Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
MeanWeedratStew · 21/11/2021 22:09

Sorry, I'm not trying to take it personally. I just think the OP is well-meaning but clueless and, honestly, a bit patronising in her assumption that women who don't BF just need more information on the wonders of breastmilk. Lack of information is NOT the reason so many of us give up. Then other posters come in with "but only a tiny minority of women can't do it, I don't believe all these women who say they couldn't, they made a choice..." etc. With attitudes like this, it's no wonder women who struggle feel so alone.

Anyway, I'll just say this and bow out: if breastfeeding rates are low overall, then there are wider issues at play. Many posters have pointed to lack of support, and that's what needs addressing, not "educating" women on what they already know.

Cameleongirl · 21/11/2021 22:01

@Abitlost2

Ok you can say it but get abusive comments thrown at you. I believe the vast majority can bf but don't , how else would humans be able to survive. But absolutely , there needs to be more education and support re bf to help mother's who want to do it. I agree re pumping, i ebf all ny babies but pumping produced very little.
If I hadn't pumped (electric pump), my supply would've dried up as DD was having so much trouble sucking. I hope my experience isn't the norm, but I still don't know why my healthy baby couldn't suck properly -there was nothing wrong with my supply - I could bf, DD was having the problems.
Magicalwoodlands · 21/11/2021 21:54

I’m sorry it upset you @MeanWeedratStew and I am sure no one wanted to do that, but a discussion about breastfeeding isn’t personal to you or anyone and I honestly do not feel that you should take it as such.

MeanWeedratStew · 21/11/2021 21:39

I should never have clicked on a BFing thread. I'm now in floods of tears as the memories of my failed attempts assail me. Stupid of me, I know, but BFing was honestly one of the most disappointing and upsetting experiences of my life, yet with each new baby, I tried again, hoping this time I might crack it.

If you were able to do it, then well done you, but please know that simply giving information about the benefits of BFing is not going to raise BFing rates. We know it's better, but that doesn't help us if we're facing problems with no practical advice or support.

If you had no issues breastfeeding, then you have no clue what it's like for those of us who did. I really hope some of you can swap your judgement for compassion.

FTEngineerM · 21/11/2021 17:30

It definitely does seem like it gets received as an attack if you ever mention breastfeeding, mention you have or mention you what to. I agree with the OP. I really don’t understand why though, nobody cares what nappies I use or what bath products I use, whether I burp or not.

I was on a thread not long ago and someone said the completely neutral statement of ‘formula changes the gut flora’ and people were absolutely raging something like ‘are you saying I’ve hurt my baby’s gut blah blah’. People lose all perspective when it comes to talking about what their tits secrete.

If someone feels like they’ve done a good job by battling through challenges to breastfeed, congratulate them like you would anyone else proud of anything.

I fed my first son for 8 months, my second for 1 month. I’m not having anymore babies but theoretically I would breastfeed again if I ever had more. I found it physically easy to breastfeed and there was never a supply or latch issue to overcome.

I do find it a little baffling when I see women going through hell trying to breastfeed and then enjoy a yoghurt or nice milky drink with a friend. Why is it such a hot topic when you introduce dairy to your child? Nobody seems to care when I introduced beef, sauerkraut or mustard.. just dairy.

Mostly kellymom and La leche league are to blame for the passion and blinkered views when it comes to BFing. They encourage night wakings, even up to ten times a night with our first and they encouraged it as normal, I should just try and get through itwrong, he had an intolerance which they ignored. The Facebook groups are littered with jovial competitions on how many times your little one woke up last night. In reality not many can sustain that with western life.

pollypokcet · 21/11/2021 16:03

Well obviously breastfeeding is physically possible for most women, but it can be very hard to establish. Yes, breastmilk is imperative for survival in infancy, biologically. So the mechanism generally works well - as in the vast majority can lactate.

In the old days people had no choice. Either you can afford a wet nurse, you exhaust breastfeeding or your child dies. Infant mortality was mostly attributed to disease and poor conditions than inability to lactate (maybe I'm wrong, but I think these were more significant).

In today's world we don't need to suffer with the pain of breastfeeding. If our baby doesn't latch, we have a good alternative.

Bottom line is- breastfeeding is generally possible. We don't have to pretend otherwise. But not wanting to do it is fair enough,

StarfishDish · 21/11/2021 16:02

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

It always surprises me that breastfeeding rates are so low in the UK yet so many also say there is lots of pressure to breastfeed. How can there be if formula feeding is clearly the norm? It doesn’t marry up for me.

For those of us who've experienced it, it marries up perfectly. If you're struggling to BF you get very little support but a lot of information thrown at you which outlines the benefits - as if that will mean you just magically find a way to do it. There's nothing incompatible about this at all. In fact, I actually think the focus on 'education' is one cause of low BF rates.

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee 100% agree. I remember telling the midwife I wanted to go home as I was getting no support in helping me to BF and I told her my views that I'd had all along; I'd try BF but if it didn't work for either me or baby, she'd be straight on formula. She told me that I had to show 3 feeds before she'd even think of discharging me. I'm so grateful my DH was there as he told her I'd be feeding our daughter twice - whether I chose BF or FF and that was my choice - and then he would be coming back to collect us. I was in absolute tears as I was so frustrated at the lack of help. Even when I was discharged, I had to watch a BF video even though I physically couldn't BF!
5128gap · 21/11/2021 14:54

While there's no denying that BF is optimum, i think the evangelical approach shown by some is a reflection of their inexperience, both of the difficulties faced by other mothers, but also of child rearing. There are countless women who have lived experience of raising robust, healthy secure children all the way to equally healthy adulthood having not BF. Yet relatively new mothers (of BF age children) have become the self appointed experts, creating anxiety and misplaced guilt amongst other women and invalidating their experiences. How you feed your child is a tiny part of the child raising journey, and a little perspective is called for.

Mindareno · 21/11/2021 14:53

@Abitlost2

Ok you can say it but get abusive comments thrown at you. I believe the vast majority can bf but don't , how else would humans be able to survive. But absolutely , there needs to be more education and support re bf to help mother's who want to do it. I agree re pumping, i ebf all ny babies but pumping produced very little.
The word “can” is doing a lot of heavy lifting there though. Presumably you mean they “can” as long as they are prepared to put up with an unlimited amount of physical pain and exhaustion, and disregarding their mental health.

I breastfed my first baby. My second baby came in lockdown. She had an awful tongue tie and there were no services to get it sorted. There were no breastfeeding clinics on. She was losing weight and the midwife said if she didn’t start to gain she would be readmitted. I was in such pain with the feeding even a month in I was too distressed to look after either child properly, and my husband as a doctor was out working all the hours you’d imagine in a pandemic. I accept there is probably no physical reason that it would be impossible for me to breastfeed. I think it is very dismissive to simply say that I could have but I didn’t.

The same is true of many women who have a very difficult journey with breastfeeding - maybe they didn’t have a medical issue, but it would have taken an intolerable toll on them to continue. Well done to anyone who breastfeeds successfully, as I did first time, but please understand it is harder for some women than it is for others.

Teacupsandtrainers · 21/11/2021 14:05

how else would humans be able to survive

Well lots of them didn’t did they, not just due to no formula (we’ve clearly made many advances in health and sanitation in addition to this). We know people had more children because not all of them would survive. Wet nursing and earlier weaning were also more prevalent and historically feeding infants animal milk appears to have been around for at least 3000 years.
Breast milk is best for babies however it would appear that not breastfeeding for whatever reason isn’t unique to modern women.

Abitlost2 · 21/11/2021 13:46

Ok you can say it but get abusive comments thrown at you. I believe the vast majority can bf but don't , how else would humans be able to survive. But absolutely , there needs to be more education and support re bf to help mother's who want to do it. I agree re pumping, i ebf all ny babies but pumping produced very little.

Tabbacus · 21/11/2021 13:30

@DingleyDel

I think I’ll trust a well respected scientific journal over fedisbest.org to be fair. This is starting to sound like an antivaxer thread!
Because people like reputable sources for claims that don't seem to have any? Again, breastfeeding has tonnes of amazing benefits and is incredible, but on these threads there are always random facts and figures that aren't true, if the same was being same of breastfeeding I'm sure many would be vocal of wanting to see the research. Still can't see in the lancet where they pulled the hypothetical figures from, and how they have assumed breast feeding as the prominent breast cancer factor rather than part of the same puzzle.
Mindareno · 21/11/2021 13:18

@Abitlost2

Of course human babies should drink human milk, it's full of antibodies, protects them and the mother against many illnesses. Is it easy? No. Do bf babies wake up a lot more? 100 percent.

Of course some mother's can't bf but it's a tiny minority. If the amount of mothers who say they can't bf really can't the human race would have died out years ago.
But you can't say this...

You can say it. You mean that you can’t say it without sounding like a complete arse, and people pointing out to you that you sound like a complete arse.
pollypokcet · 21/11/2021 13:05

@Glassofshloer

I’ll say it again, if you’re truly pro-choice on this issue, then there is no ‘right’ percentage of bfing women. Just let other people make their own decisions and stop being so nosy.
Ah this is the same argument as ' you must approve morally of all abortions/at any point or you're anti choice'

I don't think your point is true. You can think breastmilk is ideal but still think fed is best. That's my position. Ultimately I don't care how anyone's child is fed, but on a nutritional level, yes, breastmilk is better. It is part of evolution so of course it is, and formula is literally supposed to mimic breastmilk. Also, babies are going to prefer snuggling a warm breast as they feed.

This is only objective though. I do not care, I've never even asked another mum how her baby is fed.

Peaplant20 · 21/11/2021 11:06

Agree with the last post. I think the pressure comes from health professionals sadly. It’s the first question any doctor, midwife or health visitor asks you - are you breastfeeding? And if you say yes you get a big nod and smile of approval and a well done! I very much felt that as pressure to continue in the early days rather than encouragement as there wasn’t any actual support to help keep me going. The only support I can access is half an hour drive away from me run by volunteers, when you have a baby who hates the car that’s very difficult to access! There’s the national breastfeeding helpline but it’s not the same as face to face support. There’s also a lack of places to breastfeed out and about unless you’re completely comfortable doing in public (not me), and some feeding rooms that do exist consist of a small cubicle with a hard wooden chair in it! There’s also a massive lack of understanding in the general public about what breastfeeding a baby on demand entails. I’m one of the first in my friendship group to have a baby and went to a wedding recently and everyone assumed I could just leave my baby with my parents for the day. So these are just some of the examples of how there’s pressure to breastfeed but no actual support to go alongside it.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 21/11/2021 10:10

It always surprises me that breastfeeding rates are so low in the UK yet so many also say there is lots of pressure to breastfeed. How can there be if formula feeding is clearly the norm? It doesn’t marry up for me.

For those of us who've experienced it, it marries up perfectly. If you're struggling to BF you get very little support but a lot of information thrown at you which outlines the benefits - as if that will mean you just magically find a way to do it. There's nothing incompatible about this at all. In fact, I actually think the focus on 'education' is one cause of low BF rates.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 21/11/2021 10:08

[quote Jujujuly]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee I was never really engorged either (certainly not painfully so) and never ever leaked. But my babies put on weight, had the right no of wet and dirty nappies and were alert. Someone on a bf helpline told me that there’s a muscle in your nipples and if it’s very tight (just a fluke of anatomy) then pumps basically don’t work, but the sucking action of a baby is completely different, so I think that’s what it was in my case.[/quote]
That's interesting. I am learning a lot from this thread about BF challenges, including the diabetes info someone just posted. I think if you were engorged at all that is quite different than some women but more, this makes me think that the info we are getting out about BF tends to focus on hammering home the benefits and not on any of this stuff, which is really remiss. My lactation support said one issue was my flat nipples and large breasts. I vividly remember her saying 'imagine trying to latch onto a football' whilst visually demonstrating (on an imaginary ball). I don't know if pre-warned would have meant I could have done something (pull nipples out????) before things deteriorated. There were problems with both my kids sucking too - they were weak sucker and never got a good seal (maybe due to my anatomy?). The pumping for me was not really aiming to get anything much out and I never got enough to feed them with. It was supposed to be stimulating supply.

Glassofshloer · 21/11/2021 09:41

I’ll say it again, if you’re truly pro-choice on this issue, then there is no ‘right’ percentage of bfing women. Just let other people make their own decisions and stop being so nosy.

Glassofshloer · 21/11/2021 09:40

@Boobicoosg

I hear you OP. For what it’s worth, well done for breastfeeding, the very best thing for your baby if you can do it. Big emphasis on the if, and I do have compassion for anyone who couldn’t for whatever reason. It always surprises me that breastfeeding rates are so low in the UK yet so many also say there is lots of pressure to breastfeed. How can there be if formula feeding is clearly the norm? It doesn’t marry up for me.

And yes I write this at 2.30am breastfeeding 😂 and yes I am happy to read of the thymus benefits. Thanks for the post.

Because a lot of women just don’t want to, and given the health difference is negligible, what does it even matter?

I would understand the push if bfing was noticeably superior to ff but it isn’t.

DingleyDel · 21/11/2021 09:25

I think I’ll trust a well respected scientific journal over fedisbest.org to be fair. This is starting to sound like an antivaxer thread!

RidingMyBike · 21/11/2021 08:42

The 800,000 lives saved claim is really dodgy.
fedisbest.org/2017/07/the-lancet-nonexistent-magic-breasts-could-save-800000-lives-per-year/

RidingMyBike · 21/11/2021 08:39

I also think BFing promotion should be reviewed for the claims they're making - I remember thinking if it was a product I'd be sueing the manufacturer for making outrageous untrue claims!

Ironically I boycotted Nestle for decades before having my baby and distrusted the formula companies hugely, yet it was the BFing professionals who could lie without any consequences.

RidingMyBike · 21/11/2021 08:36

Baby Friendly is an utterly despicable organisation. They don't collect stats for babies readmitted because of BFing problems in their accredited hospitals, all they care about is raising BfIng rates, and penalising hospitals that offer formula. Even though this is harming babies (including mine). They also deny parents info about formula - if you say you want to BF their guidelines mean you won't get access to info or support about formula - yet most parents will say they want to BF because everyone knows it's 'best' and they don't get informed about any of the risks because Baby Friendly means only positive info is presented. It also means that parents end up using formula in an emergency (as we had to) with no idea what they're doing - I'd never sterilised anything in my life - what to buy etc.

I'd far rather parents were given the pros and cons of EBF, EFF and combi, the risk factors for not being able to EBF (which affects over 1/5 women at least initially so not insignificant numbers).

I attended a weekly obstetric diabetes clinic during the third trimester - each week loads of talk about how vital it was I BF as it would mean my baby wouldn't be diabetic (this isn't even true) but not one HCP mentioned that diabetes is a big risk factor for milk delay and low supply.

DingleyDel · 21/11/2021 08:36

The figures and the report are from the Lancet, not Unicef or the BFI. Im sure they have the papers to back up the claim. Or are we going to claim the lancet has a secret agenda?

AliasGrape · 21/11/2021 08:20

*despite WANTING to desperately