Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Silence in the waiting room

368 replies

Meatandseventeenveg · 18/11/2021 17:28

Was at the doctor's with my 2 year old this afternoon. We were playing in the children's corner of the room, nothing noisy but just a chat about the pictures of the animals in the room, and DD was also making the animal sounds.

Another person in waiting room told DD to be quiet as there are sick people there (at this point it was just us three in the waiting room). I'm afraid I snapped back that my daughter is sick as well, and turned away.

My daughter, the angel, understood the woman and proceeded to talk in a whisper until the woman left.

So WIBU to think that toddlers are allowed to talk in the doctor's waiting room?

OP posts:
SirChenjins · 18/11/2021 20:25

Yes I have, ours is quiet, not silent (even when there are kids there) unless there is a specific kids activity on

Quiet is very different from silent. Someone speaking to and playing with their child in the children’s play corner in a GP’s waiting room is behaving appropriately for that setting.

ineedsun · 18/11/2021 20:23

Do other people forget they were probably in our shoes once feeling anxious about keeping their toddler quiet in a compact space
Everyone really is so self centred now.

This made me laugh because of course people remember that, and largely managed it, because we were considerate of other people - I think when you say people are self centred now, I agree but we’re probably talking about different people.

claymodels · 18/11/2021 20:22

As you can see by this thread, these are not made up rules. For many people it’s a social norm and expectation which is based on being respectful of other people.

Social norm based on = not a rule. Talking in a doctor's waiting room isn't disrespectful to anyone.

A bit like being in a library - last time I went to one, there were no signs or people saying shh - it is a cultural expectation / norm.

Nothing like being in a library, also this isn't a cultural thing at all it a bit odd to suggest it is. Libraries usually do have quiet please signs up, but obviously I haven't been to your library so can't really comment.

2littleonesx · 18/11/2021 20:19

Honestly you can't even sit in a waiting room anymore with your two year old? What is the world coming to. I find it so irritating to think we actually share spaces with stuck up twats like that. It's pretty obvious that in a public space a child (toddler) is going to talk to their mum surely.
Do other people forget they were probably in our shoes once feeling anxious about keeping their toddler quiet in a compact space? Everyone really is so self centred now. I understand if she was screaming and shouting I would have taken my child out of the waiting room if they couldn't sit nicely and talk, but being spoken to like dirt for my child talking, id have done the exact same and told them where to go.

notanothertakeaway · 18/11/2021 20:17

How can strangers the internet possibly know if your child was being too loud??!!

What an odd thread

ineedsun · 18/11/2021 20:15

@SirChenjins

A play area in a library isn’t quiet - have you been to a library recently?! They’re community assets, rightly so, with all sorts of groups using them for all sorts of purposes - the days of libraries being deathly quiet areas are long gone, thankfully.
Yes I have, ours is quiet, not silent (even when there are kids there) unless there is a specific kids activity on.
ineedsun · 18/11/2021 20:13

@claymodels

That’s where we differ, I consider them in the same way as I would a library.

You have taken that upon yourself, so yes we certainly differ. If I am expected to be quiet somewhere, I will, but I won't make up bizarre rules of no talking in other places.

As you can see by this thread, these are not made up rules. For many people it’s a social norm and expectation which is based on being respectful of other people.

A bit like being in a library - last time I went to one, there were no signs or people saying shh - it is a cultural expectation / norm.

Bluetrews25 · 18/11/2021 20:12

Maybe she didn't have good hearing and was concerned that she would not be able to hear her name called over the fluffy tannoy if your DD was making noise at the same time. I feel like this too, but have never told anyone to be quiet. Yet!

claymodels · 18/11/2021 20:05

That’s where we differ, I consider them in the same way as I would a library.

You have taken that upon yourself, so yes we certainly differ. If I am expected to be quiet somewhere, I will, but I won't make up bizarre rules of no talking in other places.

SirChenjins · 18/11/2021 20:04

Agree @SickAndTiredAgain. No-one has the right to silence in a public area, and no-one should be forced to alter their behaviour to that extent - it would be impossible for many, as you rightly say.

furbabymama87 · 18/11/2021 20:04

@FatBettyintheCoop

FFS. Of course you were being unreasonable. Hmm

You clearly made enough noise that another waiting patient felt uncomfortable.

Surely you could have just read quietly to your daughter like sensible parents do, instead of your rude overreaction?

It’s a bloody doctors waiting room, not the local toddler group meeting.

When out in public one of the downsides is that you have to put up with other people and their general noise. It sounds like the child wasn't doing anything extreme. And sometimes with all the best intentions and every effort to keep your child calm and quiet, you can't expect them to sit in silence for a prolonged amount of time, especially if the appointments were delayed.
Twylar · 18/11/2021 20:03

Is this not just a normal interaction in life?

She was obviously annoyed (either stressed or too ill to cope with the noise) and communicated that.

People are allowed to be annoyed by kids at times and allowed to voice it. I was told off in similar scenarios as a child.

I think you're reading into it too much tbh.

SickAndTiredAgain · 18/11/2021 20:01

@XenoBitch

What do you do to manage that?

I have asked for a private waiting area. Been told there is none at my GP surgery.
I tried.

I really do understand how difficult it is, worst comes to worst, can you wait outside? I have panic attacks and have had to ask the receptionist to knock on the window when it was my turn as I was panicking in the waiting room and needed to step outside (due to the surgery layout this was not hugely inconvenient, she was sitting next to the window. I know in other surgeries it may not be as easy).

Of course you should be able to expect people to be considerate in a waiting room, but given the nature of it, you could easily find yourself in a room with someone who cannot be quiet. A baby crying despite best attempts to soothe it, a child in pain, my grandad who had dementia used to get quite distressed when he had to go to the dr and so he, along with family members’ attempts to soothe him, weren’t always necessarily quiet.

Obviously those are different to OP’s situation where her child was capable of being quiet, but I just mean you can’t expect a waiting room to be people who are always actually capable of providing a quiet environment.

Mumoblue · 18/11/2021 20:01

YANBU. Maybe if she was an older child, but a 2 year old is unlikely to sit quietly in the waiting room, especially when they already don’t feel well.

SirChenjins · 18/11/2021 19:57

A play area in a library isn’t quiet - have you been to a library recently?! They’re community assets, rightly so, with all sorts of groups using them for all sorts of purposes - the days of libraries being deathly quiet areas are long gone, thankfully.

ineedsun · 18/11/2021 19:55

@claymodels

You really can’t imagine how someone who’s experiencing terrible headaches, ear ache, is feeling disoriented, dizzy, sleep deprived, waiting for results of potentially difficult test etc might be better off and prefer a quiet or silent waiting room?

It's fine for them to 'prefer' a quiet room but waiting rooms at the GP are not designated quiet rooms so it shouldn't be an expectation, no. Sometimes people talk, kids play and realistically a child playing isn't going to make these illnesses worse. Also I do actually struggle with imagination. I'm autistic and it's not something that comes easily to me.

That’s where we differ, I consider them in the same way as I would a library.

Again, the fact that the daughter, when told, was able to then whisper tells me that she is quite capable (once told) of being quieter. All those people saying (versions of)‘have you ever met a two year old?’ - yes, and as with this little one they, when told were able to be quiet and calm for a relatively short period.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 19:54

What do you do to manage that?

I have asked for a private waiting area. Been told there is none at my GP surgery.
I tried.

FlickerBeat · 18/11/2021 19:54

@SummaLuvin

My daughter, the angel

This alone tells me that you account is probably entirely biased and unreliable. Your little darling was probably a pain in the ass, when you are sick/in pain/tired tolerance for irritating things dries up.

Yep, this.
SirChenjins · 18/11/2021 19:52

@XenoBitch

Also, due to my own MH issues.. a lot of noise in the waiting room would mean I would just walk out and not get seen.
What do you do to manage that?
Newnameforabit · 18/11/2021 19:52

It sounds like you were both a bit inconsiderate, lesson learned
I hope you got good news for their test results though

claymodels · 18/11/2021 19:47

@XenoBitch

Also, due to my own MH issues.. a lot of noise in the waiting room would mean I would just walk out and not get seen.

But as you say, these are your issues.

Theunamedcat · 18/11/2021 19:46

My youngest got told off in the hospital he wasn't being loud but everyone was pretty indulgent with him complete strangers playing cars with him he was spinning around making a quiet mmmmm noise like a bee when a woman dissolved into hysterical crying screaming can't you keep control of your child! I was so shocked I said "I think its blatantly obvious I cannot" I took him away from her and the secretary said she would call us when it was our turn another woman came down to apologise for her saying no-one else thought he was a problem and telling me about her autistic grandson (my son was suspected autistic at the time) the woman who was hysterical was being scowled at by the entire waiting room and her husband was fuming with her to this day im not sure who overreacted more her or the waiting room of people

If she had just said nicely I would have moved him sooner

I think people in general have become so intolerant when there is no need

SirChenjins · 18/11/2021 19:45

because British people hate children

Nothing to do with nationality - and everything to do with personality. We’ve all witnessed intolerance other nationalities.

claymodels · 18/11/2021 19:45

A child playing, or any noise, can make some things worse.
I have a friend who suffers with psychotic depression and anxiety. If he gets anxious, he hears voices. They can be violent. In the case of the OP, if he was in the waiting room with her child, he would be hearing "punch them in the face" about OPs child. But he would be in the wrong for telling OP that they should turn it down a touch.

If he is psychotic and hearing voices it would be sensible to ask for his own waiting space, which is a reasonable request in any GP surgery. I don't think people should take on the responsibility of silence where it isn't requested just in case someone like your friend appears.

XenoBitch · 18/11/2021 19:44

Also, due to my own MH issues.. a lot of noise in the waiting room would mean I would just walk out and not get seen.