Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
AngelDelight28 · 19/11/2021 09:38

@shrunkenhead ThanksI had an almost identical experience. Despite trying absolutely everything and engaging with all the breastfeeding support available, I just didn't produce enough milk. Formula literally saved my sanity and my baby's life. If I hadn't FF she would have simply starved to death...which, ironically, would be the "biologically normal" thing to happen...survival of the fittest and all that.

OP, I wouldn't be offended at your post but I would inwardly roll my eyes. After my BF experience I did a LOT of research. There are thousands of women affected by low supply, which is one of the main reasons for quitting BF. No amount of information or links to studies will change that. I also find it ironic that BF advocates are so keep to "inform" women, yet all of the ones I dealt with during my BF days were uninformed about the issue of low supply, or didn't want to acknowledge it was a thing. Their advice was to keep expressing (even though it was making no difference and doesn't work for many women), or to co-sleep (very dangerous given how exhausted I was). A lot of their other "information" was also not proven by science but more like old wives tales...including the advice given to me by the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator about taking certain herbal supplements to increase supply (not evidence-based, and didn't work).
There is also no study out there that definitely proves being BF has a significant impact on a person's health outcomes over their lifetime, compared to FF, when you control for other factors.
Research into BFing in general is lacking, as it's a "women's issue" that was neglected by the male dominated medical profession until recently. Many of the studies are inconclusive, use self-selective or not large enough sample sizes, or only show a correlation, not causation.
If you enjoy BFing and it's working for you, great. Crack on, feel proud of yourself, whatever. Yes, it's natural and biologically normal, but biology and nature don't always work the way they're meant to. If a mother isn't able to BF for whatever reason or it's affecting her mental health, or simply doesn't want to, then FF is a perfectly healthy way of feeding her baby too.
It's the patronising attitude that FF mums are uninformed and need to be educated that winds people up, which is why there's the backlash.

Popcornriver · 19/11/2021 09:36

Can I just ask the poster who said formula is harmful to clarify please? I read a lot on breast milk vs formula milk when deciding whether or not to breastfeed and only found 'formula can be harmful' when it related to making it incorrectly. Or of course where clean water was unavailable.

lawnotorder · 19/11/2021 09:27

But as an arthritic middle-aged asthmatic, it doesn't matter how determined to climb Everest I am, it won't happen. Determination alone will not cut it and some of the BF propaganda doesn't recognise that

But I don't think "I was determined to do X" means if you achieve something others don't were less determined.

Kendodd · 19/11/2021 09:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/11/2021 09:21

I think someone who chooses to do it without it should be proud of themselves.

Yes, I think you are right here. But as an arthritic middle-aged asthmatic, it doesn't matter how determined to climb Everest I am, it won't happen. Determination alone will not cut it and some of the BF propaganda doesn't recognise that. IMO, anything which, in this day and age, tries to increase rates of BF by sharing information about its benefits is part of the problem. It is not based on an understanding of what the challenge actually is and it would be like incessantly telling me how lovely it is at the top of Everest, sharing pictures of the view, telling me about the buzz you get when you make it to the top. I might well believe all of that but clearly it makes it no more likely that this will increase my determination to the degree that I can get to the top.

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2021 09:19

Why do you consider her being proud of that as somehow taking away from other mothers?

Because she puts that down to her 'determination'. When women's births don't go to plan, it really isn't because they weren't 'determined' enough. It's because of body/baby issues that they have no control over.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/11/2021 09:17

I think someone who chooses to do it without it should be proud of themselves.

There we go again with that (what I'd say is) naive belief that much of this stuff is a choice. I think that is the nub of the problem here. IMHO you are overestimating how much choice people can really make in extreme situations. I didn't choose not to have an epidural with my second, I was just able to cope with the (much lower level of) pain.

lawnotorder · 19/11/2021 09:15

What about the women whose babies got into difficulty during Labour and interventions were needed to save their lives? Were they just not 'determined' enough in your eyes?

I think this is where the contention is.

If someone says they were determined to to pass their driving test or climb Everest & they did I don't think that means others who fail to pass their test or die climbing a mountain are less determined.

I don't see me failing my driving test & taking ages to pass as a lack of determination, it's just one of those things. I was determined, that's why I kept going!

Kendodd · 19/11/2021 09:14

I agree about labour being a lottery. I felt like I was on a runaway train and I had an 'easy' textbook birth. If I'd ended up with a CS instead that would have just been the route the train took.

Mumoblue · 19/11/2021 09:13

I think everybody knows about the benefits of breastfeeding, so it can come across as preachy.
I get that we have a poor breastfeeding rate in this country, but I don’t think it’s because not enough people have heard “breast is best!”
I think it’s because the support isn’t adequate. I got told my son’s latch was perfect, even though he kept pulling off and screaming and he was basically chewing my boob off. When I expressed a desire to pump instead, a health visitor implied that this would damage my “bond” with my son (how I wish I could give her a slap now- saying that to a crying new mum with bleeding tits, but I was too hormonal and upset to be anything but crushed by it).

And for the topic of unmediated birth, I never saw birth as something I had to endure, and pain relief as a sign that I couldn’t hack it. If I broke my leg I wouldn’t demand that I received no pain relief so that I could “feel it”.
I got an epidural because I wanted one.

Silverclasp · 19/11/2021 09:13

@TheKeatingFive this is exactly the problem that lady can't be proud of herself? She could have opted for a hospital birth and epidural but she didn't. Why do you consider her being proud of that as somehow taking away from other mothers?
We all have privilege in some regards but does that mean we can't be proud of ourselves for anything. I recently completed my PHD.... but I'm white, straight, come from a secure home, comfortable financially, don't have any intellectual disabilities so therefore I shouldn't be proud?

I had a straight forward birth, baby was in a good position and it was quick, but I still took the epidural because I didn't want to be in pain. I think someone who chooses to do it without it should be proud of themselves.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/11/2021 09:12

That doesn't take away from what anyone else has decided to do. But I do deserve to be proud and i don't feel I was just "lucky" it took a lot of determination for me to do.

The problem is that this can sound like you're saying that mothers who don't, have less determination. I had a very large amount of determination to BF both of mine but that still did not work. I spent hours researching how to, pumped incessantly to try and get my boobs to respond (as per advice - 4 hours a day to start with), begged for multiple appointments with a lactation consultant, tried a million different nipples creams (I'm allergic to lanolin), tried various teas to stimulate milk production etc. I was very determined. I got dribbles out with my first and in the end decided to just give her whatever drops came out as maybe anything would be a positive for her immune system. Sustenance was through formula though. 24 hrs after she was born, drs and midwives advised we had to cup feed her as no-one could get her to latch on. She was not interested and would sit there next to my nipple doing nothing. Even when I tried putting it in her mouth - nothing. My breasts never engorged and did not change size.

I don't mean to belittle your efforts. I know many people who had to try very hard to get feeding established. They worked hard. But alongside pride in your determination you should also be grateful for the stroke of much which meant your determination could be effective. You're not 'just' lucky, but you are lucky.

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2021 09:04

But I do deserve to be proud and i don't feel I was just "lucky" it took a lot of determination for me to do

What about the women whose babies got into difficulty during Labour and interventions were needed to save their lives? Were they just not 'determined' enough in your eyes?

Nanny0gg · 19/11/2021 09:01

[quote Silverclasp]@MrsSchrute I saw the article and thought it was interesting and sent it to my friends who are bf but didn't post it on sm for the reason that you outlined.
Just with the Breastfeeding rates as low as they are maybe if there was more discussions about the positives then maybe more people might choose to feed? I lived in Sweden for a while and there bf rates are really high. They have lots of TV campaigns about the positives of bf. I feel like that wouldn't happen here in case it offended ppl[/quote]
See, you're coming over all evangelical.

Mothers are surrounded by feeding advice and they can make up their own minds. They don't need you posting all over SM unless it'd a bf forum.

And I breastfed all mine. My choice

Tonyschoco · 19/11/2021 08:57

@RedRobyn2021 of course it was luck. Luck that during labour neither you nor your baby were in distress, necessitating medical intervention. Luck that your baby had no feeding issues. Not to piss on your chips but you eon the lottery in that sense. A woman whose baby’s heart rate dipped during contractions and who needed to be rushed to hospital for an accelerated birth to save the baby, was no less determined than you.

RobinPenguins · 19/11/2021 08:53

I had a straight forward birth despite the fact that I had my hospital ringing me constantly because my baby didn't come on her due date, meaning I spent the last 5 days of my pregnancy frightened and upset. I am enormously proud of myself for sticking to my guns and having my baby at home, for making an informed decision about what I wanted and sticking to it.

I’m proud of myself for setting aside my original preferences for “what I wanted” and making an informed decision to do some things I perhaps didn’t want to enable my baby to be born safely.

So much of all of this is about chance and luck. Most women are not high risk or otherwise because of anything within their control in any way. Why feel proud about luck?

Tabbacus · 19/11/2021 08:51

I had a straight forward birth despite the fact that I had my hospital ringing me constantly because my baby didn't come on her due date, meaning I spent the last 5 days of my pregnancy frightened and upset. I am enormously proud of myself for sticking to my guns and having my baby at home, for making an informed decision about what I wanted and sticking to it.

I don't think that's the issue, there are times when making an informed decision or having a medical one thrust upon you is for the best- literally lifesaving yet women are often still made to feel like its a second rate birth. It's great for those who have had the births they wanted, but it's not superior to anyone else, and not always a case of sticking to your guns.

