Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 22/11/2021 14:56

They could close the class. Send the kids home and say "sorry, no teacher today."

That might concentrate the minds of the government a bit if it happened every time there wasn't a qualified teacher for a class. Parents would finally be in uproar.

Meandmini3 · 22/11/2021 14:54

Complain loudly to your MP! Schools are woefully underfunded.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 22/11/2021 14:45

To be fair to the school, if there is literally no money left, what do they do? Turn off the heating? Our kids school has been crippled by sickness and cover during the pandemic. I think it's totally unacceptable and I'd guess the SLT probably think so too, but the complaint should really land at the government's door for the extreme, extreme real world budget cuts schools have faced.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 22/11/2021 14:36

@Benjispruce5

I’m covering a sick teacher this week. I’m a HLTA. The teacher has planned the lesson so I’m only doing the tip of the iceberg so to speak, by delivering the lesson. The teacher has responsibility of planning, differentiating, marking and planning next steps. Plus subject leads. staff meetings, parent’s evenings, sports events etc.I go home at 3.30pm.Smile
It's also very different from what the OP is talking about.

There will be no teacher to prepare the lessons and do the planning there (And I have to say I am not sure how you can expect a teacher who is ILL to have the planning and lessons ready either tbh... I hope no one is expecting said teacher to work during their sick leave!).

This will go on for months - not a week or so whilst the teacher is ill.

etc...

Needdoughnuts · 22/11/2021 13:43

@Benjispruce5

I’m covering a sick teacher this week. I’m a HLTA. The teacher has planned the lesson so I’m only doing the tip of the iceberg so to speak, by delivering the lesson. The teacher has responsibility of planning, differentiating, marking and planning next steps. Plus subject leads. staff meetings, parent’s evenings, sports events etc.I go home at 3.30pm.Smile
It might seem like a walk in the park compared to what the teacher would do but it's only the same as what supply would do but they would get double your daily rate! I understand some schools are living on air at the moment but there has got to be a middle ground between supply rates and taking the piss.
Benjispruce5 · 22/11/2021 12:21

I’m covering a sick teacher this week. I’m a HLTA. The teacher has planned the lesson so I’m only doing the tip of the iceberg so to speak, by delivering the lesson. The teacher has responsibility of planning, differentiating, marking and planning next steps. Plus subject leads. staff meetings, parent’s evenings, sports events etc.I go home at 3.30pm.Smile

Abraxan · 22/11/2021 12:13

@noblegiraffe

So TAs should be allowed to teach classes while working as a TA because some of them are qualified to do so?

If they’re qualified to teach and they’re teaching, then they are being a teacher not a TA and should be paid as such. If they’re not qualified to teach, then they shouldn’t be teaching but should stick to TAing.

The main reason I chose to teach as a hlta rather than a teacher is that I have less mandatory responsibilities. I don't have report writing and parents evenings for example. If I want to I can walk away at 3:30pm and do nothing all weekend or evening.

I've also developed my role into quite a unique one based on my interests and skills. I enjoy it.

Abraxan · 22/11/2021 12:10

Some of the ta' who've posted on here are letting themselves be used by schools without even objecting.in fact, I get the impression some.of them.get a sense of importance because they are doing the job of a teacher. I find that a bit pathetic tbh. They are being paid .minimum wage and generally treated like shit! You'd get paid more and given more respect working in tesco.

I know that I teach much more than I technically ought to as a HLTA and that I do go over and above, by far. I know I could earn far more if I returned to teaching proper or even work in another sector.

However, I work because I choose to. I'm fortunate that I have a choice as to whether I work or not to an extent. I enjoy my job. I get a great sense of job satisfaction with my job and enjoy doing some of the extra stuff as it's an interest of mine.

It's nothing to do with having a sense of importance whatsoever. It's a choice and I only do what I choose generally. If I objected to teaching classes to the extent I do I would say something, but I choose to do it. Not because it makes me feel important, but because I enjoy it!

My school is incredibly supporting and we have a wonderful group of staff. Our staff room is a lovely place to be and we genuinely look out for one another. Our management team is fair and genuinely care and support staff.

I could give up working if I really wanted to, but at the moment I do it through choice and because I want to. I don't think that's a pathetic reason to do what I do.

laudete · 22/11/2021 09:37

@pokemeinthemorning

I have no idea if she is qualified. I am a L3 TA myself but wouldn't be happy teaching on a long term basis.

It's a LA maintained school not a free or an academy.

I'd guess she is a HLTA. I'd also guess there is no money left in this year's budget to hire supply teachers. Perhaps, you could discretely look her up on LinkedIn?
Wilkolampshade · 22/11/2021 09:15

@MrsHamlet yes, this! I remember being horrified when I found out. We only had one HLTA at our school and when I looked at the huge extra responsibility and massively increased workload it was clearly not worth it.

MrsHamlet · 22/11/2021 06:48

@RamsayBoltonsConscience

I don't know about other schools but whenever a HLTA has been asked to teach a class long term (as in with the roles and responsibilities of a teacher rather than just cover) in our school, they get unqualified teacher pay.
UQT pay is on a scale. When this happened to a colleague, it worked out at a little over a pound a lesson.
Wilkolampshade · 21/11/2021 23:03

It's all pretty grim for sure. Which is, in part, why I left.
But in areas of limited employment opportunities, low parental involvement and generally poor educational outcomes its really not suprising schools get away with it.
Still miss the kids tho.

Homez · 21/11/2021 22:52

@Drumshambo - yes, and you are quite right. It does seem crazy. But I think this ridiculous scenario, has been a consequence of two halves. On the one hand, there are the TAs with minimal qualification, and little else they can do. We have a few - some like a previous poster said, have been there for years, and were more accustomed to washing pots and little more. And then there are those who are better educated, but desperately keen to gain an in-depth insight into life in the classroom…before they take the plunge to something more. Quite a few of our qualified teachers, worked as TAs before they trained. And they all agree, they are grossly underpaid, and often overused. But if you don’t comply..you might not get that reference..or a placement to train if being offered. There’s usually more at stake, than the peanuts being paid.

Drumshambo · 21/11/2021 21:30

@Homez

“Some of the ta' who've posted on here are letting themselves be used by schools without even objecting.in fact, I get the impression some.of them.get a sense of importance because they are doing the job of a teacher.” Seriously?? I didn’t feel a ‘sense of importance’ when managing a global department on a six figure salary, so I certainly don’t feel it now. What I do feel, is a sense of fulfilment and enthusiasm for what I do. Simple as that. ‘Teachers’ who feel this way…really need to get off their hilariously funny high horse…Grin
I"m not a teacher. Couldn't think of anything worse than being around children all day tbh. I also have no children in the education system now, so I have no skin in the game, so to speak. I'm simply making the observation that schools are very obviously exploiting support staff and putting pressure on them to take classes and generally do stuff they are not employed to do, and more importantly not paid to do. I'm just astonished that they are so reluctant to stand up for themselves and are so ready to comply.
Homez · 21/11/2021 21:08

“Some of the ta' who've posted on here are letting themselves be used by schools without even objecting.in fact, I get the impression some.of them.get a sense of importance because they are doing the job of a teacher.”
Seriously??
I didn’t feel a ‘sense of importance’ when managing a global department on a six figure salary, so I certainly don’t feel it now. What I do feel, is a sense of fulfilment and enthusiasm for what I do. Simple as that.
‘Teachers’ who feel this way…really need to get off their hilariously funny high horse…Grin

TheHateIsNotGood · 21/11/2021 21:06

There is a great imbalance in the salaries/wages and T&Cs of those employed in Education - many don't even teach - ie: the LEA employed staff who are paid just to administrate, share out the funding pie and take a very large slice of the pie before any services are delivered.

My ex-HOD DM got herself a mighty-fine appointment post-retirement in a small LEA SEN Unit to fend off any retirement 'blues'.

Apparently, "Gail" the Manager, felt it essential that all staff should take part in an Annual 3-day Bonding Event at The Grand Hotel in Brighton.

Surrey County Council around 2005.

FrippEnos · 21/11/2021 21:02

@RamsayBoltonsConscience

I don't know about other schools but whenever a HLTA has been asked to teach a class long term (as in with the roles and responsibilities of a teacher rather than just cover) in our school, they get unqualified teacher pay.
My school used to do this, but all HLTAs are now instructors and paid on that (poor) scale.
RamsayBoltonsConscience · 21/11/2021 20:53

I don't know about other schools but whenever a HLTA has been asked to teach a class long term (as in with the roles and responsibilities of a teacher rather than just cover) in our school, they get unqualified teacher pay.

Wilkolampshade · 21/11/2021 20:49

I can answer the many PP's who ask why TA's just don't refuse to do things etc... There were hardly any permanent contracts for TA's when I did it, a decade ago. As 1-1 need and funding change all the time contracts were often VERY temporary. If my 1-1 left the school, for example, there go my hours... It wasn't unusual to start a term with no actual contract as no one had bothered renewing it OR to find term by term, your hours could be slashed - I was genuinely offered 1 hr a week at one point. When they ask in a crisis if you can 'just help out today' it was usually by the same person who decided hrs and placements for the next term and they made it very clear how being 'flexible' and a 'team player' was important. The pressure was immense. TA's were rarely unionised, where I worked anyway.

Drumshambo · 21/11/2021 20:37

@noblegiraffe

So TAs should be allowed to teach classes while working as a TA because some of them are qualified to do so?

If they’re qualified to teach and they’re teaching, then they are being a teacher not a TA and should be paid as such. If they’re not qualified to teach, then they shouldn’t be teaching but should stick to TAing.

Yes, nobody has answered this! Some of the ta' who've posted on here are letting themselves be used by schools without even objecting.in fact, I get the impression some.of them.get a sense of importance because they are doing the job of a teacher. I find that a bit pathetic tbh. They are being paid .minimum wage and generally treated like shit! You'd get paid more and given more respect working in tesco.
noblegiraffe · 21/11/2021 20:10

So TAs should be allowed to teach classes while working as a TA because some of them are qualified to do so?

If they’re qualified to teach and they’re teaching, then they are being a teacher not a TA and should be paid as such. If they’re not qualified to teach, then they shouldn’t be teaching but should stick to TAing.

Abraxan · 21/11/2021 16:53

@FrenchToasty

"many TAs are qualified teachers looking for better work life balance"

Are they though? I'd say that's a rarity. I've been working in primary schools for a long time (as a teacher and TA) and I haven't come across this army of "many" qualified teachers being TAs. People can't afford that wage drop unless they have a rich partner.

TAs are a mixed bag. Some have degrees, some are career changers trying to fit work around childcare, some were employed 20+ years ago to wash pots and sharpen pencils and there's no way they'd be employed now. They're the ones who sit in the staffroom moaning constantly and refusing to pitch in. You wouldn't want the latter to be in charge of a class.

It's not that unusual in my experience.

I am a qualified teacher working as a HLTA. Yes I took a huge drop in wage to do so.

But I'm definitely not alone, nor unique.

Of the teachers who we employed as TAs at my school, and of those who have applied for Ta roles they been predominately women and from these main groups:

  • older teachers coming towards the end of their teaching careers
  • women who have recently had children or have younger children
  • young people who have just qualified but won't to get more experience before deciding which area/phase they want to apply for
ADayintheOffice · 21/11/2021 16:25

I work in primary school recruitment and the situation is dire. We cannot recruit. We don't get enough quality applications and we can hardly get supply. With sickness and COVID cases on the rise it is an almost impossible situation.

Education is underfunded and bruised from the last 2 years. We are pretty much on our knees.

Your daughter does deserve a qualified teacher but I doubt the school is to blame. Sad but true!

SydneySquare · 21/11/2021 16:12

Teacher strikes are not the way forward.

Parents on the other hand...contact everyone possible to raise the issue of the poor state of the education system. Find out about budget cuts, staff morale and OFSTED pressures. This affects your children.

Support teachers, turn the tide on the media. Teachers really do want your child to be the best they can be.

Read up on the academy programme and respond before the education system has all democratic processes removed.

Find out about Local Authority budget cuts by central government, the loss of external support services (SEN provision, family help through children's centres, cuts to social care). Schools are picking up so many pieces.

Contact your MP's. Demand answers. Stop voting Tory.

Philandbill · 21/11/2021 15:37

@FrenchToasty so true!