Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
jgw1 · 19/11/2021 19:09

@Appuskidu

She was initially told that when the school needed to use her as an extra supply teacher on top of her TA role, they'd pay the going rate for a professional, qualified teacher. Which hasn't happened. Ever.

They haven’t used her for cover or they haven’t paid her properly?

Many TAs are actually better at teaching than those who are qualified

How would you feel about scrapping the teaching qualification altogether then? Just pay TAs to do it all on £10 an hour?

Teaching young people isn't really very important, so probably best to just pay the minimum wage.

I mean look at the amount that Boris' parents paid for his education and he still doesn't know that that Glasgow and Edinburgh are different cities.

Appuskidu · 19/11/2021 19:02

She was initially told that when the school needed to use her as an extra supply teacher on top of her TA role, they'd pay the going rate for a professional, qualified teacher. Which hasn't happened. Ever.

They haven’t used her for cover or they haven’t paid her properly?

Many TAs are actually better at teaching than those who are qualified

How would you feel about scrapping the teaching qualification altogether then? Just pay TAs to do it all on £10 an hour?

Mollymoostoo · 19/11/2021 18:57

YANBU this is a vacant position so budget cits don't come into it. They should be going to an agency and recruiting ASAP. Contact the board of governors and tell them you are going to ofsted. This is unfair to the TA and teachers.

incywincyspidery · 19/11/2021 18:55

Ever since it was decided that TAs could take whole classes there was the potential for this. I'm a former teacher and I've worked with some amazing TAs but they are not getting paid to take on that responsibility. It isn't fair on them. It may well be that the TA in your DCs class is perfectly capable and the class will not lose out but that is not the point. My DSis is a part time TA and is also a qualified teacher although she only taught for a year before getting accidentally pregnant and spending the next seven or eight years as a SAHM- hence not wanting to apply for teaching jobs again. She was initially told that when the school needed to use her as an extra supply teacher on top of her TA role, they'd pay the going rate for a professional, qualified teacher. Which hasn't happened. Ever.

stingofthebutterfly · 19/11/2021 18:45

We had something similar happen last year when my daughter was in year 6. Her teacher went on maternity leave and they hired a teacher to cover. The year 5 teacher then also went on maternity leave and this very young, inexperienced (but lovely) cover teacher was left to teach two classes, whilst sticking to covid bubbles as much as possible. This meant that both classes were left being taught by their TAs for weeks, until the teacher swapped classes again.

My first thought was that my daughter needed a qualified teacher, but then I thought no, the TAs are bloody brilliant and have years of experience. Obviously I don't know what was going on behind the scenes, and they might have hated it, and probably weren't being paid for it, but from the point of view as a parent, I couldn't have given a damn whether they were qualified teachers or not.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 19/11/2021 18:41

Yep. I agree there too @toomuchlaundry

toomuchlaundry · 19/11/2021 18:29

It’s not just the Government that have treated teachers badly. Just have to look at many threads on here over the last 2 years. So much teacher bashing. Well it’s coming home to roost now!

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 19/11/2021 18:25

@pollymere

There are lots of levels of TA. I'd have no issue with a Level 3 HLTA teaching my child. Many HLTAs are qualified teachers these days too. Care more about experience than qualifications.
In that case, I’m wondering why we even bother to have teachers. TA should be enough no?

Much better for schools, they dint need to pay them as much. No long training required. What is there not to like?

Probably just the fact that we know well that the difference between a education system that works and one that doesn’t is the actual level of training of said teachers. Turns out that well trained teachers make better teachers after all.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 19/11/2021 18:23

Many TAs are actually better at teaching than those who are qualified - it's all down to the individual and their experience, approach and ability to control the class.
It's the TAs I feel sorry for, so often having to step into a teacher's role but on minimum wage. Grossly unfair.

pollymere · 19/11/2021 18:10

There are lots of levels of TA. I'd have no issue with a Level 3 HLTA teaching my child. Many HLTAs are qualified teachers these days too. Care more about experience than qualifications.

