Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Silence in the waiting room

368 replies

Meatandseventeenveg · 18/11/2021 17:28

Was at the doctor's with my 2 year old this afternoon. We were playing in the children's corner of the room, nothing noisy but just a chat about the pictures of the animals in the room, and DD was also making the animal sounds.

Another person in waiting room told DD to be quiet as there are sick people there (at this point it was just us three in the waiting room). I'm afraid I snapped back that my daughter is sick as well, and turned away.

My daughter, the angel, understood the woman and proceeded to talk in a whisper until the woman left.

So WIBU to think that toddlers are allowed to talk in the doctor's waiting room?

OP posts:
trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 16:12

Her children won't thank her for being a loving parent that interacts with her? Yeh, I'm sure they'll be livid

I know!! Honestly I think I'm on a different planet on here sometimes 🤣

Houseofvelour · 19/11/2021 15:49

[quote Houseofvelour]@ldfdyjxzyjkv "You are clueless. But do what you like, your children won’t thank you."

Her children won't thank her for being a loving parent that interacts with her? Yeh, I'm sure they'll be livid 😂 get a grip[/quote]
*with them

jfc mumsnet can we please have an edit button 🙄

Houseofvelour · 19/11/2021 15:48

@ldfdyjxzyjkv "You are clueless. But do what you like, your children won’t thank you."

Her children won't thank her for being a loving parent that interacts with her? Yeh, I'm sure they'll be livid 😂 get a grip

pastypirate · 19/11/2021 15:38

Yanbu it's not a library or an exam hall. It just isn't.

hotmeatymilk · 19/11/2021 15:29

If there’s a child’s area – our GP has those wooden play stations with blocks on wires to move around, and a box of toy cars and animals on wheels to push around – and it has pictures of animals too, that’s a clear sign from the GP that it’s OK to play with that stuff and interact with the pictures, and it’s there precisely to distract small, poorly children, or children accompanying a poorly parent. Find a different GP if you don’t want one with an open invitation for children to (enjoy quiet, supervised) play.

Children have fewer coping mechanisms than adults and X amount of time staying quiet in a waiting room is harder than it is for an adult to grit their teeth and think “I hate ducks”.

thing47 · 19/11/2021 15:17

I would tell my DC before arriving that it is a quiet place.

But it isn't. You think it should be, but as is evident from the voting on this thread, the vast majority don't agree with you.

Most posters think what the OP was doing is entirely OK and indeed age-appropriate. Running around shouting and bumping into people = definitely not OK. Sitting in the children's corner and behaving in a manner which is precisely what that area is set up for = absolutely fine.

MindyStClaire · 19/11/2021 15:15

@trappedbylife

*I’m also strict about my children behaving/very considerate etc but a sick child playing nicely in a waiting room Sounds absolutely fine to me because I’m not a lunatic*

Second this.

Absolutely, I'll happily third it.
trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 15:12

I’m also strict about my children behaving/very considerate etc but a sick child playing nicely in a waiting room
Sounds absolutely fine to me because I’m not a lunatic

Second this.

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 15:07

*allow our children the freedom to

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 15:06

My point is simply that it is for us as parents to limit the impact of our children on other people.

It's also for us as parents to allow out children for freedom to express themselves and communicate with us in socially acceptable and age appropriate ways. Both of which apply to the child in the OP. Therefore there was absolutely nothing that needed to be "limited" about the OP's child's behaviour.

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/11/2021 15:05

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

Happy to disagree on that one! You have absolutely no idea about my parenting. I’m also strict about my children behaving/very considerate etc but a sick child playing nicely in a waiting room
Sounds absolutely fine to me because I’m not a lunatic. It’s nice for your children to be seen as a burden on others though, lovely 😊

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 15:05

Children being forced to fit in with adults and “seen and not heard” and all the other antiquated shit that most modern doctors/psychologists disagree with (obviously because we are now more educated and understand more) is probably why we have so many emotionally stunted adults, most of whom seem to be on this thread.

👏🏻

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 14:58

@Justheretoaskaquestion91

Children being forced to fit in with adults and “seen and not heard” and all the other antiquated shit that most modern doctors/psychologists disagree with (obviously because we are now more educated and understand more) is probably why we have so many emotionally stunted adults, most of whom seem to be on this thread.

Agree with PP who says I would rather listen to a parent working their arse off to keep the child happy than listen to screaming and crying snd the parent not bothering.

You are clueless. But do what you like, your children won’t thank you.
Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/11/2021 14:54

@MindyStClaire

Exactly!

Justheretoaskaquestion91 · 19/11/2021 14:53

Children being forced to fit in with adults and “seen and not heard” and all the other antiquated shit that most modern doctors/psychologists disagree with (obviously because we are now more educated and understand more) is probably why we have so many emotionally stunted adults, most of whom seem to be on this thread.

Agree with PP who says I would rather listen to a parent working their arse off to keep the child happy than listen to screaming and crying snd the parent not bothering.

MindyStClaire · 19/11/2021 14:49

Two year olds don't understand the first time you tell them that they need to be quiet in a particular place. You have to teach them, and often that means showing them over and over again. The way to teach a two year old to be quiet in a waiting room is to chat to them, engage their interest so they don't get bored, and play with books and quiet toys. This stops them running around, shouting, having a tantrum etc. That is the way to be considerate to other people, because two year olds don't have the same behaviours, capabilities or needs as older children or adults.

I.e., the OP was teaching her child how to behave in a waiting room in an age appropriate way, and well done to her for that.

Bingbong21 · 19/11/2021 14:48

It's a waiting room, not a silence room.

And yes, I will chat away to my DD whilst there.

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 14:43

@cayennepepper

Sorry I meant what small minded people I may come across that will tell me that my child has no right to be there as a paying customer or a child that needs medical attention!
My point is simply that it is for us as parents to limit the impact of our children on other people. Quite obviously if a child is crying/upset because they are unwell that is another matter but I really don’t see the problem with showing a little respect (eg asking a child to sit in your lap on a train so another adult can sit down). It is simply good manners. I would tell my DC before arriving that it is a quiet place. I have taught them from an early age that there are some places they need to be quiet (like on a plane) and they completely understand it and have no issue with it. The sooner they learn that society is made up of a lot of different people who also have feelings, the better. I teach my DC that other people need to be shown courtesy. They are confident, happy, loud, noisy, messy kids but they are also empathetic and respectful.
trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 14:38

Physically sick? Put it in perspective, please.

This is so dismissive of @cayennepepper 's feelings on the matter. If that's how she feels, then it's for a reason and it's valid.

cayennepepper · 19/11/2021 14:29

Sorry I meant what small minded people I may come across that will tell me that my child has no right to be there as a paying customer or a child that needs medical attention!

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 14:26

@cayennepepper

I couldn't agree more with your posts.

cayennepepper · 19/11/2021 14:24

People should remember that the more you push children and not accept them part of our life, the less doctors, nurses we will have in the future. If you treat the young ones like shit and push them from a young age as if they are an inconvenience, they will move elsewhere in the world where they will be treated with respect. @ldfdyjxzyjkv yes physically sick to the extent that every time I go into a public space, I get anxiety on how my toddler would contain himself what small minded people I may encounter!

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 14:18

[quote cayennepepper]@MinnieJackson people see children as a nuisance that they should not be heard or seen in public places. When did we become so intolerant? My 2.5 yo would never behave like op's daughter, he would shout and scream and throw tantrums no matter how much I will try to calm him down and distract him. The efforts I go through, sweating through my butt to keep him quiet but people will judge and say I'm a bad parent by the responses on this thread. Maybe my child's personality is like that, maybe he has asd. Is he not entitled to health care? When I broke my arm falling down the stairs years ago I was stuck in the A&E with drunk people who were shouting and screaming with police officers coming in and out with criminals that they had arrested and mangled them during their arrest shouting every swear word with children in the a&e who had broken limbs through sport etc. Im sorry if they have a right to healthcare, so does my son who has two parents that contribute to the healthcare system.

I just feel physically sick when I come across threads like this where people openly shame parents with lack of parenting in restaurants or planes when they see a child and expect a 2yo to contain themselves like a adult. You're lucky if you have child that sits perfectly silently but it's not because you are the better parent, it's because your child is like that and nothing to do with your parenting!

@PRsecrets I want to move countries as well as I'm sick of living amongst miserable people who think the world only revolves around them only and no other citizen has the right to access public spaces or public healthcare. A country where dogs have more rights than tiny human beings. What a utterly shit country we have become. My ds became ill abroad on holiday once where he required iv antibiotics. He was screaming the place down, everyone in the waiting room asked if he was ok and wished him to get better soon. I honestly really really hate this country so much and what it has become where people lack tolerance and basic compassion.
[/quote]
To add - the only thing that has changed is people are now completely selfish. Common decency is only just holding on in this country. You do realise that the obsession with children being the centre of the universe is only about 5 years old? Before then they fit in with adults.

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 14:16

[quote cayennepepper]@MinnieJackson people see children as a nuisance that they should not be heard or seen in public places. When did we become so intolerant? My 2.5 yo would never behave like op's daughter, he would shout and scream and throw tantrums no matter how much I will try to calm him down and distract him. The efforts I go through, sweating through my butt to keep him quiet but people will judge and say I'm a bad parent by the responses on this thread. Maybe my child's personality is like that, maybe he has asd. Is he not entitled to health care? When I broke my arm falling down the stairs years ago I was stuck in the A&E with drunk people who were shouting and screaming with police officers coming in and out with criminals that they had arrested and mangled them during their arrest shouting every swear word with children in the a&e who had broken limbs through sport etc. Im sorry if they have a right to healthcare, so does my son who has two parents that contribute to the healthcare system.

I just feel physically sick when I come across threads like this where people openly shame parents with lack of parenting in restaurants or planes when they see a child and expect a 2yo to contain themselves like a adult. You're lucky if you have child that sits perfectly silently but it's not because you are the better parent, it's because your child is like that and nothing to do with your parenting!

@PRsecrets I want to move countries as well as I'm sick of living amongst miserable people who think the world only revolves around them only and no other citizen has the right to access public spaces or public healthcare. A country where dogs have more rights than tiny human beings. What a utterly shit country we have become. My ds became ill abroad on holiday once where he required iv antibiotics. He was screaming the place down, everyone in the waiting room asked if he was ok and wished him to get better soon. I honestly really really hate this country so much and what it has become where people lack tolerance and basic compassion.
[/quote]
Physically sick? Put it in perspective, please.

IntermittentParps · 19/11/2021 14:01

Another person in waiting room told DD to be quiet as there are sick people there
This made me laugh. What on earth did they think you were doing there? Sightseeing?

Children screaming/shouting/running about of course would be irritating. But talking and a bit of animal noise I think people could be a bit more tolerant about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread