Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
5128gap · 19/11/2021 14:42

So much angst would be saved on every side if people just minded their business, fed their own child the way they see fit, and let other women do the same.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 14:30

I hate the whole 'fed is best' mantra. No it's not, it's the bare minimum

For whom?

If a marginal benefit to the baby is always seen as the priority over the mother's mental health, wellbeing, ability to work in any circumstances, yes.

If, on the other hand, the health and wellbeing of the mother is the priority its not quite so clear is it?

I take the view that breast is obviously optimal but that I was not prepared to go through months of massively downgrading my own quality of life to maintain this marginal some would say inconsequential benefit to my child's nutrition. Ten years on I'm comfortable I made the best decision.

Fed is best has helped me and masses of other mothers who found breastfeeding unbearably difficult come to terms with this and forgive ourselves. It made it possible for me to live with my decision as opposed to being relentlessly ground down by other women who told me I was failing my baby.

So I'll take fed is best, thanks very much.

Thehop · 19/11/2021 14:28

Couldn’t agree more @Silverclasp

blubberyboo · 19/11/2021 14:26

If you repost things on social media it almost always comes across as a sort of expression of your beliefs and opinions and impressing them onto others.

Think vax versus anti vax
Pro life versus pro choice
Man United versus Liverpool
Political opinions
Religious sayings

If you put something up about breastfeeding you have to be prepared that many will take it to mean you are proclaiming that everyone should be breastfeeding their babies.

In reality it is nobody’s business but the mothers and they will be getting advice from medical professionals.

sharing something about T cells isn’t going to change the circumstances of someone who chooses to formula feed for whatever reasons

Basically why do you want to share the post for any reason other than to try and persuade someone not to formula feed?

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/11/2021 14:17

I do think the pendulum has swung a bit too far the other way. In attempt to ensure formula isn't shamed, I see a lot of people downplaying the benefits of breastfeeding on social media. The only militant perspective I've seen is from people who've chosen to formula feed without even trying breastfeeding.

I hate the whole 'fed is best' mantra. No it's not, it's the bare minimum.

Nemorth · 19/11/2021 14:13

How a baby is fed is, in the main, up to the parents.

Knowledge is power though so the more that is known about the benefits of breastfeeding the better.

It is due to this knowledge that I fought and fought and fought to breastfeed and luckily for me after a rocky start both times I managed it. I had many complications including a congenital breast defect in both breasts which negatively affected my ability to breastfeed.

I combo fed both my children with artificial formula until I was able to breastfeed successfully. The formula saved my breastfeeding relationship and helped me nurture my babies. I combo fed DS for 6-weeks and kept going for 14 months. I combo fed DD for 10 weeks and kept going for 18 months.

I was lucky. I was privileged.

It was the knowledge that kept me going.

So I would have been interested in that post but I think I'm the exception rather than the rule. I think you would have to get the tone and the explanation of why you shared it just right for it to land safely.

It's such a horrible contentious area.

I don't know what the solution is.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 14:06

Because the main reason IMO is the attitudes in the society we live in, which isn't convinced breastfeeding is even a positive thing really, and certainly not something that should be talked about in the community even in a respectful way to all mothers.

I simply don't buy this. Our society is overwhelmingly convinced that breastfeeding is a positive thing. You'd have to have lived under a rock not to know that there is scientific evidence that breastfeeding is helpful. And its talked about ad nauseam in communities of new mothers and in the medical community. There is no more convincing which needs to take place. That ship has sailed.

But what isn't talked about enough is that its convenient for some women its actually bloody difficult for many women to breastfeed. For a variety of reasons. Sometimes technical (tongue-tie/latching problems etc). Sometimes cultural (no-one else did it in my family etc) and often logistics (breastfeeding is pretty onerous in terms of time and the limitations on women and many women simply aren't prepared to sacrifice that much of their time). There is some support for this but it's at best patchy.

A lot of women go into new motherhood with very good intentions and then discover that breastfeeding is much harder than they expected. Some of them stick it out and all power to them.

Many of them, not unreasonably, weigh it up and decide they'll take a marginal downgrade to the quality of their child's nutrition in order to to stop spending every minute of their time obsessing over how to breastfeed. In order to be able to leave the house and not to have to be cluster feeding throughout the night. In order to not have to go and find a place to express at work every couple of hours. In short, to get their lives back. If the impact on a child's health of a mother doing this was really significant then we as a society would owe it to those mothers and those children to support them more comprehensively.

But we don't. We bully them and nag them and send them "well-meaning" stories about a study that's been published somewhere which shows another marginal impact on the child's health. We make them feel inferior to developing world mothers when in fact the entire infrastructure in these countries is completely different and you're not comparing like with like. Etc etc.

Going on and on and on about breastfeeding being a positive thing is really not the solution to this.

NerrSnerr · 19/11/2021 13:51

I breastfed 2 children to toddlerhood and managed to breastfeed alongside work etc etc. It was a positive experience for me (although it's lovely to be able to have lemsip again!) I wouldn't go around posting breastfeeding posts on Facebook or trying to persuade people on Mumsnet to breastfeed. If someone asks for specific bf advice I'll give it the best I can though.

I think some people dismiss bf as an option due to their own culture which I personally think is a shame as it should be an option but I don't think people preaching on Facebook and Mumsnet will ever increase BF rates.

Frezia · 19/11/2021 13:40

@Puppyseahorse
The point was that many more women in developing countries are able to breastfeed even without access to great system support. They can because they're able to replace a lot of it through community resources and support, but for that to be available there has to be a culture where breastfeeding is visible, seen in a positive way and women are surrounded by other breastfeeding women from an early age.

Of course we need lactation consultants, tongue tie clinics and all the other system support features, just like women in developing countries should have those too. But claims that not having them is the reason why breastfeeding rates here are particularly poor, even compared to some other developed countries with safe drinking water, are only partially true IMO.

Because the main reason IMO is the attitudes in the society we live in, which isn't convinced breastfeeding is even a positive thing really, and certainly not something that should be talked about in the community even in a respectful way to all mothers. We won't be able to have adequate system support unless we can fix some of those attitudes.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 12:32

If people don't want to breastfeed that's fine. If some people do that's fine. The problem is when someone does want to breastfeed and doesn't have access to support.

This is true. the whole narrative we're discussing, ie "helpful" posts about the benefits of breastfeeding on Facebook etc, doesn't really touch on this.

Women who are struggling to breastfeed don't need yet another argument as to why they should be doing it. The PR battle in favour of breastfeeding was comprehensively won decades ago. Everyone knows they ought to be doing it and hitting women over the head with it clearly isn't achieving much.

The real discussions are:

  • Is the nutritional/health trade off for the baby worthwhile in terms of the impact on the mother if its difficult? (given that for many women the negative impacts of breastfeeding are significant). My personal view is that for many women the benefit is too marginal to be worth the stress and difficulty.
  • If we decide as a society it is a worthwhile trade off, why are women not being better supported with it? It's not enough for nurses/midwives/health visitors just to shout about the benefits of breastfeeding. It needs practical advice and support.
AveryGoodlay · 19/11/2021 12:28

Breastfeeding should be promoted; but I believe there should be way more support for the percentage of women who can’t breastfeed I really agree with that. People forget some women just can't breastfeed or comment "it's a very small percentage". Well guess what? Some people are in that small percentage! One of my friends is and she felt similar to the poster I quoted. She really struggled and at one point she said she felt like less of a woman, which took her a while to overcome. The most support she received was an online group for women in the same situation which really helped.

AveryGoodlay · 19/11/2021 12:19

But i bet you can't pick out the bottle fed babies from the breastfed babies in a class of 7 year olds, or 15 year olds. Some people post this as some sort of gotcha thinking they are clever. I think it is more about giving them what is nutritionally best for babies at the time though as in giving them the best start. Milk is the only form of nutrition babies get at the time. There are so many things that contribute to nutrition once they start eating and drinking other things.

If people don't want to breastfeed that's fine. If some people do that's fine. The problem is when someone does want to breastfeed and doesn't have access to support. I really struggled with breastfeeding with both babies. I was so lucky with my first because I had a midwife who showed me a "trick" for want of a better phrase which amazingly worked for us! And it took her literally no more than ten seconds to show me.

With my second I remembered the trick but still struggled so much. I remember crying in the early hours of the morning those first few weeks as it was so painful, my nipples were bleeding and I was just so tired. I explained this to various midwives who all worded it differently but gave me the message that if I couldn't feed my baby then I'd have to bottle feed. One told me to buy bottles and formula to keep in the house "because if you give up it will be in the middle of the night". In the end my grandmother recalled everything she tried for her 3 son's and eventually we cracked it. I still breastfeed her at 2

There should be no pressure to breast or bottle feed. But I've heard of more midwives who push mum's to bottle feed because the hospitals don't have the resources to help struggling mothers. There do seem to be quite a few people who seem to advocate bottle feeding so the dad can "bond with the baby". In my opinion that's often just misogyny because the dad can feed the baby then think he should be treated like a king for the day whilst the mother does everything else.

I do agree that we should be able to discuss the positives of breastfeeding. I don't necessarily think posting facebook statuses is appropriate though, it's just a bit weird. If you're wanting to help someone in particular, do it privately. If you'd like to help people, offer it and help people who would like it.

Puppyseahorse · 19/11/2021 12:18

@Frezia the reason women breastfeed more in developing countries isn’t culture, it’s because they have no alternative. Water isn’t safe for babies. This is a large part of the reason WHO and other agencies push breastfeeding so hard.

Please don’t present this as a pure positive. Trying to feed a baby in a developing country is no picnic.

cherrypie66 · 19/11/2021 12:01

@JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil

I’d think ‘where the fuck is a thymus gland?! then Google it. Then wonder why you care about this research other than to be preachy. Then inwardly roll my eyes and thank God my kids are way past that stage.

Eventually you’ll realise that good parenting goes way beyond breastfeeding for a bit and enlarging thymus glands.

Do you plan to put up research at every stage of your child’s development OP. Guaranteed way to get people to mute you.

Exactly my thoughts. It really makes no difference many more things to worry about. Bottle or breast just so what you like and keep it to yourself !
JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 19/11/2021 11:52

I’d think ‘where the fuck is a thymus gland?! then Google it. Then wonder why you care about this research other than to be preachy. Then inwardly roll my eyes and thank God my kids are way past that stage.

Eventually you’ll realise that good parenting goes way beyond breastfeeding for a bit and enlarging thymus glands.

Do you plan to put up research at every stage of your child’s development OP. Guaranteed way to get people to mute you.

AnxiouslyAnxiousToday · 19/11/2021 11:48

I fall into the very small percentage of women who just don’t produce milk and was not able to breastfeed my daughter. I’m well aware of the benefits and would always shout it from the rooftops to a mother who is looking specifically for more information on breastfeeding or BF vs Formula. The majority of people know that it comes with a great deal of benefits.

However that said, I’ve written in posts and forums asking for BF experience/formula decision ect and the amount of cult like pro-breast feeders really does annoy me.

I’m pro breastfeeding; but I couldn’t do it. I had support, we tried and tried and when it got I the point where they were thinking of admitting her to hospital for her weight loss (IUGR baby who lost more weight after birth and never gained it back until we used formula) at that point we agreed that I simply can’t breastfeeding and that formula is best, for us. So for us, breast is not best.

I still consistently have “you should have been given more support” “you didn’t try hard enough” “formula is BARE MINIMUM” “only 2% of women actually CANT breastfeed, most just give up too early”

I can’t tell you how painful it was to get these comments when DD was a newborn. I tried to the best of my ability to BF her. I felt shamed to move into formula. My HV said that although breastfeeding will always be the recommended, it’s almost pushed too much now and all some people are doing are pushing mothers into PND by making them feel as if they haven’t done enough. Which is exactly how I felt.

Breastfeeding should be promoted; but I believe there should be way more support for the percentage of women who can’t breastfeed, and those who tried but moved over to formula because of stress, PND, pain ect. The women who tried, who really wanted it and really tried need more support than we get now

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/11/2021 11:40

@lawnotorder

But as an arthritic middle-aged asthmatic, it doesn't matter how determined to climb Everest I am, it won't happen. Determination alone will not cut it and some of the BF propaganda doesn't recognise that

But I don't think "I was determined to do X" means if you achieve something others don't were less determined.

Agree, so it is both determination and luck which makes the difference. Most of my friends were very much of that opinion when I struggled for months. I appreciated their support. If someone took credit for their determination without also recognising their luck, I think that's quite different.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/11/2021 11:38

However, in my experience saying anything about this does tend to infuriate people who haven’t breastfed.

Perhaps because most of those people did want to, did feel the loss of the extra bonding which you were fortunate to benefit from and don't think they 'haven't' breast fed, but 'couldn't'. I really don't think that you saying that BF was a great experience for you infuriates people, it's using language like this which suggests that people had a choice which infuriates people. Maybe you don't actually think that and you've just chosen a bad turn of phrase but I think much more sensitivity is needed and if that were there, some more useful conversations could result.

LiJo2015 · 19/11/2021 11:36

@Silverclasp

I think one of the issues with the bfing is best campaign is the fact there's lots of confounding variables that will create the differences. In addition, it is a fact that you don't have 2 groups of people with bfing people being superior in terms of health. It is also fact that babies have died owing to malnutrition owing to inadequate bfing and a push to do this at the expense of actually feeding the baby.

Fed is best - it is that simple.

MozzarellaMonster · 19/11/2021 11:17

@RobinPenguins what nonsense posting a positive article of the benefits of breastfeeding is not the same as ppl actively telling me they think me breastfeeding is icky or wrong. I wouldn't be offended to see a pro formula article and would be happy if it helped any mother feel better about their choice. A pro breastfeeding or pro formula article can help the person doing either one feel better about their choices and as we can see from this thread there are pros and cons on both sides but the OP is pointing out how when it comes to breastfeeding it's seen as a negative to share the pros, my experience is just showing how generally attitudes towards breastfeeding in my experience are still overall negative. It would be nice if both options could be seen more positive and women encouraged to feel good about whichever option they choose that is best for them.

Thecurliestwurly · 19/11/2021 11:15

@heliosunburg

The short version is breastfeeding is not compatible with modern life. It works well for SAHMs, but not people like me who work FT and have had to struggle through

Not saying you're wrong but don't most people take maternity leave? I had to work from 2 weeks PP and still breastfed/pumped.

I think it's also good to say "you can do it" rather than be defeatist and say it's incompatible. Broadly, yes, but it's still possible for some

My point was that I did do it though, for many years and still am currently. Yes I had maternity leave, but I worked long shifts and my children did not sleep well. It was fucking hard. It can be done, but it was at the detriment to my own wellbeing.

We are expected to breastfeed, but workplaces and wider society don't support it. For many, maternity leave is quite short and there is little advice about how to transition to work as a breastfeeding parent. I'm glad you had a good experience though, as it provides balance to my negative rantings. Grin

Summerfun54321 · 19/11/2021 11:14

It’s cultural. Other cultures are openly dismissive of bottle feeding as its so uncommon in their culture. I spoke to a friend in another country in Europe about bottle feeding and she just said “mums don’t bottle feed here”.

Somethingsnappy · 19/11/2021 10:50

@Frezia

Breastfeeding rates are higher in developing countries than the developed. You don't need an expensive or elaborate healthcare support system to improve them. But you do need a culture with a positive attitude towards breastfeeding and a community you can draw knowledge and support from. All the educated midwives and accessible lactation consultants and amazing maternity/paternity benefits cannot replace that.
Brilliant post.
Antsgomarching · 19/11/2021 10:46

I knew the benefits I hated breastfeeding and it was affecting my mental health. Tbh I just don’t care how other people feed their kids as long as they are feeding them.

I don’t mind people talking about the benefits of breastfeeding, theres loads of upsides but not if you randomly start a convo with me about it - i refer you back to the “I don’t care” bit. in reference to childbirth, I also refer you back to “I don’t care” how you did it but I hope mum and baby were both well afterwards. I feel neither proud nor ashamed of the choices I made in relation to those things.

I would never judge and I think people sometimes feel judged, bit like talking to (some) vegans where you are expected to praise them and then bow your head in shame for not being one of them.

hotmeatymilk · 19/11/2021 10:45

The short version is breastfeeding is not compatible with modern life. It works well for SAHMs, but not people like me who work FT and have had to struggle through
I just don’t think this is true and you can’t extrapolate from your experience to apply it to all breastfeeding any more than I can say I worked FT from 9 months and breastfed successfully til 2.5 years, therefore breastfeeding and FT work are perfectly compatible.

Breastfeeding and formula feeding threads always come down to personal experience and high-level arguments that don’t actually take into account the breadth and nuance of individual experience and circumstances, and that’s a large part of the paucity of support for breastfeeding in this country – it assumes the social support is there so a quick midwife visit will do and there you go, on your way, Tits McGee.