Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To invite 8 out of 13 girls from DD's class?

393 replies

Fr0thandBubble · 18/11/2021 22:56

DD is in Y1 and she will be having a party at home (with an activity) for her birthday.

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

Is that bad? I can't decide! Don't have room for all of them so if the consensus is that it's bad I will tell her she can only invite 7 - which is a slightly better ratio of invited/not invited!

OP posts:
SaltyPepper · 19/11/2021 04:52

Disagree that it’s mean. You can hardly be expected to invite the whole class to every young child’s birthday party.

On the boys I think you are right, they are unlikely to enjoy a painting party with girls despite the posters who want to be PC about this.

LaurenKelsey · 19/11/2021 04:11

When I was a teacher I wouldn’t allow children to pass invitations at school unless they invited everyone.

cali2000 · 19/11/2021 03:56

Please have a little more kindness

DeepaBeesKit · 19/11/2021 03:47

Oh and its always the same 3 or 4 kids who get excluded and believe you me they know about it and hate it. It would be fine if different mixes of kids got invited each time but ime that's not what tends to happen.

DeepaBeesKit · 19/11/2021 03:32

How much of this is typical child development, and how much is learned behaviour, I don't know

Its learned and it depends a lot on parenting where you live. My son is friends with lots of the girls, playdates of either sex, parties very mixed.

He is having a whole class party but when he listed names of children he wanted at his party the first 8 he listed were 4 boys and 4 girls!

DeepaBeesKit · 19/11/2021 03:24

But the activity is painting-related - not sure boys would be into

Starting this whole thing of gendered parties at 6 is Hmm

Joenlivsmom · 19/11/2021 03:20

I agree with the majority. I remember my daughter not being invited to a party where most of the girls were going and it was traumatic. Either invite all the girls or ask her to choose a couple of friends and do something more intimate. Just imagine it was your child who was one of the ones left out x

Nancydrawn · 19/11/2021 03:17

That is brutal and cruel, OP.

Four girls of the whole group not invited, whilst everyone else goes on about the fun they had with their t-shirts (which of course becomes wearable code for those who got to attend)?

Have some empathy: the little girls will be crushed.

Breakingmad · 19/11/2021 02:37

*not you

Breakingmad · 19/11/2021 02:36

It's my story to tell

Well yes, but it’s nothing to do with this thread, really. If one of the Brownies had invited 9 of your little pals to her party and if you, then that would be the equivalent.

However I clearly haven't forgotten the brownie incident hmm all these decades later so maybe I was more upset than I remember

That said, this makes a lot of sense.

1forAll74 · 19/11/2021 02:32

Invite how many you can accomodate thats all.

NiellyNoFive · 19/11/2021 02:18

@Breakingmad

I literally did not give two shits age 8 when half the girls I'd invited couldn't make it to my party because they had a brownie trip and no one had thought to tell me.

That’s not remotely the same.

It's my story to tell

NiellyNoFive · 19/11/2021 02:17

However I clearly haven't forgotten the brownie incident Hmm all these decades later so maybe I was more upset than I remember BlushConfused

Breakingmad · 19/11/2021 02:15

I literally did not give two shits age 8 when half the girls I'd invited couldn't make it to my party because they had a brownie trip and no one had thought to tell me.

That’s not remotely the same.

NiellyNoFive · 19/11/2021 02:12

I literally did not give two shits age 8 when half the girls I'd invited couldn't make it to my party because they had a brownie trip and no one had thought to tell me.

My party was great. Completely forgot about it all by the Monday and was playing with all my friends from the brownies as per usual and didn't occur to me to join the brownies to be part of their brownie gang to prevent it happening in the future.

I guess DM and I planned it a bit better for the next year.

IHateCoronavirus · 19/11/2021 02:08

As a teacher of young children, I have seen far too many hurt little faces, left out from selective parties. Kids this age are such little innocents, they approach life with so much excitement, parties get spoken about a lot.

Then once a few kids get stung by rejection, they realise how much power having a party has and can use it as a play for power and often as a weapon. “Do x,y,z or your not coming to my party!” “Don’t play with her, or your not coming to my party!” It becomes the bullying tactic of choice with this age group.

Not going to a party IS HURTFUL at this age. They feel it.

As such I warn my parents at the start of the year that I can only facilitate invitation giving out for class invites, if they are inviting specific kids invites must be given out sensitively away from the class. The parents a great and do this, but kids still talk. Birthdays are exciting.

NiellyNoFive · 19/11/2021 02:06

When I was growing up no one ever invited all the girls in the class to their party at any age you just invited the children you played with and hung out with.

I would invite a mix of friends from school and my neighbourhood friends.

Whereas for my DD and DS we had to do all these whole class joint parties in reception and year 1 - 2. They were fun to be fair as all the parents stayed and had wine and got to know each other better.

It was also great when you could finally just invite the DC your children were actually properly friends with in and out of school and also just drop your kids off and have a break.

Breakingmad · 19/11/2021 02:03

@TheGirlCat

The OP says, in the second paragraph of her opening post, ‘There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.’ It’s quite clear there are four little girls being left out, not five.

‘Parents like you do a lot of damage.’ I’m not a parent.

I was that child. The best reason so far not to give little children, practically babies, a reason to be upset and hurt about not being invited to a party they easily could be. Poor things won’t understand and it’s unnecessary harmful and leads to these sort of strange attitudes and complexes in adults. ‘I was hurt to hurt them too’.

Marynotsocontrary · 19/11/2021 01:59

Sorry, that was for TheGirlCat.

Marynotsocontrary · 19/11/2021 01:56

There are 13 girls in her class, and she wants to invite 8 of them - meaning that 9 girls would be at the party (including her), and 4 girls wouldn't be invited.

This is what the OP said re numbers.
(I'm not remotely hysterical by the way.)

Breakingmad · 19/11/2021 01:55

Those GIRLS should be reminded that they are one of 23 not invited, and encouraged not to limit their thoughts on life to their gender. And yet, only one gender is being invited to the party.

Reading through the thread it's obviously the parents, not the children, who are the ones most hurt with wounded pride who still immaturely carry on.

I am not a parent, so obviously don’t have children. Nor do I want them. I’m not remotely maternal. But why, why, would a grown woman choose to hurt four little girls when it’s completely unnecessary to? Seems to me that the posters in agreement are either little bullies of the past, or raising those of the present/future. Just let the four poor girls go the the party.

And those who are saying that it doesn’t matter that they’re girls - of course it does. The kids will know they’re one of four girls left out. They’ve plenty of time to learn resilience/disappointment etc over the next 80 years. They don’t need OP’s DD to teach them a lesson at 5 years old.

Dancingonmoonlight · 19/11/2021 01:55

I was that child, @Dancingonmoonlight That's why I speak with experience

For someone in that situation, you are now suggesting its ok to do that? The hardened 'suit yourself' and lack of empathy you have shown in your posts reflect the effect it had on you. It wasn't ok that it happened to you. It isn't ok for it to happen to others either.

TheGirlCat · 19/11/2021 01:52

@Marynotsocontrary

I can guarantee you the children got over it 5 minutes after they found out they didn't get an invite.

It's ridiculous you think you can speak for all children @TheGirlCat

Yet it's ok that you think you can hysterically speak for all children? Don't you see the hypocrisy?
TheGirlCat · 19/11/2021 01:51

@Dancingonmoonlight

The other (five!) girls who aren't close to the OP's daughter won't even know about it because they won't be close enough to the girl to even discuss it or even care either way.

Come back when your child first comes home first in tears at not being invited. When you attempt to make light of it and then it happens again. When you have chats about how not everybody can afford to invite everyone. Then it happens again. When you attempt to teach your child 'resilience' and not everybody can be popular and in this case its her and three others. When your child tells you that the majority of the girls are going to a party they have spoken about excitedly for the week running up to it. When they return to school on Monday telling the teacher and everyone else what a wonderful party they had. When your child tells you about the parties, sleepovers and outings the other girls are going on. Worse when she stops telling you about them. When she comes home and you find her crying by herself in her room brushing away tears trying to assure you she knows it isn't a big deal and she is trying hard to accept her fate is not being included with the majority of girls because for some reason she isn't 'liked enough'. When you find your child hitting herself in her room because she must be 'ugly' and that must be why she is left out.
Come back after six years of dealing with all the above. It never gets easier for the child. Never.

I was that child, @Dancingonmoonlight That's why I speak with experience.
Marynotsocontrary · 19/11/2021 01:51

I can guarantee you the children got over it 5 minutes after they found out they didn't get an invite.

It's ridiculous you think you can speak for all children @TheGirlCat