Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
FrenchToasty · 21/11/2021 15:31

"many TAs are qualified teachers looking for better work life balance"

Are they though? I'd say that's a rarity. I've been working in primary schools for a long time (as a teacher and TA) and I haven't come across this army of "many" qualified teachers being TAs. People can't afford that wage drop unless they have a rich partner.

TAs are a mixed bag. Some have degrees, some are career changers trying to fit work around childcare, some were employed 20+ years ago to wash pots and sharpen pencils and there's no way they'd be employed now. They're the ones who sit in the staffroom moaning constantly and refusing to pitch in. You wouldn't want the latter to be in charge of a class.

jacks11 · 21/11/2021 15:31

I do find it very sad that our education system has come to this. It’s infuriating and tragic at the same time. But it is the consequence of years of mismanagement (not just funding issues)/political interference and theorists trying to reinvent the wheel, and I think problems in wider society related to lack of discipline/seeing education as important and so on.

I feel sorry for the good teachers, hamstrung by the system which wants carbon copy/“teach like this” rather than giving professionals the latitude to teach their own way (as long as meeting the required standards), all the whole eroding discipline and respect for teachers- I’m not surprised that so many have left. Reap what we sow, I suppose.

Homez · 21/11/2021 13:57

That’s not the inference at all. Yes the quality of TA is often better - in that it’s not the rarity often assumed. That doesn’t denigrate teachers overall? And let’s not forget, many TAs are qualified teachers looking for better work life balance. It’s still cheap labour - and schools are inevitably cutting costs where they can. Using a well educated, competent TA, (whether QTS or not) has proved to be far more successful for our school, as the quality of supply teachers, has often been hit & miss. Not to mention the added benefit of consistency for the children themselves.

Appuskidu · 21/11/2021 13:31

the quality of TA is often better than some who are qualified

‘Often’? Really?

If people have such a low opinion of teachers, why do we need them to have qualifications at all?

Homez · 21/11/2021 12:46

You’re right @Drumshambo - it is cheap labour, and is completely inappropriate for all concerned. However, as @Nikkibrad and others have said, the quality of TA is often better than some who are qualified, so schools will inevitably take advantage of that where they can. In my case, my school know they are getting a great deal for their money, and many parents have been hugely complimentary. I am educated to a high standard - have LLB, masters and BSc, as well as professional qualifications - and am proficient in their taught language - far more than most of the teachers at my school. So while I am mulling the logistics of cementing this career change with a PGCE, the school are inevitably utilising the benefit of their ‘cheap labour’. I am sole teacher for a class for the coming three weeks, as their regular class teacher, will be away on planned leave. I am sometimes allocated an occasional TA to help, and yes…as you’d expect with cheap labour, standards do very much vary!
State education, is very much on its knees. Sad but true.

Drumshambo · 21/11/2021 11:54

@Nikkibrad

In a couple of years at primary school my sons TAs were much better than the teachers.
That's not the point though! The quality of teachers coming through the system is a separate issue! There is no justification for schools using teaching assistants as cheap labour. It seems from a lot of posts on here, that is exactly what's happening.
ChloeDecker · 21/11/2021 11:53

@Drumshambo

No wonder British kids are the most poorly educated in europe!
No they are not

worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/most-educated-countries

Drumshambo · 21/11/2021 11:46

No wonder British kids are the most poorly educated in europe!

Penistoe · 21/11/2021 10:51

I wonder how many people who think this is unreasonable also have contributed to teacher bashing threads and moan about their holidays.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 21/11/2021 10:40

@motherrunner

Parents should also be aware that at secondary level their child’s teacher may be qualified but not qualifies in the subject they’re teaching. In my dept we have a non-specialist teaching my subject. He is given KS3 so less ‘damage’ is caused but his class aren’t getting the best deal. I’ve taught for 22 years and this has been a regular occurrence for the last 10 years as schools operate on a skeleton staff.
Yep. And then they are crap at it. Someone sent to teach french when they don’t speak the language doesn’t help. Even in the lower classes.
motherrunner · 21/11/2021 09:44

Parents should also be aware that at secondary level their child’s teacher may be qualified but not qualifies in the subject they’re teaching. In my dept we have a non-specialist teaching my subject. He is given KS3 so less ‘damage’ is caused but his class aren’t getting the best deal. I’ve taught for 22 years and this has been a regular occurrence for the last 10 years as schools operate on a skeleton staff.

Nikkibrad · 21/11/2021 09:28

In a couple of years at primary school my sons TAs were much better than the teachers.

Oblomov21 · 21/11/2021 09:20

This is so poor. Gove allowing our kids to not be taught by an actual qualified teacher.

bobisbored · 21/11/2021 08:55

YANBU
I am a HLTA and I'm allowed to cover classes for odd days of sickness/training etc. but if it's a long term absence TAs shouldn't be covering. I know a lot of TAs who are perfectly capable and would do a great job but they're not paid to take on that role!

Xtraincome · 21/11/2021 08:46

My DDs school struggles to find qualified supplies. It's the state of the system and it's been a long time in the making. Teachers don't want to teach and the industry isn't appealing to new recruits as the pay is appalling and expectations are insanely high- it's exhausting!! I don't have any advice but just grin and bear it. The school system is no longer fit for purpose.

RamsayBoltonsConscience · 21/11/2021 08:35

That should say 11 absences per day not per week.

RamsayBoltonsConscience · 21/11/2021 08:31

@nohouseyet

It makes my blood boil to think of qualified teachers sitting in offices raking in huge salaries in education management while the goods aren’t being delivered on the shop floor. Grr!
HA! HA! HA! HA! if you think this is the case, you live in cloud cuckoo land! At the moment, with absences, we have on average 11 members of staff missing per week. One member of our teaching staff died before half term. We are a big primary school, 30 classes and over 130 members of staff but every possible spare person is being used. We have a maternity leave coming up and have advertised the job 3 times but applicants are thin on the ground or very poor quality. It takes everything that the head teacher and I have to keep the school running. Both of us would love to teach but there aren't enough hours in the day. I find your comment incredibly ignorant but probably shouldn't surprised. (And if you think that 'rake in a huge salary' you are sadly mistaken.

In reference to the OP, you will probably find that the school have made the difficult decision to keep the good TA with the class (who has a proven track record of being able to give the children a good standard of education) rather than appoint a less than satisfactory teacher. It's incredibly difficult to get good candidates at this time of the year.

Homez · 21/11/2021 07:58

@toomanypillows - yes completely agree.
Having QTS, does not necessarily mean you are a great teacher, nor does it mean you are expert in your field!
Particularly with primary. At my large primary, I am the only member of staff who has maths beyond A level, most only have it to GCSE, including the subject lead! And I’m the only member of staff in my phase, who can teach or speak any semblance of french. Many teachers are young newly qualified, or doing placement years. Sometimes their subject knowledge falls way short of what I would expect. Some of the better ‘teachers’ I’ve seen, are those who have had previous careers and interesting life experiences. I travelled extensively with my previous career, and the children love asking questions about some of the countries I have visited. One teacher I helped cover for, was asked by a child during one lesson, where Burma was, but couldn’t answer….and she was subject lead for Humanities!

toomanypillows · 20/11/2021 23:36

It's quite nuanced this, though.
I work in a school, emoyed as support staff (pastoral role) I'm not a qualified teacher, in that I didn't complete a pgce year. Over the 18 years I've worked in schools, I've formally taught for 10 of them as I am a subject specialist - way more knowledgeable in my area than most of the teachers.
I currently teach 6 periods a week and I am a form tutor. I'm "unqualified" and don't earn what teachers earn but I am hugely experienced and have a post grad and a doctorate in my field of expertise.

A parent discovered I was "unqualified" and wrote to the governors about it, despite my class's results over the last several years. School had to do some placating for sure.
However I still teach, I save the school money and though they've offered to send me on a pgce, I don't want to, as then I will be seconded as a proper teacher and have to give up the bits of my job I love.
It's not always a good/bad issue. Some TAs are way better than some teachers.

Appuskidu · 20/11/2021 23:04

@Murdoch1949

Didn't realise state schools could now have unqualified teachers I/c of classes. What a dire situation we are in. I would be writing to the head, the chair of governors, the chair of the LEA education committee. You may get platitudes back but you'll have registered your unhappiness unhappiness. I'd also contact the local teachers' trade union to seek their views. Then I'd write to the local paper, make it uncomfortable for this school to continue doing a disservice to the children.
All of those people know it’s a shit situation already but there is no money and no supply.

You’d be best off writing to your MP.

Murdoch1949 · 20/11/2021 22:56

Didn't realise state schools could now have unqualified teachers I/c of classes. What a dire situation we are in. I would be writing to the head, the chair of governors, the chair of the LEA education committee. You may get platitudes back but you'll have registered your unhappiness unhappiness. I'd also contact the local teachers' trade union to seek their views. Then I'd write to the local paper, make it uncomfortable for this school to continue doing a disservice to the children.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 20/11/2021 22:55

[quote madroid]**@Philandbill* What do you suggest teachers do other than vote with their feet and leave education?*

I suggest teachers do what exploited labour force has always done - unite and strike.

While parents and teachers pull back from this the employers take advantage (and aren't they just and have taken for years).

Teachers need to start a campaign to tell parents they are going to strike for the sake of their children's education. Then do it. Go on strike until hours, wages and conditions are addressed properly. Permanent and total strike until it's sorted once and for all.

It would definitely work. And then the govt would know that they couldn't fuck around with schools and teachers anymore.[/quote]
Teachers going on strike has never been favourably received by the public. they don't care about teachers' pay and conditions; they only care that strikes interferes with parents' jobs when their children can't go to school and their children's education (though so many don't support teachers when their children don't behave in school, I highly doubt that these days).

And to strike now, after so many weeks/months of missed school due to covid, and continuing weeks off due to covid here and there, there is ZERO chance that the public would support teachers going on strike now.

monkeysox · 20/11/2021 22:12

Some schools have made TAs redundant and teachers are wholly responsible for meeting the needs of SEND students. Fucking shocking state of affairs.

Thisislifefornow · 20/11/2021 21:52

I've worked with many TAs that can deliver a lesson far better than some teachers. A qualification does not guarantee you child will learn better. As long as planning is being set by the teacher they should be no problem at all. The school will have every faith in that TA or they wouldn't do it .

saraclara · 20/11/2021 21:45

Teachers need to start a campaign to tell parents they are going to strike for the sake of their children's education. Then do it. Go on strike until hours, wages and conditions are addressed properly. Permanent and total strike until it's sorted once and for all.

It would definitely work. And then the govt would know that they couldn't fuck around with schools and teachers anymore.

What planet are you on @madroid? Do you have any recollection of the times over the last decade or two when teachers have gone on strike? We had NO public support whatsoever. None. It's absolutely pointless and the govt doesn't shift an inch. I fact they use it to slate and punish us even more.

It would definitely work

Seriously, that's laughable. You don't have a clue.