Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
Kendodd · 18/11/2021 22:15

Interesting isn't it, even the language we use around breastfeeding seems to be shaped not to upset formula feeding mothers. We talk about the health benefits of breast feeding rather than the negative health consequences to the baby and mother of giving formula. We always say, for example, breast fed babies suffer fewer ear infections, never, formula fed babies suffer more ear infections.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 22:06

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee well I would have complained about someone who implied it.

LouiseLaChain · 18/11/2021 21:59

Love a smug AF breast feeder.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 21:57

@WhyMeLord no I was equating people not being informed with people not being informed. That particular study I wasn't aware of, and lots of ppl on this post also said they didn't know about it even those who were seasoned breastfeeders.
I'm not saying that even with all the information ppl would choose any different (those that have a choice) I just mean that they are entitled to have all the information before making their decision.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/11/2021 21:55

@lawnotorder

I honestly doubt that for most of the things you can't do in life, there are health practitioners and peers following you around for months telling you you're a failure for not doing them.

No one should call you a failure. I would have put in a complaint about any staff that did that.

You don't have to use those exact words to 'say' it.
WhyMeLord · 18/11/2021 21:53

[quote Silverclasp]@Chichichiwawa because given the benefits to both mothers and baby I think that ppl are entitled to make informed decisions. They need the information to be informed.[/quote]
The problem is that you are equating a person not making the same decision as you with them being ill informed. The same happens with voting and the 'anyone who voted differently to me is ill informed and did so due to a bias in the mainstream media' brigade. It couldn't possibly be that people can have the same information and having thought about it, then come to different conclusions.

cherrypie66 · 18/11/2021 21:52

This has been done to death now. Just feed your babies the way you want to it really makes zero difference it's really annoying

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 21:47

I honestly doubt that for most of the things you can't do in life, there are health practitioners and peers following you around for months telling you you're a failure for not doing them.

No one should call you a failure. I would have put in a complaint about any staff that did that.

WorraLiberty · 18/11/2021 21:47

There's a lot of evidence that exclusive breastfeeding reduces the risk of obesity- and I think a lot of the people concerned with breastfeeding are also concerned with baby food marketing.

Not if you're going to feed your kids adult sized portions and constant snacks etc, without seeing they get enough exercise to burn it off.

63% of adults are overweight or obese. If they can't get their own weight under control, all the breast milk in the world is unlikely to help keep their children slim and healthy into adulthood.

Milk is such a tiny part of good feeding habits.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 21:45

@Tyrantosaurus exactly!

RobinPenguins · 18/11/2021 21:41

I honestly doubt that for most of the things you can't do in life, there are health practitioners and peers following you around for months telling you you're a failure for not doing them.

Especially when the impact of not doing them is so marginal in the grand scheme of things.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 21:40

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee I certainly haven't ever called anyone a failure for not breastfeeding and that's all I can do. I can't control health practitioners and I can't change the science.
I don't post anything about Breastfeeding because I don't want to hurt any of my friends.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/11/2021 21:39

And just to say as mothers we all get nasty unsolicited advice constantly and it's not ok.

Cool, we agree. We need to make sure then that sharing thoughts/ new info about breastfeeding is not doing it in an unsolicited advice kind of way. Currently it is absolutely done in that way.

Babyboomtastic · 18/11/2021 21:39

@ConfusedBear

There have been studies which have attempted to look at causation rather than correlation by comparing siblings that had been ff and bf, as they are both to the same families, same socio- economic group, same opportunities, likely diet when older etc.

The results were that there was an advantage to breastfeeding, but only in a few areas, and they were very small. Less tummy bugs and ear infections basically, but none of the other 'benefits' were found. So more important in poorer countries, pretty marginal in the UK.

Wealthier parents tend to have children with better outcomes in life in general. Breastfed children may be slightly healthier, but using the same correlation, so are those who go abroad at least twice a year. It's really important not to assume causation just because there is a correlation.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/11/2021 21:36

[quote Silverclasp]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee I know that some people cannot breastfeed.... there are lots of things I can't do that others can. That's just life.[/quote]
That's not really the point though, is it? You said about people making more informed choices - which suggests that you think that people are choosing not to breastfeed as they don't understand properly. Given how abusive the breastfeeding police can be, there is a need to be sensitive about this. Sure, share articles. I think breastfeeding is fascinating and personally I'd like a whole heap more research into why some women just can't and some women find it so easy. I'd like proper help for women who want to and I'd like much more info about the benefits and risks. But all of that needs to be done sensitively given how much some women have been traumatised by the judgements they've suffered. All I'm saying is you need to stop blindly thinking this is really a choice much of the time. Then you can start to share things in a more sensitive way.

I honestly doubt that for most of the things you can't do in life, there are health practitioners and peers following you around for months telling you you're a failure for not doing them.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 21:33

And just to say as mothers we all get nasty unsolicited advice constantly and it's not ok.
Here is some unsolicited advice I have been given.....
"Don't sleep train it is damaging" "you need to sleep train babies need their rest" "if she has teeth she's too old to breastfeed" "why are you still feeding?" "Babies need to sleep in their own bed" "cosleeping is best for baby" "you need to wean she'll still be bf when she's going to uni"

My little one does sleep in her own room but I wouldn't be offended if someone shared a study on the benefits of cosleeping.

OP posts:
Dazedandconfused28 · 18/11/2021 21:30

I wasn't able to breastfeed & my mental health took a serious dive as a result in the first few months. I even said to my husband 'what is the point in me?'

I'm not an idiot - I knew breastfeeding was the ideal, but as a doctor pointed put to me, it was not ideal for my baby to starve.

I think most women are well aware of the benefits - having them repeatedly reiterated to me just reinforced the fact I was failing my baby.

Tyrantosaurus · 18/11/2021 21:30

@lawnotorder

I get it's upsetting if you really wanted to do it and can't, but that's the same with literally anything in life.

This is what I get confused about as many people do & have things others can't do everything potentially is insensitive. Eg buying their own home, taking their kids on a trip of a lifetime, sending their dc to private school etc

Or even having kids in the first place.

Yep. Infertility was the first thing that sprang to mind. I also imagine it's much more heartbreaking than not being able to breastfeed yet we don't hide our children. Bottom line is employ common sense, but that doesn't mean a blanket ban on breastfeeding talk.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 21:27

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee I know that some people cannot breastfeed.... there are lots of things I can't do that others can. That's just life.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/11/2021 21:22

OP the fact that you are talking about BF as a choice and thinking that more info will help people make an informed choice suggests you are struggling to understand that for some women it's not really a choice. The incessant refusal to believe this leads to a lot of nasty and judgemental things being said to women who can't do it.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 21:19

I get it's upsetting if you really wanted to do it and can't, but that's the same with literally anything in life.

This is what I get confused about as many people do & have things others can't do everything potentially is insensitive. Eg buying their own home, taking their kids on a trip of a lifetime, sending their dc to private school etc

Or even having kids in the first place.

DeepDown12 · 18/11/2021 21:18

I had to stop BF after only 2 weeks because I was hospitalized and put on very strong medication due to an infection I picked up whilst giving birth. I still feel guilty about not BF DD who is turning 2 in a month. And information about BF was literally rammed down my throat while I was pregnant and once she was born by midwives, hospitals, pharmacies, nosy neighbours, relatives, friends... who all thought that 'If only I understood the benefits of BF surely I'd choose what's better for my child'. So yeah, unless you were a scientist in the field or a medical professional whose job was to inform me about it - I'd be irritated by your post and probably unfollow you.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 21:17

Which is the key thing not to do.*

Agree, your friend sounds a bit crap tbh.

Maybe it's not what posters say it's the way that they say it. People on MN posting for BF support are very often feeling very low about it already.*

I posted a few times because I did some pumping & also combi fed & did find that info quite hard to access elsewhere. I find it very helpful.
If someone had popped up on my thread & told me not to do & only bf then yes I would be annoyed.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 21:15

@Tyrantosaurus exactly! People always post pictures of themselves with their kids on mothers day and I'm sure ppl going through infertility find this difficult.
But if I posted a photo of me breastfeeding on World Bf week I'd be accused of shaming, being smug, being insensitive etc.

OP posts:
Throckmorton · 18/11/2021 21:13

Dietary recommendations tend to come from expert sources though, eg government guidelines. I think the bit people find galling is when it's some random on SM telling them stuff about how to feed their baby. People would look askance at someone who started posting info on vegetables on SM - breastfeeding is the same. I don't hear anyone on here objecting to medical personel giving info on breastfeeding, just on non-experts telling them about it