Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Silence in the waiting room

368 replies

Meatandseventeenveg · 18/11/2021 17:28

Was at the doctor's with my 2 year old this afternoon. We were playing in the children's corner of the room, nothing noisy but just a chat about the pictures of the animals in the room, and DD was also making the animal sounds.

Another person in waiting room told DD to be quiet as there are sick people there (at this point it was just us three in the waiting room). I'm afraid I snapped back that my daughter is sick as well, and turned away.

My daughter, the angel, understood the woman and proceeded to talk in a whisper until the woman left.

So WIBU to think that toddlers are allowed to talk in the doctor's waiting room?

OP posts:
Sleepyblueocean · 20/11/2021 06:09

Ds cannot cope with being around young children particularly when he is feeling unwell but we understand that we have to solve that problem by waiting somewhere else. It is possible that this women had the same difficulty but either way OP you were doing nothing wrong.

overnightangel · 20/11/2021 04:51

Also “ My daughter, the angel” 🙄

overnightangel · 20/11/2021 04:50

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

The person is a moron- ignore - even if your child was screaming, they are 2, how much can you do
Or maybe just very fucking stressed because they’re ill? Doesn’t make them a moron, as you so delightfully put it
1forAll74 · 20/11/2021 04:11

I love to hear small children talking,, they don't know what the etiquette is supposed to be in a GP's waiting room.. I certainly wouldn't be bunging a gadget in front of them, as too much of that goes on.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 20/11/2021 03:35

@WheelieBinPrincess

Were you doing loud parenting about animals and their noises though?

If so it would be very irritating to listen to when sick and trapped in a waiting room.

Indeed
claymodels · 19/11/2021 23:34

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

Well lbh none of us has any idea what OP and her DD did or didn’t do and none of us can assess whether the woman was unreasonable. Everyone is just positing extreme scenarios in both directions. My simple point is that when other bystanders and in a room with parents and young children through no choice of their own they would expect some effort to be made to limit the noise their child makes. That’s all.

You are being extreme. The majority can understand an exchange between a parent and child is not bad manners but mere normality; even in a waiting room/

AudacityBaby · 19/11/2021 23:30

Why is talking in a waiting room bad manners though?!

I posted upthread about a horrible experience I had in a hospital where the gynae oncology department and the maternity department shared a waiting room - in that situation I think the parents should’ve been particularly mindful about noise, whereas in reality it was like a zoo. That was really disrespectful and very ill-mannered.

But talking in a waiting room? Talking?!?! It’s not the theatre. I’m baffled.

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 23:28

Well lbh none of us has any idea what OP and her DD did or didn’t do and none of us can assess whether the woman was unreasonable. Everyone is just positing extreme scenarios in both directions. My simple point is that when other bystanders and in a room with parents and young children through no choice of their own they would expect some effort to be made to limit the noise their child makes. That’s all.

claymodels · 19/11/2021 23:23

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

Honestly if you don’t have a grasp on the concept of manners (ie it is not about rules it is norms of behaviour) I can’t help you. Do people not even understand the concept of manners anyone? We are more screwed than I thought.

We understand manners perfectly. The scenario we speak about isn't bad manners though.

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 23:22

@trappedbylife

A child talking to their parents in public is poor manners?? Confused
More extreme nonsense.
ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 23:21

Honestly if you don’t have a grasp on the concept of manners (ie it is not about rules it is norms of behaviour) I can’t help you. Do people not even understand the concept of manners anyone? We are more screwed than I thought.

SirChenjins · 19/11/2021 22:57

@trappedbylife

A child talking to their parents in public is poor manners?? Confused
No, of course it isn’t.
thing47 · 19/11/2021 22:57

OP is imposing by sitting with her young child in the children's corner, participating in an activity for which that area has been specifically designed…? Confused

Honestly I have no idea how somebody who thinks like this manages to get through a normal day's interaction with other people.

RAFHercules · 19/11/2021 22:55

2 is a baby.
She was lucky your poorly girl wasn't screaming the walls down. But I will give her the benefit of the doubt and believe that she had sensory issues (rather than she was an intolerant arse Wink).
Hope your DD is feeling better.

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 22:49

A child talking to their parents in public is poor manners?? Confused

claymodels · 19/11/2021 22:48

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

I know you find it hard to grasp but yes *@trappedbylife* I would consider that inappropriate - and I am well brought up, well educated, successful and have DC who know how to behave (I say this only because of the slurs that have been levelled against those who you and other PP disagree with - suggesting there is something wrong with those who don’t agree with you). Why does everything else trump manners these days? I also wonder how some people were brought up.

Why do you think this is an issue of 'manners'?

So well educated but can't grasp the fact that the waiting room is not a designated quiet area Grin

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 22:47

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

It has got nothing to do with whether a waiting room is a library or not a library, soft play or not soft play, it is just a basic social principle that you don’t impose yourself and your offspring on other people who don’t care how wonderful and spirited your child is.

Allowing your child to interact with you in public is not them "imposing on" others, ffs!? What an utterly bizarre outlook.

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 22:46

@ldfdyjxzyjkv

I know you find it hard to grasp but yes *@trappedbylife* I would consider that inappropriate - and I am well brought up, well educated, successful and have DC who know how to behave (I say this only because of the slurs that have been levelled against those who you and other PP disagree with - suggesting there is something wrong with those who don’t agree with you). Why does everything else trump manners these days? I also wonder how some people were brought up.

Honestly - if you consider a conversation like that "inappropriate" then I am genuinely flabbergasted. Confused

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 22:43

It has got nothing to do with whether a waiting room is a library or not a library, soft play or not soft play, it is just a basic social principle that you don’t impose yourself and your offspring on other people who don’t care how wonderful and spirited your child is.

ldfdyjxzyjkv · 19/11/2021 22:41

I know you find it hard to grasp but yes @trappedbylife I would consider that inappropriate - and I am well brought up, well educated, successful and have DC who know how to behave (I say this only because of the slurs that have been levelled against those who you and other PP disagree with - suggesting there is something wrong with those who don’t agree with you). Why does everything else trump manners these days? I also wonder how some people were brought up.

thing47 · 19/11/2021 22:32

As a parent of toddlers, I used to treat the waiting room like a library.

You're free to treat it that way if you wish. However, it really isn't like a library at all and nobody else is under any obligation to treat it as such. What you prefer is neither here nor there really.

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 22:09

@Roxy69

What's wrong with bringing up children to respect the fact that in some places it really isn't polite to play. It's not hard to understand.

It's impolite for a 2 year old to interact with her mother in a waiting area by noticing animals on a picture and mimicking their sounds?

Based on OP's descriptions, I'm imagining the interaction (at a normal volume) to have gone something like:

"Look mummy, a pig"
"Oh yes, what sound does a pig make?"
"Oink oink"
"Yes, clever girl" etc....

If this is considered impolite or inappropriate, for a TWO year old and their parent in a waiting area, then I'm genuinely concerned about those who think and feel this way. Bizarre.

trappedbylife · 19/11/2021 22:05

@SirChenjins

You mean it isn’t polite to play in a children’s corner? Exactly do you suggest children should do in a children’s area other than play?

The world does not revolve round adults who can’t cope with a parent interacting with their child through quiet play - the sooner some adults realise that the better. I do wonder how some were raised.

Your second paragraph is spot on.

MindyStClaire · 19/11/2021 22:02

@Roxy69

What's wrong with bringing up children to respect the fact that in some places it really isn't polite to play. It's not hard to understand.
Pretty much everything children that age do is some form of play, that's how they learn and communicate.

It's not appropriate to play with loud toys, shout or play running games in a waiting room. Chat, books and quiet toys (i.e. what OP was doing) are absolutely appropriate.

I agree older children shouldn't be playing in waiting rooms, but again this is a two year old we're talking about, and there are limits to their behaviour and attention spans.

SirChenjins · 19/11/2021 21:55

You mean it isn’t polite to play in a children’s corner? Exactly do you suggest children should do in a children’s area other than play?

The world does not revolve round adults who can’t cope with a parent interacting with their child through quiet play - the sooner some adults realise that the better. I do wonder how some were raised.

Swipe left for the next trending thread