Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

....to think my daughter's class has a right to a qualified teacher?

466 replies

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 20:16

So we had a message tonight on the system to explain what is happening in my daughter's year 5 class. Apparently, their teacher will now be teaching another class because one teacher left two weeks ago and they have said they have 'dispensed of any supply staff'. Basically the TA will be teaching the class for the foreseeable future.
I know there are many dedicated and wonderful TA's who could make great teachers BUT we are not qualified to teach classes on a regular basis.
On questioning my daughter I found out that from the start of this year she has her teacher in class 2 days a week and the rest is taken on by the TA. We were not told about this.
As a TA myself, I know that they often cover classes but this is on a regular basis for a prolonged period of time.

I feel that this is very unfair and they should at least be employing supply teachers in the meantime.

OP posts:
Ozanj · 19/11/2021 14:22

@jgw1

DN’s future secondary school does have some excellent TAs for maths, science, and engineering - mostly Indian grads who live locally and are waiting to start their masters. Her primary is also full of highly experienced teachers from India who work as TAs instead of qualifying because it fits in with family life. It’s part of the reason why, despite there being a teacher shortage, every single primary and secondary school in all of the local Indian areas is outstanding.

These are the right kind of immigrants, quite unlike those from the European Union, or people so desperate they would get in a rubber dinghy to cross the channel.
We need more of this sort of immigrant, the kind that will happily do skilled work for a fraction of the cost of a British worker, thus saving the government money which could be better spaffed on pointless white elephants and the mates of ministers.

Blame the UK government for not recognising certain Indian teaching qualifications. It must be awful for them too, to have 10 years experience in class sizes of 30-50 where the majority not only passed their exams they got over 90%, to then get demoted to a TA for a ‘qualified teacher’ who has 2-3 years experience and gets all the credit for their work.
PerfectlyUnsuitable · 19/11/2021 14:20

Nan
The TA will end up doing it all because there is no way a teacher can do their job AND do all the prep and planning fur another class.

Tal45 · 19/11/2021 14:17

The difference will be that the TA won't be doing any of the planning, the teacher will be planning and the TA implementing. How good is the TA? Some are fantastic and I wouldn't have a problem with it but plenty of others it wouldn't work at all with. It's not ideal IMO but an experienced TA in some cases can be better at delivering the curriculum than a newly qualified teacher.

jgw1 · 19/11/2021 14:10

DN’s future secondary school does have some excellent TAs for maths, science, and engineering - mostly Indian grads who live locally and are waiting to start their masters. Her primary is also full of highly experienced teachers from India who work as TAs instead of qualifying because it fits in with family life. It’s part of the reason why, despite there being a teacher shortage, every single primary and secondary school in all of the local Indian areas is outstanding.

These are the right kind of immigrants, quite unlike those from the European Union, or people so desperate they would get in a rubber dinghy to cross the channel.
We need more of this sort of immigrant, the kind that will happily do skilled work for a fraction of the cost of a British worker, thus saving the government money which could be better spaffed on pointless white elephants and the mates of ministers.

Ozanj · 19/11/2021 12:09

@noblegiraffe

No, fifth, unqualified teachers wasn’t part of the Labour academies program. It was Michael Gove in 2012 who gave schools the freedom to hire unqualified teachers.

The idea was that some amazing engineer/physicist who could already teach was desperate to work in state schools but was being put off by the need to do teacher training. This gave heads the power to hire them.

What actually happened was that we ended up with heads hiring anyone with a pulse to have a warm body in front of the kids instead of having to send them home due to no teacher.

DN’s future secondary school does have some excellent TAs for maths, science, and engineering - mostly Indian grads who live locally and are waiting to start their masters. Her primary is also full of highly experienced teachers from India who work as TAs instead of qualifying because it fits in with family life. It’s part of the reason why, despite there being a teacher shortage, every single primary and secondary school in all of the local Indian areas is outstanding.
Fifthtimelucky · 19/11/2021 10:25

The only schools I have ever seen that list staff qualifications have been private ones - presumably because they want to make clear that they have qualified staff even though they don't need to.

Appuskidu · 19/11/2021 10:09

@84wood

Responding to a point - how do you know teacher qualifications? A decent school website should list qualifications. I’d ask if there is no information.
I have never worked in a school which has listed staff qualifications on the website!
AudacityBaby · 19/11/2021 09:57

Feels a bit like a chickens coming home to roost situation unfortunately. I saw so many threads during the pandemic where posters were adamant that schools had to stay open because education took priority over the health of the staff. It was pointed out that schools can't run if the teachers get ill or leave because they don't want to work in a petri dish. It was pointed out that you can't force a person to be a teacher if they don't want to be.

And here we are. This is the reality. If teachers can't be recruited, then I understand why. I have every sympathy because children need and deserve an education, but that means treating the educators with respect rather than looking at them as people who should be conscripted.

monkeysox · 19/11/2021 07:50

Search cover supervisor vacancies.
I know a state secondary which had 7 supply staff yesterday.

Vacancies for teachers are advertised and cannot be filled.

There are some amazing unqualified teachers but these are experienced and effective. This has to be true or everyone with DC in private would be going mad as private schools have employed unqualified teachers for years.

FrippEnos · 19/11/2021 07:01

NovemberWitch

Don't forget all the failed bankers that were encouraged to join the teaching ranks.

MrsHamlet · 19/11/2021 07:00

@84wood

Responding to a point - how do you know teacher qualifications? A decent school website should list qualifications. I’d ask if there is no information.
Why should it?
84wood · 19/11/2021 06:59

Responding to a point - how do you know teacher qualifications? A decent school website should list qualifications. I’d ask if there is no information.

Valeriekat · 19/11/2021 03:47

There is a massive teacher shortage because no-one can work 16 hour days.

waitingpatientlyforspring · 19/11/2021 00:07

@pokemeinthemorning

Then why have they not recruited since September? Clearly there are not enough teachers for the classes.
It depends why there is a vacancy. If the teacher is on long term sick and not covered by insurance or insurance doesn't cover enough then the budget might not allow a proper replacement. If it's short term they just might not have found anyone suitable.
Fifthtimelucky · 19/11/2021 00:06

People have been able to work as unqualified teachers for years though haven't they in certain circumstances? My mother in law was employed as an unqualified teacher for years in the 1970s.

Fifthtimelucky · 19/11/2021 00:03

@noblegiraffe

No, fifth, unqualified teachers wasn’t part of the Labour academies program. It was Michael Gove in 2012 who gave schools the freedom to hire unqualified teachers.

The idea was that some amazing engineer/physicist who could already teach was desperate to work in state schools but was being put off by the need to do teacher training. This gave heads the power to hire them.

What actually happened was that we ended up with heads hiring anyone with a pulse to have a warm body in front of the kids instead of having to send them home due to no teacher.

Apologies. I stand corrected. I'd forgotten that.
Almostmenopausal · 18/11/2021 23:54

@helterskelter3

Anyone saying about management sat doing nothing really needs to spend some time in a school. My friend is a deputy head and is full time DSL, working in child protection. No time to go in class when you’re constantly in CiN meetings, supporting families etc. Schools are plugging the social services gap too…

Another source of chronic underfunding.

My daughter's teacher is also the deputy head! A veritable Octopus 🐙
noblegiraffe · 18/11/2021 23:54

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/secondary/2554784-Only-32-Troops-to-Teachers

Thanks, past me. 32 to be precise.

Still, that’s way more than applied for Boris’s Christmas HGV visas so they probably think the program was a roaring success.

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 23:53

@CallmeHendricks

Well yes. But some people could ease up on the teacher-bashing as well. That would help a lot.
Teacher bashing has probably contributed to the problem. I'm not bashing teachers, I'm annoyed that they are not teaching my children in the way I was led to believe because I DO value teachers! This is not the teachers' fault and I can understand why so many are leaving but something needs to be done.
OP posts:
CallmeHendricks · 18/11/2021 23:50

"I think it resulted in a few tens of candidates,"

That many?! Grin

NovemberWitch · 18/11/2021 23:48

@noblegiraffe

No, fifth, unqualified teachers wasn’t part of the Labour academies program. It was Michael Gove in 2012 who gave schools the freedom to hire unqualified teachers.

The idea was that some amazing engineer/physicist who could already teach was desperate to work in state schools but was being put off by the need to do teacher training. This gave heads the power to hire them.

What actually happened was that we ended up with heads hiring anyone with a pulse to have a warm body in front of the kids instead of having to send them home due to no teacher.

As a class teacher way back, I remember waiting hopefully for the platoons of fit squaddies who were going to leave the army and enter teaching. To show us how to be disciplined and focused. We were promised. I think it resulted in a few tens of candidates, who have probably left teaching by now.
CallmeHendricks · 18/11/2021 23:43

Well yes.
But some people could ease up on the teacher-bashing as well.
That would help a lot.

pokemeinthemorning · 18/11/2021 23:39

@CallmeHendricks

We can say "children are entitled to/have a right to...." all we like, but the bottom line is that as schools have been SO starved of cash and conditions in education so awful (and Covid has been the last straw) that the profession is haemorrhaging staff for years. If there are too few teachers in schools, no supply staff available or money to fund them even if there were and SLT are already in class, then just what are people expecting to happen? Complaining to the Head just exacerbates the issue - many of them are on a knife-edge anyway and many more complaints will just mean even more of them jacking it in. Then what?
Less properly educated pupils to go on to get good university education and enter the professions. Students who might never realise their full potential. Students who never get an answer to the complex questions and don't understand basics because they haven't been taught properly. Possibly by staff who don't know the answer or subject themselves. We should all be worried.
OP posts:
CallmeHendricks · 18/11/2021 23:28

We can say "children are entitled to/have a right to...." all we like, but the bottom line is that as schools have been SO starved of cash and conditions in education so awful (and Covid has been the last straw) that the profession is haemorrhaging staff for years.
If there are too few teachers in schools, no supply staff available or money to fund them even if there were and SLT are already in class, then just what are people expecting to happen?
Complaining to the Head just exacerbates the issue - many of them are on a knife-edge anyway and many more complaints will just mean even more of them jacking it in. Then what?

Sadsammy · 18/11/2021 23:22

Every child is entitled to be taught by a qualified teacher. TAs can be great at their jobs but they are support staff and for the most part, instructed and led by the teacher. Teachers either have a 4 year BEd degree or a degree with qualified teacher status or a PGCE after a degree. Then they have their NQT years. It is not easy to train to be a teacher and training is ongoing throughout a teacher's career. Many teachers leave after five years because the demands of the job are too hard, leaving no work/life balance. I've had good TAs and poor. The best one, who I could trust to take over in an emergency for a significant length of time, was a teacher in the past however she was not up-to-date on new methods and expectations. Others could certainly cover basic lessons, if a teacher had to leave the class suddenly and briefly for example, and ensure children were 'on task' but this is simply not the same as teaching complex concepts and ensuring children attain their potential. What some people on this thread fail to realise is that work left for supply teachers, HLTAs and TAs to cover are the easier lessons or simplified tasks. My experience is the vast majority do not have degrees and in some cases do not have qualifications in English and maths. They are taken advantage of when schools are desperate and were relied upon heavily to support during Covid. If no-one complains, it will just keep happening.