Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
DeadButDelicious · 18/11/2021 18:09

I breastfed for a grand total of 3 days. And I hated it. I knew right from the first feed that it wasn't for me. So we switched to formula and feeding became a joy, she was happy, I was happy, win win.

I can't say that I've ever thought that much about how other women feed their babies to be honest. As long as the babies are being fed and cared for I'm not too fussed about whether it comes from a boob or a bottle. I'm well aware of the benefits of breastfeeding and I definitely think we need more support for those who wish to do it.

If someone were to share an article about the benefits of breastfeeding on social media I wouldn't personally feel shamed, I gave it a go, didn't like it, so used the perfectly good alternative, case closed as far as I am concerned. I would roll my eyes and wonder why they posted it though and I can definitely see how someone who really wanted to breastfeed and couldn't could be upset by it. It just comes off as a bit preachy and smug to be honest. Especially if it's because you think they just need to be 'educated'. If you really want to improve rates maybe you could train as a peer supporter as a PP suggested?

Ileflottante · 18/11/2021 18:09

I had the privilege of both being able to bf and having the financial ability to get a lactation consultant

Well there you go. You’ve been very privileged. Learning about T cells from a 25-year-old study is not helping or ‘informing’ anyone is it? Who is going to see ‘the error of their ways’ because of your link?!

Basically you’ve had a pretty straightforward breastfeeding ‘journey’ (that you’ve likely mistaken for your own achievement, when it was probably luck) and you feel buoyant about it and can’t see why everyone else can’t do the same as you…

I’ve never felt ‘silenced’ about BF, I just don’t feel the need to talk about how I fed my child. Nor about how I clothed them, got them to sleep, what nappies I chose, etc.

I don’t actually think it’s BF vs FF, I think it’s just that some mothers are preachier than others. You sound like one of them.

LadyoftheWoods · 18/11/2021 18:08

I wouldn't be offended but I wouldn't bother to click and read the article either. I know the benefits of breastfeeding, is there any woman who's had a baby who doesn't?? We're told repeatedly during pregnancy and the first few days, and so we should, I don't disagree it's the best option.

However it's not repeatedly hearing how great bf is that will increase bf rates, it's actual practical support. I desperately wanted to bf and tried for 3 weeks with my first dealing with incredible pain and him not gaining any weight while all the HCPs said I had a great latch. Eventually I became actually depressed at my failure and my bond with him was seriously affected. It turned out he had a serious tongue tie that finally got snipped when he was 12 weeks. Just look on the infant feeding board to see all the women at their wit's end and desperate for help. I really don't think reminding them of how wonderful bf is will be of any use whatsoever.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 18/11/2021 18:07

@Namechangetimes100 balls to your opinion too.

I went to BF workshops, I had great support getting established in hospital, my midwife was pro BF, I went to a BF group and found a huge support network there. My GP was amazingly supportive as DD1 had reflux and the easy fix would have been putting gaviscon in a bottle. All of this despite having no family or friends who had experience to help me. I appreciate I was lucky as you clearly haven't been supported.

However if I have ever tried to post my success story on a forum I have repeatedly been told I'm wrong, there's no support. it's weird, it's exhibitionism, it's smug. So I stand by MY opinion.

GodKnowWhut · 18/11/2021 18:02

Well I'd just think why would you post it other than to imply breastfeeding = better than formula feeding.

People can do their own research on whether or not breastfeeding is for them.

If there was some article to say, for example, mothers who formula feed are less stressed and therefore bond better in the early days than breastfeeding mothers, I wouldn't post it because why would I? I'd rightly look like I was just trying to prove something.

(I'm not suggesting my example is true it's just an example for a comparison!).

MaskingForIt · 18/11/2021 18:01

[quote Silverclasp]@MollieMaeve maybe if ppl knew the benefits it could help them with their decision?[/quote]
FFS,EVERYONE KNOWS the benefits. It’s not like you’ve suddenly made a magical discovery.

Babdoc · 18/11/2021 17:59

I get rather tired of breast feeding zealots shaming depressed exhausted new mothers who are already upset about their failed milk supply, or who chose to bottle feed to fit their personal circumstances.
I'm a retired doctor and baby boomer. My generation was majority bottle fed and is the healthiest, longest lived generation in history.
The benefits of breast feeding v bottle are minimal in the UK, and undetectable by adulthood.
I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.

ThreeFeetTall · 18/11/2021 17:58

I can't seem to read the whole text, only the abstract...which says "The cause of this difference is unknown".

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:56

@CeeceeBloomingdale this!

OP posts:
MaskingForIt · 18/11/2021 17:55

Imagine a SM post telling poor people that fresh meat and vegetables are better for their children than frozen chicken nuggets and canned vegetables. How do you think they are going to feel? Are they going to magic up the money to buy fresh meat and veg, or are they going to feel a bit shit that they can’t do the best for their children?

That’s how being hammered with Breast Is Best information feels to women who wanted to breastfeed but couldn’t.

Throckmorton · 18/11/2021 17:54

That article is from 1996. By now any topic of that age has either been superceded or gone mainstream. If there is a large body of literature on this and its established scientific fact then it will already be informing the advice people get on breast feeding: ie it improves the immune system. Therefore you don't need to share the article as people already know the main take home message. Unless your mates are immunologists, they won't care by what parameters the improvement of the immune system was measured by.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 18/11/2021 17:53

@HeartsAndClubs

It’s smug and self righteous, and literally nobody cares once the baby gets to about 3 or so.

I was unable to breastfeed, I actually never produced milk.

I didn’t go and seek support because as long as my baby was fed I really didn’t care that it wasn’t able to be through bf.

And let’s be honest, while people bleat on about the health benefits of bf, no-one ever seems to talk about the negatives, the effect on women’s mental health when they are unable to put the baby down for hours and hours and hours, and the guilt they feel because they should be constantly feeding.

I know more than one woman who attributes her post natal depression to the fact that she breastfed and felt that she should be breastfeeding, and who say that as soon as they gave up and switched to formula. But if anyone started posting about that they would be shot down for not being pro bf.

BF has benefits, but it has an awful lot of downsides as well, and these should be recognised as well.

Smug Self righteous No one cares Bleat Causes post natal depression Constantly feeding

So many negative words and phrases, you sound angry and bitter. I completely disagree. All you see is people talking about the negatives, if you try and share a positive experience you are labelled smug, self righteous etc. Honestly your post is illustrating precisely why people feel unable to talk about BF.

zoemum2006 · 18/11/2021 17:52

In my experience women who formula fed had a better relationship with their baby’s dad and we know how much better it is for children to grow up in a two parent family.

SEE it’s really * obnoxious isn’t it?!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/11/2021 17:50

@HeartsAndClubs

It’s smug and self righteous, and literally nobody cares once the baby gets to about 3 or so.

I was unable to breastfeed, I actually never produced milk.

I didn’t go and seek support because as long as my baby was fed I really didn’t care that it wasn’t able to be through bf.

And let’s be honest, while people bleat on about the health benefits of bf, no-one ever seems to talk about the negatives, the effect on women’s mental health when they are unable to put the baby down for hours and hours and hours, and the guilt they feel because they should be constantly feeding.

I know more than one woman who attributes her post natal depression to the fact that she breastfed and felt that she should be breastfeeding, and who say that as soon as they gave up and switched to formula. But if anyone started posting about that they would be shot down for not being pro bf.

BF has benefits, but it has an awful lot of downsides as well, and these should be recognised as well.

Why’s it smug?
SickAndTiredAgain · 18/11/2021 17:50

Given the general shit posted on SM, I’m not sure why so many people are saying “but WHY would you post it?”
Why does anyone share an article on SM - I assume because they think it’s interesting. I don’t really use fb so would never post an article, but people post all sorts of nonsense without having to examine their deep motivations for it.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:49

Just for the record I wasn't chomping at the bit to post the article. I just found it interesting that I wouldn't post it out of fear of offending someone, when if it was another scientific article about something else I was interested in I would prob have posted it.
I just wanted to see others opinions and whether they feel the same.
I do find in interesting that ireland where I live has the lowest bf rates in Europe but the support here is non existent. I had the privilege of both being able to bf and having the financial ability to get a lactation consultant.

OP posts:
ThreeFeetTall · 18/11/2021 17:49

Does your article about this gland thing know the difference between correlation and causation, because 90% of the stuff that was pushed on me as a new mother did not. See also, 'evidence' that it is bad that breastfeeding rates are low in this country because in the developing world babies die due to poor sanitation Confused

user14943608381 · 18/11/2021 17:49

@CeeceeBloomingdale

Unfortunately BF rates will never increase as the very minute you try and share a positive experience there will be 10 others telling you you're making them feel bad for not BF or not wanting to BF. It's a shame women can't support other women regardless of feeding decisions, I felt like my feeding choice was either ridiculed, belittled or silenced.

The key thing to successful BF is to have support and advice from women who have experienced it positively. As most women who BF are silenced at every opportunity the support isn't there. BF is not the norm any longer sadly.

Balls! You’re putting the blame on mothers and it doesn’t belong at their door. It’s at the door of HCPs. The midwives and support workers who in hospital after delivery, refuse to provide feeding support, the midwife on the day 5 visit who says a painful latch is normal but baby has lost 10% weight so needs to ‘top up’, the HV who can’t be arsed and says well just give formula it will be fine, the GP who says formula is best, the dentist who says breastfeeding rots teeth, the paediatrician who advises early weaning due to nightwaking. Not to mention the utterly backwards culture the UK has towards breastfeeding and this weird children should be seen and not heard mentality.

Breastfeeding support is rarely sign posted to and often is the preserve of the wealthy.

You can understand why some women feel tremendous shame about not getting as far in their breastfeeding journey as they’d wanted. The support is not there, but it’s not other women who are the real problem. Women are being let down, yet again by HCPs.

This is why breastfeeding isn’t common place.

I’ll get off my soapbox now

HeartsAndClubs · 18/11/2021 17:48

It’s smug and self righteous, and literally nobody cares once the baby gets to about 3 or so.

I was unable to breastfeed, I actually never produced milk.

I didn’t go and seek support because as long as my baby was fed I really didn’t care that it wasn’t able to be through bf.

And let’s be honest, while people bleat on about the health benefits of bf, no-one ever seems to talk about the negatives, the effect on women’s mental health when they are unable to put the baby down for hours and hours and hours, and the guilt they feel because they should be constantly feeding.

I know more than one woman who attributes her post natal depression to the fact that she breastfed and felt that she should be breastfeeding, and who say that as soon as they gave up and switched to formula. But if anyone started posting about that they would be shot down for not being pro bf.

BF has benefits, but it has an awful lot of downsides as well, and these should be recognised as well.

itsjustnotok · 18/11/2021 17:44

Tbh I think people love to be offended and will find a way to feel discriminated against if they feel so inclined. It doesn't matter what the topic is, you will find offense has been found somewhere.

Chichichiwawa · 18/11/2021 17:44

I mean ... Do you really think women will think "i was going to formula feed but as breastfeeding has a slight chance of giving my baby a few more t cells, I'll breastfeed instead". Women don't breastfeed because of t cells. They breastfeed because they want to, their body produces the milk and they have the support to do so.

Wouldn't it be a better use of your time volunteering to help women who can and want to breastfeed to be able to do that? That's would be a tangible useful thing you could do to improve breastfeeding rates, with women who actually want to talk about breastfeeding instead of lecturing women who don't want to hear it.

Posting these things on Facebook to "inform" women who can't or don't want to breastfeed is just really pointless.

Porfre · 18/11/2021 17:43

I wouldn't be offended at all.
Post to your hearts content.

I'm not interested though, so wouldn't respond to your post.

But if you plaster it all over and keep posting the same things over and over, if you keep spamming the same message over and over, you'll probably find yourself blocked by me.

user14943608381 · 18/11/2021 17:43

@Silverclasp

Grin fair enough thinks it's clear I was being unreasonable for asking the question
If you genuinely want to be supportive of breastfeeding not just come across as a bit of a show off or one of those holier than thou mums, maybe train as a peer supporter? You can go to peoples homes or attend groups or even take a few calls? I think that’s more supportive.

Or if SM posts really are your ‘thing’ why not maybe post something about accessing the right support for breastfeeding. You know highlighting infant feeding teams as an amazing free resources, IBLBCs, tongue tie and what the signs and symptoms of that are? Again, more helpful

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:42

@Throckmorton There have been many studies about this from what I can gather it's widely known throughout the scientific community but I wasn't aware until a doctor I follow posted it. The way it was phrased in this article didn't help either hence why I didn't share.

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8888912/

OP posts:
Frezia · 18/11/2021 17:42

@CeeceeBloomingdale

Unfortunately BF rates will never increase as the very minute you try and share a positive experience there will be 10 others telling you you're making them feel bad for not BF or not wanting to BF. It's a shame women can't support other women regardless of feeding decisions, I felt like my feeding choice was either ridiculed, belittled or silenced.

The key thing to successful BF is to have support and advice from women who have experienced it positively. As most women who BF are silenced at every opportunity the support isn't there. BF is not the norm any longer sadly.

Agreed.