None of my DCs were brought up to be entitled enough to expect an invite to everyone's party! And I'd be a pretty poor parent if I encouraged them to feel entitled or aggrieved about not being invited.. you say "oh ok I understand .... but Johnny can't invite everyone and you don't really play with him you play more with Fred and Joe".

What reasonable parent IRL really supports this view : "DS yes you should be sad that you weren't invited when little Johnny has invited 7 of his friends but not you and 3 other boys in the mixed class of 30!!" ??? HmmShockConfused

Marynotsocontrary · 20/11/2021 12:33

[quote Cassandrainthenight]@Marynotsocontrary I agree there should basically be balance when taking those decisions, I just think there was enough balance in the OP's situation - where parents and children feel guilt tripped into something which isn't enjoyable or convenient (less alone affordable) for them, that's surely lack of balance as well![/quote]
Yes, I agree, but for me, the balance was 'out' in the situation the OP described originally. For others, like you, it wasn't. Clearly OP was worried about the balance herself, which is why she posted.

ikeptgoing · 20/11/2021 12:23

Since it's next year you have plenty of time. Really it's best to just invite who DD wants there nearer the time & who she thinks might enjoy the activity. She gets to pick 8 or whatever number you feel you can manage.

Please Don't feel you have to invite everyone or invite less or more than you are comfortable with as
a) it's your DDs birthday party not a community or school event
b) there's nothing worse than being forced to have classmate you don't like (or a moody one that spoils it for everyone and complains a lit) at your own childhood birthday party .

Please dont go down the route of forcing DD to be polite and invite girls she doesn't know or really like for sake of appearances . Your DDs feelings are important too- it's her choice not others'.

I disagree with the PPs that say you have to think of "others feelz ". You're not holding a village event, it's a private party at your house.

I'd understand the angst if you were inviting whole class and only leaving out one single child- (unless the child has been bullying and horrible to DD, then fair enough). But inviting 8 (out of 11-12 girls) in a class of 30 isn't "leaving the others out" it's inviting who DD wants to a party that is small.

It's really overextending for some PPs to describe how the other girl classmates may suffer emotional problems by not being invited to your DDs party. They'll have their close friends that they invite to their parties and your DD to hers. People are overthinking "rules for a private birthday party" that aren't there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread