Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We can't mention positives of Breastfeeding for fear of offending

707 replies

Silverclasp · 18/11/2021 17:00

Recently there was an interesting thread about a husband not wanting his wife to Breastfeed (he wanted to give formula) posters were highlighting the positives of Breastfeeding (since this was the topic) but there was a response essentially saying that by pointing out the benefits that we are shaming non bf mothers.
It got me thinking that I actively don't speak about bf for this very reason, I feel like if the person I'm talking to doesn't bf it can be seen as "shaming" like I never post anything pro Breastfeeding on SM in case I offend someone. It's kind of ridiculous.
Interested in both sides of the argument.

So say I reposted an article on SM which stated that studies have indicated that breastfed babies have a larger thymus gland than formula fed babies and more tcells as a result. Would this be unreasonable and cause offence to non bf mothers?

OP posts:
Bumblenums1234 · 19/11/2021 17:54

[quote Silverclasp]@Kendodd I'm surprised this one hasn't been deleted considering how outraged some people have been at the mere suggestion that the biologically normal way for humans to feed their baby has benefits to it.[/quote]
God you are so bloody up yourself

I fed my son formula as if I had continued my desperate attempts to bf he would have died. Plain and simple.

Fed is best

WorraLiberty · 19/11/2021 17:53

@heliosunburg

I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.

You think breastfeeding in bed next to baby is more tiring then faffing with bottles?

And if you're right that it is, surely that's more reason to applaud these misters for sticking with it?

Applaud complete strangers for how they're choosing to feed their babies? Confused

Too weird to even contemplate.

mehface · 19/11/2021 17:43

I know so many people those babies have had major reflux or
with formula. Of course diary allergies can happen bf or formula fed, but it's not natural food to give babies treated cows milk.

ThreeFeetTall · 19/11/2021 17:29

I wished people cared more about a clean water supply in those developing countries. Babies can be breastfed and the die age 2 because of unclean water supply.

mishmased · 19/11/2021 17:23

@Puppyseahorse it is the culture in most developing countries. It is what have been done for generations. The knowledge of breastfeeding is passed down from mothers to daughters. Children grow up seeing parents, aunts, sisters, cousins breastfeeding babies. They share experience and offer support to new mums. It was all they knew about feeding babies until formula manufacturers tried to tell them that formula is better for their babies and promote a stigma that only poor people breastfeed. There is access to good water supply in a lot of developing countries but obviously not everywhere so saying a blanket statement that water isn't safe is untrue. In some parts yes they struggle for clean water but not in all parts.

There is also the push by formula companies that formula is better for babies which it isn't and that is a fact. Except in cases where mum is on meds incompatible with BF or due to IGT or whatever other reason.
Formula companies do not have the wellbeing of babies at heart they're more interested in profit and use language like breast milk research, close to breast milk to promote their product.

MrsToadflax · 19/11/2021 16:57

@Babdoc

I get rather tired of breast feeding zealots shaming depressed exhausted new mothers who are already upset about their failed milk supply, or who chose to bottle feed to fit their personal circumstances. I'm a retired doctor and baby boomer. My generation was majority bottle fed and is the healthiest, longest lived generation in history. The benefits of breast feeding v bottle are minimal in the UK, and undetectable by adulthood. I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.
Interesting that a professional has this experience. I can't imagine a 60 year old woman being told, 'I'm sorry to tell you that you wouldn't have this condition if you'd been breastfed.' Without exception, every child I know who has been breastfed has either allergies, ongoing health issues or are just generally sickly children. Obviously only my experience, but I think another reason breastfeeding rates aren't higher is because in real life in the UK the benefits really aren't obvious.
MrsToadflax · 19/11/2021 16:57

@Babdoc

I get rather tired of breast feeding zealots shaming depressed exhausted new mothers who are already upset about their failed milk supply, or who chose to bottle feed to fit their personal circumstances. I'm a retired doctor and baby boomer. My generation was majority bottle fed and is the healthiest, longest lived generation in history. The benefits of breast feeding v bottle are minimal in the UK, and undetectable by adulthood. I see young mums worn out with cluster feeding and sleep deprivation, and frankly don't believe the game is worth the candle.
Interesting that a professional has this experience. I can't imagine a 60 year old woman being told, 'I'm sorry to tell you that you wouldn't have this condition if you'd been breastfed.' Without exception, every child I know who has been breastfed has either allergies, ongoing health issues or are just generally sickly children. Obviously only my experience, but I think another reason breastfeeding rates aren't higher is because in real life in the UK the benefits really aren't obvious.
Fieldofgreycorn · 19/11/2021 16:22

@Piglet89

I will never, ever understand why some women care so very much about what other women feed their babies.
Some of us have to care because we do it for a living. You don’t suddenly stop caring because it’s one minute past 5.
JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 16:15

@Onairjunkie

For me, formula was a better choice than breast feeding. It just simply was. It meant both myself and my baby thrived.
It is for many people. The nutritional/ health benefits of breastmilk are only a small part of the overall benefits of any feeding choice and need to be taken as a part of a much bigger picture.
Piglet89 · 19/11/2021 16:14

I will never, ever understand why some women care so very much about what other women feed their babies.

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 16:13

thepeopleversuswork

I'm not missing any point. I was directly responding to a question. The question was unrelated to your point.

I'm not telling random women in baby groups that fed isn't best. But I'm also not repeating the stupid mantra either. I don't talk about infant feeding in real life unless asked directly for factual information or advice.

thepeopleversuswork · 19/11/2021 16:02

@JunoMcDuff

Would you actually tell a woman you knew who’s chosen to formula feed from the off, for a number of reasons (none of which are any of your business) that’s she’s done the bare minimum to feed her child? Or would you just run her down behind her back?

If she were saying "formula is just as good as breast milk" I'd correct her or refute her claim. If she was just saying "I formula fed because I didn't fancy breastfeeding" I'd say fair enough. I dislike the spreading of misinformation.

But this spectacularly misses the point that by far the largest group of people who don't breastfeed are not feckless types who can't be arsed or desperately ignorant people who don't know. They are people who have tried and failed.

It's not a simple binary thing of people either being uninformed (and needing more information) or being too selfish.

Telling someone who has struggled for weeks and months with pain, discomfort, sleeplessness, massive challenges in adapting to any semblance of normal life that they are doing the "bare minimum" for their baby is just really really shitty.

This is what "fed is best" is about. It doesn't literally mean that any kind of food is preferable to breastfeeding. Any fool knows formula isn't better than breast. It's a way to get people to get things into perspective and support those of us who struggled with massively and allow ourselves not to have to beat ourselves up over it for the rest of our lives.

Onairjunkie · 19/11/2021 15:53

For me, formula was a better choice than breast feeding. It just simply was. It meant both myself and my baby thrived.

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 15:46

I also think we should normalise milk sharing!

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 15:46

Would you actually tell a woman you knew who’s chosen to formula feed from the off, for a number of reasons (none of which are any of your business) that’s she’s done the bare minimum to feed her child? Or would you just run her down behind her back?

If she were saying "formula is just as good as breast milk" I'd correct her or refute her claim. If she was just saying "I formula fed because I didn't fancy breastfeeding" I'd say fair enough. I dislike the spreading of misinformation.

IWouldntHavetoWorkatAll · 19/11/2021 15:44

I agree with you OP.

I think what offends women is being told what to do with their bodies

It’s not about telling women what to do. It’s about centring the needs of the baby. Human babies require human milk for optimum development. I’m sorry if some people find that difficult but it’s factually correct.

Posting about the benefits of breastfeeding will make you look smug and self important IMO. There are women who can't breastfeed who want to and are aware of the benefits and this sort of shit isn't helpful. If you breastfeed then great, look after your own baby the way you want and keep your opinions and articles to yourself.

There should definitely be more support and yes some women have difficulties. But that doesn’t mean it’s ok to devalue human milk. It is a sensitive issue but those sort of comments are used to shut down discussion. I find it bordering on bullying tbh.

Tonyschoco · 19/11/2021 15:42

@Willyoujustbequiet

I do think the pendulum has swung a bit too far the other way. In attempt to ensure formula isn't shamed, I see a lot of people downplaying the benefits of breastfeeding on social media. The only militant perspective I've seen is from people who've chosen to formula feed without even trying breastfeeding.

I hate the whole 'fed is best' mantra. No it's not, it's the bare minimum.

Would you actually tell a woman you knew who’s chosen to formula feed from the off, for a number of reasons (none of which are any of your business) that’s she’s done the bare minimum to feed her child? Or would you just run her down behind her back?

What an astonishing way to think about something that has fuck-all to do with you and affects you even less.

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 15:40

@5128gap

So much angst would be saved on every side if people just minded their business, fed their own child the way they see fit, and let other women do the same.
The reality is that this is exactly what most people in real life do.

I don't think I've ever instigated a conversation about infant feeding with anyone. I've had people instigate them with me - usually as I was feeding one of my DC. I'm very open to talking but would never actually instigate a conversation about it myself.

Ozanj · 19/11/2021 15:31

Yes, formula is better than starvation. Breast milk is optimal

Lavender24 · 19/11/2021 15:26

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@thepeopleversuswork

Fed is the bare minimum. Starvation being the alternative.

See I just knew someone would take issue with someone advocating breastfeeding. This is exactly what I meant. I don't care what you chose or your reasons for it. Everyone is free to make their own choices and no one should feel shamed but breast is best.[/quote]
I agree. Formula is better than starvation but it is not better than breast milk. And this is coming from someone who ended up formula feeding due to baby not latching and lack of support.

Ozanj · 19/11/2021 15:25

@5128gap

So much angst would be saved on every side if people just minded their business, fed their own child the way they see fit, and let other women do the same.
Yes
Ozanj · 19/11/2021 15:25

Agreed. I still bf my toddler and the stupid, ill informed comments by people who didn’t even try to breastfeed me sick. DS was unwell recently and I had to bf him outside (no choice but to as he wasn’t eating) and a woman (in front of her family) tried to make me out to be a pervert for feeding my child. Not because he’s a toddler (he’s thin so looks much younger) but because he was breastfeeding. I gave her a fitting reply but I felt so fed up afterwards.

Lavender24 · 19/11/2021 15:24

I think the replies on this thread highlight just how touchy people are about it. It's bizarre.

JunoMcDuff · 19/11/2021 15:21

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@thepeopleversuswork

Fed is the bare minimum. Starvation being the alternative.

See I just knew someone would take issue with someone advocating breastfeeding. This is exactly what I meant. I don't care what you chose or your reasons for it. Everyone is free to make their own choices and no one should feel shamed but breast is best.[/quote]
Exactly.

Formula from a reputable, safe, regulated company is absolutely fine.

But fed is not best - you get some totally cockamami idiots making their own vegan or whatever they fancy formula. Not safe, not good, not best.

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/11/2021 15:02

@thepeopleversuswork

Fed is the bare minimum. Starvation being the alternative.

See I just knew someone would take issue with someone advocating breastfeeding. This is exactly what I meant. I don't care what you chose or your reasons for it. Everyone is free to make their own choices and no one should feel shamed but breast is best.

Swipe left for the next trending thread