Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
Homez · 20/11/2021 21:37

Having left a highly paid career to be at home with young family, I volunteered at my children’s schools for some years. A year ago I decided to get some formal experience, with a view to doing a PGCE. Am currently employed as a Higher level TA, and my responsibilities cover everything from teaching full classes 2/3 days per week, to specific interventions & SEN support. We are also expected to run after school clubs and the school have not brought back any MDS staff since lockdown ended, so we are expected to provide that too! On top of all this, I am also first aider. We are lucky to get a break some days. I have to plan my own lessons, mark and upload data…as well as managing classroom resources and displays. Most days I work 9 to 10 hours, which works out a measly £6 / £7 per hour some weeks! It’s simply astonishing how much the TA role is being abused in schools. While I am well educated and have a lot to offer the school in terms of what I provide - a lot of TA agency staff, are really scratching the bottom of an ‘only job I can find’ barrel..and it sadly really shows. I would certainly not be happy, if they were my child’s only teacher for weeks on end.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 20/11/2021 21:36

@madroid
Teachers? On strike? Have you seen the uproar each time they’ve threatened to do that? Parents angered because dcs wouldn’t go to school, they are so privileged anyway etc…,

What about parents making a fuss instead of banging on that TA are better anyway?

noblegiraffe · 20/11/2021 21:34

Teachers need to start a campaign to tell parents they are going to strike for the sake of their children's education.

We did. It was the 'Standing up for Standards' strike. Unfortunately teachers aren't actually allowed to strike for the sake of children's education, only about their pay and conditions, so technically the strike was about teacher pensions.

We got absolutely slated. In the press and on MN. It has made teachers very wary about national strikes as they don't actually improve anything and just invite a whole heap of abuse.

madroid · 20/11/2021 21:30

@Philandbill What do you suggest teachers do other than vote with their feet and leave education?

I suggest teachers do what exploited labour force has always done - unite and strike.

While parents and teachers pull back from this the employers take advantage (and aren't they just and have taken for years).

Teachers need to start a campaign to tell parents they are going to strike for the sake of their children's education. Then do it. Go on strike until hours, wages and conditions are addressed properly. Permanent and total strike until it's sorted once and for all.

It would definitely work. And then the govt would know that they couldn't fuck around with schools and teachers anymore.

Wilkolampshade · 20/11/2021 19:17

Oh dear, this thread made me look up TA vacancies in local schools and think about my old job.... Despite everything I've said, the pictures of kids and classrooms made me so sad! And now I really want to apply again... Must resist!

spanieleyes · 20/11/2021 17:45

We were recruiting for 2 1:1 TAs, ( the only ones we can recruit for as class TAs are not being replaced when they leave, we can't afford them) . We had THREE applicants, none of whom had ever set foot in a school since leaving school themselves but thought it would be nice working with children, one trained dogs and thought it might be similar! TAs used to wash paint pots and stick sheets in books, now they run intervention and booster groups and yes, cover teacher absences but they are also a dying breed!

Wilkolampshade · 20/11/2021 17:13

@Drumshambo I can't speak for anyone else but I personally put up with it because I loved working with the children and as my DH worked away badly needed employment which fitted around school hours and there was bugger all locally that would do that. Conditions did get progressively worse though, ultimately quite shockingly bad and I left in the end after a really awful safeguarding case I was involved with absolutely broke my heart. Still miss the work and the children though (and can recite a worrying number of Biff and Chip books from memory).
I should have considered proper teacher training and was told by a Head that she would recommend me but lacked the confidence for it then.
I wholeheartedly agree with PP that if this were a male domain things would be VERY different.

SydneySquare · 20/11/2021 17:12

So many TA jobs advertised locally, more than I have ever seen. So many readvertised as they couldn't appoint. TA jobs, once upon a time, couldn't be found.

Certainly not a job people want to do anymore.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 20/11/2021 17:05

@StormyTeacups

Oh yes, and my hours don't cover getting everything sorted for intervention classes in the morning, dealing with whatever at lunchtime or after school.
Treated as teachers without the pay for it; grossly unfair. Which is why I no longer 'volunteer' my time. I arrive on the dot and leave on the dot. If it can't get done during school hours, I'm not longer willing to put my hand up.
Fleshmechanic · 20/11/2021 16:15

Doesn't surprise me that teachers are scarce these days. Shit pay, treated shittily during covid, overworked, unappreciated. Who would want that job.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 20/11/2021 16:11

@Drumshambo

Why on earth are teaching assistants putting up with this? Why dont they refuse to take lessons when they're not qualified to do so., Or paid a teacher's salary. If more refused, the greedy unscrupulous schools would be stuffed.
Maybe because they’ve already shouted. By when teachers or TS go on strike, they are the vilains.

If PARENTS were starting to refuse that sort of things, just like the OP is, maybe it would change.
I’d even go as far as saying, maybe if FATHERS were to start to grumble loud as clear, it would change.

StormyTeacups · 20/11/2021 15:40

Oh yes, and my hours don't cover getting everything sorted for intervention classes in the morning, dealing with whatever at lunchtime or after school.

StormyTeacups · 20/11/2021 15:39

I do similar at the moment. Work as a ta in the morning for 9.86 or similar, then an HLTA taking classes in the afternoon for 11 something. For a few months I was solely responsible for a class, which I wouldn't do again for 11 something. Even now I often turn up to classes to find no planning etc...as a parent this doesn't please me.

Drumshambo · 20/11/2021 14:48

Why on earth are teaching assistants putting up with this? Why dont they refuse to take lessons when they're not qualified to do so., Or paid a teacher's salary. If more refused, the greedy unscrupulous schools would be stuffed.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 20/11/2021 14:38

[quote Wilkolampshade]@Endoftether2000 re TA's pay, I was paid minimum rate (around £8.50 an hr) for mornings as whole class TA. Then slightly higher in the afternoon for 1-1, (around 8.75 I think?). That was around 10 years ago in Cornwall but it hasn't changed much. I covered for my teachers PPA one afternoon a week and in exceptional circumstances due to staff shortages and was paid the lower whole class rate whilst doing so.

Whilst I didn't have to plan I did mark according to schemes already in place and provide feedback. I was never paid a penny beyond my hours finishing after 3:15 p.m even when regularly required to stay later for numerous reasons. In fact one Head wanted to NOT pay me for the 15 minutes between my closing Breakfast Club and returning to class despite it being physically impossible to do this any quicker as I covered breakfast club alone and had to fold those bloody great dinner tables up and put them away, mop floor etc. I had to plan, deliver and record activities for small group literacy and numeracy interventions and did so, as did we all, but was never given any paid time nor any space to do so and usually had to sit in a busy corridor with my group.
@Abraxan is entirely correct in all details.[/quote]
I was working in an Academy chain like that: they've whacked their fulltime TAs' hours down to 25 hours per week, 3 in the morning and 2 in the afternoon, but still magically expecting work to get done/prepared/covered in the half hour before school starts, during the 'lunch unpaid' hour when classes are still in session when they go off the clock, and at the end of the day when school is still going and they're off the clock.

One of the reasons I left.

Complete abuse of low paid TAs' desire to be there for the children when too much is already expected of them.

If men filled these roles in great numbers, it wouldn't be happening. Much like Teachers, Nurses, Carers, etc are treated like their public service jobs are 'callings' because theyre women primarily, while male-dominated MPs demand more pay for their own public service jobs.

Wilkolampshade · 20/11/2021 14:14

@Endoftether2000 re TA's pay, I was paid minimum rate (around £8.50 an hr) for mornings as whole class TA. Then slightly higher in the afternoon for 1-1, (around 8.75 I think?). That was around 10 years ago in Cornwall but it hasn't changed much. I covered for my teachers PPA one afternoon a week and in exceptional circumstances due to staff shortages and was paid the lower whole class rate whilst doing so.

Whilst I didn't have to plan I did mark according to schemes already in place and provide feedback. I was never paid a penny beyond my hours finishing after 3:15 p.m even when regularly required to stay later for numerous reasons. In fact one Head wanted to NOT pay me for the 15 minutes between my closing Breakfast Club and returning to class despite it being physically impossible to do this any quicker as I covered breakfast club alone and had to fold those bloody great dinner tables up and put them away, mop floor etc. I had to plan, deliver and record activities for small group literacy and numeracy interventions and did so, as did we all, but was never given any paid time nor any space to do so and usually had to sit in a busy corridor with my group.
@Abraxan is entirely correct in all details.

Philandbill · 20/11/2021 12:59

@Jenster03 and @noblegiraffe well said. I also can't see this getting any better any time soon.

Needdoughnuts · 20/11/2021 11:48

With TAs teaching at primary, no interventions get done. TAs are then possibly teaching classes with groups of children who may not be able to access the lessons where as the teacher would have pitched the lessons differently as the groups would be elsewhere getting targeted help. The children have action plans which are thrown to the wayside, there is a knock on effect all round.

zingally · 20/11/2021 11:48

Yes, your DD SHOULD have a qualified teacher. But unfortunately there are massive issues in teaching right now with teacher working conditions and therefore retention/recruitment.

I'm a primary supply teacher, and since September have never been busier. With covid, everyone is dropping like flies, and with teachers going off with long-term issues such as stress, there just aren't enough supply teachers to go around.

Jenster03 · 20/11/2021 11:43

I'm a primary school teacher and I've read the entire thread. I'm not going to quote anyone in particular but the situation looks like this currently:

Covid is still having quite a dire impact and due to illness and isolation, we have a lot of supply teachers in. Our budget is in deficit already and it's only November.

