Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 18/11/2021 20:34

@lawnotorder

There's a way to explain a positive experience knowing not everyone has one though.

How should one do it? with a caveat after the positive experience?

I had two very unremarkable births. If pregnant friends ask me about my experience I tell them but I point out how lucky I was.

If they asked about my horrendous BF experience I would tell them all about it but probably also say that they should give it a go because you never know until you try and some people find it very easy.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 20:29

There's a way to explain a positive experience knowing not everyone has one though.

How should one do it? with a caveat after the positive experience?

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 20:28

@Throckmorton

You are just being pedantic. What the previous poster said was pretty accurate in layman's terms. Babies saliva goes back through the nipple and is essentially analysed by the woman's body and if virus etc are detected breastmilk is changed accordingly. It's amazing.

OP posts:
Throckmorton · 18/11/2021 20:25

[quote Silverclasp]@Tabbacus

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4556682/[/quote]
That article does not support the statement made by a previous poster that the nipple analyses the baby's saliva and adapts the milk accordingly. It says that breast mink and baby saliva interact in synergistic ways. Which is fascinating, but not the same thing.

IncompleteSenten · 18/11/2021 20:24

I think you'd have to be pretty dim to not know that the milk produced by a mammal is normally the best food for that mammals offspring. Kittens - cat milk. Puppies - dog milk. Babies - human milk.

Acknowledging that fact is not a criticism. It's not an attack on anyone. It's simply a fact

And it's also a fact that formula is perfectly fine. Better in some cases if for example the mother is taking medication that makes her milk unsuitable.

If she can't or doesn't want to breastfeed for whatever reason, we are so lucky to be able to have a good substitute. Formula gets the job done which is what matters. Baby gets fed. Mum is happy. All is good.

Puppies get adopted by cats and drink cat milk. Kittens get adopted by dogs and drink dog milk. Hell, I saw a YouTube video of a cat raising ducklings and they were latched on good and proper.

People need to stop feeling defensive or guilty about something there is no need to feel either of those things about.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 20:23

@Chichichiwawa you don't agree with science?

OP posts:
Sparklingbrook · 18/11/2021 20:23

Any positivity is labelled as shaming, or boasting

Bit of a blanket statement. I've seen posts that are both positive and supportive. There's a way to explain a positive experience knowing not everyone has one though.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 20:22

I totally agree with this post. I think we are in a place culturally where it’s considered judgmental or offensive to state facts which someone else might find uncomfortable or hurtful

This & it's scary!

Someone told me off a thread because I said Trump was still popular with some. He is! It doesn't mean I like that he is or Im a supporter, it's simply stating a fact.

I don't understand why saying breastfeeding is better is offensive etc

It should be okay for people to disagree and to make different choices, without there being an inference that there is any judgment attached to that.

Absolutely, would it have been the ideal thing for me to breastfeed for 6 months? yes. was it ideal for my circumstances & life? no. Im fine with that.

Chichichiwawa · 18/11/2021 20:20

I think mothers are the wrong primary audience for the benefits though. We should be shouting about the benefits of breastfeeding and better postnatal support to government, health boards etc, employees and everyone else about making society a friendly place for all mothers of newborns, most of whom want to breastfeed.

I don't agree that breastfeeding is particularly important. I totally agree with this though. Society is set up to discriminate against women with children whether they breast or bottle fed and that's what needs to change. Families should be properly supported to look after their children.

Bagamoyo1 · 18/11/2021 20:19

@Sparklingbrook

I don't think MN does hate breastfeeding really.

It's not hard to post a positive experience but also acknowledge it isn't like that for everyone.

If at the ante natal group I attended I was warned that things might not be a walk in the park I'd have been a bit more prepared when I had difficulties.

Any positivity is labelled as shaming, or boasting.
Hystericaluterus · 18/11/2021 20:17

@JunoMcDuff

Any time you provide the scientifically proven positives of something you are perceived as shaming those who have not followed that path for whatever reason.

People seem incapable of being able to accept they may have chosen a path based purely on preference, and that it may not have been "the best" in an objective sense, but worked best for them. It's like they always need to be right or seen to be doing the best, when people chose things for lots of reasons with no shame. Drives me fucking nuts.

My feelings exactly.

I am only on page 3 of the thread but so far the negative responses prove the OP’s point

Also, as a different PP pointed out. The benefits of BF are often underplayed - essentially to make people feel better about their preference to stop breastfeeding.

Obviously it’s every woman’s choice and it’s got nothing to do with me. But I wish that it would be acceptable to say: it’s ok sometimes not to do what’s objectively best, but to do what’s ‘best’ or even just ‘good enough’ for the specific circumstance.

Chichichiwawa · 18/11/2021 20:17

People always seem to come back to national breastfeeding rates being low. So what? Why do you care what other women do with their breasts? Why's it any of your business? Breastfeeding really isn't that important in the grand scheme of things you know.

Sparklingbrook · 18/11/2021 20:15

I don't think MN does hate breastfeeding really.

It's not hard to post a positive experience but also acknowledge it isn't like that for everyone.

If at the ante natal group I attended I was warned that things might not be a walk in the park I'd have been a bit more prepared when I had difficulties.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 20:14

@Tabbacus

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4556682/

OP posts:
Puppyseahorse · 18/11/2021 20:14

@AvocadoOrange

Some of the answers to this thread show that people are ignorant of the benefits of breastfeeding...the evidence it's healthier is overwhelming. Stating that as a fact isn't shaming- it's what science shows.

I think mothers are the wrong primary audience for the benefits though. We should be shouting about the benefits of breastfeeding and better postnatal support to government, health boards etc, employees and everyone else about making society a friendly place for all mothers of newborns, most of whom want to breastfeed.

No, the evidence isn’t overwhelming from a statistical standpoint. The evidence is mild. As @Namechangetimes100 pointed out, BF mothers tend to be wealthier/ have higher socioeconomic status, which creates a correlation between BF and good long term outcomes. That said, I still chose to BF as I liked the bonding element.

Emily Oster’s Cribsheet has a great chapter on this and a good explainer around statistics and drawing conclusions from them.

Just10moreminutesplease · 18/11/2021 20:14

@Silverclasp

I just found the article really interesting and was like "wow everyone should know this" but then stopped myself from sharing because I didn't want anyone to get hurt or think I was a preachy twat.... which clearly given the responses on this post I would have Smile
If you shared the article on social media I would definitely think that you were a preachy twat.

The pressure to breastfeed 100% of the time is causing so many women to breakdown and quit entirely. And the whole ‘breast is best’ brigade is responsible for so making so many women feel like shit. Women’s mental and physical health still matters once they become a mum and I’ve listened to enough of my friends cry over this, thanks.

As an aside, I truly believe that a less pressured approach (and normalisation of combi-feeding!) would result in happier mums and more breastfeeding overall.

MrsSkylerWhite · 18/11/2021 20:14

I’ve never understood why anyone feels the need to tell anyone else how they chose to feed their child.

Bagamoyo1 · 18/11/2021 20:11

As a rule, MN hates breastfeeding. If anyone posts a positive experience they’re jumped on. And bombarded with “my kids were all formula fed and they all went to Cambridge” lectures. And if you dare to say it’s the best thing for the baby, you’re just plain evil.
I was nagged constantly by the women in my baby group to give up breastfeeding. It really pissed me off.

Bancha · 18/11/2021 20:10

@JunoMcDuff

Any time you provide the scientifically proven positives of something you are perceived as shaming those who have not followed that path for whatever reason.

People seem incapable of being able to accept they may have chosen a path based purely on preference, and that it may not have been "the best" in an objective sense, but worked best for them. It's like they always need to be right or seen to be doing the best, when people chose things for lots of reasons with no shame. Drives me fucking nuts.

I totally agree with this post. I think we are in a place culturally where it’s considered judgmental or offensive to state facts which someone else might find uncomfortable or hurtful. I do think that BF vs FF is an area where this is especially true. Breastfeeding is objectively better all round, that’s a fact. But stating that is considered shaming or offensive, when it’s neither. It’s just true. More broadly, I think we need to become a little less sensitive as a society. It should be okay for people to disagree and to make different choices, without there being an inference that there is any judgment attached to that.

At the same time, whilst I know objectively that breastfeeding is best, I would always support a mother’s choice about how to feed her own baby because what is objectively best, statistically, may not be what is objectively best for an individual (and her baby).

I’ve also read a lot of responses questioning why OP would want to post that article on social media. But I feel that question can (and should, ha!) be applied to pretty much any post on social media. Are social media posts often driven by anything other than people’s egos, and ideas of how they want to present themselves?

Tabbacus · 18/11/2021 20:10

I didn't know that my nipple analyses my baby's saliva and adapts to what they need

Because it doesn't?

suzyscat · 18/11/2021 20:08

I didn't know even a tenth of benefits of breastfeeding until I was several months in.
And I didn't know the one from your article either.

I hate that any form of interest in this amazing thing our bodies do has to be silenced for fear of insetting people. I understand that new mothers are vulnerable and it's hard, but women's bodies have long been left behind in scientific and medical research and discussion and we shouldn't silence ourselves.

I don't care how anyone chooses to feed their baby. Breastfeeding needs to be normalised, as does combi feeding and bottle fed, but we can't do this by staying quiet. (Yes both breastfeeding and bottle feeding mothers feel alienated and judged)

I didn't know that my nipple analyses my baby's saliva and adapts to what they need.
Going thick colostrum like when they're sick and thinner when they're thirsty.

I didn't know breast milk cleared up baby's goopy eyes.

I didn't know that fussing at the boob was upping your supply ready for a growth spurt.

Acknowledging and sharing these amazing things doesn't have to be at the expense of anyone else. We're all just trying to get through the day.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 20:07

@Frezia this is exactly it. Even if a newspaper shares a study showing breastfeeding in a positive light the comment section is just full of "stop shaming mums" "fed is best" etc.
It literally cannot be mentioned without backlash.

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 18/11/2021 20:04

I breastfed 2 children. I believe it has some benefits (although not huge in developed countries) but I also believe people should be able to justify their own choices and shouldn't be offended by being informed of the benefits. E.g. by midwives or GP etc.

However I do find the preaching on Facebook quite offensive - not because of the information presented but because of the preachy nature of it.

Frezia · 18/11/2021 20:02

Demanding better BF support from public healthcare system would indicate we believe breastfeeding was important, but also we shouldn't publicly talk about breastfeeding being important or actually talk about it at all in a positive sense. No wonder we can't get anywhere.

Tabbacus · 18/11/2021 20:01

Ah a tale as old as time. Something in this country is ducked in relation to infant feeding, breastfeeding rates are through the floor, everyone feels shame or guilt for how they feed, and there's inadequate support across the board for new mums to be honest.

Invariably though what kicks threads into high gear is when people start commenting directly on say formula feeding, so instead of saying I felt really close to my baby when breastfeeding, there's always 1 that says omg you won't bond as well if you ff. There are also all sorts of random claims that aren't backed up by science, and everyone gets defensive.

Information should be bountiful along with support for all women, so they can make an informed decision and have the physical and emotional support to embrace whichever works for them. Breastmilk might be the best for example nutritionally, but formula feeding might be best for a family- neither are poison or harmful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread