Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
mishmased · 20/11/2021 14:49

Apologies @Yoyomelon I misread your post 🤦‍♀️

mishmased · 20/11/2021 14:48

@Yoyomelon that's incorrect. According to UNICEF 81% initiate breastfeeding and 24% (in England) are EBF at 6 weeks and 17% at 3 months. Probably outdated survey.

www.google.ie/amp/s/www.unicef.org.uk/babyfriendly/about/breastfeeding-in-the-uk/amp/

JadeTrinket · 20/11/2021 14:45

@roolz

Why did you post the study?

Why does anyone post anything? Op wants to share an article she found interesting or informative. How did this thread even get to 450+ posts?

I think @5128gap has a point -- the reason people post things on SM often bears interrogation, and, given that every woman who hasn't lived under a rock for decades is thoroughly informed about the health benefits of breastfeeding, it is pretty unlikely that someone who posts this genuinely believes she is educating the ill-informed, who might make different, healthier choices if they had this information.

One of the obvious other reasons, if not education, is to reaffirm the poster's own choices. Which, as we've established, do not need further affirmation, because literally everything in public discourses about infant feeding from The Lancet to some Instamummy posting 'You go, fabulous breastfeeding mamas!' validates breast-feeding.

Look, I am delighted other people were able to breastfeed their babies. Genuinely. But being repeatedly told about the health benefits for your baby I once had a practice midwife who, discovering I wasn't BFing at some check-up (at this point, I had stopped explaining why it hadn't been a choice), started telling me about the health benefits for me,as if, although I was clearly too lazy/feckless etc to bf my baby for his own health, might sit up and rethink if I were told it might reduce my risk of ovarian cancer Hmm is a bit like being hit repeatedly on the head with a teaspoon.

I mean, I'm not a stupid person. I have a doctorate, I conduct research, I understand stats and the difficulty of correcting for social factors, I don't take research personally, but God, I do sometimes find myself wanting to roll my eyes and say 'Breast-feeding is good for your baby? WHO KNEW?'

Yoyomelon · 20/11/2021 14:42

76% of mothers in the UK are not breastfeeding their newborn at the 6 week mark. Where I'm from (Croatia) that number is 29% at the 3 month mark (I couldn't find the 6 week stat for Croatia)
I find it incredible on this thread the amount of people claiming that most of those doing so because they physically couldn't breastfeed. "It's not a choice". Unless there is something physically different about Croatia women and UK women there is no physical reason why 71% of babies couldn't be breastfed. This suggests that a large number of those in the UK don't breastfeed for other (also valuable) reasons. It also suggests that the support given to Croatian women must be significantly better than in the UK.

RidingMyBike · 20/11/2021 14:40

The trouble with people posting about the benefits (and I do get this on my SM as I have relatives who are lactivists and obsessed about it!) is that a) the benefits are hugely bigged up with no reference to how poor the research is b) the negatives are never mentioned and c) there is no mention ever of the people who can't either partially or fully BF so it doesn't matter if it's beneficial or not, they can't do it. I should never have been encouraged to EBF as I have numerous risk factors for low supply.

It would be the same if someone was boasting about their perfect eyesight and the benefits of not having to wear glasses. Some of us don't have a choice!

There is rarely a mention of the high failure rate for BFing, which in the past, caused a lot of infant mortality. And that now, a lot of the things that cause low supply/total inability to BF would once upon a time mean someone wouldn't even have been pregnant, let alone trying to BF or they/the baby wouldn't have survived the birth (infertility, PCOS, diabetes, thyroid problems, difficult birth ending in a CS, haemorrhage).

5128gap · 20/11/2021 14:33

[quote Silverclasp]@5128gap people on this thread have literally said that they would feel it is a personal attack on them if someone on their SM posted that article.[/quote]
A lot of people are giving other reasons why it would be upsetting too though. Given how controversial it is and how much potential it does have to cause hurt, I think you made a good call in not sharing it, as it seems the benefits if doing that would be outweighed by the upset.

Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 14:24

@5128gap people on this thread have literally said that they would feel it is a personal attack on them if someone on their SM posted that article.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 20/11/2021 14:22

@updownroundandround

Feeling you're being got at by people who were luckier than you in one very specific area of life which you struggled with when they hit you over the head again and again with research that backs up their argument doesn't make you narcicisstic. Confused

Why on earth would you use the words '' they hit you over the head again and again'' and expect to be viewed as anything other than paranoid ? Confused

I think it speaks volumes about you, rather than being a 'reflection' on anyone else........

I feel for anyone who has ever felt 'got at' by others, but that doesn't change the fact that someone will be offended about something others believe or think or say.

The key is to not keep returning to the company of others who make you feel that way.

I don't hang around with breastfeeding zealots -- I'm too old now to be in the demographic really but when I was younger I just avoided getting drawn into discussion about it with people who I knew took a hardline view. But its very hard to avoid it

But I think putting this down to "everyone gets offended by something" is willfully misleading. There's a specific section of society which seeks to "educate" women about breastfeeding in a fairly zealous way and the right to proselytize about breastfeeding seems to takes precedence over the feelings and circumstances of people on the receiving end. This way of thinking doesn't take into account the very many variables and reasons why people don't breastfeed and assumes that failure to breastfeed is basically tantamount to negligent parenting. In some ways the closest analogy is to religious evangelism: its the belief that your argument gets to be heard over all other points of view and at all costs.

This is fairly unique to the breastfeeding debate. Look at another highly emotionally charged debate which you get on here all the time: the working mum vs SAHM debate. This often gets very heated and sometimes quite nasty on both sides. But there's a basic acceptance on both sides that no-one has the automatic moral high ground.

Even those people with the strongest views will acknowledge that their worldview doesn't work for everyone and there isn't a "one true way".

The breastfeeding debate is equally charged but different in that the pro bf lobby assumes that it has the moral authority over the argument at all times. There is no quarter given to people who struggle, who compromise or who just switch off and no attempt to take account of the broader question of health -- including the health of the mother. So no attempt is made to listen to the people who don't breastfeed and engage with the reasons why they don't. It's just "here's another study that proves why we're right". A bit like someone finding another Bible verse that proves something.

However vehement people's views are as to whether women should work or not, you rarely get people posting studies on Facebook that show the effects on children of their parents working or not. It's accepted that this is subjective, very difficult to quantify and highly likely to upset and irritate people.

For some reason, bf enthusiasts have no such filter or self-awareness. And it appears not to cross their mind that a very large number of people reading their posts will be upset by it. Not because they are professionally offended or "paranoid" but because they all have a personal story of not being able to breastfeed and reading yet another screed that shows why they were lazy or feckless or didn't try hard enough makes no difference.

5128gap · 20/11/2021 14:21

[quote Silverclasp]@5128gap I didn't post it. I was interested in the article and thought other people might be interested but didn't post it because I thought (it appears correctly) that people would take it as a personal dig if they didn't BF.[/quote]
I think to say people take it as a personal dig is unfair. People are saying that it upsets them to have the benefits of something they can't provide reinforced. By stretching this to say they see it as a dig, implies they are paranoid and slightly ridiculous, as who on earth is so self obsessed to think a factual post is aimed at them? In doing so this invalidates their feelings about the content of the post. I think if you genuinely don't want to upset people it's best to keep that sort of post for sharing with other BF women.

RidingMyBike · 20/11/2021 14:15

I heard nothing but the positives of BFing before I had my baby. It sounded amazing and I couldn't wait to get started with it.

The reality was very different and if I'd heard the negatives I could have made an informed choice to do it. It caused a seriously ill Mum and baby (severe PND and hypernatraemic dehydration - she came very close to brain damage), was possibly the least enjoyable thing I've ever done, wrecked our first months together, stopped me bonding with my baby and cost at least double the cost of formula. It then turned out the supposed 'benefits' had been hugely bigged up and weren't worth the sheer hell of doing it.

I ended up BFing for 3.5 years as I was under so much pressure to keep doing it and can honestly say it's the only thing I regret doing from the baby years.

5128gap · 20/11/2021 14:09

@roolz

Why did you post the study?

Why does anyone post anything? Op wants to share an article she found interesting or informative. How did this thread even get to 450+ posts?

Well there can be many reasons can't there? To inform, educated or persuade, to spark discussion, to affirm ones own choices... I was just curious.
Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 14:08

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee actually they did say that about him. He committed suicide

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 20/11/2021 14:06

@Silverclasp

For example I find pictures of people with their dad's on fathers day really hurtful as my dad passed away..... but I wouldn't expect people not to post anything about their fathers and certainly wouldn't feel like it was directly aimed at me if they did. I would be very self centered if I thought that.
But no-one has ever told you that the reason your dad died was because you were not determined enough or gave up too easily so whilst I can see why this pains you, it is not a good comparison.
OhWhyNot · 20/11/2021 13:51

I have been told on a few occasions I would have been able to exclusively bf and would have produced enough milk by so called experts because they had breastfed and done a little reading told me over and over again if only I persevered

I was unable to give birth naturally so why is that accepted that at times we need intervention but not for feeding.

Luckily I didn’t feel upset or offended by these women who never met me but knew my body so much better than I did but I can see if I had felt down i would have done but they certainly annoyed me not because they were hitting a raw nerve but because of their condescending know all opinions that was not support it was smug condescending

We don’t all produce enough milk (runs in my family) our bodies do not always do as we few they should as designed to and we no longer have (or rarely have) family around to also bf feed (which was common in the past and still in some cultures)

I’ve tried to give support on here to women who are struggling because they can’t bf but the threads are so often over taken by the breast is best I shall tell you what to do as I know best brigade

roolz · 20/11/2021 13:46

Why did you post the study?

Why does anyone post anything? Op wants to share an article she found interesting or informative. How did this thread even get to 450+ posts?

Tumbleweed101 · 20/11/2021 13:33

There needs to be a lot more support in all areas of the early years. This push to get mums back to work so soon is damaging because it drives away support for parents. There seems to be a dismissive, you chose to do this so get on with it attitude in society now instead of seeing the upbringing and support of young families as an investment to the future of our country.
Information about the benefits of breast feeding need to go hand in hand with support, starting before the birth, and right through until mum and baby are ready to stop. If a mum can't breast feed but wanted to then if they have had every bit of support then the transition to bottle feeding might feel easier and if a mum wants to bottle feed from birth all the information and support should be there about the ingredients used in different brands and the pro and cons for those too.

Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 13:26

@5128gap I didn't post it. I was interested in the article and thought other people might be interested but didn't post it because I thought (it appears correctly) that people would take it as a personal dig if they didn't BF.

OP posts:
Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 13:24

For example I find pictures of people with their dad's on fathers day really hurtful as my dad passed away..... but I wouldn't expect people not to post anything about their fathers and certainly wouldn't feel like it was directly aimed at me if they did. I would be very self centered if I thought that.

OP posts:
5128gap · 20/11/2021 13:23

@Silverclasp

People posting photographs of themselves with their kids on mother's day or posting quotes about parenthood could be hurtful to someone who is struggling with infertility but anyone with any kind of self awareness knows it's about their own insecurity rather than people deliberately trying to upset them. The OP clearly says it's one article about a scientific study it's hardly beating people over the head. I have literally never posted any BF related post publicly on my SM.
Why did you post the study?
JadeTrinket · 20/11/2021 13:20

@updownroundandround

Feeling you're being got at by people who were luckier than you in one very specific area of life which you struggled with when they hit you over the head again and again with research that backs up their argument doesn't make you narcicisstic. Confused

Why on earth would you use the words '' they hit you over the head again and again'' and expect to be viewed as anything other than paranoid ? Confused

I think it speaks volumes about you, rather than being a 'reflection' on anyone else........

I feel for anyone who has ever felt 'got at' by others, but that doesn't change the fact that someone will be offended about something others believe or think or say.

The key is to not keep returning to the company of others who make you feel that way.

But I don’t think that poster was talking about her friends, just about public discourses about breastfeeding, including on here. Obviously you can avoid people you know have a bee in their bonnet about bf — just as I avoided a friend of a friend who turned out to have something against c-sections and twice told me I ‘hadn’t given birth’ because I had one — but it’s omnipresent.

We all know the health benefits. This means that when you see us formula-feeding, there is no need to keep telling us about the research on health benefits. Whatever decision (or in some cases not a decision) we made was made in the full knowledge of those.

Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 13:19

People posting photographs of themselves with their kids on mother's day or posting quotes about parenthood could be hurtful to someone who is struggling with infertility but anyone with any kind of self awareness knows it's about their own insecurity rather than people deliberately trying to upset them.
The OP clearly says it's one article about a scientific study it's hardly beating people over the head. I have literally never posted any BF related post publicly on my SM.

OP posts:
Glassofshloer · 20/11/2021 13:15

There really isn’t such a noticeable difference in health between ff babies and bf babies that it is worth all this angst.

Tonyschoco · 20/11/2021 13:14

@Kendodd

I didn't breast feed because I had no choice. Why this constant need for a reason as well? Even if you choose from day one to ff that's fine, bf has to work for both of you, there are two people in this relationship and they are both important.

I am very straightforward about the benefits/harms of bf/ff. I am also very straightforward that women have a right to choose what works for them and really don't get the guilt around it. We will do many, many things that are less than perfect for out children, I don't understand why bf has this special elevated place that mothers (never dads) feel uniquely guilty about.
Give up on the agonies over ff, you're going be giving them fucking Haribo in a few years (despite believing that'll never happen).

You literally said you believed formula to be harmful, and now you’re criticising women for feeling the need to defend their formula feeding. Are you high? You’re actively perpetuating the divisive narrative that you’re now criticising women for reacting to. Absolutely mental.
Glassofshloer · 20/11/2021 13:14

I think a lot of very pro-bfing people have problems acknowledging that a lot of people are aware of the benefits but feel formula is the right choice for them anyway.

Because of work commitments, childcare, MH issues, or simply because they don’t want to.

Different priorities.

updownroundandround · 20/11/2021 13:10

Feeling you're being got at by people who were luckier than you in one very specific area of life which you struggled with when they hit you over the head again and again with research that backs up their argument doesn't make you narcicisstic.

Confused

Why on earth would you use the words '' they hit you over the head again and again'' and expect to be viewed as anything other than paranoid ? Confused

I think it speaks volumes about you, rather than being a 'reflection' on anyone else........

I feel for anyone who has ever felt 'got at' by others, but that doesn't change the fact that someone will be offended about something others believe or think or say.

The key is to not keep returning to the company of others who make you feel that way.