Supply teachers are generally in quite short supply, even if there is money for it.

The Ofsted framework currently isn't fit for purpose for primary schools. They are expecting subject leaders (which in small schools teachers, even part time, can have several subjects to lead), to know the complete ins and outs of that subject and how it's taught. Teachers need time out of class for this, so heads are under pressure to use even more supply budget for this or Ofsted will knock us down.
Our TAs are having to cover here and there for this as well.

Ofsted are also being given more money to ramp up inspections, while schools are still grappling with covid.

Teachers and TAs are burned out. Pressure from subject leadership, having to still provide 'quality first' teaching.

Children now have so many more needs post covid. More children with SEND, social and emotional needs with limited budget to support this.

Teachers and TAs are having to deal with these problems and are having to support families much more, essentially doing the jobs of CAMHS and social services due to limited services.

Safeguarding is huge now. Every little thing has to be written up. Discipline is tricky as so much behaviour is down to needs that can't be easily supported, so teachers end up having to tip toe around kids rather than giving them a damn good bollocking.

This is why teachers are leaving, and I don't blame them. I'm part time and incredibly stressed, especially with the last point. I have a child who could easily cause me a lot of damage if he has an outburst, but even with a 1:1 because of his background there's only so much we can do for him. His issues stem from his home life.

It's about time people know the truth and yes, your child shouldn't be taught by a TA, but I'm sure schools are doing absolutely everything they can to prevent this, with probably quite limited resources. It's a shit situation for everyone, basically, and I can't see it getting much better anytime soon.

cansu · 20/11/2021 11:31

We have many of our TAs now teaching. It is poor practice. They have not been trained and it is fairly obvious. They are also stressed out by the whole thing.

noblegiraffe · 20/11/2021 11:14

I wonder if this ‘oh some TAs are wonderful, better than a qualified teacher’ attitude extends to secondary? Are posters similarly happy with their teen being taught maths by unqualified teachers, or teachers not qualified to teach maths? (This is also a massive issue).

There seems to be a perception of primary teaching as something that doesn’t require any pedagogical knowledge or skill, but simply being good with young kids, and that if you hand a TA a lesson plan, they’ll be able to teach it just fine. I thought that perception had disappeared over lockdown with parents crying ‘I’m not a teacher, I can’t do this’ when presented with work for one child.

I’m a secondary maths teacher, people regularly say ‘god I couldn’t do your job’, particularly as it involves teens. But I am in awe of my primary colleagues and their skills in establishing the foundations that I rely on in my teaching.

Drumshambo · 20/11/2021 11:10

I'm so glad I don't have any children in the education system any more. It seems to be getting steadily worse. My teacher friend worked in the French system (she is french) and can't believe how underfunded the system is in the uk. Also the lack of discipline in schools and the prevalence of disruptive behaviour largely ignored in schools here, left her horrified! She no longer teaches.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 20/11/2021 11:06

@007Stocko

Show's how much I know! I thought Teaching Assistants were there to support children in the class that maybe need that little bit of extra help to understand the lesson, and to support the teacher in preparing the class etc.

I didn't think that TA's were allowed to take a class on their own.

They're pressured constantly to 'cover' when teachers are off/out, doing PPA, etc ... and told there's no extra money to pay them for the additional responsibility. It's completely unethical and wrong and I know so many TAs are fed up with it and trying to stand firm and say no. But it's hard, because we care about the children, and the leadership teams rely on that to push for coverage without fair pay.
itsallgoingpearshaped · 20/11/2021 10:58

@saraclara

If you are happy for a TA to be teaching, what is the argument for requiring a graduate and QTS?

It's important to recognise that the TA is delivering the teachers work. If she or he was doing the planning, the resource marking and the assessing, then it would be entirely wrong, for them, for the kids and for teachers who've put all the work into training and qualifying.

But as I said before, when my TA took over in my absence, she taught from my planning and resources, she was given an extra TA from another class, and was supported by the other teachers in my department of five classes in the same corridor.

So she really wasn't doing 'my.job'. Valuable as she was, she was 'only' delivering my work and managing the class. And if there were any problems, the other teachers would step up with resources and share their planning with her.

Well, gee, by that standard, why doesn't one teacher 'plan' all the lessons for each year group, and then underpaid TAs can be deployed to teach all the classes and most teachers can be let go. Great for everyone ... oh wait.

Sucks for teachers, perpetually underpaid AND no longer needed in numbers.

Sucks for TAs, even more perpetually underpaid for what they're expected to do in a normal TA role, now being stressed over things they didn't sign up for.

Sucks for state school educated children, who aren't getting the education they deserve because the Tory government doesn't give a shit.

Sucks for parents because who do they talk to now about any of it?