Monkeytennis97 · 19/11/2021 18:03

@84wood

Responding to a point - how do you know teacher qualifications? A decent school website should list qualifications. I’d ask if there is no information.
I've been teaching over 25 years in 5 schools. Grammar, secondary modern and comprehensive. My qualifications have never been displayed on any staff list.
cansu · 19/11/2021 17:59

Complain. It isn't acceptable. They need to at least try and get a replacement even if that is a supply teacher.

granny24 · 19/11/2021 17:57

Of course your child is entitled to be taught by a properly qualified professional, but until people stop voting Conservative it’s unlikely to happen.

caringcarer · 19/11/2021 17:56

I think you have every right to be angered by the plight of your dd's class. I would write in to complain, especial in the underhand way they done thing by not keeping parents informed. I wonder what would happen if there was a serious incident in your dd class while no qualified teacher was present? This year and last schools could access a lot of Covid catch up finding.

duffeldaisy · 19/11/2021 17:51

"These [teachers] are the right kind of immigrants, quite unlike those from the European Union, or people so desperate they would get in a rubber dinghy to cross the channel."

Imagine for a moment that the UK fell into bloody civil war, or was invaded, and life in bombed-out cities became a living hell. Or the new authorities started torturing citizens and their families.
Who would have the resources to leave and seek asylum first?

As someone who has worked with asylum seekers and refugees, most of the people I was working with were people who previously were teachers, professors, lawyers, journalists etc. because 1) they tend to get persecuted first in a dangerous regime 2) they may have the financial resources and contacts to be able to afford the astronomical prices to travel to safety. And all of them had suffered enormous loss, or emotional/physical abuse and pain, which is why they made an incredibly difficult decision to leave their previous lives.

It's extremely patronising to assume that because someone is travelling on a dinghy, seeking refuge, that they're not highly skilled, highly qualified and/or intelligent people. The stupidity of the government is in not allowing asylum seekers to work, if they can, during the time that their long drawn out assessments take place.

ArthurTudor · 19/11/2021 17:51

I think it depends. An excellent TA who knows the pupils well may well be better than having a string of supply teachers. Obviously it's not a long term solution though

And from the TAs perspective I really hope they have increased her pay up to unqualified teacher scale

Davygran · 19/11/2021 17:45

You are absolutely not being unreasonable but I know several teachers across the country who tell me those who leave the profession are harder & harder to replace because few people are prepared to do the job. Covid showed far too many of them how poorly this govt thinks of them & they’ve had enough.
Sadly I can’t blame them. This country doesn’t value or listen to people who actually do the job.

woodhill · 19/11/2021 17:37

I think it's awful,for the TA, are they giving her/him a pay increase

Not good for your dd either

nymum · 19/11/2021 17:31

I’m a TA that covers my class one day a week and other days as needed. I am much more able to teach the students who I know very well in a school I know very well (and with planning support from colleagues in the school) than any supply teacher. I am a teacher not qualified in this country, but have a degree and experience in another country and been a TA for several years in this country. It really depends on the staff and situation. I wouldn’t say a qualified supply teacher is always a better option.

Suja1 · 19/11/2021 17:30

TAs shouldn't have to take classes long term. They aren't paid the same and it's not fair on them. Cover teachers are in short supply as they were sometimes older teachers who just wanted to work part-time. I used to work in this way but, at my age, wouldn't enter a school given the current working conditions: no masks, ventilation etc. So, schools are probably losing out on the older cover/supply teachers.

monkeysox · 19/11/2021 16:46

Just had another thought. If your school employ teach first they are unqualified too. Few weeks before hand and straight into teaching full classes!

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 19/11/2021 16:44

I’m a teacher currently working in a charity with children part time. Makes me think I should register for supply for my day off!

FrippEnos · 19/11/2021 16:39

pokemeinthemorning
We should all be worried.

yes we should.

But teachers have been saying for years that this is a problem and get called all sorts of names for brining up what is now a major problem.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 19/11/2021 16:30

I know a lot of TAs that have quit since the pandemic started and the full effects of Brexit finally kicked in. They can make more money and receive more appreciation in lots of places that aren't schools. Our school is really, really struggling to hold on to TAs and find people who can fill the now empty roles, not helped by the fact that they receive no training, not support and are asked to work well beyond their pay grade, so to speak, for no extra money.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/11/2021 14:30

@nohouseyet

You are not being unreasonable, the school should cut its budget elsewhere, your child should be taught by a teacher and the if the school have budgeting issues they should be cutting elsewhere, not teaching staff. Is it an academy / free school? This is the problem when schools don’t have proper oversight and accountability in place. This would never happen in a million years in my LA maintained school.
Exactly. The Tories had to find a way to destroy the limited power teaching unions had, so they have dismantled the Local Authority School system in many places and its a free-for-all.