Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
LazJaz · 18/11/2021 23:01

I think at some level each “side” of the debate might be quite envious of the other at certain points,” and so look for ways to feel good about the compromised choice that had to make (because even if your combi feed that is still a compromised choice)
Then again, maybe that’s just me?

PurBal · 18/11/2021 23:01

I have a health problem that could have been exacerbated by BF and my obstetrician advised it might not be possible. Seeing posts about positive BF made me feel like utter shit because there was a good chance my body couldn’t do “what it’s designed for”. I consider myself lucky that as it happens I can BF but it wasn’t an easy journey.

Thecurliestwurly · 18/11/2021 22:58

I've extended breastfed two kids for at least 2.5 years each and my biggest annoyance is that nobody discusses the negatives of breastfeeding. And there are a lot of them!

I had an easy ride starting breastfeeding, but it's a shit experience most of the time. Some of my issues are

-shit sleep
-no help from partner for nightfeeds
-not being able to go anywhere without the baby in the early stages if they refuse bottle
-cluster feeding spells when young
-biting when they are older
-People being arseholes about you breastfeeding and saying you are 'making a rod for your own back' and all that crap
-It's also really hard to stop a habit in a child that is used to having it there all of the time, particularly in the night, but no advice as to how you can wean off breast - only 'dont offer, don't refuse' which is probably the most useless advice ever.
-people who have never breastfed telling you that you can just tell the child no When you want to wean (can't do this without a massive meltdown, which I don't have the time or energy to deal with as a FT working parent
-did I mention the complete lack of pumping facilities/spaces in workplaces too?

The reason so many give up early is nobody forewarns people that it is quite hard sometimes. I think we actually need to be honest about breastfeeding and understand it is not always compatible with modern life/working mothers. We need to encourage mix feeding as a solution, instead of a formula vs breast approach.

Given that I've spent six years of my life breastfeeding, I consider myself a well experienced breastfeeder and this is my biggest frustration. It's become a badge of honour among some women, who only preach about the benefits, but don't understand that for a lot of women (even ones like me who have breastfed a lot) it is a negative experience. So even people like me would be annoyed at the preaching of the benefits without being honest about the negatives too.

heliosunburg · 18/11/2021 22:55

@Tonyschoco

And here I think is the issue, most people don't have the mental resilience to breastfeed

Wow.

Tbf it's hard in the early days when your nipples are cracked and bleeding and boobs are engorged. The pain of contractions when breastfeeding a second born child.

I was so close to giving up with dc2. Pp wasn't having a go imo

Throckmorton · 18/11/2021 22:52

Why do people care how other people feed their babies? It's not like the difference between bf and ff is so massive as to constitute harm, so why do you care? As someone above said, it just seems like a way to divide women and/or gain kudos for your own choices.

Kendodd · 18/11/2021 22:47

I made myself ill trying desperately to breastfeed both my children. I knew the benefits. I haven't forgiven myself 8 years later. I don't even know what t-cells are but trust me, I knew 'breast is best' thanks.
Why? I just don't get the guilt about bf. There are loads and loads of things we do as parents that are less than perfect, why does bf hold this special place?

user14943608381 · 18/11/2021 22:45

@RealBecca I’m not too au fait with plastics but aren’t most bottles BPA free?

I was going to say well chilled bags of breast milk that are warmed in warm water should be ok then (which is what i did) but then the bottles themselves were sterilised at one point and same with the bottles you express into. Ah gah minefield. I’m a little worried now about my use of plastics in my infant feeding journey. I’m expecting my second any day now so it’s something top of my priority list. I’m going to do some research on this.

I agree with your point on being informed, but often the groups that spout ‘informed and supported is best’ are coming out with woo about breastfeeding and harp on about the dangers of formula often when there is a v real risk of a baby becoming underfed. Completely agree that often the answer to a mum struggling with BF is ‘oh just give formula then’ because it’s frankly easier than providing any real support, ‘just give formula’ could have been the slogan of my breastfeeding journey with DD, every single sodding health professional was so woefully undertrained and Ill informed about breastfeeding it was like a chorus of ‘give formula’. If someone had spent the time observing a feed and looking at a latch they could have spotted a tongue tie and that would have been the first step to resolution. At one point, i even got threatened with social services if I didn’t stop breastfeeding. (To clarify DD never dropped centiles but she was SGA so didn’t catch up as quickly as they wanted)

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 22:43

@lawnotorder yes to all of this!

OP posts:
JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 22:42

And I'm not anti formula. But I am massively pro informed decision making.

Ileflottante · 18/11/2021 22:42

This thread sucks. These threads always suck. Ironically.
And it proves how women are often women’s own worst enemy sometimes. Certain people are banging on about ‘support’, while actively seeking to divide women and mothers into BF vs FF.

IT DOESN’T FUCKING MATTER. LEAVE OTHER PEOPLE’S TITS ALONE.

lawnotorder · 18/11/2021 22:42

Why would you tell people you felt proud of yourself though? Seems an odd thing to bring up in conversation

Is it odd to be proud of something & share it. Ive seen people proud at passing their driving test, getting a degree or qualification, losing weight, running a race, proud about kids achievements, getting a new job, so many different things.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 22:41

@Ginger1982 if you were proud of something you wouldn't mention it to anyone? Job promotion, Ran a marathon, Painted a picture etc
Some people like to share when they have achieved something they are proud of.

OP posts:
JunoMcDuff · 18/11/2021 22:41

@Kendodd

This was actually a deliberate strategy by the formula companies - ie inverting the language to mask the fact that breastfeeding (ie the biological norm) is the default

How come they got to shape the language then?

Money. There's no money (or was no money) in breastfeeding - it was a skill passed down and supported by family and friends.

Formula companies came to mother and baby classes, antenatal classes, maternity wards. Women sales people in Dr style white coats, extolling the benefits of formula. Handing out free tubs, free bottles - just enough to allow mother's milk to dry up. Women were shamed out of breastfeeding. Couldn't they afford to give baby the best? Were they too poor? Didn't baby deserve everything science had to offer? It came at a time when there lots of amazing and genuinely revolutionary scientific breakthroughs (the pill, TB, diphtheria and polio vaccinations, emergency medicine etc) and the rode on the tailcoats of science being very positively perceived.

The history of formula companies marketing strategies is one of the best marketing ploys ever.

guardianegg · 18/11/2021 22:41

I made myself ill trying desperately to breastfeed both my children. I knew the benefits. I haven't forgiven myself 8 years later. I don't even know what t-cells are but trust me, I knew 'breast is best' thanks.

Tonyschoco · 18/11/2021 22:38

And here I think is the issue, most people don't have the mental resilience to breastfeed

Wow.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 22:38

@Kendodd I'm surprised this one hasn't been deleted considering how outraged some people have been at the mere suggestion that the biologically normal way for humans to feed their baby has benefits to it.

OP posts:
Ginger1982 · 18/11/2021 22:38

@EsmeSusanOgg

Breastfeeding was really difficult for me, but after a difficult pregnancy I really wanted to do it. Especially after people kept telling me to quit. So I'm proud of it as an achievement I had. But I felt super uncomfortable saying I was proud of myself, because people would then accuse me of shaming people who couldn't breastfeed. Or who decided to stop when I didn't. Which is not true. It feels like, especially as a woman, you aren't allowed to be proud of your own achievements/ to see something as a personal achievement without being told you should consider the feelings of everybody else and their brother!
Why would you tell people you felt proud of yourself though? Seems an odd thing to bring up in conversation.
loveisanopensore · 18/11/2021 22:36

I had to mix feed because of supply issues. We were lucky enough to be able to pay for a lactation consultant to help me carry on.

For the NHS to promote breastfeeding while you're pregnant and then provide really crap support post natal is cruel.

Kendodd · 18/11/2021 22:36

@Silverclasp
I wonder if you had started a thread saying formula fed babies suffer poorer health, if it would have been deleted because it upset to many people?

RealBecca · 18/11/2021 22:29

@Namechangetimes100 i think glass bottles do 100% mitigate it- its to do with the boiling water hitting the plastic realising a huge amount in one go.

I agree my first post sounded unkind and i felt bad about that and tried to clarify in my second post - the issue isnt personal choice, it's the lack of accessible information, support and societal support that should be available to make an informed choice. Its as unhelpful to rush to reassure someone with a feeding crisis that formula is an equivalent choice to breastfeeding but that person should at the very least have easy access to support and resources to make a choice that suits her and if that choice is formula thwn in no way is it helpful for people to discuss it after the fact. Its not helpful or kind to tell a mum who is already formula feeding that breast is best.

Kendodd · 18/11/2021 22:28

This was actually a deliberate strategy by the formula companies - ie inverting the language to mask the fact that breastfeeding (ie the biological norm) is the default

How come they got to shape the language then?

Jujujuly · 18/11/2021 22:25

@Kendodd

Interesting isn't it, even the language we use around breastfeeding seems to be shaped not to upset formula feeding mothers. We talk about the health benefits of breast feeding rather than the negative health consequences to the baby and mother of giving formula. We always say, for example, breast fed babies suffer fewer ear infections, never, formula fed babies suffer more ear infections.
This was actually a deliberate strategy by the formula companies - ie inverting the language to mask the fact that breastfeeding (ie the biological norm) is the default.

The woeful lack of funding and support for all new mothers in this country is a disgrace, and low breastfeeding rates are just one symptom of it.

CantStartaFireWithoutaSpark · 18/11/2021 22:25

I get annoyed at the breast is best army when it totally ignores that women have reasons for using formula, health and otherwise. It comes on very hot and heavy on Mumsnet, like a swarm of bees. It’s anxiety inducing.
Formula feed, breast feed, what ever. As long as your baby is fed, that’s best.
So no, OP, to provide debate or risk pissing people off, just don’t bother posting. It’s a very emotive topic, so just leave it.

mehface · 18/11/2021 22:21

@EsmeSusanOgg

Breastfeeding was really difficult for me, but after a difficult pregnancy I really wanted to do it. Especially after people kept telling me to quit. So I'm proud of it as an achievement I had. But I felt super uncomfortable saying I was proud of myself, because people would then accuse me of shaming people who couldn't breastfeed. Or who decided to stop when I didn't. Which is not true. It feels like, especially as a woman, you aren't allowed to be proud of your own achievements/ to see something as a personal achievement without being told you should consider the feelings of everybody else and their brother!
This 🙌 it is hard to get started and can be painful just as your body gets used to being sucked 24-7. And here I think is the issue, most people don't have the mental resilience to breastfeed. To avoid putting people off the NHS/ midwives don't really cover the issues there can be enough and formula is waiting to take over.

I'm very proud of breastfeeding and it was hard to start both times, and hard times being the only one that can feed them, but it's worth it to me.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 22:19

@Kendodd i even did this in my OP I said that the study was "breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies" but actually the study was "decreased thymus size in formula fed babies".

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread