Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
AngelDelight28 · 20/11/2021 22:24

@DingleyDel They don't have to be anyone's "friend". They supply a product for which there is demand. They make a profit, because no one is going to manufacture something for no profit. It's how all businesses work. No one is forced to buy their products.
There's special non dairy formula for babies that are allergic to cows milk. That's not the same as them saying they can cure allergies.
I've already done expensive research into BF vs FF, when my baby was at that stage, including reading peer reviewed papers rather than YouTube videos by people with an agenda.
I got the whole ForMulA CoMpAnIeS ArE EviLz spiel from the "feeding support" person at the hospital, even though I'd been through 8 weeks of gruelling triple feeding with no improvement, and it was obvious it just wasn't going to work for me. Not what I needed at that moment. I just needed formula, and the formula companies provided it. Without it my baby would have starved. The simple fact is not all women can or want to breastfeed and formula provides a healthy, nutritionally complete alternative.

Vbree · 20/11/2021 22:12

Most people know the benefits of breastfeeding. If they ask for your opinion then sure go ahead but it can be a sensitive topic for some people who aren't able to for various reasons. I know the benefits of breastfeeding but would definitely formula feed any other children I have. I don't judge or try to impose my opinion on anybody.

NerrSnerr · 20/11/2021 22:11

@Abitlost2

Of course human babies should drink human milk, it's full of antibodies, protects them and the mother against many illnesses. Is it easy? No. Do bf babies wake up a lot more? 100 percent.

Of course some mother's can't bf but it's a tiny minority. If the amount of mothers who say they can't bf really can't the human race would have died out years ago.
But you can't say this...

It's not that simple though. Lots of people don't have support from others who have knowledge of breastfeeding or good professional support. I did manage to breastfeed but my mental health was in tatters after really struggling to establish breastfeeding with my eldest. It was massively painful, she didn't sleep for more than an hour at a time for months, she lost weight so we had to express and do top ups etc. I did end up continuing breastfeeding but now she's 7 I wonder if she'd have had more benefit from having formula and a mum who was utterly exhausted because even if it didn't improve her sleep I could have at least shared it.
Tabbacus · 20/11/2021 22:11

@DingleyDel

Do you also get your knickers in a twist about all claims made on packaging? Or just infants’ food?

Generally just infants food. Because they need food to stay alive and be healthy. Infants have no voice so historically corporations haven’t given a shit what is best for them. No one died from not have 100% longer lashes, lots of infants have died from false formula marketing claims. And currently in the U.K. a lot of parents are struggling to meet the cost of formula (as cited in a gov. Report). This is a product that costs pennies to produce. When you pay £8 for a tub, you, the parent
are paying for their false advertising campaigns.

Care to back up your claim that lots of infants have died from false formula marketing claims?
Tabbacus · 20/11/2021 22:08

@DingleyDel

Do you also get your knickers in a twist about all claims made on packaging? Or just infants’ food?

Generally just infants food. Because they need food to stay alive and be healthy. Infants have no voice so historically corporations haven’t given a shit what is best for them. No one died from not have 100% longer lashes, lots of infants have died from false formula marketing claims. And currently in the U.K. a lot of parents are struggling to meet the cost of formula (as cited in a gov. Report). This is a product that costs pennies to produce. When you pay £8 for a tub, you, the parent
are paying for their false advertising campaigns.

It costs more than pennies to produce, there are very, very specific guidelines manufactures have to follow- both ingredients wise and in the manufacturing process but yes of course they turn a profit. The law prohibits first formula from ever being on offer, and as they cannot advertise, brands that are cheaper aren't allowed to scream "hey, we are so tightly regulated in this country that I'm more or less the same as that one you're paying more money for!". Perhaps it would be better if money invested in breastfeeding support so that those who wanted to could access it, but also if the sale of formula was looked into. BFing rates are never going to reach 100%, some are always going to use it, so why not try and address issues like the price and misinformation, because at the moment the enforcement of a blackout only really harms women who are using formula, and lack of support those who want to breastfeed- shitshow all round. No doubt though if the government made formula and sold it at cost price many would complain it was corrupt, so it is what it is I guess.

Good to see lots of fellow vegans on this thread though, or is the argument it's weird for a baby to drink milk from another mammal just for when they're small?

JunoMcDuff · 20/11/2021 22:07

Is it easy? No. Do bf babies wake up a lot more? 100 percent.

I'd disagree with both these points in my experience!

Breastfeeding came easy to me. DC2 slept better than any baby I've known or heard of.

FTEngineerM · 20/11/2021 22:05

You’re choosing the example carefully there Del, lots of people have died from eating carcinogenic foods that aren’t ‘labelled’ as carcinogenic. Plenty of info out there about it if anyone wants to look, yet the packaging suggests these foods are healthy.

I mean I’m not going to suggest that breastmilk isn’t the biological ideal, because I’m not a plonker but if people have switched to/started on formula the packaging seems to be a bit of a weak argument when you consider the world we live in.

Abitlost2 · 20/11/2021 21:59

The formula lobby is so strong.

Abitlost2 · 20/11/2021 21:58

Of course human babies should drink human milk, it's full of antibodies, protects them and the mother against many illnesses. Is it easy? No. Do bf babies wake up a lot more? 100 percent.

Of course some mother's can't bf but it's a tiny minority. If the amount of mothers who say they can't bf really can't the human race would have died out years ago.
But you can't say this...

DingleyDel · 20/11/2021 21:53

Do you also get your knickers in a twist about all claims made on packaging? Or just infants’ food?

Generally just infants food. Because they need food to stay alive and be healthy. Infants have no voice so historically corporations haven’t given a shit what is best for them. No one died from not have 100% longer lashes, lots of infants have died from false formula marketing claims. And currently in the U.K. a lot of parents are struggling to meet the cost of formula (as cited in a gov. Report). This is a product that costs pennies to produce. When you pay £8 for a tub, you, the parent
are paying for their false advertising campaigns.

FTEngineerM · 20/11/2021 21:41

So tell me more about how formula companies can’t possibly make false claims?

Do you also get your knickers in a twist about all claims made on packaging? Or just infants’ food?

I mean I had a matcha tea for breakfast.. I’m expecting great things tomorrow, what was it the bumf said, 4 times the calories will be burnt yehaw.

Don’t make me laugh, people have been loose with the truth on packaging since packaging began. It’s not new and it’s not confined to formula.

DingleyDel · 20/11/2021 21:29

False advertising claims can land companies in a lot of trouble with the Advertising Standards Authority

It would be nice if it did. Yet we still have formula here advertised with pre and probiotics, formula to ‘cure’ allergies. Yet..there is no evidence to back up these claims. The opposite in fact. So tell me more about how formula companies can’t possibly make false claims?

DingleyDel · 20/11/2021 21:23

Watch the lecture and then comment. Helen Crawley and her charity provide extensive info. on formula (not the actions of someone who is anti formula). Formula companies are no ones friend.

Jujujuly · 20/11/2021 21:18

@AngelDelight28 the speaker is from First Steps Nutrition - they are independent, impartial and evidence-based. Whether the baby friendly initiative is impartial or not is irrelevant.

Magicalwoodlands · 20/11/2021 21:15

No pump is as effective at getting breast milk from breasts than a baby.

Jujujuly · 20/11/2021 21:13

I exclusively breastfed two babies for over a year (obviously they started eating solids, but they never had formula because they wouldn’t accept bottles). I tried very hard to pump with both of them and never ever got more than 1oz. I had a perfectly adequate milk supply but pumps had basically no effect.

I see time and time again on these threads women saying they couldn’t breastfeed because they had no milk, because they couldn’t get anything out with a pump. Of course some people do have no/low milk supply but it will be a much smaller proportion than those who thought they did, but just didn’t get on with pumping.

Before I had my first baby I thought you basically just hooked yourself up to a pump and it would all flow out, like a cow 🤣. I can imagine if I hadn’t had good support and confirmation that my baby was actually getting milk the tiny dribbles I was producing would have terrified me.

There is so little cultural knowledge/understanding about normal bf experiences these days and I think that’s a major barrier.

AngelDelight28 · 20/11/2021 21:08

@DingleyDel Lol, the Baby Friendly Initiative is literally an initiative to promote breastfeeding. So obviously they have an agenda to have a speaker like this.
False advertising claims can land companies in a lot of trouble with the Advertising Standards Authority, including hefty fines, so you can always report formula companies if you feel they've made false claims.
Its highly unlikely in this day and age, in the UK, though. The advertising of formula is now as strictly regulated as the likes of tobacco and alcohol. Even though it's not actually a harmful product.
I've found the false claims and old wives tales told to me by lactation "experts" and midwives far more damaging tbh. Lots and lots if "advice" out there that isn't evidence based.

Italiandreams · 20/11/2021 20:52

Love the idea of having a ‘baby moon’ with a toddler!
When my second was born they wouldn’t let me go home until she was consuming a certain amount of milk, my milk hadn’t come in yet so that couldn’t happen through breast feeding alone, and once she was used to the bottles she didn’t what to spend time on my breast first.

Sparklingbrook · 20/11/2021 20:51

Back in 2000 I used to buy Aptamil formula at a discounted rate from the GP surgery, on the advice of my Health Visitor.

DingleyDel · 20/11/2021 20:45

As for the dramatics of "formula companies don't care about babies and women's health

They most definitely don’t. Formula in this country is fairly well regulated but even so nothing like as regulated as people think. They can still make completely false claims on the tub. If you can be arsed, watch this lecture. Helen Crawley runs an impartial charity dedicated to infant nutrition.

Silverclasp · 20/11/2021 20:38

@AngelDelight28 in fairness Nestle are really evil.... even if you take the infant formula/dead babies scandal out of the equation they are still evil.

OP posts:
AngelDelight28 · 20/11/2021 20:32

Also, breastfeeding is only "free" if we don't place any value on women's time, effort and mental health. The £50 per month I spent on formula was well worth it for the peace of mind that my baby was getting enough to eat (I posted further down about difficulties with supply) and for the improvement in my mental health.
As for the dramatics of "formula companies don't care about babies and women's health", don't be ridiculous. Formula is one of the most strictly regulated products out there, to ensure it's a nutritionally complete food for babies. There are very strict laws about what ingredients can be used and in what proportion, and how it's advertised.
Yes, the companies make profit, obviously. So what, they're supplying a product that there's demand for and they aren't going to do that for no profit.
Breast pump companies, lactation consultants, supplement manufacturers etc also make a profit. In fact there's a whole cottage industry around breastfeeding that makes money out of selling hope (often false hope) to desperate women at the most vulnerable time of their life...women who've been guilt tripped by the "breast is best" messaging and are desperately trying to make BFing work at the expense of their mental health. But sure, breastfeeding is "free" and formula companies are evil Hmm

Jouleigh · 20/11/2021 20:26

@WorraLiberty

To be honest if you posted that, I'd wonder why you bothered?

The majority of people really don't give a shit how others feed their kids. Only a small amount of people tend to get offended by these things IME, and they're generally easy to offend anyway.

But no-one likes a preacher, especially on social media. It's just boring.

I didn't breastfeed, I was judged. Honestly when your kids are teenagers and adults no one remembers. Do what you want when you want. Just don't tell others they are wrong and get on with your own life.
AngelDelight28 · 20/11/2021 20:08

@Yoyomelon Actually there is. (White) British women are generally of Anglo Saxon descent and Croation women are south Slavic. There are genetic differences, plus differences in lifestyle and diet. Maybe these differences affect breast milk supply, maybe not. There are actually very few global studies that have looked at how genetics and lifestyle can influence supply. It's still unknown exactly what causes low supply, there are only guesses. It's a hugely under researched area and a large % of those involved in the breastfeeding support world don't even want to acknowledge it exists.

ShadowKitty · 20/11/2021 20:07

Not sure if this perspective has been covered but if I saw a post on Facebook about the positives of breastfeeding then it probably would have encouraged me to persevere when I was in the thick of it and struggling. I felt like giving up a few times in the early days as I found it hard.

People kept telling me to stop and it was my own fault they didn't sleep, I was a martyr, etc etc so positive stories and scientific info were helpful to me in terms of keeping on with it because I really did want to do it.

Everyone's reception to this kind of info will be unique to their personal experience I think.