MoreAloneTime · 19/11/2021 08:38

Its not offensive in of itself to share facts about the benefits of breastfeeding. That said I'm not convinced it's a good way to improve BF rates. I thought the statistics showed that the majority of new mums would start breastfeeding but then most of them would later stop, this implies they know the benefits as it's what made them start but that wasn't enough to help them continue.

I just hate the whole way we go about it. Its like we ramp up the guilt by forcing information onto women whether they want it or not but don't actually warn them about what it can really be like "in case it puts them off". Result, traumatized mums with painful nipples or supply problems who feel they have to keep going or else it will harm their baby.

For every fact sheet about IQ, infection or cancer I'd rather have had honest information about nipple pain and cluster feeding so I'd have been better prepared.

Sparklingbrook · 19/11/2021 08:19

You think breastfeeding in bed next to baby is more tiring then faffing with bottles?

I found I wasn’t sleeping at all with the baby next to me dreading them waking up and going through the trauma and pain of the next breast feed.
But I didn’t find bottles a faff either, just a welcome relief.

RedRobyn2021 · 19/11/2021 08:03

@Chichichiwawa

Being proud of yourself for having a straightforward birth is just ridiculous though. Birth is a lottery. It's not an achievement to have a vaginal birth without pain relief, any more than it is to have an elective section. It means that you had a birth that was luckily free of complications.

And this is the issue. Other women creating a societal expectation of what birth and raising a newborn is supposed to be, i.e a magical experience, with a straightforward vaginal birth and breastfeeding being the pinnacle. the suggestion therefore being that any woman who didn't "achieve" that didn't do her best, didnt try hard enough, wasn't mentally resilient enough.

It's bollocks, and it's all perpetuated by other women. Like the op.

I had a straight forward birth despite the fact that I had my hospital ringing me constantly because my baby didn't come on her due date, meaning I spent the last 5 days of my pregnancy frightened and upset. I am enormously proud of myself for sticking to my guns and having my baby at home, for making an informed decision about what I wanted and sticking to it.

I also have breastfed my daughter and that was also straight forward in the sense that I didn't have bleeding or mastitis, but psychologically for months it was extremely hard. Hard on me, hard on my relationship. So I am extremely proud of myself for managing to stick with it even though I found it hard.

That doesn't take away from what anyone else has decided to do. But I do deserve to be proud and i don't feel I was just "lucky" it took a lot of determination for me to do. Perhaps it comes more easily to some others I have no idea. But the point is, I'm ALLOWED to feel proud of myself because it was fucking hard and nobody else is going to be proud of me, are they?

lawnotorder · 19/11/2021 08:00

Being proud of yourself for having a straightforward birth is just ridiculous though. Birth is a lottery. It's not an achievement to have a vaginal birth without pain relief, any more than it is to have an elective section. It means that you had a birth that was luckily free of complications.

I think it's ok for women to be proud of giving birth if they want to, whichever way they did. People are proud of all sorts of things that are often just luck eg their bum or their hair.

heliosunburg · 19/11/2021 07:59

I suppose it’s the same reason why I wouldn’t post about the massive benefit of bottle feeding being that the mother isn’t tied to the baby and all the night feeds. Ultimately the subliminal message is that I, the poster, am trying to get people to bottle feed.

No different to saying how easy your vaginal birth/c section was and yet people do that. I wouldn't mind someone telling me how convenient formula is for them, truly. But maybe it's easy for me to say because breastfeeding/expressing worked out for me so I'm don't feel jealous or that it's a put down

Silverclasp · 19/11/2021 07:58

I get your points but after I had my daughter I kept thinking of my grandma giving birth to a giant headed baby after a 16 hour labour in a time when baby and mother mortality was so high. She must have been so scared, and I do have respect for her, I know women had no choice but because I found it so difficult i find it awesome that they did it without pain relief. Good to know every birth is different though maybe I'll be able to handle the pain next time (doubt it though haha)

OP posts:
heliosunburg · 19/11/2021 07:55

I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.

You think breastfeeding in bed next to baby is more tiring then faffing with bottles?

And if you're right that it is, surely that's more reason to applaud these misters for sticking with it?

shrunkenhead · 19/11/2021 07:54

I felt that I'd failed as so wanted to breastfeed, but only lasted weeks. I genuinely didn't have enough milk - my baby's weight dropped significantly so that we had to see a paediatrician - advice was to just keep feeding....I couldn't even Express more than 1 oz.
After 10 weeks I buckled and asked dh to buy some formula. I was so scared anyone would find out and think I was poisoning my baby. I think what is important to remember is that for new mothers it's a highly emotive issue at a v difficult time. Their bodies are healing, they are sleep deprived, they may have PND....
Prior to birth I was totally gungho to BF and couldn't see why I wouldn't. Afterwards I took every thing - from Breastfeeding posters on maternity dept walls - personally. Like it was actually directed at me and me alone.
As a pp said there are two camps - those that choose not to and those that really want to but (for whatever reason) just can't.

Sensitivity around both is needed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread