Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 23:20

@RosesAndHellebores

My dd with a high 2:1 from Cambridge is presently working as a TA to see if she wants to teach. SEN specifically. The school have offered her a permanent contract and funding to qualify.

When my DC were at primary SEN and TA responsibilities were delivered by the dinner ladies. Somehow I think things may be improving.

That's nice but you and I know it is not the norm!
OP posts:
BonnesVacances · 18/11/2021 23:19

YANBU. Yes your DD deserves a qualified teacher. But when teachers are told just leave if they don't like the current working conditions, this is the consequence. Not enough teachers to teach our DC. We can't magic them out of the air, so we have lovely TAs to step in and teach for less money than a qualified teacher.

Appuskidu · 18/11/2021 23:17

@Needdoughnuts

Most TAs I know don't have a degree. In fact some have no paper qualifications at all, just an equivalency in Maths and English. Their training is in supporting teaching and learning not actual teaching and while some teach admirably and enjoy it IT'S NOT THEIR JOB!!
Same as us. Not one of our TAs have a degree. Most were employed 20+ years ago when their own children were at the school. They may have a handful of O levels (very few have maths) and training done at school in recent years but nothing higher than O level. They are amazing at their jobs, but they aren’t, and shouldn’t be expected to be, teachers.
RosesAndHellebores · 18/11/2021 23:15

My dd with a high 2:1 from Cambridge is presently working as a TA to see if she wants to teach. SEN specifically. The school have offered her a permanent contract and funding to qualify.

When my DC were at primary SEN and TA responsibilities were delivered by the dinner ladies. Somehow I think things may be improving.

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 23:09

@Needdoughnuts

Most TAs I know don't have a degree. In fact some have no paper qualifications at all, just an equivalency in Maths and English. Their training is in supporting teaching and learning not actual teaching and while some teach admirably and enjoy it IT'S NOT THEIR JOB!!
This!

And many older TAs are still there from years ago with no qualifications still on their permanent contracts. The best we get now is 9 months or agency with zero security.

OP posts:
Platax · 18/11/2021 23:07

Write to the Head and the Chair of Governors asking them to clarify the situation, as TAs aren't allowed to be class teachers in state maintained schools.

Needdoughnuts · 18/11/2021 23:06

Most TAs I know don't have a degree. In fact some have no paper qualifications at all, just an equivalency in Maths and English. Their training is in supporting teaching and learning not actual teaching and while some teach admirably and enjoy it IT'S NOT THEIR JOB!!

BungleandGeorge · 18/11/2021 23:05

I presume that pre 2012 it was permissible to have sessions taught by those without qualified teacher status? Or did there need to be a teacher present 100% of the time?

noblegiraffe · 18/11/2021 23:05

[quote CallmeHendricks]@noblegiraffe, Who knew that could possibly happen?![/quote]
One of the great things about never name changing…

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?
Penyu · 18/11/2021 23:02

You are definitely not being unreasonable.
This is happening all over England.

Blame multi academy trusts (employing 'tutors' cheaply and a chronic lack of money. Also, for some reason it is really hard to get supply teachers at all, qualified or not.

I found that the school I taught in had about 30% unqualified staff, and this had a huge knock on effect with behaviour management, workload for the qualified teachers, parent complaints etc etc etc
It was a nightmare.
The MAT model seems to be the preferred model going forward, I can't believe it's been allowed to happen.

So many parents don't realise their child's teacher may be unqualified, it's scary. Schools are obviously not advertising it.

Not the case in other countries in the UK though.

CallmeHendricks · 18/11/2021 22:58

@noblegiraffe, Who knew that could possibly happen?!

Appuskidu · 18/11/2021 22:58

@noblegiraffe

No, fifth, unqualified teachers wasn’t part of the Labour academies program. It was Michael Gove in 2012 who gave schools the freedom to hire unqualified teachers.

The idea was that some amazing engineer/physicist who could already teach was desperate to work in state schools but was being put off by the need to do teacher training. This gave heads the power to hire them.

What actually happened was that we ended up with heads hiring anyone with a pulse to have a warm body in front of the kids instead of having to send them home due to no teacher.

Which I think we all predicted would be the case at the time!
pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 22:57

come*

OP posts:
pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 22:57

@Sowhatifiam

It's only one year of formal training (school or uni based) that separates a 'qualified' teacher from a TA

That might be true in some cases, but certainly not in all. Many TAs don’t have degrees.

I'd say the majority don't. Many have just comes out of school.
OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 18/11/2021 22:55

No, fifth, unqualified teachers wasn’t part of the Labour academies program. It was Michael Gove in 2012 who gave schools the freedom to hire unqualified teachers.

The idea was that some amazing engineer/physicist who could already teach was desperate to work in state schools but was being put off by the need to do teacher training. This gave heads the power to hire them.

What actually happened was that we ended up with heads hiring anyone with a pulse to have a warm body in front of the kids instead of having to send them home due to no teacher.

Needdoughnuts · 18/11/2021 22:55

Can't believe there's someone on this thread actually blaming Labour for this shitshow.

Sowhatifiam · 18/11/2021 22:54

It's only one year of formal training (school or uni based) that separates a 'qualified' teacher from a TA

That might be true in some cases, but certainly not in all. Many TAs don’t have degrees.

Appuskidu · 18/11/2021 22:53

Surely this happened under the previous Labour Government, which set up the first Academies?

www.theguardian.com/education/2012/jul/27/gove-academies-unqualified-teaching-staff

nohouseyet · 18/11/2021 22:51

@MainRd

Gosh! Well then I’d suggest a very very strongly worded letter to the LA. They should be supporting the schools, a) keeping oversight of their budgeting and b) divvying out more money when it is needed. They will have to find it from elsewhere- send in an advisory teacher to cover, for example.

@nohouseyet
So much misinformation.
LA's do support maintained schools and academies under statutory duties.
They do have oversight of school budgets, governing boards cannot legally run with a deficit, licensed deficits and in serious cases LA control of budgets are in place.

'Divvy out more money' - brilliant - from where? - given the huge Tory cuts to Local Authority's. In my LA, 2 out of every 3 schools have a licensed deficit. ( not enough money to run the school).

'Send in an advisory teacher' - again who? Restructured out to save money. Senior advisers are cut to the bone too and have statutory duties to fulfil.

I agree all children should be entitled long term to a qualified teacher, however that right is being eroded. Academies do not have to have a qualified teacher, though neither do private schools.

Locally schools are reverting to online through a shortage of teachers.

@MainRd I am ready to admit that I don’t know how academies operate. If LAs do in fact have oversight of how they spend their money … well, what can I say? I am 100% in agreement with you that the funding of education is shambolic.

I take exception to your sweeping accusation of misinformation however. My suggestion was that finance be found by schools by sending non-teaching management staff back to teach in the classroom. This is something I know about: I am a deputy headteacher.
There are also advisory teachers where I work: I am married to one.
So just because my view doesn’t match your experience, does not make it misinformation.

GinGinItsAWonderfulThing · 18/11/2021 22:50

A lot of TAs are brilliant and better than some supply teachers. But I understand your concerns. Raise them with the head and hopefully they’ll be able to reassure/confirm the TAs ability. X

Fifthtimelucky · 18/11/2021 22:49

@noblegiraffe

Michael Gove took away children's right to a qualified teacher.
Surely this happened under the previous Labour Government, which set up the first Academies?
pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 22:49

@beatrice82

I'm a TA. I'm also a qualified teacher from days gone by so I'd be fine teaching the class... the year team will be supporting with the planning aspect.
And happy to be on a TA salary or do you get a teacher's salary and PPA?
OP posts:
pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 22:46

@Needdoughnuts

For £9.60 an hour TAs in my school teach whenever they are asked, sometimes for weeks on end, plan, deliver, mark, assess. No overtime and no TA to assist. If you say no you are busted down a level but even then they still ask! Bear in mind the TA may only have a few weeks of working in a school under his or her belt and have no proven strategy for classroom management or lesson delivery because you can gain a level 3 qualification just by volunteering a couple of times a week! So not necessarily an ex-teacher or experienced TA. In the old days if you were asked to take a class for the afternoon there would either be time off in lieu or extra pay. This is not fair on TAs and I wish parents would kick up a stink. It doesn't matter if the TA is an ex-teacher, they will still be on the TA salary. Definitely exploitative and it also devalues the teaching profession itself!
This is shocking and the reason why I'm concerned. There is quite a lot of studying to do for L3 but very little practical experience required. I don't recall doing much, if anything, on classroom management. It's all focused on supporting not leading.

I have a degree and quite a few years experience in schools but I am weak in maths and avoid placements in secondary because of this. I know my limits. I am not qualified to take a class, I am qualified to support.

OP posts:
friedeggandsauce · 18/11/2021 22:46

[quote Appuskidu]**@Appuskidu maybe it depends on authorities as the course is still run here, I know someone doing it

Sorry, my error and I phrased that poorly-courses may still be run in some areas (not mine), but they aren’t government funded and there’s no requirement to have the qualification, to be employed as one in a school. We have nobody who had done the course but still have people called HLTAs in my school. They are just used as pitifully cheap cover, under the guise of being ‘Higher Level’. They aren’t.[/quote]
@Appuskidu oh I understand, I agree, teaching on the cheap.

Appuskidu · 18/11/2021 22:43

@Appuskidu maybe it depends on authorities as the course is still run here, I know someone doing it

Sorry, my error and I phrased that poorly-courses may still be run in some areas (not mine), but they aren’t government funded and there’s no requirement to have the qualification, to be employed as one in a school. We have nobody who had done the course but still have people called HLTAs in my school. They are just used as pitifully cheap cover, under the guise of being ‘Higher Level’. They aren’t.