Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 10:42

@Popcornriver

Can I just ask the poster who said formula is harmful to clarify please? I read a lot on breast milk vs formula milk when deciding whether or not to breastfeed and only found 'formula can be harmful' when it related to making it incorrectly. Or of course where clean water was unavailable.
I'm not the poster. But I think it depends how you define "harm". Harm taken in a generally understood sense, then no, formula in the UK is not harmful - it's a nutritionally complete feeding substitute perfectly adequate for sustaining infants and babies allowing them grow in to healthy children and adults.

Harm is not the best word to use really as it's very emotive in common use.

If you are talking about 'harm' in a more scientifically specific context (e.g. less than ideal or not as intended), then there are 'harms' to gut flora, microbiome, the thymus glad etc. Which can have longer term concequences to health, particularly on a population level, which then impacts overall health care etc. But so do lots of things, so taken in isolation, the impact is likely to be minimal!

Sparklingbrook · 19/11/2021 10:40

I had 9 months maternity leave with DC1, spent (or wasted as it turned out) a month and a half of it trying to make breastfeeding work, and ultimately it didn't. Then after that spent a bit longer trying to get back to feeling myself while FF.

Italiandreams · 19/11/2021 10:37

@OlympicProcrastinator I really like the way you put that. I felt guilt for not breast feeding my second, but it was so difficult and I felt that it was having a massive impact on my first child and my mental health. So weighing everything up formula feeding felt the best option. Having read research and understanding that breast feeding does have an impact on babies health, but then also understanding the impact it would have on the development of my children if my mental health suffered and that of my elder child. I think most of us do everything we can to do the best for our children but every situation is different.

HarrietM87 · 19/11/2021 10:34

The pp who made the point about the breastfeeding relationship is absolutely right. If I had the choice between feeding my child formula from my boobs or breastmilk from a bottle, I’d definitely choose formula from my boobs, even though @Thecurliestwurly is totally right about all the downsides. It’s the feeling of closeness to my baby and everything that goes with that that makes it worthwhile for me. That is my own personal feeling about my own babies and my own circumstances, and not a comment on anyone else’s choices at all. However, in my experience saying anything about this does tend to infuriate people who haven’t breastfed.

heliosunburg · 19/11/2021 10:32

The short version is breastfeeding is not compatible with modern life. It works well for SAHMs, but not people like me who work FT and have had to struggle through

Not saying you're wrong but don't most people take maternity leave? I had to work from 2 weeks PP and still breastfed/pumped.

I think it's also good to say "you can do it" rather than be defeatist and say it's incompatible. Broadly, yes, but it's still possible for some

Italiandreams · 19/11/2021 10:30

I guess my question would be why are you posting it? What are you hoping it will achieve? Don’t mean that in an argumentative way, but I guess your intentions show if you are being unreasonable or not.

OlympicProcrastinator · 19/11/2021 10:24

RobinPenguins I’m not sure it does matter no. I haven’t done any research on that at all. Just in response to the OP that telling everyone about nutrition is pointless at this stage. We are all very well informed (I think) on that aspect. Like the example Thecurliestwurly offered and so many other PP’s there is so much more TO our feeding choices and ignoring that fact while shoving more ‘helpful nutrition’ info at us it at best, counterproductive.

Indeed, who can say that increasing breast feeding rates and the benefits associated with that would not have a negative impact elsewhere on women / children / wider society. Women are not stupid. We generally centre our children’s well-being before all else. If collectively we are making the choice to formula feed it is because at this moment in time, in the UK, considering all factors it is the best option as a WHOLE even if not nutritionally so.

lawnotorder · 19/11/2021 10:23

I think it's fine for her to say that for her, it was down to determination

I agree

She's downplaying 'luck' and upgrading 'determination'

Is she? Luck plays into everything; if you win the gold medal, get that job, buy that house. Doesn't mean you weren't determined.

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 10:23

[quote Silverclasp]@Bunnycat101 I agree with you.

I have such respect for women who have given birth without pain relief though, My god I was induced and lasted only 2 hours of contractions before I was screaming for the epidural.
I def wouldn't be offended if someone posted a study that showed the benefits of an unmedicated birth, I made my decision at the time and it was right for me.[/quote]
Why? I have birth without pain relief. It was absolute hell. I should have had pain relief. Might have prevented the PTSD I got. My decision was not right for me but by the time I asked for pain relief it was too late (it wasn't, but that's what they told me).

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 10:20

@Thecurliestwurly

I've extended breastfed two kids for at least 2.5 years each and my biggest annoyance is that nobody discusses the negatives of breastfeeding. And there are a lot of them!

I had an easy ride starting breastfeeding, but it's a shit experience most of the time. Some of my issues are

-shit sleep
-no help from partner for nightfeeds
-not being able to go anywhere without the baby in the early stages if they refuse bottle
-cluster feeding spells when young
-biting when they are older
-People being arseholes about you breastfeeding and saying you are 'making a rod for your own back' and all that crap
-It's also really hard to stop a habit in a child that is used to having it there all of the time, particularly in the night, but no advice as to how you can wean off breast - only 'dont offer, don't refuse' which is probably the most useless advice ever.
-people who have never breastfed telling you that you can just tell the child no When you want to wean (can't do this without a massive meltdown, which I don't have the time or energy to deal with as a FT working parent
-did I mention the complete lack of pumping facilities/spaces in workplaces too?

The reason so many give up early is nobody forewarns people that it is quite hard sometimes. I think we actually need to be honest about breastfeeding and understand it is not always compatible with modern life/working mothers. We need to encourage mix feeding as a solution, instead of a formula vs breast approach.

Given that I've spent six years of my life breastfeeding, I consider myself a well experienced breastfeeder and this is my biggest frustration. It's become a badge of honour among some women, who only preach about the benefits, but don't understand that for a lot of women (even ones like me who have breastfed a lot) it is a negative experience. So even people like me would be annoyed at the preaching of the benefits without being honest about the negatives too.

Totally agree.

I'm also a long term breastfeeder. I know, understand and appreciate the benefits of breastfeeding. But it ain't half shit at times!

RobinPenguins · 19/11/2021 10:16

@MozzarellaMonster

I breastfed both my children. but I had a lot of pressure not to in the form of MIL / acquaintances made comments, i had articles sent to me basically saying all my choices were wrong from PIL 😂 I stopped at 10 months not because I thought 10 months was enough but more because of the social pressure I felt before returning to work and not feeding over a year old etc second time around my DD is now 19 months and I'm still feeding her morning abs evening, there is very much a sense of shock from people that I should have stopped by now when I explain why I'm not drinking etc so OP I would find this article helpful although I'm past generally caring what other people think these days thank god.
That’s shit of your MIL and acquaintances. So it’s really surprising you’d want formula feeding mothers to experience the same social pressure from the other side.
DingleyDel · 19/11/2021 10:15

Formula is certainly harmful globally, that can’t be disputed. I think unicef estimate about 1million infants per year are killed by unsafe formula use. That could be no access to safe water, watering down formula (this does happen in the U.K. too because of food poverty), Chinese milk scandal etc.

In the developed world (for want of a better term) it really depends which way you look at it. For instance, we all prefer to say ‘breastfed infants have less gastro illness and lower risk of sids’ yet some will undoubtedly hear ‘formula fed infants have more gastro illness and higher risk of sids’.There have been a few scandals where large batches of formula were contaminated in the EU market, and the ingredients are purchased on the global market wherever is cheapest, so not as tightly regulated as people think. As formula feeding is the norm in the U.K. we should probably be using that as the base, however clearly breastfeeding is the bio norm and some people will always use that as the baseline. I don’t think it’s helpful to refer to formula as ‘harmful’. Most ff infants will be absolutely fine and yes they will all be made from fish fingers and haribo by they time they’re 5 s a pp pointed out. however I think the nhs should do a lot more education on formula ie. you don’t need to buy the most expensive brand, you need to store and make correctly. I see praise for perfect prep machines time and time again and yet the nhs is very clear that they don’t meet safely standards. Lots of people don’t understand that you’re sterilising the formula, not the water! There are no comparable risks to breastmilk clearly but I certainly don’t think it’s helpful to describe formula as ‘harmful’.

Thecurliestwurly · 19/11/2021 10:14

Thanks for posting about this OlympicProcrastinator. I did type a long post about my experiences, but lost it.

The short version is breastfeeding is not compatible with modern life. It works well for SAHMs, but not people like me who work FT and have had to struggle through

I have worked FT after each child and breastfed one until 3.5 and one is still going now at 2.5. I worked 14 hour shifts with my first on 3 hrs sleep as breastfed babies generally do not sleep well, or not in my case at least. I had to pump on my breaks during these shifts while eating my lunch and my colleagues walking in on me.

Breastfeeding is a limiting thing to do, especially in the early stages and the advice is poor, particularly around weaning off the breast. The only reason I did it with baby number 2 was I felt guilty for doing it for so long with my first. I thought it would be a different experience the second time around, but it wasn't and was worse. FWIW, they both latched perfectly on day one, it's just the general demands of breastfeeding that I found difficult.

I would love to do research on this myself, as I do feel passionately about expectant mothers having a realistic expectation of it and changing our expectations of mothers too, so that breastfeeding is a more viable option.

Working parents are very stretched generally and I think you just can't expect breastfeeding to fit with this.

RobinPenguins · 19/11/2021 10:14

The UK is culturally incompatible with breast feeding and is unique in this respect. (Other countries may also be culturally incompatible but UK culture is unique)

But does that…matter? Is there evidence that outcomes for UK children that can be directly linked to bf are worse in the UK than comparable nations? If there isn’t, perhaps we should just chill out about it because it doesn’t really matter. I was gutted not to be able to bf. But that was wholly because I’d been convinced that it was so important, so critical for my child’s health and our bond. If I’d known the actual facts I don’t think I’d have experienced those negative emotions and would have just cracked on with doing what was right for us because really, it wasn’t that important. I was only grieving for a bf relationship I couldn’t have because I thought that relationship was so crucial and important and I was missing out by not having it.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 19/11/2021 10:13

I truly can't understand why so many women are so caught up in how other women feed their children. Not your body, not your baby, quite literally the definition of nothing to do with you.
OP, do you think that by posting a study on SM, women reading it will go 'oh, goodness, I wasn't going to BF but now I know my babies thymus gland will be larger, I'll rethink that decision?'. No, of course not.
Women do and don't breastfeed for a multitude of very personal reasons that are - I'll repeat - nothing to do with anyone else.
Rather than ramming the benefits of breastfeeding down pregnant women's throats, and how natural and easy it is, the industry would do better to provide support once the baby arrives. Breastfeeding is fucking hard - I know about 3 women who found it easy. Your nipples will be annihilated, the baby feeds CONSTANTLY, they may not latch properly, tongue tie is a thing, your milk may not come in. NOBODY prepares you for the realities of breastfeeding. Nobody. If they focused on that - and the things that can be done to help - rather than just pumping out the benefits over and over and over again, we'd have much higher breastfeeding rates. Ironically.

MozzarellaMonster · 19/11/2021 10:10

I breastfed both my children. but I had a lot of pressure not to in the form of MIL / acquaintances made comments, i had articles sent to me basically saying all my choices were wrong from PIL 😂 I stopped at 10 months not because I thought 10 months was enough but more because of the social pressure I felt before returning to work and not feeding over a year old etc second time around my DD is now 19 months and I'm still feeding her morning abs evening, there is very much a sense of shock from people that I should have stopped by now when I explain why I'm not drinking etc so OP I would find this article helpful although I'm past generally caring what other people think these days thank god.

OlympicProcrastinator · 19/11/2021 10:01

Sorry I repeated some there and a random break appeared! Hmm

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2021 10:01

The UK is culturally incompatible with breast feeding and is unique in this respect. (Other countries may also be culturally incompatible but UK culture is unique)

This is very true and something the nhs absolutely fails to take on board.

OlympicProcrastinator · 19/11/2021 09:59

I did some research into this a few years ago. This is what I concluded in a (very summarised) version.

The UK is culturally incompatible with breast feeding and is unique in this respect. (Other countries may also be culturally incompatible but UK culture is unique)

When a woman makes a decision about feeding their baby, nutrition is a single factor that is considered. Yet there are so very many other factors that go into the decision, both conscious and unconscious. By focusing purely on the nutritional aspect, healthcare professionals are failing to address other factors that contribute to our low breast feeding rates. Examples (in no particular order)

Peer group expectation
Societal expectations of modesty.
Familial influences and expectations

Peer group culture & experience
Religious / cultural expectations.
Sexual connotations around breasts.
Class.
Work / labour both in and out of the home.
Male support / lack of support both in the home and wider society.
Money.
Professional support.
Geography / history (where is the woman located, what past experiences influence decision making)
Popular culture / media influences.
Safety (does the woman feel safe and able to make a free choice and carry out actions within her family / community)
Community / family support.

There’s loads more but don’t want to waffle on or bang on about individual points.

The main point is nutrition is a single factor in a decision that is impacted by a huge number of wider factors. These other influences are both conscious and unconscious. Focussing on nutrition (which pretty much everyone has the info on) is unhelpful as the UK is not culturally accommodating to breastfeeding as a whole.

AryaStarkWolf · 19/11/2021 09:58

I didn't breast feed, I did try with my first but I found it too difficult and I was exhausted so I bottle fed and am happy with my choice, it doesn't offend me in the slightest when people talk about breast feeding and it's benefits though

TheKeatingFive · 19/11/2021 09:55

I think it's fine for her to say that for her, it was down to determination.

That's not really what she's saying though.

She's downplaying 'luck' and upgrading 'determination'. But in reality, you only ever have the type of birth your body/baby allows. This idea that it comes down to a superior mindset or 'determination' isn't the reality, despite what those who have straightforward births sometimes believe.

MrsColon · 19/11/2021 09:48

@TheKeatingFive

Why do you consider her being proud of that as somehow taking away from other mothers?

Because she puts that down to her 'determination'. When women's births don't go to plan, it really isn't because they weren't 'determined' enough. It's because of body/baby issues that they have no control over.

I think it's fine for her to say that for her, it was down to determination. Women shouldn't be afraid of sharing their own personal experience for fear someone else will read far more into it that they intended because they feel (wrongly!) ashamed or judged for not being able (or choosing not) to breastfeed.

We need to be kinder to ourselves and not constantly infer judgement/criticism where none is intended.

Mumoblue · 19/11/2021 09:47

Formula is not harmful. It’s disingenuous to say that FF mums shouldn’t feel guilty while also implying they are harming their babies.

Shit like that is why people think BF mums are evangelical.

imagen · 19/11/2021 09:45

Being proud of yourself for having a straightforward birth is just ridiculous though.

Saying something like "gas and air was fab for me. Amy, you should really try it when you're in Labour" or some such isn't really bragging. Now substitute gas and air for breastfeeding. It's not shaming anyone, it's not an attack on anyone.

Most people don't approve of shaming others choices especially for something as insignificant as infant feeding. But fgs, it's lie you can't even talk about it without someone getting touchy.

If you couldn't or didn't want to fine, but it's almost as if some people who argue fed is best (it is, ofc) don't even believe it themselves

AngelDelight28 · 19/11/2021 09:42

@Popcornriver That's because it's utter nonsense. There is zero harm caused by formula, in developed countries with a clean water supply.
Thing is, if someone is so invested in BF and has gone to significant lengths to do it then they need to convince themselves it's the absolute best thing to do and the alternatives are bad. I've seen this happen so many times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread