Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
WillyWollyWandy · 18/11/2021 23:53

I suppose it’s the same reason why I wouldn’t post about the massive benefit of bottle feeding being that the mother isn’t tied to the baby and all the night feeds. Ultimately the subliminal message is that I, the poster, am trying to get people to bottle feed. And yet why would I do that. If someone asked me I’d extol the many virtues of bottle/formula feeding. But I certainly wouldn’t offer this information unless asked about my experience. Similarly you posting on SM about breastfeeding, you’re ultimately convincing others to do it. And possibly shaming those who can’t.

In the same way people who post about their vaginal pain free labours seem to imply that this the whole grail of childbirth, no matter how much they aren’t. I never see these same people raving about their pain free root canal.

thepeopleversuswork · 18/11/2021 23:51

@Siameasy

In my experience yes. It’s fine for someone to make adverse comments about BFers (I received many disparaging and defensive comments) but you are not allowed to state true facts about formula milk because someone will get offended.

Just shows the hold the formula companies have over everyone and the brainwashing that has taken place

Sorry but this is just balls. I've literally never seen anyone saying formula milk is superior to breast milk. On here or anywhere else. There can't be a person alive today who is unaware that breastfeeding has benefits.

The argument, which @Babdoc makes eloquently, is that the marginal benefits of breastfeeding in developed countries are usually not enough to justify the bullying of young mothers who are not given adequate support to breastfeed and find it very difficult.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:50

@JadeTrinket both are difficult for some people and both things you can be proud of.... there are lots of examples in the post above.
The person posting about being sober is not shaming those that drink, they are just proud of themselves for what they have achieved.
Similarly people who feel proud about bf should be allowed to be proud.... but you can't because you're a mum shaming, braggy, smug twatSmile

OP posts:
Siameasy · 18/11/2021 23:48

In my experience yes. It’s fine for someone to make adverse comments about BFers (I received many disparaging and defensive comments) but you are not allowed to state true facts about formula milk because someone will get offended.

Just shows the hold the formula companies have over everyone and the brainwashing that has taken place

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:46

@Luredbyapomegranate no I'm not a midwife, I work in Science though and there are lots of ppl in that field on my sm so would repost studies that I find interesting from time to time as do many of my colleagues/ friends.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 18/11/2021 23:45

@Babdoc

I get rather tired of breast feeding zealots shaming depressed exhausted new mothers who are already upset about their failed milk supply, or who chose to bottle feed to fit their personal circumstances. I'm a retired doctor and baby boomer. My generation was majority bottle fed and is the healthiest, longest lived generation in history. The benefits of breast feeding v bottle are minimal in the UK, and undetectable by adulthood. I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.
This is interesting to hear from a medical professional and what I've always suspected to be true.

I don't think its "unreasonable" to post this article exactly. But I would slightly wonder about the motivations of anyone who really thought anyone would have a lightbulb moment reading yet another no shit sherlock study about breastfeeding being marginally better.

As others have said, mothers who don't breastfeed don't either because a) they don't want to and don't care or b) because they found it unsustainably hard and decided it wasn't worth ruining their lives over (I fall into the latter camp). In neither scenario is posting yet another article about a marginal benefit of breastfeeding going to change a young mother's mind, all it is likely to do is increase anxiety and stress in someone who already has a ton of that to deal with.

So while not exactly offensive it's at best pointless and at worst tone deaf and insensitive.

JadeTrinket · 18/11/2021 23:44

@Silverclasp

If someone is sober for a year they can be proud of themselves and say to their friends "guess what I'm sober a year today and I'm really proud to have gotten to this point" and most people would say "well done! That's amazing. You're doing great". If I was to say "guess what! I'm breastfeeding a year today and I'm really proud to have gotten to this point" I'm being braggy, smug, holier than thou, shaming other mums.
It’s a pretty odd comparison, though — recovering from an addiction and breastfeeding your baby?
ConfusedBear · 18/11/2021 23:44

@Babyboomtastic thank you for sharing the outcome of that study. I was originally looking for quantified benefits to try and mitigate the negative effects of not breast feeding so it's reassuring to me that these effects are not as large as sometimes implied. It used to really frustrate me that the claims were never referenced or measurable.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:43

@Kendodd that's your decision to make.
There are many benefits to both mum and baby in an unmedicated birth. Noone is forcing anyone to do it one way or another, I'm just saying I think those that do it without pain relief are awesome because I found it so hard.

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 18/11/2021 23:42

Why would you post it on your social media? Are you a midwife?!

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:40

If someone is sober for a year they can be proud of themselves and say to their friends "guess what I'm sober a year today and I'm really proud to have gotten to this point" and most people would say "well done! That's amazing. You're doing great".
If I was to say "guess what! I'm breastfeeding a year today and I'm really proud to have gotten to this point" I'm being braggy, smug, holier than thou, shaming other mums.

OP posts:
Kendodd · 18/11/2021 23:39

I literally wouldn't say, 'I've got a new job, I'm really proud of myself.' Would you?

I would!

Kendodd · 18/11/2021 23:37

But why would I want to endure the pain if I didn't have to?

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:34

@Ginger1982 noone says it in that way but it's implied, look at this medal I won. Look at this picture I painted etc
There is nothing wrong with being proud of yourself.

OP posts:
Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:32

@Kendodd I have respect for them because I found it so painful and difficult I can't imagine doing it without pain relief. I'm not saying they are winners and I'm a loser for choosing the epidural.... I'm just saying I think they are awesome because they did something that I found too difficult to endure.
Haven't you ever had respect for someone who was able to do something you couldn't?
Like people who can do 100 pull ups or run a marathon..... I can't do those things but I think those that can are awesome.

OP posts:
Ginger1982 · 18/11/2021 23:30

[quote Silverclasp]@Ginger1982 if you were proud of something you wouldn't mention it to anyone? Job promotion, Ran a marathon, Painted a picture etc
Some people like to share when they have achieved something they are proud of.[/quote]
I literally wouldn't say, 'I've got a new job, I'm really proud of myself.' Would you?

Ginger1982 · 18/11/2021 23:28

"And here I think is the issue, most people don't have the mental resilience to breastfeed."

FFS 🙄

user14943608381 · 18/11/2021 23:24

@RealBecca nooooo don’t be silly, I just hadn’t thought, feel a little guilty and mad at myself about it now though. I’d seen a plastic world/ ocean too! I never made formula in the bottles, always breast milk so no hot hot water was ever put in but they were sterilised and my DDs water bottle is a plastic one. Balls!
I’m really glad you mentioned it though as I’ve done some reading and now bought a glass bottle for dc2 and a stainless steel water beaker for DD. If you hadn’t mentioned it we’d have probably carried on with the plastic ones, so shout out to you! Thanks! Now I just need to invest in cast iron pots and pans!

Oh btw SGA means small for gestational age (born under 9th centile) meaning she was measuring small throughout my pregnancy and had to be born early. Extra challenging breastfeeding a small baby…. Breastfeeding is blamed for everything but we did nearly 2 years

Kendodd · 18/11/2021 23:22

I have such respect for women who have given birth without pain relief though

Again, why?
Childbirth isn't some sort of competition with winners and losers. It's just about getting your baby out and hoping you both come though it safety.

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:12

@Bunnycat101 I agree with you.

I have such respect for women who have given birth without pain relief though, My god I was induced and lasted only 2 hours of contractions before I was screaming for the epidural.
I def wouldn't be offended if someone posted a study that showed the benefits of an unmedicated birth, I made my decision at the time and it was right for me.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 18/11/2021 23:08

@Namechangetimes100

BPA was banned but most plastic bottles are propylene and the tests were on those :(

Take a look at this, it gives an overview and some advice about heating or making formula in alternatives (presumably you can transfer them to the plastic bottles afterwards, i think its just the heating up thats the problem (i think its the same principal for heating up food in a microwave- dont use plastic)

www.verywellfamily.com/plastic-baby-bottles-shed-millions-of-particles-of-microplastics-5083893

I really hope i havent upset you or anyone, its just another problem thing the modern world- trying to do your best only to find theres another problem to deal with. I guess its that old phrase about a million people doing something small makes a big difference... If we all try our best, even if we dont always make the "perfect" choice (which doesnt exist) then overall things should hopefully turn out ok. Microplastics really scare me and are scarily unavoidable.

Im really sorry to hear about your journey, that all just sounds awful. I had the same experience RE just give formula. I absolutely swear they are just underresourced so badly they do anything to get us signed off the books. Im not sure what SGA is im afraid but i hope she is ok X

Bunnycat101 · 18/11/2021 23:06

Factual information is fine but sometimes it goes too far and people can become quite superior (same for birth without pain relief). I was incredibly well informed on the benefits, never intended to do anything else but was unable to breastfeed and felt like a massive failure. As the midwives gave no advice about formula, I was largely clueless (and see many people that are on safe preparation). Even going to the formula websites to get advice I was confronted by lots of messages re breast is best that were just irritating.

I agree with the post above that more information on mixed feeding rather than a polarised breast versus bottle would be helpful. I remember one of my friends being v irritated by the fact she didn’t count in the breastfeeding stats because of her one formula bottle a day for 6 weeks. She breastfed for well over a year with both of hers but felt it wasn’t ‘good enough’ for some because she hadn’t exclusively breastfed.

CantStartaFireWithoutaSpark · 18/11/2021 23:05

Yes @Thecurliestwurly everything you say is absolutely correct. Except no one else talks about this. It’s total taboo

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:04

@Thecurliestwurly
We crossed post but completely agree.
It can be wonderful and there are lots of benefits but it can also be really really tough.

OP posts:
Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 23:02

@heliosunburg it is really hard at the start and I think it doesn't help that people are not usually told that either, they don't want to tell women it's hard because it'll put them off breastfeeding but by not telling them it makes them feel like they are doing it wrong. I can imagine without adequate support I could have given up.

OP posts: